Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

Would this be any better if they still taught basic American history and civics in the public schools? I really think so much of it is pure ignorance. Ignorance begets surprise when things work out differently than assumed.


I still think they are taught, but taught so badly that the facts do not take hold.
I think the real problem is it's a new version of a old disease which I..and most people..have suffered from in our youth: 17 to 23 year old "Know It All Disease". You when you are that age, you often consider yourself a freaking genius who knows it all, who has a uniquely brilliant mind, and knows better then all those old fogies who have been teaching him.
Usually this is cured once you get out of school into The Real World.
 
If you ask me, it's a 50-50 toss-up about what Cain REALLY desperately needs and wants.

It is either (a) the destruction of the evil unfair system so that his genius could rebuild the world, or (b) a girlfriend.
 
I still think they are taught, but taught so badly that the facts do not take hold.
I think the real problem is it's a new version of a old disease which I..and most people..have suffered from in our youth: 17 to 23 year old "Know It All Disease". You when you are that age, you often consider yourself a freaking genius who knows it all, who has a uniquely brilliant mind, and knows better then all those old fogies who have been teaching him.
Usually this is cured once you get out of school into The Real World.
Ummm.... The aspect that they seem to be hicupping on is an aspect of philosophy not really politics.
 
This the second communique from the shadow government headed by cool, hip democratically chosen Internet Revolutionaries.

It's instructive to see the droolers not even pretend to offer up an argument. Well, apart from the "you-just-want-to-be-evil-dictator" ad hominem, which is one I've never heard anywhere, ever. I think it's only funny because it's sincerely intended. Then there's the notion we Californians should be disenfranchised because they're "too crazy." jsfisher talking about ignorance? Skeptic's moniker (and here's a person who actively supports an apartheid regime accusing ME of wanting to oppress people). Dudalb's adding the umpteenth variation of the same post he always writes.
 
Last edited:
(and here's a person who actively supports an apartheid regime accusing ME of wanting to oppress people).
You do. You want to give power to a large group of people who are concerned about meddling around in people's lives who they should have no right to get involved with. Dumb, stupid, moronic, and myopic are just a few of the words to describe your plan.
 
This the second communique from the shadow government headed by cool, hip democratically chosen Internet Revolutionaries.

It's instructive to see the droolers not even pretend to offer up an argument. Well, apart from the "you-just-want-to-be-evil-dictator" ad hominem, which is one I've never heard anywhere, ever. I think it's only funny because it's sincerely intended. Then there's the notion we Californians should be disenfranchised because they're "too crazy." jsfisher talking about ignorance? Skeptic's moniker (and here's a person who actively supports an apartheid regime accusing ME of wanting to oppress people). Dudalb's adding the umpteenth variation of the same post he always writes.
It's because your argument falls flat on its face. The constitution defines how senators are elected and apportioned. You would have a gripe if the both state Senators were required to be from the same party but they are not. The United States is not a direct democracy and it would be disastrous to even contemplate becoming one. You base your argument that the late GOP majority in the Senate was undemocratic since they represented less people than the DNC minority. That is specious argument given that we see the majority change hands on a regular basis in the Senate just as we do in the House and in the White House. What you are looking for is one party rule not more democracy.
 
Madison argues that the Senate breaks the violence of faction by providing a different means of electing representatives. A kind of demagogic leader who could sway public opinion might be able to dominate a popular body like the House, but would have more trouble, so goes the argument, to also dominate the Senate, given the vastly different means by which they were chosen.

Also the kind of men needed to oversee the President's treaty power would have to be, for want of a better word, elites. One, so that they would have the necessary knowledge and experience to make sense of international affairs, and two, so that they wouldn't be as easily swayed by the filthy lucre on offer from foreign states who have an interest in the direction of American foreign policy.

The internal rules of the Senate, I think, are just fine. The purpose of separate institutions sharing power, to paraphrase Youngstown, was to make legislation harder, not easier. Senators who are jealous of their minority rights may be an annoyance, but they also force legislation to be pitched to a broader audience.
 
What you are looking for is one party rule not more democracy.

One-party rule that agrees with his views, of course.

As he says quite openly, he wouldn't mind "undermocratic" rule as long a it's by "enlightened progressive elitists".

Why those stupid, non-progressives who disagree with him were ever given the right to vote, he has no idea.

This the second communique from the shadow government headed by cool, hip democratically chosen Internet Revolutionaries.

Ah, weak sarcasm -- the last resort of those thoroughly defeated in an argument.

The internet equivaent of, "I MEANT to do that!"
 
Last edited:
One-party rule that agrees with his views, of course.

As he says quite openly, he wouldn't mind "undermocratic" rule as long a it's by "enlightened progressive elitists".

Why those stupid, non-progressives who disagree with him were ever given the right to vote, he has no idea.



Ah, weak sarcasm -- the last resort of those thoroughly defeated in an argument.

The internet equivaent of, "I MEANT to do that!"
The democrats are making a fatal mistake by assuming that they have driven the GOP into the sea. That attitude inevitably leads to over reach and with Obama, Pelosi and Reid their reach is coming close to shoulder dislocation.
 
It's painful to see how these threads always devolve into restatement of the current state of affairs: the senate is comprised of two senators from each state, the constitution says so, etc.

Does it ever occur to anyone that this it is exactly this state of affairs being called into question? That X is insufficient justification for X? That the constitution can and might need to be amended with regard to the election of senators?

This is an almost exclusively American disease. I watched some British show on YouTube recently, a debate on the state of faith schools. I'm deeply envious, first that this kind of format for debate exists at all in other countries, and second that throughout the entire conversation, nobody said anything remotely like "The constitution says...!" I wonder if people here even realize the degree to which they've venerated a bunch of dead lawyers.
 
It's painful to see how these threads always devolve into restatement of the current state of affairs: the senate is comprised of two senators from each state, the constitution says so, etc.

Does it ever occur to anyone that this it is exactly this state of affairs being called into question? That X is insufficient justification for X? That the constitution can and might need to be amended with regard to the election of senators?
It can't and doesn't need to be changed. To understand why it can't be so amended, read the requirements for a constitutional amendment.

I'm still waiting for a cogent argument for why we need to abolish the senate. "It isn't sufficiently democratic for my tastes" is not an argument. It seems to have worked well enough the way it is.
 
Last edited:
It's because your argument falls flat on its face. The constitution defines how senators are elected and apportioned.

As mumblethrax just said, this is not an argument. The Constitution, I remind you, was amended in the early part of the last century, revising how Senators are chosen. If we go back to the discussion at that time, what free-standing arguments can you make for and against? A policy is not (morally) right or wrong because the Constitution says so.

You would have a gripe if the both state Senators were required to be from the same party but they are not. The United States is not a direct democracy and it would be disastrous to even contemplate becoming one.

Look up the definition for "direct democracy" -- you have no idea what you're saying.

You base your argument that the late GOP majority in the Senate was undemocratic since they represented less people than the DNC minority... What you are looking for is one party rule not more democracy.

No, I do not base my argument on which political parties are in power. This has been the weak, unsubstantiated slur against my motives -- mostly, if not entirely, because others cannot defend their position. What's interesting about this lie is that I've always been a supporter of third parties because the two we have are too similar.

That is specious argument given that we see the majority change hands on a regular basis in the Senate just as we do in the House and in the White House.

This is a howler. Did you fail maff? What I said was the Senate does not accurately reflect the views of the citizenry, so it does not matter who is in the majority or the minority. What's also interesting is this all-consuming fear of a Democratic (capital D) majority. If you guys are going to say majorities shift between parties, then why the fear of a Democrats in charge? That can change, as it did in the 90s.

Again, the argument about who democratic institutions will empower says more about my opponents than it does about me. They cannot argue this on principles.

----------------
Skeptic:
As he says quite openly, he wouldn't mind "undermocratic" rule as long a it's by "enlightened progressive elitists".

I wonder why you would have to resort to this out-and-out lie if you have "so thoroughly defeated" my argument. What I did was play along with your ad hominem -- the first word of the sentence you reference was "maybe." Thoroughly defeated, indeed.

------------------
Freddy:
I'm still waiting for a cogent argument for why we need to abolish the senate. "It isn't sufficiently democratic for my tastes" is not an argument.

It's an undemocratic institution that arbitrarily discriminates against people based on geographic location, empowering some at the expense of others for no good reason.

But I do like this stunning argument:

It seems to have worked well enough the way it is.

And let's also look at the doom and gloomers who claim democratizing (or abolishing) the Senate will result in tyranny. More than once I have asked for evidence to support this idea and the silence has been overwhelming. We can look at other Western governments more representative than our own and see they are not on the road to serfdom. Of course, this is probably their real fear: we will become more like Western Europe, and the Senate frustrates that move.

The executive branch has expanded way beyond what the Founders intended, arguably changing the character of government far more than simply reforming (or abolishing) the Senate.
---------
Stone Island:

The internal rules of the Senate, I think, are just fine. The purpose of separate institutions sharing power, to paraphrase Youngstown, was to make legislation harder, not easier. Senators who are jealous of their minority rights may be an annoyance, but they also force legislation to be pitched to a broader audience.

If you want to make it more difficult to pass laws, nudge proponents in the direction of appealing to a larger audience, then have a democratically elected Senate that requires more than a simple majority. The thing about its current composition is that we do not NOT need to appeal to a broader audience because it's not democratically representative.
 
It can't and doesn't need to be changed. To understand why it can't be so amended, read the requirements for a constitutional amendment.
I'm not sure I understand the significance of the highlighted portion; are you aware that this describes the 17th amendment?

Anyway, the practical hurdles to reform of the senate are serious but not insurmountable. The easiest path would be to first amend Article V, which does not contain any explicit prohibition on amending Article V (I'll leave the inevitable debate here to the constitutional scholars). More serious than the procedural hurdle is overcoming indoctrination. The debate dies on the vine because "the constitution says...."

I'm still waiting for a cogent argument for why we need to abolish the senate. "It isn't sufficiently democratic for my tastes" is not an argument. It seems to have worked well enough the way it is.
Here you're mischaracterizing the basic principles of justice at stake as matters of taste and incorrectly identifying where the burden of proof lies, given that those principles are well supported by argument and widely sanctioned by law. Cain has already made the salient argument against, it's now up to someone to offer a meaningful response.

To further drive this point home, the courts have held that the equal protection clause is violated where state legislatures apportion representation on the basis of geography. How, then, can we coherently argue that the Senate is the only legislative body in the US that can be so unrepresentative? Because the Founding Fathers (pbut), the constitution, necessary compromises, it's called federalism, etc. Non-arguments that do not address the basic injustice at hand.

I don't disagree that reform of the senate is unlikely to occur, by the way. I just think we ought to be able to recognize how absurd that situation is, if only as a warning to future lawmakers.
 
What I did was play along with your ad hominem

And "playing along with my ad hominem" made you post that you'd support a dictatorship by people you like?

the first word of the sentence you reference was "maybe."

When someone will MAYBE support a dictatorship by people he likes, that means he WILL support a dictatorship by people he likes.
 
It's painful to see how these threads always devolve into restatement of the current state of affairs: the senate is comprised of two senators from each state, the constitution says so, etc.

Does it ever occur to anyone that this it is exactly this state of affairs being called into question?

I think you mischaracterize things. Yes, Cain, for instance, doesn't like the current state of affairs, but he needs to advance some argument why a change is appropriate.

So far, all he's done is observed the obvious: The Senate doesn't represent the people of the United States. A statement like that demands the obvious response.
 
I think you mischaracterize things. Yes, Cain, for instance, doesn't like the current state of affairs, but he needs to advance some argument why a change is appropriate.
And he has, for example here:

Cain said:
It's an undemocratic institution that arbitrarily discriminates against people based on geographic location, empowering some at the expense of others for no good reason.

jfisher said:
So far, all he's done is observed the obvious: The Senate doesn't represent the people of the United States. A statement like that demands the obvious response.
The obvious response is inadequate. Cain is not merely describing the senate, he is identifying specific problems. It is clear that the Senate is not a democratic institution--clear because this is the very feature of the Senate being criticized.

Let me risk misrepresenting Cain and rephrase a bit to elucidate: what's being said is that it is necessary for a society and its representative bodies to be democratic to be considered just. As Madison said (I'm paraphrasing), it is evidently unjust that we should move away from the principle of proportional representation--once we do that, we move from democracy towards 'tyranny of the minority', away from the import placed on founding ideals like liberty and equality.

Any response of the form "So? The Senate is not a democratic institution" entails a failure to appreciate what it means for injustice to occur. Why would arbitrary discrimination be morally acceptable here, and not, for example, in the Jim Crow South? You can find, without too much effort, similarly wrong-headed pragmatic justifications for segregation. And there is real harm done by this arrangement: it's long been known that the senate systematically directs funds away from big states and towards small states, all other things being equal.
 
I think the basic argument is against Federalism.
That an all powerful Central Government might not be a good idea does not get through to these people.
IN the end, it is a case of wanting to replace something has, on the whole, functioned well with something based on nothing but ideology and abstract reasoning. Politics ,above all, is the art of the practical..something ideologues seem to forget.
 
Therefore, equal representation is given to both. This is a simple concept of federalism
This is incoherent--giving equal representation to one necessarily entails denying equal representation to the other. Furthermore, there is no good reason to give arbitrarily determined political entities rights of equal representation, and saying "federalism" does not immunize against charges of arbitrary discrimination. It is possible, for example, to form a federal government without egregiously unrepresentative legislatures.

(We also are not a democracy, but a democratic republic. So.... )
A distinction without a difference, and one that is not relevant. If we lived in a benevolent dictatorship, the senate populated by appointment, the argument for democratic reform would still apply. The fact of our failure to apply democratic principles is not justification of same.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom