gumboot
lorcutus.tolere
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2006
- Messages
- 25,327
These sorts of threads always amuse me. I often see people showing a total lack of understanding of "democracy" or "republic". Most often, those arguing a clear democracy is not a democracy decide to use the extremely narrow definition of "direct democracy" - a type of state that's quite clearly impossible to implement in a modern country.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned much in this thread is that the USA is not just a democracy, or a republic. It's also a Federation. There's a reason it's called the United States of America and not the United State of America. And to remind some people a "state" is not an administrative sub-district. A state is sovereign.
To talk of the US Senate as not being democratic is akin to saying the UN isn't democratic because China has the same number of votes as New Zealand, despite representing about 300 times as many people.
In any sort of Federation the states are sovereign, not the populace. Each state gets equal number of votes. Applies to the UN, and to the US Senate.
Interestingly, if you adhere to the original model of democracy, the actual organ of democracy is not the general elections, but the legislature's act of voting on laws.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned much in this thread is that the USA is not just a democracy, or a republic. It's also a Federation. There's a reason it's called the United States of America and not the United State of America. And to remind some people a "state" is not an administrative sub-district. A state is sovereign.
To talk of the US Senate as not being democratic is akin to saying the UN isn't democratic because China has the same number of votes as New Zealand, despite representing about 300 times as many people.
In any sort of Federation the states are sovereign, not the populace. Each state gets equal number of votes. Applies to the UN, and to the US Senate.
Interestingly, if you adhere to the original model of democracy, the actual organ of democracy is not the general elections, but the legislature's act of voting on laws.
