You are going to have to explain this to me. I agree none of these things are physically possible - but I don't think they are logically possible either.
A simple explanation of what jjramsey is getting at is that "a married bachelor" is logically impossible. The definition of "married" and the definition of "bachelor" make the combination semantically meaningless. Same with a "square circle." Therefore to say that God is not omnipotent unless he can create a "square circle" is an argument based on a logical impossibility. The argument that "one isn't omnipotent if one cannot do something that cannot be done" is simply an incorrect and illogical definition of the word "omnipotent."
The reason for making such a statement is simply to disprove the first half of the statement by defining it so that it's only true if the second half of the statement is true, then ensuring that the second half of the statement can never be true by making it self-contradictory.
I can use a similar argument for anything. For example, I can just as easily make the argument that you are a moron unless you can do a math problem that's too difficult for you to do. I've equated the word "moron" with something that is logically impossible (to be able to do something that you're unable to do). Does that mean you're a moron, or does that mean that my definition of "moron" is incorrect and illogical?
-Bri