There is No God (And You Know It)

The apologists come out in force when faced with the concept of good and evil and an omnipotent God, but in the process only prove that all the hoops you have to jump through to justify God's behaviour is a pretty good indicator that he doesn't exist at all.

That's just it, though: it's an indicator, but not a proof. Sam Harris is trying to have the Argument from Evil bear more evidential weight than it can support.
 
If the sole basis for the existence of god stems from the premise "You can't prove he doesn't exist" then I think that shows how incredibly weak the argument for his existence is.

You know that isn't the case though. However "you can't prove electrons don't exist" is a small but key part of the argument for the existance of electrons since if you could prove they didn't exist we would have a problem.
 
I never cease to be amazed by the fact that the same people who can so smugly accept as proven fact that a horse can be bred from a bacterium in four billion years...

You are aware there was stuff in between the bacterium and the horse, right?

Yes, and Ronald Reagan could have ended the cold war on his first inauguration day; all he had to do was push the button. But, looking back, do you think that Reagan might have had some reasons for pursuing a more drawn-out strategy? Does anyone really regret the fact that he didn't nuke the Soviets the first time he had a chance?

This is slightly off-topic - but I must correct a misconception that appears to be common with laypeople. There is no 'button' for anyone to push. If the President wanted to start a nuclear war on his Inauguration Day - he couldn't do it, because of the checks and balances inherent in our NC2 System. It takes more than one person to launch a nuclear war. It also takes an 'evolution' of events.
 
What a strange life you must lead. Never to have heard of the koran or the bible or torah or the veldic texts behind hinduism etc. You may not except these as enough evidence to come to the conclusion that god does exist but they are evidence non the less.

Further more the logical end point of your position is that certian roman emperors did not in fact exist nor did any of the pharos. Of course this is simply due to your failer to define your terms.

OK let me insert the unspoken word "credible". Or perhaps I should say externally supported evidence for the existence of god.
I have heard of no more credible evidence for the existence of god than i have for superman.

Pedantry can be taken too far you know, your post adds nothing whatsoever to the debate.
 
OK let me insert the unspoken word "credible". Or perhaps I should say externally supported evidence for the existence of god.
I have heard of no more credible evidence for the existence of god than i have for superman.

Pedantry can be taken too far you know, your post adds nothing whatsoever to the debate.

It is a very important disitinction. It is a common error for sceptics to say that there is no evidence for X,Y or Z. Thus when the beliver comes up with some evidence regardless of it's credibilty it damages your position more than it would if you took a less absolutist postion.
 
It is a very important disitinction. It is a common error for sceptics to say that there is no evidence for X,Y or Z. Thus when the beliver comes up with some evidence regardless of it's credibilty it damages your position more than it would if you took a less absolutist postion.

that of course depends how you define "evidence".
I do not belive that the bible is evidence for the exsistance of god any mroe than superman commics are evidens of superman. Beceasue in their most important claims they lack independent verifaction.
 
I never cease to be amazed by the fact that the same people who can so smugly accept as proven fact that a horse can be bred from a bacterium in four billion years nevertheless kick and scream and threaten to turn blue in the face at the notion that God might take a mere few hundred human lifetimes in order to completely and unconditionally defeat evil and the evil one for all eternity.

Yes, I know the next line in the litany: "If there is a God, he should be able to do [fill in the blank] right now!" Sounds like a certain three-year old I remember. Yes, and Ronald Reagan could have ended the cold war on his first inauguration day; all he had to do was push the button. But, looking back, do you think that Reagan might have had some reasons for pursuing a more drawn-out strategy? Does anyone really regret the fact that he didn't nuke the Soviets the first time he had a chance? If not, then can your feeble minds perhaps stretch enough to make the connection that God, as well, might have some reason for delaying the last judgment? And that, when the day comes when we know all of the relevant facts, we too might agree that he was right to do so?
Is this a comparison of Ronald Reagan to God? or God to Ronald Reagan?

Either way:

:dl:
 
I find this sort of argument tedious as hell, but the comparison of "God" to Ronald Reagan was comic entertainment of the highest stripe. Thanks for that.
 
ehbowen --- Could you demonstrate more clearly what preventing a hurricane has in common with perpetrating a global nuclear holocaust?

Otherwise I question the validity of your analogy.

You are making an invalid linkage--although it is valid if you include a few more steps. "Perpetrating a global nuclear holocaust" is, in my analogy, comparable to the immense and permanent collateral damage which could ensue if God were to attack Satan and his current domains by main force. Instead, God chooses for the moment to maintain the status quo--which is comparable to allowing the cold war to continue. But it would appear that one of the requirements to allow humanity to survive under those circumstances is a geologically and atmospherically active planet--which means that earthquakes, tsunamis, and hurricanes periodically occur. (Of course, if you can construct a workable ecosystem, complete down to the DNA level, which does not require geological and atmospheric activity, I'd be interested in seeing it.)

So in my cold war analogy, tsunamis and hurricanes et al. are comparable to the frequent food shortages and summary executions which were experienced behind the iron curtain. Would we like to eliminate them? Of course we would--and, prophetically, it appears that some day God will. But for the time being they are, perhaps, a requisite corollary of a world whose ownership is contested between good and evil.
 
Arguments for athiesm? Meh. Arguments are reserved for people with things to prove.
 
Exellent. I await with bated breath for evil to finally be eradicated from this world by God, who, by garsh, is giving it his best shot. Kinda like Reagan, I guess (Oh man! Someone is actually comparing Reagan to GOD!!)

Or perhaps some of the feeble minds who are defending God might just explore the notion that the delay in eradicating evil on God's part is soley the product of his non-existence.
It makes much more sense than the alternative. The apologists come out in force when faced with the concept of good and evil and an omnipotent God, but in the process only prove that all the hoops you have to jump through to justify God's behaviour is a pretty good indicator that he doesn't exist at all.

Pascal's wager is good as far as it goes, but for my money it doesn't go far enough. If (I'll say "if", to humor you) a God exists, I am not satisfied to simply believe in that God or go through a few religious motions; I intend to actively pursue and search after that God with the objective of achieving direct two-way contact, in this world and in this life. (Which God, to answer the most common objection to PW? Whichever one answers a call directed to the ultimate authority in the universe--if there is more than one candidate, I'll let them fight it out and take the winner at his or her word.) If you are correct and there is no such God, then I have lost nothing--I am content with my life as it is. If I am correct, however--jackpot.

I am convinced by what I have seen so far that I am on the right track. It's little that would convince you, I'm sure--largely circumstances which were too cute to be "coincidence". But it has convinced me to keep on seeking--and to expect, at the right time, that big payoff.
 
Sam Harris is now the most eloquent and incisive spokesperson for atheism that I am aware of.

I give him credit for eloquence, but not for being insightful. He has dealt very superficially with the Problem of Evil, but it's his eloquence that helps hide this superficiality.

A Salon review of his book The End of Faith shows some of his weaknesses:

On the role of religious moderates, perhaps the most important aspect of the question of how religion should factor into public life, Harris' polemic is inconsistent even before you hold it up to the facts. On page 45, "religious moderates are, in large part, responsible for the religious conflict in our world" but on page 152 Muslim moderates hold "the fate of civilization" in their hands because only they can "reshape their religion into an ideology that is basically benign."

. . . Harris finds himself floating the idea that "some propositions are so dangerous that it may even be ethical to kill people for believing them." How -- despite Harris' strenuous efforts to distinguish good, rational belief systems from noxious, irrational ones -- this differs significantly from executing people for blasphemy and other thought crimes is hard to say.

(The above is from the fourth page of the review.)
 
So in summary, God is caring, but incompetent. :p

"Caring" is a much different term than omni-benevolent. Caring implies action or inaction at least to be verifiable. Caring also implies a perspective. But I get your point. Can an omni-benevolent God be uncaring? Probably not.

So yes, I believe God is caring.

Incompetent assumes much. First of all I find the concept of omnipotence as logically ineffable, because all-powerful is basically assuming not only an infinite action verb, but also an all encompassing action verb, meaning it is omni-X in every logically possible situation...

This is much more than a mere adjective of description. It carries embedded in the grammar a logical fallacy, like saying "omni-victorious." If your favorite sports team is omni-victorious than it logically negates the possibility of an unwinnable game. "Omni" here has to mean that in every and all possible situations, your team will neither lose nor tie. It will always win, meaning that anyone who constructs an omni-word utilizing an adjective dentoing action, any reasonable person can construct a logically contradictary sentence with the very same omni-word.

Example: The omniscient archeologist unearthed an unsolvalbe mystery in ancient Egypt.

When it comes to the assumed god's power or lack of power, I would be more likely to hasten us to think of ourselves as incompetent if the said god truly exists on both sides of our timeline and in every logically possible universe.

I think at this point we need to define "good" and "evil", the definition I tend to work from "evil"= suffering, and "good"= the negation of suffering. Comments?

That assumes that suffering is evil. It's not my assumption. Suffering is evil to me, especially when its my own.

from your posts i understand that Your definition of "good" is the negation of suffering which has already taken place, this does logically require"evil" in order to exist, but I do not agree that all other forms of "good" are just "quasi-good"

Not exactly, charity can be demonstrated in the presence of suffering. Without charity, there can be no omni-benevolence. Therefore suffering is needed, the only question is how much and who decides.

I would argue that your definition focuses too much on the process, and not on the outcome.

To which I'd say we are in no position to judge the outcome.

Is more good achieved by a hungry man finding food, or by another man giving him food?

Another man giving him food is a different form of good, and to be "all good" any definition must logically include this form.

Also by my definition of "good" and "evil", natural disasters are "evil" by definition as they casue suffering.

Not by mine.

If you disagree with my definition of "evil", fine don't call it the problem of evil, call it the problem of suffering. The problem still stands, how is it better to allow some members of humanity to suffer, to allow god to show how "good" he is by reducing that suffering for some people, some of the time?

That's the right question. It is a question of quantity, not presence.

God cannot logically be both Omnipotent and Omni-benevolence

Correct. This assumes that our experience is real, in a real timeline that will last and be the final state of our existence. This is a reasonalbe assumption, and given our experience (which is all we have) God is not omnipotent. This isn't to say that our experience is in fact real, we can only assume that it is. A truly omnipotent God could have a multiverse of processs & outcomes from which to generate a complete timeline without suffering. But this is less reasonable than assuming God in our timeline is limited.

The whole debate is hypothetical, until such time as we have evidence for they existence of god (or gods).

God is not hypothetical to me. God is hypothetical to "you," and God more importantly for the purpose of our discussion, God must remain hypothetical to "us."

Flick
 
Something else to consider:

If God is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent... then 'evil' does not truly exist, save as a cultural artifact specific to the lesser beings who codify 'good' and 'evil'. As such, if God is omnibenevolent, then pain, death, suffering, disaster, etc. is all Good.

Look at the food chain: certainly, it is good that a lioness take down a gazelle, feed her young, and continue the propagation of her species; and, perhaps, contribute to the overall good of the gazelle tribe, by helping to prevent overpopulation. But is it good for the gazelle who must die? We rarely apply our attention to the problem of good and evil for animals, because we assume that the cycle of life is natural and therefore good.

What, in all the observable universe, is not natural? It must, therefore, be good...

So either good and evil don't exist as a dichotomous state beyond human conception, or good and evil are present as a natural part of the universe, and God is not 'omnibenevolent' at all.
 
Something else to consider:

If God is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent... then 'evil' does not truly exist, save as a cultural artifact specific to the lesser beings who codify 'good' and 'evil'. As such, if God is omnibenevolent, then pain, death, suffering, disaster, etc. is all Good.

Look at the food chain: certainly, it is good that a lioness take down a gazelle, feed her young, and continue the propagation of her species; and, perhaps, contribute to the overall good of the gazelle tribe, by helping to prevent overpopulation. But is it good for the gazelle who must die? We rarely apply our attention to the problem of good and evil for animals, because we assume that the cycle of life is natural and therefore good.

What, in all the observable universe, is not natural? It must, therefore, be good...

So either good and evil don't exist as a dichotomous state beyond human conception, or good and evil are present as a natural part of the universe, and God is not 'omnibenevolent' at all.

But how can benovlance exsist when there is no good or evil?
 
You are making an invalid linkage--although it is valid if you include a few more steps. "Perpetrating a global nuclear holocaust" is, in my analogy, comparable to the immense and permanent collateral damage which could ensue if God were to attack Satan and his current domains by main force.

I'm trying to figure out why there would be any collateral damage. Could God not simply will out of existence Satan and anyone else who has to go?

It's exciting to imagine God having to go to war, but it's not consistent with being all-powerful.
 
The God familys make things work but they also do caculate the wrong...which is worry...things slip...the whole things is...if you think about a certain things for so long...like reading this...it will provoke things to go that way....eventually it will go into action unless you are preconsciously amazing...or logical enough to find a purpose for such a scenario...but if infl;uence a mass of people...worrying will cause alot of porblems...why alot people aren't aloud power...becasue they do not fit requirements...but that is just christian terms...if you want to be like I...into forensics and beastly hood and psycokinesis....you got to gain the logic and power...these christain scenario creators, or the fabrication of karma into destiny takes a logic so great...you have to be able to caculate what exactly is going to come together and how to make it work with all natural systems and man made systems...

Christains have been trying to pull down the heavens for years...what a storm that manages to stablize it self....see they are so powerful in the heaven bond that they create storms and catastrophe....


when the satanist aren't even bad...infact...they follow natural causes...Im just not for the impulse...IM wiccan...I like earth and the universe...I like to share special terrestrial powers with animals...like I am a beast...I just don't like to act upon impulse or instinct...even though repression of such things cause problems...and horrible expression...they could easly be put back into nature of animals who must kill...but statnist do not belive this...because balancing power or abilty between all terrestrials...is stupid...where as Christains try to make us all super human...I'd rather be both...wiccan...


God was a man to smart for even some of the smartest people today...he knew how to make things work and happen...he started a huge empire all contributing to his Power...The compsoing of both God and Satan, Jah and Lucifer are from eygpt....Niether are bad...this or neither mean a damn things to yo... or you will be foghting yourself for years untill you come to this conclusion...
 
I'm trying to figure out why there would be any collateral damage. Could God not simply will out of existence Satan and anyone else who has to go?

It's exciting to imagine God having to go to war, but it's not consistent with being all-powerful.

Furtehr more, why did god create Satan in the first place?
 
Everything that is written about Godand satan is ********...the truth can be seen through history and present day...now lets prognosticate
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom