There is No God (And You Know It)

The God familys make things work but they also do caculate the wrong...which is worry...things slip...the whole things is...if you think about a certain things for so long...like reading this...it will provoke things to go that way....eventually it will go into action unless you are preconsciously amazing...or logical enough to find a purpose for such a scenario...but if infl;uence a mass of people...worrying will cause alot of porblems...why alot people aren't aloud power...becasue they do not fit requirements...but that is just christian terms...if you want to be like I...into forensics and beastly hood and psycokinesis....you got to gain the logic and power...these christain scenario creators, or the fabrication of karma into destiny takes a logic so great...you have to be able to caculate what exactly is going to come together and how to make it work with all natural systems and man made systems...

Christains have been trying to pull down the heavens for years...what a storm that manages to stablize it self....see they are so powerful in the heaven bond that they create storms and catastrophe....


when the satanist aren't even bad...infact...they follow natural causes...Im just not for the impulse...IM wiccan...I like earth and the universe...I like to share special terrestrial powers with animals...like I am a beast...I just don't like to act upon impulse or instinct...even though repression of such things cause problems...and horrible expression...they could easly be put back into nature of animals who must kill...but statnist do not belive this...because balancing power or abilty between all terrestrials...is stupid...where as Christains try to make us all super human...I'd rather be both...wiccan...


God was a man to smart for even some of the smartest people today...he knew how to make things work and happen...he started a huge empire all contributing to his Power...The compsoing of both God and Satan, Jah and Lucifer are from eygpt....Niether are bad...this or neither mean a damn things to yo... or you will be foghting yourself for years untill you come to this conclusion...


Can you please try and write in sentences, it would make reading your drivel so much less time consuming.
 
He is confusing the illogicality of the God of the Bible with the illogicality of any description of God.

It's not so much an anti-God article as an anti-God-of-Abraham (Yahweh, Jehovah, Allah) article.
And, given that, I agree with him.

But there are other notions of God.


I didn't read the article yet, but I agree with what you wrote.
 
Yeah, you're right, Stimpy.

I don't believe it. Someone at JREF actually caves into what some other poster said? Gee, there is hope after all. Can I join in and say that I agree also? Huh,huh, huh? I have made posts before where yes, I believe that most people believe in the Bible-like God where they know that Jesus ascended physically in the sky to go back and sit at the right hand of the Father, again. And I doubt the Bible writers were thinking about Jesus turning back into a thinking electron or something.
 
I have seen horses, and I have seen bacterium, and I have seen a lot of well supported research on evolution. I have seen how short term evolution of bacterium and other micro-organisms are having a direct effect on our day to day lives (MRSA anyone?)

I have yet to see god, or any evidence for god.

Also, if god is so set on eliminating evil why did he create it in the first place?

It seems rather logical that God who is all inclusive of him (it)self and the universe ...that he (it) chose to make variation. Through variation...this is the only way we have description. There could be no 'good' without bad. We would only know...um, you couldn't hardly use the word 'good' because it would have no relevance, would it? God made hot/cold, long/short, hard/soft, colorful/black and white, smart/stupid, love/hate...and EVERYthing is like that. Sooo...good/EVIL. It just has to be. Maybe God himself couldn't even alter that fact. Just like God can't pick up a rock that is too big for God to pick up, or however that stoogy argument goes.
 
Wouldn't omni-benevolence be dependent on what is considered "good" and what is "not good?" Many who believe in God also believe that God views free will as being the ultimate "good." But in order to allow free will, God must allow humans to freely choose between doing "good" and "bad." Does that make God bad because he allows bad to occur, or does that just mean that our definition of what is ultimately "good" might be incomplete? I would guess that those who believe in an omni-benevolent God simply consider human knowledge of "good" to be incomplete.

-Bri
 
Anything towards good will to man, animal and nature is benevolent. Pervalent benevolence is on many levels. You seem to be thinking of morality is descion making skills. It is sunday, so that seems about right. When I look out into pervalent benevolence I see a bunch of ball and chain gangs or bonds and a bunch of smiling yogis, miracle workers and magicians.
 
Anything towards good will to man, animal and nature is benevolent. Pervalent benevolence is on many levels. You seem to be thinking of morality is descion making skills. It is sunday, so that seems about right. When I look out into pervalent benevolence I see a bunch of ball and chain gangs or bonds and a bunch of smiling yogis, miracle workers and magicians.
The elementalist, remember when brodski asked you to clean up your "drivel"? Your reply:
Could you strive for that clarity again, please.

For example, I used my magic decoder ring to translate your first sentence as follows: "Anything that is good is good." Thanks for the insight.
 
Man son...

Occulstist are good with literature and poetry, esoteric and syntatic. Go through out time and read any occultist writings. They are usually hard to interpret.


I'll quit posting on these types of threads.
 
I'm trying to figure out why there would be any collateral damage. Could God not simply will out of existence Satan and anyone else who has to go?

Actually, I believe the answer is both no and yes. The no answer first: I believe that it is, in fact, as impossible to simply "will" Satan and his entourage out of existence without losing things that God considers worth saving as it would be to completely erase the Holocaust from existence without losing the story of Oscar Schindler.

Now for the "yes" answer. Bear in mind that this is speculation, that I fully acknowledge that I can be wrong, and that I am not trying to argue anyone into agreeing that I am right; I am simply presenting a possibility. I believe that what we call "alternate realities" exist, and that >>some<< of our dreams may be "echoes" of those alternate realities. I can think of several very vivid dreams in which, during the dream, I had absolutely no memory of any of the details of my life and in which, again in the dream, I thought I was completely awake and conscious.

I need to make a few things clear. Some think of the concept of alternate realities as there being "another you." I don't see it that way; I believe that it is you- the same you - living out an alternate set of circumstances. And so - speculating here - I believe that there very well may be numerous alternate realities in which many if not all of us are experiencing a very different life under very different circumstances--including realities in which evil and many of its consequences do not exist, or are only ghosts and shadows of themselves as we now know them. I tend to think that, at at least one point as the space-time continuum was taking shape, it was God's intention to make one or more of those alternates the defined reality and for the events in this timeline to fade away and become no more real than a bad dream. But it seems that this has not happened and furthermore I now believe it will not happen for at least one of two reasons: either, as I mentioned above, there is something or someone in this timeline which God is not willing to lose and/or God now sees the way to complete and unconditional victory from this point in our timeline with no changes whatsoever needed to the points we see as being the "past" and the "present".

My money is on "both".

It's exciting to imagine God having to go to war, but it's not consistent with being all-powerful.

In my view, omniscience and omnipotence have developed as God himself has developed while the space-time continuum has been taking shape. During the initial stages of the conflict, God saw events little better than we do. If you were to have a heart-to-heart talk with him, I think that after the third beer or so he would admit that he had goofed more than once during the process. But I believe that he has accepted and dealt with the consequences of any mistakes he might have made, and now that events have crystallized and the past and present have become set, he is satisfied to let things stand as they are.
 
Actually, I believe the answer is both no and yes. The no answer first: I believe that it is, in fact, as impossible to simply "will" Satan and his entourage out of existence without losing things that God considers worth saving as it would be to completely erase the Holocaust from existence without losing the story of Oscar Schindler.

I'd make that trade in a heartbeat. I imagine Mr. Schindler would, too. It's not a really difficult decision, in truth.

Now for the "yes" answer. Bear in mind that this is speculation, that I fully acknowledge that I can be wrong, and that I am not trying to argue anyone into agreeing that I am right; I am simply presenting a possibility. I believe that what we call "alternate realities" exist, and that >>some<< of our dreams may be "echoes" of those alternate realities. I can think of several very vivid dreams in which, during the dream, I had absolutely no memory of any of the details of my life and in which, again in the dream, I thought I was completely awake and conscious.

I need to make a few things clear. Some think of the concept of alternate realities as there being "another you." I don't see it that way; I believe that it is you- the same you - living out an alternate set of circumstances. And so - speculating here - I believe that there very well may be numerous alternate realities in which many if not all of us are experiencing a very different life under very different circumstances--including realities in which evil and many of its consequences do not exist, or are only ghosts and shadows of themselves as we now know them. I tend to think that, at at least one point as the space-time continuum was taking shape, it was God's intention to make one or more of those alternates the defined reality and for the events in this timeline to fade away and become no more real than a bad dream. But it seems that this has not happened and furthermore I now believe it will not happen for at least one of two reasons: either, as I mentioned above, there is something or someone in this timeline which God is not willing to lose and/or God now sees the way to complete and unconditional victory from this point in our timeline with no changes whatsoever needed to the points we see as being the "past" and the "present".

My money is on "both".



In my view, omniscience and omnipotence have developed as God himself has developed while the space-time continuum has been taking shape. During the initial stages of the conflict, God saw events little better than we do. If you were to have a heart-to-heart talk with him, I think that after the third beer or so he would admit that he had goofed more than once during the process. But I believe that he has accepted and dealt with the consequences of any mistakes he might have made, and now that events have crystallized and the past and present have become set, he is satisfied to let things stand as they are.

More on this later, I need to head out for now.
 
I'm trying to figure out why there would be any collateral damage. Could God not simply will out of existence Satan and anyone else who has to go?

I'm just curious how you define what is "good?" How can we as individuals ever presume to know what the ultimate good is? From our limited perspective, perhaps what we think of as "bad" is actually for the greater good. If having free will is "better" than having no evil in the world, then an omnibenevolent God would allow evil into the world for an ultimate good. In that case, wouldn't willing Satan out of existance actually be bad?

Furtehr more, why did god create Satan in the first place?

Same question.

-Bri
 
Since we can't even define good, to the point that we can't even say if evil is good, if that holocaust was actually a good thing, if the horrible agony experienced by millions of people with fatal diseases is actually a good thing (I'm not even talking about their deaths, just the fact that they experience horrible pain before that death), then how the hell do we know what "omnibenevolence" is?

Does it mean anything to us? If not, how can anyone justify applying this word that doesn't mean anything at all to them to God?

On the other hand, I'm pretty sure I see things in the world that aren't part of some grand plan, but are just plain wrong. All we need is one example to show that God allows evil to exist without any good reason to do so. Meaning he can't be omni-benevolent and still exist.

And I'm pretty sure I've seen at least one in my life. How about you?
 
On the other hand, I'm pretty sure I see things in the world that aren't part of some grand plan, but are just plain wrong. All we need is one example to show that God allows evil to exist without any good reason to do so. Meaning he can't be omni-benevolent and still exist.

And I'm pretty sure I've seen at least one in my life. How about you?

I'm not sure I would know. What's your one example?

-Bri
 
I'm just curious how you define what is "good?" How can we as individuals ever presume to know what the ultimate good is? From our limited perspective, perhaps what we think of as "bad" is actually for the greater good. If having free will is "better" than having no evil in the world, then an omnibenevolent God would allow evil into the world for an ultimate good. In that case, wouldn't willing Satan out of existance actually be bad?



Same question.

-Bri


OK, theists can always fall back on the "god is unknowable" answer, but it is intellectually very unsatisfying, it also raises the question, if we cant know god's motivations, how can we know his desires? if he is prepared to play all sorts of games with humanity by creating evil, how do we know that, even if god exists, his revealed holy;y texts are not just some kind of big practical joke?

Free will may be an argument for an omni-benovalant god, but only if you assume that he is not omnipotent, an omnipotent god is capable of anything conceivable, so squaring the circle of having free will without evil should be possible.

however what possible good can come from creating an entity whose sole purpose is to do evil? It is not necessary for free will, and it is not necessary for the free will of humanity, in fact in some ways it is a restriction on the free will of humanity (especially if you believe that Satan walks abroad).
 
OK, theists can always fall back on the "god is unknowable" answer, but it is intellectually very unsatisfying, it also raises the question, if we cant know god's motivations, how can we know his desires?

Well, yes, it's certainly intellectually unsatisfying not to have all the answers, but science also readily admits that it doesn't have all the answers. A theist would probably say that it's not important for us to know everything about God, which I suppose is why they call it "faith."

I think what you are probably getting at is how do we know what God wants from us since we can't discern what the "ultimate good" might be? Fundamentalist Christians might answer that God left us instructions (the Bible) that tells us how to act. Possibly a better answer is that we're not responsible for knowing what constitutes "ultimate good" and we're all given the ability to know good behavior from bad behavior in ourselves and other people without understanding "ultimate good" (which would be God's domain).

Free will may be an argument for an omni-benovalant god, but only if you assume that he is not omnipotent, an omnipotent god is capable of anything conceivable, so squaring the circle of having free will without evil should be possible.

No, that's the "God can't make a boulder that's too big for him to lift" paradox. Free will (according to most theists) would require the person to be able to choose freely between "good" and "bad." This necessarily means that there must be at least the potential for "bad" in the world.

however what possible good can come from creating an entity whose sole purpose is to do evil? It is not necessary for free will, and it is not necessary for the free will of humanity, in fact in some ways it is a restriction on the free will of humanity (especially if you believe that Satan walks abroad).

That I don't really have a good answer to. Many religions believe in free will and good/evil but don't believe in Satan in the Christian sense. Any Christian theologians out there who can clarify?

-Bri
 
I think what you are probably getting at is how do we know what God wants from us since we can't discern what the "ultimate good" might be? Fundamentalist Christians might answer that God left us instructions (the Bible) that tells us how to act. Possibly a better answer is that we're not responsible for knowing what constitutes "ultimate good" and we're all given the ability to know good behavior from bad behavior in ourselves and other people without understanding "ultimate good" (which would be God's domain).

My point is that if it's presumptuous of us to question ultimate goodness, isn't it equally presumptuous to accept ultimate good as a given?
 
My point is that if it's presumptuous of us to question ultimate goodness, isn't it equally presumptuous to accept ultimate good as a given?

I never said it would be presumptuous for us to question ultimate goodness, just that it would be presumptuous for us to assume that we could possibly know what does or does not constitute the ultimate good.

Whether or not it would be presumptuous to question ultimate goodness is irrelevant. The point here is that you cannot disprove the existance of an omni-benevolent God by pointing out that there is evil in the world.

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom