It's because your argument falls flat on its face. The constitution defines how senators are elected and apportioned.
As mumblethrax just said, this is not an argument. The Constitution, I remind you, was amended in the early part of the last century, revising how Senators are chosen. If we go back to the discussion at that time, what free-standing arguments can you make for and against? A policy is not (morally) right or wrong
because the Constitution says so.
You would have a gripe if the both state Senators were required to be from the same party but they are not. The United States is not a direct democracy and it would be disastrous to even contemplate becoming one.
Look up the definition for "direct democracy" -- you have no idea what you're saying.
You base your argument that the late GOP majority in the Senate was undemocratic since they represented less people than the DNC minority... What you are looking for is one party rule not more democracy.
No, I do not
base my argument on which political parties are in power. This has been the weak, unsubstantiated slur against my motives -- mostly, if not entirely, because others cannot defend their position. What's interesting about this lie is that I've always been a supporter of third parties because the two we have are
too similar.
That is specious argument given that we see the majority change hands on a regular basis in the Senate just as we do in the House and in the White House.
This is a howler. Did you fail maff? What I said was the Senate does not accurately reflect the views of the citizenry, so it does not matter who is in the majority or the minority. What's also interesting is this all-consuming fear of a Democratic (capital D) majority. If you guys are going to say majorities shift between parties, then why the fear of a Democrats in charge? That can change, as it did in the 90s.
Again, the argument about who democratic institutions will empower says more about my opponents than it does about me. They cannot argue this on principles.
----------------
Skeptic:
As he says quite openly, he wouldn't mind "undermocratic" rule as long a it's by "enlightened progressive elitists".
I wonder why you would have to resort to this out-and-out lie if you have "so thoroughly defeated" my argument. What I did was play along with your ad hominem -- the first word of the sentence you reference was "maybe." Thoroughly defeated, indeed.
------------------
Freddy:
I'm still waiting for a cogent argument for why we need to abolish the senate. "It isn't sufficiently democratic for my tastes" is not an argument.
It's an undemocratic institution that arbitrarily discriminates against people based on geographic location, empowering some at the expense of others for no good reason.
But I do like this stunning argument:
It seems to have worked well enough the way it is.
And let's also look at the doom and gloomers who claim democratizing (or abolishing) the Senate will result in tyranny. More than once I have asked for evidence to support this idea and the silence has been overwhelming. We can look at other Western governments more representative than our own and see they are not on the road to serfdom. Of course, this is probably their real fear: we will become more like Western Europe, and the Senate frustrates that move.
The executive branch has expanded way beyond what the Founders intended, arguably changing the character of government far more than simply reforming (or abolishing) the Senate.
---------
Stone Island:
The internal rules of the Senate, I think, are just fine. The purpose of separate institutions sharing power, to paraphrase Youngstown, was to make legislation harder, not easier. Senators who are jealous of their minority rights may be an annoyance, but they also force legislation to be pitched to a broader audience.
If you want to make it more difficult to pass laws, nudge proponents in the direction of appealing to a larger audience, then have a democratically elected Senate that requires more than a simple majority. The thing about its current composition is that we do not NOT need to appeal to a broader audience because it's not democratically representative.