There is No God (And You Know It)

You are going to have to explain this to me. I agree none of these things are physically possible - but I don't think they are logically possible either.

A simple explanation of what jjramsey is getting at is that "a married bachelor" is logically impossible. The definition of "married" and the definition of "bachelor" make the combination semantically meaningless. Same with a "square circle." Therefore to say that God is not omnipotent unless he can create a "square circle" is an argument based on a logical impossibility. The argument that "one isn't omnipotent if one cannot do something that cannot be done" is simply an incorrect and illogical definition of the word "omnipotent."

The reason for making such a statement is simply to disprove the first half of the statement by defining it so that it's only true if the second half of the statement is true, then ensuring that the second half of the statement can never be true by making it self-contradictory.

I can use a similar argument for anything. For example, I can just as easily make the argument that you are a moron unless you can do a math problem that's too difficult for you to do. I've equated the word "moron" with something that is logically impossible (to be able to do something that you're unable to do). Does that mean you're a moron, or does that mean that my definition of "moron" is incorrect and illogical?

-Bri
 
Speaking of the hurricane, has anyone here noted the irony of having a national day of prayer soon after katrina, and then god responds with Rita.

Yes, god answers prayers. This time, his answer was another hurricane!

But, who are we -- mere mortals-- to try and undstand god?
 
For you to attempt to prove an imaginary creature created scientific laws for Earth people - and regularly violates these laws for personal or tribal reasons - is much harder than my proof.

No, it is equally difficult to prove that no gods exist as it is to prove that God exists. That is to say that neither can be proven.

All I have to submit is - a miracle never happened. Not only does such an event violate the laws of science - such an event has never been witnessed.

You are correct. I cannot meet the burden of proof that would be required to claim that God exists (nor have I ever made such a claim).

Now it's your turn to prove your claim that no gods exist.

-Bri
 
A car is a type of vehicle (subset), but a vehicle and a car are not the same thing (equality). A bus is also a type of vehicle, but is not a car. If a car and a vehicle were the same thing, then a bus would be a type of car.

You're a little confused here. If I remember my math. A U B (A is a subset of B) A car is a vehicle. EVERY car is a vehicle. But not every vehicle is a car.

I want to know how you can use logical equations to prove a pig flies.
 
The reason for making such a statement is simply to disprove the first half of the statement by defining it so that it's only true if the second half of the statement is true, then ensuring that the second half of the statement can never be true by making it self-contradictory.

As Homer asked: "Can God microwave a burrito so hot even He cannot consume it?"

When you are dealing with a unexplainable mystery (God), it is very easy to word-play Him out of existance.
 
Now it's your turn to prove your claim that no gods exist.

Gods have always been manifestations of natures' power. We don't need them anymore.

Believing in a god based on 2500 year old writings from a nomadic tribe is insane.
 
You're a little confused here. If I remember my math. A U B (A is a subset of B) A car is a vehicle. EVERY car is a vehicle. But not every vehicle is a car.

Here is the information you seek. The "U" symbol is for the union of two sets, and no, "subset" and "equals" are not the same.

I cannot display the standard "subset" character, so let's use the symbol "<" to denote "subset" as in "cars < vehicles" for "the set of cars is a subset of the set of vehicles."

"cars < vehicles" is akin to the English phrase "all cars are vehicles."

"cars = vehicles" is akin to the English phrase "cars and vehicles are exactly the same" or BOTH "all cars are vehicles" AND "all vehicles are cars."

In other words, in order for "A = B" to be true, both "A < B" AND "B < A" must be true.

-Bri
 
Bri
You're using an incorrect definition of the word "miracle." A miracle is not defined as "something that is impossible."
So you would have no trouble parting the Red Sea, causing a rain of fire, starting a plague, turning a woman into a pillar of salt, walking on water, raising someone that had been dead for days, healing the blind, causing earthquakes, cause a whale to swallow someone and manage to keep the victim alive for three days, view all the earth from one location, cause darkness to fall over a country for days on end.

It is rather something that cannot be explained by the laws of nature.
Which is supernatural, i.e. impossible.

jjramsey
You are conflating "physically impossible" and "logically impossible."
Nope, you’re just being weasely again. Omnipotent means all powerful. If you want a lesser form come up with another word for it.

Iamme
So why aren't these seeming impossible things just going on all the time then? Why not wine that becones water all the time? Because God said so, that's why. He wanted water to be water. That's why water is water. Yet, God, if he wants to, can change the rules for when he wants.
Wow, the same weasely crap as the others.

You want it both ways. Either god can do the impossible/supernatural/miraculous or he can’t. If he can then nothing is illogical because god could change the rules of logic. Duh! If that’s not good enough he could change the basic laws of the universe any way he wanted, gravity, speed of light, fluid dynamics, etc.

To us it’s illogical to say we can make a square circle. But if god decided to do so he could change the natural properties to make square circles the norm.

jjramsey
Of course not. The physically possible is a subset of the logically possible. Now as for things that are logically possible, but physically impossible, examples abound:
· Pigs flying.
· Turning lead into gold.
· Water flowing uphill.
· and on and on . . .
None of those things are physically possible, but they don't fall afoul of the laws of logic.
You don’t get out much do you?
Pigs flying – strap it into a hang glider and guide it off a cliff – or better yet put it in an airplane
Lead into gold – nuclear reactor – admittedly the gold will be radioactive for a bit
Water flowing uphill – pump

Bri and triadboy
A = physically impossible
B = logically impossible

A != B

You asked him to give an example of something which is not A but is B. How exactly does that show that A = B?
No he didn’t. Go back and read what c4ts did say (color added for emphasis).
Can you give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible?

A = physically possible
B = logically impossible

Ossai
 
If that is so, then would that mean then that if I don't like what is written on a piece of paper and I wish to eradicate it, that the simple burning of it won't make it go away? That it has to cry Uncle first?
All you do is light the fire. It has to do the burning.
 
Here is the information you seek. The "U" symbol is for the union of two sets, and no, "subset" and "equals" are not the same.

Yep, I forgot my math. But - now you also realize 'subset' and 'inequality' are not the same thing. So your initial equation above (A!=B) is wrong.

A = physically impossible
B = logically impossible

A != B
 
Yep, I forgot my math. But - now you also realize 'subset' and 'inequality' are not the same thing. So your initial equation above (A!=B) is wrong.

They are related, but not the same, you're correct. A equals B if A is a subset of B and B is a subset of A. In this case, A is a subset of B, but B is not a subset of A, therefore A does not equal B.

-Bri
 
What a strange life you must lead. Never to have heard of the koran or the bible or torah or the veldic texts behind hinduism etc. You may not except these as enough evidence to come to the conclusion that god does exist but they are evidence non the less.

These are not evidence. They are claims. They are not supported by evidence, and are mutually exclusive.

Belz...
 
If you are correct and there is no such God, then I have lost nothing--I am content with my life as it is. If I am correct, however--jackpot.

That is not quite true. There is a lot to be lost from belief in God. Time, effort. Look at those people who blow themselves up or refuse medical assistance to their children because of their beliefs. Beliefs can be very dangerous, indeed, and with some critical thought there's a thousand years of dark ages that could have been avoided.

Belz...
 
You're using an incorrect definition of the word "miracle." A miracle is not defined as "something that is impossible."
So you would have no trouble parting the Red Sea, causing a rain of fire, starting a plague, turning a woman into a pillar of salt, walking on water, raising someone that had been dead for days, healing the blind, causing earthquakes, cause a whale to swallow someone and manage to keep the victim alive for three days, view all the earth from one location, cause darkness to fall over a country for days on end.

I'm flattered that you feel that if I can't do something it must be impossible, Ossai.

Which is supernatural, i.e. impossible.

"Supernatural" isn't a synonym for "impossible" to anyone but (apparently) you.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Well, yes, it's certainly intellectually unsatisfying not to have all the answers, but science also readily admits that it doesn't have all the answers. A theist would probably say that it's not important for us to know everything about God, which I suppose is why they call it "faith."

Science admits not having all the answers because it's in the process of finding them. Religion has no intention of finding the answers because it thinks it knows all it needs to know already.

Belz...
 
Perhaps God considers the ability for humans to be able to choose between good and bad to be "more good" than to have a world full of robots who have no choice but to do good.

Perhaps ? Perhaps he's just messing with us and laughing maniacally. Perhaps Plato was right.

Belz...
 
Really? Name one human who can do anything that's possible to do. For that matter, name one human who can do anything that's humanly possible to do.

The point is, that if God can only do what is possible then he's not very supernatural, is he ?

Belz...
 
A = physically impossible
B = logically impossible

A != B

You asked him to give an example of something which is not A but is B. How exactly does that show that A = B?

No he didn’t. Go back and read what c4ts did say (color added for emphasis).

Can you give an example of something which is physically possible, but logically impossible?

Perhaps you need to go back and re-read what I wrote (I added the emphasis in my post to help you out). That is indeed exactly what c4ts was claiming.

I defined A as "physically impossible" (as in jjramey's original statement) and not A (physically possible) to indicate what c4ts was asking (since he chose to change it).

c4ts was asking for an example of something which is not A (physically possible) but is B (logically impossible), claiming that somehow this proves that A = B.

Even if I had gotten it backwards (which I didn't) c4ts is still using flawed logic in assuming that if one thing is a subset of another that they are the same.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom