There is No God (And You Know It)

I think you will find that the definition of omniscience I am using was posted by ceo_esq. I have already pointed out the proof is compatible with one of the other definitions you have posted earlier.

I agree. It was Ossai who didn't get this.

You implied that there was some other definition that was incompatible with my proof but you did not actually post it. If this definition involves God not being able to predict a free will event even by timelessly viewing the future you are correct that it is not compatible with my proof.

Yes, that's the one. Yes I did post it (several times) but perhaps my definition wasn't as clear as it might have been.

But you never made this clear. My proof is compatible with any definition that has been discussed in this topic. It is compatible with the way most theologists define omniscience.

Please post this alternate definition.

I did, and you posted it again above. Before any more confusion sets in, be very clear that I was not using this definition in any argument about the conclusions of your proof. For all arguments, I have been using your definition. I simply pointed out once that there are other possible definitions that don't fit your proof.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Then what the heck does the following mean?

3. A true statement made about the world in the world exists at a specific time (t)

-Bri
It might help if you continued reading on to the end of the statement, rather than just stopping half way through. Here is what I actually said:
3. A true statement made about the world in the world exists at a specific time (t) (Hyp logically possible from Arg 1)
There - does that help?

Do you understand the process of deduction? If not then why did you ask for a deductive argument?

If so then show me even one line in my proof that would be invalid if God could interact with the world but chose never to do so in any way.
 
I've got a lot of respect for mathematics and mathematical proof.

I don't have much respect for attempts at philosophical proofs - they require a set of attitudes, set of skills, and a level of honesty that are really hard to find in one person. People seem to be satisfied with their own efforts far too easily.

Issues related to determinism, non-determinism, and free will are fascinating. I honestly haven't decided what I think on these yet. I'm currently reading Dennett. I really appreciate the skill with which he explores this area. On the other hand, the discussions in this thread that relate to determinism, non-determinism, and free will are neither interesting nor helpful. Sorry.

I fully support your right to spend your time exploring issues of complexity with tools that may not be up to the task.
 
I've got a lot of respect for mathematics and mathematical proof.

I don't have much respect for attempts at philosophical proofs - they require a set of attitudes, set of skills, and a level of honesty that are really hard to find in one person. People seem to be satisfied with their own efforts far too easily.

Issues related to determinism, non-determinism, and free will are fascinating. I honestly haven't decided what I think on these yet. I'm currently reading Dennett. I really appreciate the skill with which he explores this area. On the other hand, the discussions in this thread that relate to determinism, non-determinism, and free will are neither interesting nor helpful. Sorry.

I fully support your right to spend your time exploring issues of complexity with tools that may not be up to the task.

I completely agree with you, however, you seem to be siding against those who are claiming that they can prove that God and/or free will cannot possibly exist.

-Bri
 
It might help if you continued reading on to the end of the statement, rather than just stopping half way through. Here is what I actually said:

3. A true statement made about the world in the world exists at a specific time (t) (Hyp logically possible from Arg 1)

There - does that help?

No, it doesn't really help. If you're not assuming your hypotheticals to be true, then I admit that I don't understand your proof. I'll let ceo_esq comment if he can make more sense of it than I have. I still don't see that you've proven your conclusion since nothing in your proof even pertains to the conclusion, but perhaps it's just my lack of understanding.

-Bri
 
It is not simply misrepresenting the opposite opinion. Ossai posted a correct definition here.

Well, mine is this, from the secular web:

"The straw man fallacy is when you misrepresent someone else's position so that it can be attacked more easily, knock down that misrepresented position, then conclude that the original position has been demolished. It's a fallacy because it fails to deal with the actual arguments that have been made."
 
Well, mine is this, from the secular web:

"The straw man fallacy is when you misrepresent someone else's position so that it can be attacked more easily, knock down that misrepresented position, then conclude that the original position has been demolished. It's a fallacy because it fails to deal with the actual arguments that have been made."

I can accept that definition. Not only does the straw man fallacy require misrepresenting another position, but it requires having done so for the purpose of being able to refute a simpler argument than the one presented.

I may very well have been mistaken about something (I'm certainly not perfect), but that would not qualify as a straw man.

For future reference, if someone does invoke a fallacy, it is seldom constructive to assume that it was done on purpose, and even less constructive to throw out accusations without showing specifically where the fallacy was made and correcting it. Unless you're simply attempting an ad hominem attack, which is a fallacy itself.

-Bri
 
No, it doesn't really help. If you're not assuming your hypotheticals to be true, then I admit that I don't understand your proof. I'll let ceo_esq comment if he can make more sense of it than I have. I still don't see that you've proven your conclusion since nothing in your proof even pertains to the conclusion, but perhaps it's just my lack of understanding.

-Bri
On the other hand it could also be my line references which are pretty askew.

But no step in a deductive argument can pertain to the conclusion - that would be a big and nasty fallacy. The propositions must pertain to a previous proposition, an assumption/premise or a definition.

Rather the conclusion should pertain to some previous proposition or definition and make this explicit. My references are mixed up which is my bad. A result of using the list tag and not being able to see the line numbers.

But if you mean that the conclusion (which is line 11) does not follow from the other propositions in the argument then you will have to be more specific and it should be fairly easy to do this, just start from the conclusion and work backwards.

Having been badgered for deductive arguments (although I had already supplied them) I feel justified in badgering back for responses that are a little more specific than "nothing in your proof even pertains to the conclusion".

For example would the conclusion in line 11 be a valid reductio ad absurdum if propositions 9 and 10 were valid? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.

If my definition of free will and propositions 5 and 6 were all valid would proposition 10 be a valid deduction? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.

If my definition of omniscience and proposition 8 were valid would propostion 9 be a valid deduction? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.

Is proposition 8 a logically possible consequence of propositions 2,3 and 4? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.

Are propositions 5,6 and 7 logically possible consequences of the definition of free will? If not, why not? If so then we can tick these steps and work backwards.

Is proposition 4 a consequence of the definition of omnipotence? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.

Is proposition 3 a hypothesis logically possible from the premise? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and work backwards.

Is Proposition 2 a consequence of the premise and the definition of omniscience? If not, why not? If so then we can tick this step and say that my conclusion does follow from my argument.

So unless I have broken some rule of logic I am justified in saying !P1.

The statement An omniscient being G participates in a universe in which at least one agent has free will is not a logical possibility according to the definitions stated.

The only thing I can see that I left out was a definition for the predicate "participates in".

Note this evaluation does not guarantee my proof is valid, but it is the first step.

So let me clean up the line references and restate the argument.
 
Last edited:
To fix up a couple of errors, here is the argument 1 again:
Definitions:
1. Free will : A has free will if for at least on action voluntarily performed by A at time t the possibility existed before t that A had the ability to perform that action but did not.
2. Free choice : A choice can said to be free if it could not (even theoretically) be deduced from causal antecedents
3. Will (1) : the ability to form intentions and follow through on them
4. Omniscient : Knows every true proposition and does not believe any proposition that is not true.
5. God : Creator of all things that has at least the properties of omnipotence, omniscience and omnibenevolence
6. Predictable (1): Predictable(f) means that (a=f(x)&b=f(y))->(x==y->a==b)
7. Predictable (2): Can (at least theoretically) be deduced from causal antecedents
8. Participates in: G participates in a physical universe U if G can produce some effect in U that can be at least indirectly empirically measured in U.
That an omniscient being cannot participate in a universe that contains free will:
Argument 1 (semi-formalisation of my safe example):
1. An omniscient being G participates in a universe in which at least one agent has free will (Assumption)
2. G can make a true statement (s) about the world in the world (T Def 4, Arg 1)
3. A true statement made about the world in the world exists at a specific time (t) (Hyp logically possible from Arg 1)
4. A statement at time t can be about an action at time t1 where t1 > t (T Def 4)
5. Let A be a free agent (Hyp from 1)
6. Let a(A,t) be an action performed by free agent A at time t. (Hyp from 1)
7. Let a1 and a2 be the possible actions for A at time t (Hyp from Def 1)
8. A true statement s by G exists at time t and says that a(A,t1) == a1 (Hyp logically possible from 2,3,4)
9. The probability given t<t1 that a(A,t1) == a1 is 1 (Ded Def 4, Arg 1,8)
10. The probability given t<t1 that a(A,t1) == a1 is not 1 (Ded Def 1, Arg 5,6)
11. We reject the hypothesis (RAA 1,9,10)
 
There is no god. This is my working hypothesis. There is no evidence to the contrary. What theists regard as evidence of a god is mere garbage.
But a theist would alter this statement to say:
There is a god. This is my working hypothesis. There is no evidence to the contrary. What atheists regard as evidence of a no god is mere garbage.
So why is the theist's statement less reasonable than yours? That is really the question that is being debated here.

I think that is at least an interesting question.
 
Nice try, Robin, but vapid.

I don't believe that your discussion is one that is worth having.

I don't think that you are well-equipped to engage in such a discussion.

I think there are much more interesting ways of spending my time.

Babble on as you wish. I'll check back later and see if you've learned when enough is enough.
 
Nice try, Robin, but vapid.

I don't believe that your discussion is one that is worth having.

I don't think that you are well-equipped to engage in such a discussion.

I think there are much more interesting ways of spending my time.

Babble on as you wish. I'll check back later and see if you've learned when enough is enough.
It is funny how some atheists seem to think that just because they are atheists they must also be rational and brilliant critical thinkers.

So they assume that whatever random words issue forth from their mouths or fingertips must be Bertrand effing Russell.

Don't bother checking back - just be happy in your little dreamworld.
 
Having been badgered for deductive arguments (although I had already supplied them) I feel justified in badgering back for responses that are a little more specific than "nothing in your proof even pertains to the conclusion".

I agree that you are justified, and will provide more details when I have more time. By the way, I wasn't badgering for deductive arguments, only that the arguments that some were claiming were hidden among multiple posts be articulated. I do remember your already having supplied the proofs, and thought it a good idea that you repost them so that folks didn't have to go searching for them, but I think ceo_esq missed the proofs you posted the first time and wanted to see them.

That said, this one seemed fairly straightforward, but I don't understand what you mean by "hyp" which is in parenthesis after most of the key the lines. If you don't assume those lines to be true, then it doesn't seem that there's much left of the proof.

-Bri
 
It is funny how some atheists seem to think that just because they are atheists they must also be rational and brilliant critical thinkers.

So they assume that whatever random words issue forth from their mouths or fingertips must be Bertrand effing Russell.

Don't bother checking back - just be happy in your little dreamworld.

Sorry, Robin, but I can't oblige you - I've got to check in every so often.

Must keep an eye on the woos.
 
I've pondered on this for a while and I have now shifted my position slightly on the free will issue. In the context of this thread I recind my claim that free will has been disproved. I have not changed my fundemental position but rather, the tack on which I think it makes sense to argue the point.

It is clear that we cannot present a tight disproof of a concept that has the loose definitions presented by the proponents of its possibility to exist. This is why we have been going around in circles.

I now think of it another way - 'free will' does exist. However, the free will that exists is simply an effect of the consciousness, a mental process. We could go on from that position to explore additional arguments about whether the choices we make are predetermined or have a random element.

The key point here, though, is that free will is an effect or a perception of the concsiousness resulting from the complex interaction of caused and / or possibly uncaused events. To put it another way, we know that we have 'will' and we percieve it as 'free' therefore we can be said to have 'free will'.

Now, if someone wants to argue that free will is not that or is more than that then the onus is upon them to give some evidence or credible logical argument. In the context of this thread they particularly have to show how the free will described above can give us accountability before an omniscient God.
 
Last edited:
For future reference, if someone does invoke a fallacy, it is seldom constructive to assume that it was done on purpose, and even less constructive to throw out accusations without showing specifically where the fallacy was made and correcting it. Unless you're simply attempting an ad hominem attack, which is a fallacy itself.

Oh, no. Fallacies can be made unknowingly. I agree.
 
I've pondered on this for a while and I have now shifted my position slightly on the free will issue. In the context of this thread I recind my claim that free will has been disproved. I have not changed my fundemental position but rather, the tack on which I think it makes sense to argue the point.

It is clear that we cannot present a tight disproof of a concept that has the loose definitions presented by the proponents of its possibility to exist. This is why we have been going around in circles.

I now think of it another way - 'free will' does exist. However, the free will that exists is simply an effect of the consciousness, a mental process. We could go on from that position to explore additional arguments about whether the choices we make are predetermined or have a random element.

The key point here, though, is that free will is an effect or a perception of the concsiousness resulting from the complex interaction of caused and / or possibly uncaused events. To put it another way, we know that we have 'will' and we percieve it as 'free' therefore we can be said to have 'free will'.

Now, if someone wants to argue that free will is not that or is more than that then the onus is upon them to give some evidence or credible logical argument. In the context of this thread they particularly have to show how the free will described above can give us accountability before an omniscient God.

In other words, you're going with 'practical free will'. Good - a step in the right direction.
 
I now think of it another way - 'free will' does exist. However, the free will that exists is simply an effect of the consciousness, a mental process. We could go on from that position to explore additional arguments about whether the choices we make are predetermined or have a random element.

I completely agree that practical free will as you describe is perhaps more likely than libertarian free will to be reality. However, if you are saying that it is a fact that libertarian free will (something other than strict causation or randomness) can be ruled out as a possibility (is impossible) then the burden would be on you to prove it.

However, if you admit that it's possible that libertarian free will exists then you have truly joined the other side of the argument.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Bri
Timeless doesn't mean "existing at all times" but rather it means "existing at no time" or in other words completely outside of and unrestricted by the timeline.
Actually from Merrian-Webster:
Timeless
1 archaic : PREMATURE, UNTIMELY
2 a : having no beginning or end : ETERNAL b : not restricted to a particular time or date <the timeless themes of love, solitude, joy, and nature -- Writer>
3 : not affected by time : AGELESS

That you would say that I'm lying because I was pointing out an alternate definition of omniscience is absolutely astounding! My other point (a problem with Robin's conclusion) had nothing whatsoever to do with this alternate definition.
Again from Merriam-Webster
Omniscient
1 : having infinite awareness, understanding, and insight
2 : possessed of universal or complete knowledge

None of the other sources I checked had your definition either. So what alternate definition are you speaking of?

Timeless knowledge would be assumed to exist at all times, not just time t.
No, it would exist at no time (completely outside of the timeline).
Wow, another Bri-esk definition. You’re on a roll today, how many more words can you mangle?

You would have to prove that God cannot interact with the world without causing his knowledge to enter the timeline (whatever that would mean).
Fine, first prove god exists.

In the programmer example, the programmer can interact with the world (add walls to the world, for example) without his knowledge of future events ever entering or affecting the world at all.
Are you serious? The programmer knows that the agent, A, will go straight from t-30 to t-20. The programmer places a wall in the agents path such that the agent will collide with the wall at t-25. What will happen at t-25?

Ossai
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom