There is No God (And You Know It)

can the last two words be shaped to = "illogically possible"?

No, they can't. I really mean "impossible." Jjramsey says the terms are conflated, implyling they are separable. That means you should be able to have something which is physically possible, but not logically possible. There are no logical impossibilites in screwing an elephant, though there are many hygenic, moral, and aesthetic reasons for not doing so.
 
There was a poster who, despite his other flaws, pointed out why the Argument from Evil is not conclusive:



He isn't quite right, AFAIK, in saying that "the Problem of Evil is no longer argued against God in professional philosophy." However, the rest is about right. To point this out does not even require doing the "pirouette" of saying that "God cannot be judged by merely human standards of morality." Regular old humans can have their own morally sufficient reasons for allowing evil, which generally revolve around allowing some evil so that a greater evil would not take place. If God is omnipotent but still constrained by logic, then there is a possibility that his choices are constrained and that for whatever possibly unknown reasons, a universe that involves no suffering at all is not feasible or not the one that truly maximizes the good. The problem is that while we can protest that if God exists, then he's done a botched job of the universe and that not even the hope of a blessed life after death can make up for that, it would take a "God's-eye view" to establish that was truly the case.

This does not mean that the Argument from Evil is totally without force, since atheism more parsimoniously accounts for evil than theism. However, while the presence of evil is evidence against God, it is not sufficient evidence in and of itself to rule out an omnipotent, omnibenevolent god.
Yes, I've heard the "utilitarian argument" before, that God allows suffering because by preventing it, he will only be inadvertently causing a greater amount of it in the future. But then one has to question how paradises separate from the material world described in many of the holy texts of the major religions such as Heaven can exist. God doesn't allow suffering in Heaven, and still, no unintentional suffering is produced there.
 
No, they can't. I really mean "impossible." Jjramsey says the terms are conflated, implyling they are separable. That means you should be able to have something which is physically possible, but not logically possible. There are no logical impossibilites in screwing an elephant, though there are many hygenic, moral, and aesthetic reasons for not doing so.

In the words of John Varley, you can't have sex with an elephant. At best, you can have sex at an elephant.
 
Logically impossible: Square circle (If you're restricted to two dimensions. Add a dimension and it becomes trivial to create an object which is square in cross section and circular in plan view.)

Physically (to us humans) but not logically impossible: Time travel.
 
The point is, that if God can only do what is possible then he's not very supernatural, is he ?

The answer to your question is that if the supernatural is possible, then yes God can be supernatural without doing the impossible.

If you could prove that the supernatural is impossible, then you've proven that a supernatural God (by definition) cannot exist.

Unfortunately, you cannot prove that the supernatural is impossible since science only deals with the natural.

-Bri
 
It was a joke. It would have made sense to you if you really thought that supernatural means impossible.

That's what I thought and that's what I really think. You haven't argued with me yet, and therefore cannot comment on how hard it is.

Only people with nothing to support their claims rationally say it's impossible to win an argument against Belz...

Belz...
 
Bri
"Supernatural" isn't a synonym for "impossible" to anyone but (apparently) you.
Let’s see according to Merriam Webster
Supernatural
1 : of or relating to an order of existence beyond the visible observable universe; especially : of or relating to God or a god, demigod, spirit, or devil
2 a : departing from what is usual or normal especially so as to appear to transcend the laws of nature b : attributed to an invisible agent (as a ghost or spirit)

Supernatural – outside of or breaking the laws of nature

Supernatural has the connotation of being impossible for specific reasons. I’m using a broad brush and using similar terms for understanding.

Perhaps you need to go back and re-read what I wrote (I added the emphasis in my post to help you out). That is indeed exactly what c4ts was claiming.
I directly quoted c4ts post #89 to be exact. C4ts didn’t change it jjramey did
Can you give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible?

The answer to your question is that if the supernatural is possible, then yes God can be supernatural without doing the impossible.
Begging the question. If you want the supernatural to be possible, prove it.

Ossai
 
Let’s see according to Merriam Webster
Supernatural
1 : of or relating to an order of existence beyond the visible observable universe; especially : of or relating to God or a god, demigod, spirit, or devil
2 a : departing from what is usual or normal especially so as to appear to transcend the laws of nature b : attributed to an invisible agent (as a ghost or spirit)

Supernatural – outside of or breaking the laws of nature

I don't see the word "impossible" in any of these definitions.

Supernatural has the connotation of being impossible for specific reasons. I’m using a broad brush and using similar terms for understanding.

No, you're squaring words to fit a circular argument.

I directly quoted c4ts post #89 to be exact. C4ts didn’t change it jjramey did

jjramsey was the one who made the initial statement, which is obvious from this post. jjramsey was saying that "physically impossible" and "logically impossible" are not the same. c4ts then made the statement you quoted, which asked jjramsey to give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible. The fact that c4ts is using unsound logic in an attempt to prove that something that is a subset of another thing must be equal to that thing notwithstanding, his use of "physically possible" is the negation of jjramsey's "physically impossible," or "not physically impossible" as I put it in my restatement of c4ts' question.

Begging the question. If you want the supernatural to be possible, prove it.

I don't, I can't, and that's not what the discussion was about. It was about proving that there is no God.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Yes, I've heard the "utilitarian argument" before, that God allows suffering because by preventing it, he will only be inadvertently causing a greater amount of it in the future. But then one has to question how paradises separate from the material world described in many of the holy texts of the major religions such as Heaven can exist. God doesn't allow suffering in Heaven, and still, no unintentional suffering is produced there.

A God could have decided that a universe where there was suffering that is later "fixed" by the advent of heaven maximized the good better than a universe that was heavenlike from the start. Now there is no guarantee that a God had decided this, or that it would have been a good decision had he did. However, without any way of knowing what a universe that was pure heaven from the beginning would be like, we have no way of knowing what the flaws in such a universe would be. We can speculate and guess, but never quite know.

My argument is less the "utilitarian argument" per se, and more that we do not have sufficient knowledge to deny or affirm the proposition that an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God could never have reasons to allow suffering.
 
My argument is less the "utilitarian argument" per se, and more that we do not have sufficient knowledge to deny or affirm the proposition that an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God could never have reasons to allow suffering.

But the point is made, I think, that it requires a lot of speculation to reach that point... it's hardly obvious that it should be so.
 
A God could have decided that a universe where there was suffering that is later "fixed" by the advent of heaven maximized the good better than a universe that was heavenlike from the start. Now there is no guarantee that a God had decided this, or that it would have been a good decision had he did. However, without any way of knowing what a universe that was pure heaven from the beginning would be like, we have no way of knowing what the flaws in such a universe would be. We can speculate and guess, but never quite know.

My argument is less the "utilitarian argument" per se, and more that we do not have sufficient knowledge to deny or affirm the proposition that an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God could never have reasons to allow suffering.

But what specifically concerns this discussion isn't whether suffering as an abstract concept might sometimes be allowed by a benevolent and omnipotent god, but rather that the amount of suffering in this world would be.
I'm sorry, but I can't credit that anyone would believe that all the suffering in the world is necessary.
An omnipotent, omnibenevolent god suggests that this is the best of all possible worlds. And yet there is nothing that suggests that there is any force at all that maximizes 'goodness' in the world. I suggest that it is not just very unlikely that we would not see any such effect, but actually impossible.
I'm not sure I can make a good logical argument here. Alas.
Maybe my logic is flawed, I'm sure you'll point out that it is. But is it possible for god to maximize the 'goodness' in the world without showing any evidence of it?
I guess if god were trying to hide that evidence, maybe that would explain it. Maybe you can argue that it's for the good that we don't know about god, and if He let us see the evidence of His existence...

But this all sounds really contrived. And if that's what it takes to believe in an omnipotent omnibenevolent god, well, I'm out...
 
But the point is made, I think, that it requires a lot of speculation to reach that point... it's hardly obvious that it should be so.

Of course, it is hardly obvious that we don't have the knowledge to "deny or affirm the proposition that an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God could never have reasons to allow suffering." That's why it's so easy for Sam Harris to pontificate on the Argument from Evil being the knockout argument against God's existence. Still, "hardly obvious" is not even remotely the same as "not true," as anyone decently familiar with evolution can attest.

Sam Harris, though, is supposedly a bright person, and there is no reason for him not to do his homework and grasp the nonobvious truths before writing about the merits of atheism.
 
Yeah, I know. I was less trying to prove my point with that statement than wondering if you or others in this thread arguing that point would be able to credit it either?
I just doubt that there is anyone out there who, if he or she had absolute power at his disposal, wouldn't remove some of the suffering in the world. I doubt they would think "Oh, but that suffering is there for a reason..."

Now, I know this isn't an argument. It's more of a wondering if you support your own position.
But then, I also realise that isn't fair, you're not saying "God is omnipotent and omnibenevolent", rather you're saying it isn't impossible that he is.
And I'm not sure I can argue for that impossibility. I just don't credit it's possibility. But the two are different.

So. I guess I'm saying I don't really know what I'm saying.
 
So. I guess I'm saying I don't really know what I'm saying.

I think what's happening is that you are intuitively recognizing that atheism more parsimoniously accounts for evil than a belief in an omnipotent, omnibenevolent god, but you're having trouble putting it into words. What you are probably doing is some subconscious (but valid) abductive reasoning.

The problem I see is that many who use the argument from evil get their abductive and deductive reasoning mixed up. It is one thing to say that evil is accounted for most parsimoniously by atheism, and combined with other considerations, atheism is most probably correct. It is another thing to say that one can use deductive reasoning to conclude that God doesn't exist based solely on the presence of evil. The former makes sense; the latter does not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom