No, it doesn't really help. If you're not assuming your hypotheticals to be true, then I admit that I don't understand your proof. I'll let ceo_esq comment if he can make more sense of it than I have. I still don't see that you've proven your conclusion since nothing in your proof even pertains to the conclusion, but perhaps it's just my lack of understanding.
-Bri
On the other hand it could also be my line references which are pretty askew.
But no step in a deductive argument can pertain to the conclusion - that would be a big and nasty fallacy. The propositions must pertain to a previous proposition, an assumption/premise or a definition.
Rather the conclusion should pertain to some previous proposition or definition and make this explicit. My references are mixed up which is my bad. A result of using the list tag and not being able to see the line numbers.
But if you mean that the conclusion (which is line 11) does not follow from the other propositions in the argument then you will have to be more specific and it should be fairly easy to do this, just start from the conclusion and work backwards.
Having been badgered for deductive arguments (although I had already supplied them) I feel justified in badgering back for responses that are a little more specific than "nothing in your proof even pertains to the conclusion".
For example would the conclusion in line 11 be a valid reductio ad absurdum if propositions 9 and 10 were valid? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.
If my definition of free will and propositions 5 and 6 were all valid would proposition 10 be a valid deduction? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.
If my definition of omniscience and proposition 8 were valid would propostion 9 be a valid deduction? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.
Is proposition 8 a logically possible consequence of propositions 2,3 and 4? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.
Are propositions 5,6 and 7 logically possible consequences of the definition of free will? If not, why not? If so then we can tick these steps and work backwards.
Is proposition 4 a consequence of the definition of omnipotence? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.
Is proposition 3 a hypothesis logically possible from the premise? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.
Is Proposition 2 a consequence of the premise and the definition of omniscience? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and say that my conclusion does follow from my argument.
So unless I have broken some rule of logic I am justified in saying !P
1.
The statement
An omniscient being G participates in a universe in which at least one agent has free will is not a logical possibility according to the definitions stated.
The only thing I can see that I left out was a definition for the predicate "participates in".
Note this evaluation does not guarantee my proof is valid, but it is the first step.
So let me clean up the line references and restate the argument.