There is No God (And You Know It)

I never said it would be presumptuous for us to question ultimate goodness, just that it would be presumptuous for us to assume that we could possibly know what does or does not constitute the ultimate good.

How is that different than questioning ultimate goodness?

Whether or not it would be presumptuous to question ultimate goodness is irrelevant. The point here is that you cannot disprove the existance of an omni-benevolent God by pointing out that there is evil in the world.

But the argument that you resort to in order to get there means you can't conclude that there is ultimate goodness either. It makes it presumptuous for any human to propose that God has ultimate goodness either.
 
There could be no 'good' without bad.

Sure there could. Genocide doesn't need to exist in order to enjoy an ice cream. As long as "differential" exists, we can have good. We just need to lop off the "hideous" end of that scale. But I am not God.

Anyone ever wonder why God could end evil with an infinitely small flick of his finger, but does not because he can. While decidedly finite humans are expected to do Herculean efforts with their finite abilities in the same direction? Yes, God is a ass.
 
How is that different than questioning ultimate goodness?

You can question all you like, but there is no reason to assume that any human being could possibly have enough information to determine what would be for the ultimate good of all humanity, much less the universe.

But the argument that you resort to in order to get there means you can't conclude that there is ultimate goodness either. It makes it presumptuous for any human to propose that God has ultimate goodness either.

Correct, I can't prove that there is ultimate goodness. Furthermore, I admit that the existance of God cannot be proven. The question was whether or not God can be disproven, not whether or not God could be proven. The premise of the thread is that there is no God, which is a statement that requires evidence.

My point was that God cannot be disproven by attempting to show that there is evil in the world because there are plenty of reasons that there might be evil in the world, even with an omni-benevolent God.

-Bri
 
Genocide doesn't need to exist in order to enjoy an ice cream.

Perhaps God considers the ability for humans to be able to choose between good and bad to be "more good" than to have a world full of robots who have no choice but to do good.

-Bri
 
ehbowen
I never cease to be amazed by the fact that the same people who can so smugly accept as proven fact that a horse can be bred from a bacterium in four billion years nevertheless kick and scream and threaten to turn blue in the face at the notion that God might take a mere few hundred human lifetimes in order to completely and unconditionally defeat evil and the evil one for all eternity.
Considering that god was also the one that created the evil, why would he want to destroy it?

Yes, I know the next line in the litany: "If there is a God, he should be able to do [fill in the blank] right now!" Sounds like a certain three-year old I remember.
What, 4.5 billion years isn’t long enough? Or do you want universal instead of Earthly, just take another 10 billion or so. So, why is there still evil?

"Perpetrating a global nuclear holocaust" is, in my analogy, comparable to the immense and permanent collateral damage which could ensue if God were to attack Satan and his current domains by main force.
You are removing omnipotence. If god were omnipotent, he could easily destroy Satan with no collateral damage.

Bear in mind that this is speculation
i.e. stuff you made up

jjramsey
If God is omnipotent but still constrained by logic,
Now that’s an illogical statement.

However, while the presence of evil is evidence against God, it is not sufficient evidence in and of itself to rule out an omnipotent, omnibenevolent god.
Hmmm. God is omnipotent and omnibenevolent yet evil exists. God is capable and motivated to stop evil. Yet evil persists.
Sorry, but that is compelling evidence to rule out an omnipotent omnibenevolent god.

The elementalist
Have you ever heard of something called a complete sentence?
Clarity of though is expressed by clarity of communication.

Roboramma
All we need is one example to show that God allows evil to exist without any good reason to do so. Meaning he can't be omni-benevolent and still exist.
Crack babies
Pontine tumors

Ossai
 
If there's no god and you know it
and you really want to show it

If there's no god and you know it
CLAP YOUR HANDS!
 
jjramsey

If God is omnipotent but still constrained by logic,

Now that’s an illogical statement.

:rolleyes: Hardly. Nonsense does not become sense just because the words "God can" are put in front of it. The statement "God cannot make a square circle" is syntactically correct but meaningless because "square circle" is nonsense, so it cannot even be said to meaningfully describe a limitation of God.

Bear in mind, too, that if you do allow God to do the logically impossible, then it becomes impossible to rationally discuss God, and all your arguments for or against his existence become moot.

Hmmm. God is omnipotent and omnibenevolent yet evil exists. God is capable and motivated to stop evil. Yet evil persists.
Sorry, but that is compelling evidence to rule out an omnipotent omnibenevolent god.

It is only compelling if it can be demonstrated that God could not possibly have morally sufficient reasons for allowing evil, which is not doable without having a "God's-eye" view.
 
jjramsey
Hardly. Nonsense does not become sense just because the words "God can" are put in front of it.
Nope, that’s just weasely.

Bear in mind, too, that if you do allow God to do the logically impossible, then it becomes impossible to rationally discuss God, and all your arguments for or against his existence become moot.
Ahem, to quote numerous people numerous times.
“It’s God’s will.” – usually just after a disaster
“God moves in mysterious ways.”
“God is so far above people that we don’t have a chance of understanding him.”
“God works in mysterious ways.”


Sorry, but applying logic to god, pretty quickly negates anyone talking about him in any meaningful way. Yet people still claim to hear god, speak for god, interpret god’s will, obey god’s judgment, follow god’s laws.

It is only compelling if it can be demonstrated that God could not possibly have morally sufficient reasons for allowing evil, which is not doable without having a "God's-eye" view.
Hey look, another restatement of “God works in mysterious ways.”

Basically, I’m trying to get across that once you throw out logic anything goes.
Omnipotence is not logical. You even acknowledge it in an off hand manner.

Ossai
 
Basically, I’m trying to get across that once you throw out logic anything goes.
Omnipotence is not logical. You even acknowledge it in an off hand manner.

That we cannot know what entiails omnipotence or omnibenevolence as they pertain to God perhaps this makes these concepts abstract (to us at least), but does that make them illogical?

For the sake of argument, let's say that God's power is "limited" in the sense that God can "only" do anything that is possible to do. Does that make him less than all-powerful?

-Bri
 
For the sake of argument, let's say that God's power is "limited" in the sense that God can "only" do anything that is possible to do. Does that make him less than all-powerful?

That would make Him human. Gods have to have fire shooting out of their ears for them to be effective.
 
Here is a snippet from the movie "Contact" which is based on the novel by one of the JREF's culture heroes Carl Sagan. The context is taken from a discussion in the movie on the existence of God. It has helped me somewhat in dealing with this proving God business:

Palmer Joss: Did you love your father?
Eleanor Arroway: Yes.
Joss: Prove it.
Arroway: (silence)
---------------------------------
If the essential nature of God is Spiritual Love, then how can love/God be proved? Love/God cannot be proved with with words, empiricism, or even deeds (deeds can be faked). Either you love someone or you don't--you either 'know it' or you don't, and there's no proving either way. This is just one way to approach the issue--certainly not the only way--but it has helped me.

If one wants to investigate the question of whether God exists, one might want to use an aspect of the psyche other than the intellect. "Open up your heart" as the song goes. Agree or disagree, its just one other way.

:)
 
Last edited:
If YOU made something...ANYthing...and you *didn't* think it was good, what would you do with it? But by keeping it around for say 13.5 billion years, would you then have to agree that whoever made it must have thought that he did something right, and that it was good?

But I, like any other skeptic, get hung up on this so called God of goodness sending floods...sending down fire...killing the first born sons...allowing worldwide calamities...not making it clear WHICH religion he endorses (out of the ones who believe in a supreme deity) so that holy wars that have killed thousands upon thousands (or millions over the years?). In fact, this one argument alone seems to be the biggest counter-weight to go up against the argument FOR God, being that all the splendor about us just surely couldn't have happened without purpose and design. But one really wonders when there appears to be acts of God and his goodness AGAINST man.
 
Yes, and Ronald Reagan could have ended the cold war on his first inauguration day; all he had to do was push the button.

This was an interesting statement.

yes, I think in the end, human history is a small time in the scope of time in the whole cosmos

would you want to easily accept that you have to have an amputation when you wanted to be a baseball player or something like that?

but yes, at some point you would have to accept it. If there is a rotten apple core in the middle of a great clean shiny room, eventually it will be removed
 
Basically, I’m trying to get across that once you throw out logic anything goes.
Omnipotence is not logical. You even acknowledge it in an off hand manner.

What I acknowledge is that your definition of omnipotence is illogical. You were the one who introduced the idea that omnipotence must entail the ability to do the logically impossible. Of course, you are correct in saying that "once you throw out logic anything goes." Actually, I pretty much pointed it out before you did:

Bear in mind, too, that if you do allow God to do the logically impossible, then it becomes impossible to rationally discuss God, and all your arguments for or against his existence become moot.

Since you were the one who introduced illogic via your own dubious definition of omnipotence, you hoisted yourself on your own petard. If you decide that logic doesn't apply to God, then it is pointless for you to use logic in an argument that makes reference to him.

It is only compelling if it can be demonstrated that God could not possibly have morally sufficient reasons for allowing evil, which is not doable without having a "God's-eye" view.

Hey look, another restatement of "God works in mysterious ways."

Hey look, a straw man. :rolleyes:
 
If the essential nature of God is Spiritual Love, then how can love/God be proved? Love/God cannot be proved with with words, empiricism, or even deeds (deeds can be faked). Either you love someone or you don't--you either 'know it' or you don't, and there's no proving either way. This is just one way to approach the issue--certainly not the only way--but it has helped me.

If one wants to investigate the question of whether God exists, one might want to use an aspect of the psyche other than the intellect. "Open up your heart" as the song goes. Agree or disagree, its just one other way.

:)

That is a powerful sentiment... but there is a world of difference between the existence of an entity and the existence of an emotion. God as a general hypothesis may not be testible, but you start giving details such as omnipotence and omnibenevolence, and suddenly there's something worth debating.
 
jjramsey,

Excuse me if you've addressed this elsewhere, but at some point I'd be interested to know your opinion (if any) of the Flint-Freddoso and Wierenga approaches to omnipotence.

I've skimmed the papers to which you linked, and I can't say offhand that I found anything objectionable about them.
 
...
This is slightly off-topic - but I must correct a misconception that appears to be common with laypeople. There is no 'button' for anyone to push. If the President wanted to start a nuclear war on his Inauguration Day - he couldn't do it, because of the checks and balances inherent in our NC2 System. It takes more than one person to launch a nuclear war. It also takes an 'evolution' of events.
Not so much off-topic.

It takes more than God to eradicate evil. Satan has to cry Uncle!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom