So in summary, God is caring, but incompetent.
"Caring" is a much different term than omni-benevolent. Caring implies action or inaction at least to be verifiable. Caring also implies a perspective. But I get your point. Can an omni-benevolent God be uncaring? Probably not.
So yes, I believe God is caring.
Incompetent assumes much. First of all I find the concept of omnipotence as
logically ineffable, because all-powerful is basically assuming not only an infinite action verb, but also an all encompassing action verb, meaning it is omni-X in every logically possible situation...
This is much more than a mere adjective of description. It carries embedded in the grammar a logical fallacy, like saying "omni-victorious." If your favorite sports team is omni-victorious than it logically negates the possibility of an unwinnable game. "Omni" here has to mean that in every and all possible situations, your team will neither lose nor tie. It will always win, meaning that anyone who constructs an omni-word utilizing an adjective dentoing action, any reasonable person can construct a logically contradictary sentence with the very same omni-word.
Example: The omniscient archeologist unearthed an unsolvalbe mystery in ancient Egypt.
When it comes to the assumed god's power or lack of power, I would be more likely to hasten us to think of ourselves as incompetent if the said god truly exists on both sides of our timeline and in every logically possible universe.
I think at this point we need to define "good" and "evil", the definition I tend to work from "evil"= suffering, and "good"= the negation of suffering. Comments?
That assumes that suffering is evil. It's not my assumption. Suffering is evil to me, especially when its my own.
from your posts i understand that Your definition of "good" is the negation of suffering which has already taken place, this does logically require"evil" in order to exist, but I do not agree that all other forms of "good" are just "quasi-good"
Not exactly, charity can be demonstrated in the presence of suffering. Without charity, there can be no omni-benevolence. Therefore suffering is needed, the only question is how much and who decides.
I would argue that your definition focuses too much on the process, and not on the outcome.
To which I'd say we are in no position to judge the outcome.
Is more good achieved by a hungry man finding food, or by another man giving him food?
Another man giving him food is a different form of good, and to be "all good" any definition must logically include this form.
Also by my definition of "good" and "evil", natural disasters are "evil" by definition as they casue suffering.
Not by mine.
If you disagree with my definition of "evil", fine don't call it the problem of evil, call it the problem of suffering. The problem still stands, how is it better to allow some members of humanity to suffer, to allow god to show how "good" he is by reducing that suffering for some people, some of the time?
That's the right question. It is a question of quantity, not presence.
God cannot logically be both Omnipotent and Omni-benevolence
Correct. This assumes that our experience is real, in a real timeline that will last and be the final state of our existence. This is a reasonalbe assumption, and given our experience (which is all we have) God is not omnipotent. This isn't to say that our experience is in fact real, we can only assume that it is. A truly omnipotent God could have a multiverse of processs & outcomes from which to generate a complete timeline without suffering. But this is less reasonable than assuming God in our timeline is limited.
The whole debate is hypothetical, until such time as we have evidence for they existence of god (or gods).
God is not hypothetical to me. God is hypothetical to "you," and God more importantly for the purpose of our discussion, God must remain hypothetical to "us."
Flick