There is No God (And You Know It)

Really? Name one human who can do anything that's possible to do. For that matter, name one human who can do anything that's humanly possible to do.

Oh, you want me to name names?! I knew a SEAL once who was close.

My point was - if God can only do things that are possible - then miracles vanish. A God without miracles is like a day without sunshine.
 
Really? Name one human who can do anything that's possible to do. For that matter, name one human who can do anything that's humanly possible to do.

Oh, you want me to name names?! I knew a SEAL once who was close, but he couldn't dance well.

My point was - if God can only do things that are possible - then miracles vanish. A God without miracles is like a day without sunshine. Thus, God becomes moot...and a moot God is a human.

[I may misunderstand what you mean by 'possible', because now you make an additional distinction by saying 'humanly possible'. Please explain this difference.]
 
[I may misunderstand what you mean by 'possible', because now you make an additional distinction by saying 'humanly possible'. Please explain this difference.]

There is "physically possible," meaning what can be done that is not in violation of the laws of physics, and then there is "logically possible," meaning whatever is potentially conceivable, that is, what does not violate the rules of logic.
 
Oh, you want me to name names?! I knew a SEAL once who was close, but he couldn't dance well.

My point was - if God can only do things that are possible - then miracles vanish. A God without miracles is like a day without sunshine. Thus, God becomes moot...and a moot God is a human.

[I may misunderstand what you mean by 'possible', because now you make an additional distinction by saying 'humanly possible'. Please explain this difference.]

A miracle is simply an event that appears inexplicable by the laws of nature and so is held to be supernatural in origin or an act of God. There's nothing in that definition that states that a miracle is impossible. Indeed, if God can do it (even if it's supernatural) then it's possible.

My point here is that the statement that God can't make a "square circle" and therefore can't do "everything" and therefore isn't omnipotent is nonsense. Let's just pretend that God can't do "everything" but can only do a limited subset of "everything" that we'll call "things that are logically possible." Does that make God any less all-powerful?

Put another way, you might claim to be able to count all integers between 1 and 10, but I could say that you skipped those integers that are in-between the integers that exist, and therefore you don't have the ability that you claim. Does that mean that you can't count all integers between 1 and 10 or does that simply mean that my definition of "integer" is irrational?

Likewise, a definition of omnipotence as "being able to do everything including things that are impossible" is irrational.

-Bri
 
That is a powerful sentiment... but there is a world of difference between the existence of an entity and the existence of an emotion. God as a general hypothesis may not be testible, but you start giving details such as omnipotence and omnibenevolence, and suddenly there's something worth debating.


Thanks for the help, Gnome, I was thinking of this point but did not quite get around to it.

The Thread is: "There is No God (And You Know It)." My intention was to offer an alternative mode of, for lack of a better word, "thinking" about God in relation to the negation. Instead of focusing just on the "something worth debating" using logic and employing words such as omni this or omni that, maybe the authentic seeker would also benefit by using an aspect of the inner being other than the intellect in the search for or understanding of whom we call God. What might that aspect of the inner person be? Well the statement that God IS as Spiritual Love has more to do with ontology than it does with emotion, so just using our emotions in the accessing or understanding of God may not be primary. I can't say for certain what that aspect of the inner person may be which is best suited for understanding God. The only thing I can think of at this time is that it is the inner part of the psyche which loves at the most profound level--not love for self pleasure or survival, not love for romance or procreation--but Love as the utmost action in and for the utmost reality available to the human race. :)
 
Last edited:
Bri
For the sake of argument, let's say that God's power is "limited" in the sense that God can "only" do anything that is possible to do. Does that make him less than all-powerful?
Yes.
If you look at the miracles in the bible examine how they were possible to do, you’ll come up with one of two answers. It was a trick of some kind (what we would now call an illusion or conjuring trick) or it was a miracle. Since the bible purports that they were miracles then “possible to do” gets thrown out.

jjramsey
What I acknowledge is that your definition of omnipotence is illogical. You were the one who introduced the idea that omnipotence must entail the ability to do the logically impossible.
Nope, reference miracles. God is supposed to have done miracles, which by their very definition they are illogical.

Hey look, a straw man.
Sorry but it’s not a straw man.

There is "physically possible," meaning what can be done that is not in violation of the laws of physics, and then there is "logically possible," meaning whatever is potentially conceivable, that is, what does not violate the rules of logic.
You’re being weasely. If god can do the physically impossible, then god could change the laws of nature (physics, chemistry, geometry, etc) to make the logically impossible no longer impossible.

Or to put it anther way. It's possible if god did it or you can imagine god doing it, but if you can't then it becomes impossible/illogical.

Ossai
 
Yes.
If you look at the miracles in the bible examine how they were possible to do, you’ll come up with one of two answers. It was a trick of some kind (what we would now call an illusion or conjuring trick) or it was a miracle. Since the bible purports that they were miracles then “possible to do” gets thrown out.

You're using an incorrect definition of the word "miracle." A miracle is not defined as "something that is impossible." It is rather something that cannot be explained by the laws of nature. If God performs miracles as suggested in the Bible, then those miracles are certainly possible (just perhaps not by us) in the same way that we cannot fly unaided and yet unaided flight is possible (by birds, not by us). That we can't perform miracles because we are natural beings doesn't make miracles impossible for supernatural beings.

See this post where I previously responded to this question in more detail.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
If god can do the physically impossible, then god could change the laws of nature (physics, chemistry, geometry, etc) to make the logically impossible no longer impossible.

You are conflating "physically impossible" and "logically impossible."
 
Not so much off-topic.

It takes more than God to eradicate evil. Satan has to cry Uncle!

If that is so, then would that mean then that if I don't like what is written on a piece of paper and I wish to eradicate it, that the simple burning of it won't make it go away? That it has to cry Uncle first?
 
Can you give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible?

can the last two words be shaped to = "illogically possible"? If so, then the parameters of this are easier to understand and perhaps give an example for.

Like...it's physically possible for a human to screw an elephant, but would also be illogically possible. I'm sure there are even better examples, but I'm not into doing abstract thinking right now. I'll let somebody else.
 
Bri
Yes.
If you look at the miracles in the bible examine how they were possible to do, you’ll come up with one of two answers. It was a trick of some kind (what we would now call an illusion or conjuring trick) or it was a miracle. Since the bible purports that they were miracles then “possible to do” gets thrown out.

jjramsey
Nope, reference miracles. God is supposed to have done miracles, which by their very definition they are illogical.

Sorry but it’s not a straw man.

You’re being weasely. If god can do the physically impossible, then god could change the laws of nature (physics, chemistry, geometry, etc) to make the logically impossible no longer impossible.

Or to put it anther way. It's possible if god did it or you can imagine god doing it, but if you can't then it becomes impossible/illogical.

Ossai

I don't agree. If God can do it, the seeming impossible is actually possible. It is just only known by God how to do it. Just like a magician, the trick would be impossible to you...until of course you were shown the trick!

God can turn water into wine. Impossible? Ya...for us...right NOW. But because every chemical in the universe is inter-related and God knows all the formulas...he probably has the key to the formula and can do as he choses to rearrange things. Right?

So why aren't these seeming impossible things just going on all the time then? Why not wine that becones water all the time? Because God said so, that's why. He wanted water to be water. That's why water is water. Yet, God, if he wants to, can change the rules for when he wants. And obviously it was possible to do. So it is possible, even if WE can't do it...yet. There were lots of things in the past that we couldn't do, but now we can. Flying used to be impossible. Now it's possible. Walking on water was and is impossible. Yet, one day perhaps man will master how to change water to ice through some trick and be able to walk on water. Maybe that's how jesus did it. He altered the molecular alignment below his feet. Then altered his skin to grip like sandpaper.
 
Can you give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible?

Of course not. The physically possible is a subset of the logically possible. Now as for things that are logically possible, but physically impossible, examples abound:

  • Pigs flying.
  • Turning lead into gold.
  • Water flowing uphill.
  • and on and on . . .

None of those things are physically possible, but they don't fall afoul of the laws of logic.
 
Can you give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible?

c4ts, your logic is usually impeccable, but not in this case.

jjramsey said that physically impossible is not the same as logically impossible:

A = physically impossible
B = logically impossible

A != B

You asked him to give an example of something which is not A but is B. How exactly does that show that A = B?

Hint: substitute "car" for A and "vehicle" for B. Can you give me an example of something that is not a vehicle but is a car? Is a car the same thing as a vehicle?

The hole in this logic is large enough to drive a bus through, which is ironically a vehicle but not a car.

-Bri
 
A miracle is simply an event that appears inexplicable by the laws of nature and so is held to be supernatural in origin or an act of God.

Miracles don't just 'appear inexplicable' - they defy the laws of 'nature'. One has to suspend belief in these laws to believe the miracles occurred.

Of course, any right-thinking individual will conclude the miracle DID NOT happen and that the tale containing the miracle (passed down through generations) became more and more convoluted.

These, so called, miracles occur in all religions. But in other religions they are not believed as fact. It is the religions of the tribal god Yahweh (Judaism, Islam, Christianity) which seem to stubbornly believe miracles as facts.

If God-boy changes water into wine - it doesn't 'appear inexplicable' - it IS inexplicable. But as the subject of this thread knows - There is no God - There are no miracles.
 
c4ts, your logic is usually impeccable, but not in this case.

jjramsey said that physically impossible is not the same as logically impossible:

A = physically impossible
B = logically impossible

A != B

But jjramsey said A is a subset of B. So doesn't A = B? (However B doesn't necessarily equal A). If this is true then your initial equation is wrong.
 
Miracles don't just 'appear inexplicable' - they defy the laws of 'nature'. One has to suspend belief in these laws to believe the miracles occurred.

No, one only need to believe that some things are beyond the laws of nature, that the laws of nature don't apply to those things. God, who presumably created the laws of nature, would be beyond the laws of nature. You cannot prove otherwise, I'm afraid, since science only applies to nature.

-Bri
 
The physically possible is a subset of the logically possible. Now as for things that are logically possible, but physically impossible, examples abound:

  • Pigs flying.
  • Turning lead into gold.
  • Water flowing uphill.

    None of those things are physically possible, but they don't fall afoul of the laws of logic.


  • You are going to have to explain this to me. I agree none of these things are physically possible - but I don't think they are logically possible either.
 
But jjramsey said A is a subset of B.

Yes.

So doesn't A = B?

No. A car is a type of vehicle (subset), but a vehicle and a car are not the same thing (equality). A bus is also a type of vehicle, but is not a car. If a car and a vehicle were the same thing, then a bus would be a type of car.

(However B doesn't necessarily equal A).

If A = B then B = A, but in this case, A != B and B != A. A is a subset of B (and B is not a subset of A).

If this is true then your initial equation is wrong.

It's not, and it's not.

-Bri
 
No, one only need to believe that some things are beyond the laws of nature, that the laws of nature don't apply to those things. God, who presumably created the laws of nature, would be beyond the laws of nature. You cannot prove otherwise, I'm afraid, since science only applies to nature.


For you to attempt to prove an imaginary creature created scientific laws for Earth people - and regularly violates these laws for personal or tribal reasons - is much harder than my proof.

All I have to submit is - a miracle never happened. Not only does such an event violate the laws of science - such an event has never been witnessed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom