Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

These sorts of threads always amuse me. I often see people showing a total lack of understanding of "democracy" or "republic". Most often, those arguing a clear democracy is not a democracy decide to use the extremely narrow definition of "direct democracy" - a type of state that's quite clearly impossible to implement in a modern country.

One thing I haven't seen mentioned much in this thread is that the USA is not just a democracy, or a republic. It's also a Federation. There's a reason it's called the United States of America and not the United State of America. And to remind some people a "state" is not an administrative sub-district. A state is sovereign.

To talk of the US Senate as not being democratic is akin to saying the UN isn't democratic because China has the same number of votes as New Zealand, despite representing about 300 times as many people.

In any sort of Federation the states are sovereign, not the populace. Each state gets equal number of votes. Applies to the UN, and to the US Senate.

Interestingly, if you adhere to the original model of democracy, the actual organ of democracy is not the general elections, but the legislature's act of voting on laws.
 
These sorts of threads always amuse me. I often see people showing a total lack of understanding of "democracy" or "republic". Most often, those arguing a clear democracy is not a democracy decide to use the extremely narrow definition of "direct democracy" - a type of state that's quite clearly impossible to implement in a modern country.

One thing I haven't seen mentioned much in this thread is that the USA is not just a democracy, or a republic. It's also a Federation. There's a reason it's called the United States of America and not the United State of America. And to remind some people a "state" is not an administrative sub-district. A state is sovereign.

To talk of the US Senate as not being democratic is akin to saying the UN isn't democratic because China has the same number of votes as New Zealand, despite representing about 300 times as many people.

In any sort of Federation the states are sovereign, not the populace. Each state gets equal number of votes. Applies to the UN, and to the US Senate.

Interestingly, if you adhere to the original model of democracy, the actual organ of democracy is not the general elections, but the legislature's act of voting on laws.

Good post.

This whole federal government vs states rights debate has always been in American politics and society, and always will.

Maybe we should have united as a single state before we had our Revolution...
 
Not true. The Senate a representative body. It represents the states.

Not true. It gives equal power to each state.

Given that my terms by now are reasonably well-defined, what we have here are two counts of the equivocation fallacy -- and shortly after your blabbering denial on taking a state-centric view. Very nice.

I see: Your argument still lacks substance so you continue the attempt to shift the burden.

This is a non-response.

I see you still have plenty of straw left. Your analogy is a poor one, too, because it attempts to shift the discussion from state representation at the federal level to one of voting rights and race.

You're restating the analogy, not rebutting it. It's as if a person makes an argument for a women suffrage, noting black men were historically denied (the formal) right to cast a vote. You're simply saying, "well, those were men. You're talking about women. Men and women are different." You need to produce a reason why "state representation at the federal level" trumps one person, one vote. But I fully expect you to evade this point, as you have evaded others... more than once.

Argumentum ad soap box.

That's a new one, but also rather... meaningless.
 
Last edited:
To talk of the US Senate as not being democratic is akin to saying the UN isn't democratic because China has the same number of votes as New Zealand, despite representing about 300 times as many people.

In any sort of Federation the states are sovereign, not the populace. Each state gets equal number of votes. Applies to the UN, and to the US Senate.

Yes, but I disagree with federalism too :p .

But still, federalism doesn't inherently require this sort of representation, hence the debate and compromise necessary during the writing of our Constitution.
 
I can think of mob rule that the constitution's writers meant to prevent, specifically by making a document meant to prevent the minority from the majority.

Here in my state, where the elected representatives refuse to do their job as following the constitution would make them unpopular they turn their job over to the mob, and we end up with :

Anti gay legislation

Religious smoking laws

Religious alcohol laws

Religious noise laws

Rampant environmental destruction/ economy ruining in favor of realty

Religious fear of the dark laws

Blue laws

calling mob rule a strawman does not make it any less of a mob rule
 
These sorts of threads always amuse me. I often see people showing a total lack of understanding of "democracy" or "republic". Most often, those arguing a clear democracy is not a democracy decide to use the extremely narrow definition of "direct democracy" - a type of state that's quite clearly impossible to implement in a modern country.

One thing I haven't seen mentioned much in this thread is that the USA is not just a democracy, or a republic. It's also a Federation. There's a reason it's called the United States of America and not the United State of America. And to remind some people a "state" is not an administrative sub-district. A state is sovereign.

To talk of the US Senate as not being democratic is akin to saying the UN isn't democratic because China has the same number of votes as New Zealand, despite representing about 300 times as many people.

In any sort of Federation the states are sovereign, not the populace. Each state gets equal number of votes. Applies to the UN, and to the US Senate.

Interestingly, if you adhere to the original model of democracy, the actual organ of democracy is not the general elections, but the legislature's act of voting on laws.

The main problem with this is that it totally ignores U.S. history, especially after the Civil War. The character of the country changed, and the autonomy of states diminished. This has been the trend, though it progresses in fits and starts, since the failure of the Articles of Confederation.
 
...<snip>...

So where does this leave us? You haven't advanced your argument at all.

Skeptic provided an excellent summary many posts back. It still applies:

What's to answer? You note the senate is "undemocratic" in the sense that small and large states both have the same number of senators (two).

We note that, yes, that is the whole point behind the senate.

You say you don't like it.

Well... so what? Who cares?
 
Cain:

You wanted a serious answer? Here's a serious answer. But you won't like it.

You are willing to break down the backbone of the world's most successful and free country becasue according to its system, PEOPLE YOU DON'T LIKE GOT MORE POWER THAN YOU THINK THEY SHOULD. This has nothing to do with "the people" or "democracy": it is obvious that you wouldn't mind if the Democrats had more power than they "should" in the Senate. It is only "crazily undemocratic" for Republicans, which you dislike, to have more power than they "should".

This is the very essence of totalitarian thinking. You're a would-be dictator.

You cover this up with lots of sweet talk about "democracy" and "the people", but so do all would-be dictators. In reality, you despise the people. We can see what you REALLY think about "the people" the moment they disagree with you: the vast majority of them thinks the bicameral system, with both the house and the senate, is a very good system? Who cares! YOU decided it is "stupid", indeed a "typically incredibly stupid American thing" (or words to that effect), so that's that.

You're angry, like all self-important would-be dictators, because the world -- or at least those stupid hicks who vote for the other guy -- doesn't recognize your obvious intellectual superiority to all those stupid people you disagree with. Ah well.

So, there's your serious answer. I told you you wouldn't like it.
 
Last edited:
Cain:

You wanted a serious answer? Here's a serious answer. But you won't like it.

You are willing to break down the backbone of the world's most successful and free country becasue according to its system, PEOPLE YOU DON'T LIKE GOT MORE POWER THAN YOU THINK THEY SHOULD. This has nothing to do with "the people" or "democracy": it is obvious that you wouldn't mind if the Democrats had more power than they "should" in the Senate. It is only "crazily undemocratic" for Republicans, which you dislike, to have more power than they "should".

This is the very essence of totalitarian thinking. You're a would-be dictator.

You cover this up with lots of sweet talk about "democracy" and "the people", but so do all would-be dictators. In reality, you despise the people. We can see what you REALLY think about "the people" the moment they disagree with you: the vast majority of them thinks the bicameral system, with both the house and the senate, is a very good system? Who cares! YOU decided it is "stupid", indeed a "typically incredibly stupid American thing" (or words to that effect), so that's that.

You're angry, like all self-important would-be dictators, because the world -- or at least those stupid hicks who vote for the other guy -- doesn't recognize your obvious intellectual superiority to all those stupid people you disagree with. Ah well.

So, there's your serious answer. I told you you wouldn't like it.

do you belive you can read other peoples mind? or are you just extremly arrogant?
 
Internet Revolutionary/Wannabe Dictator -- this the first communique the People's Shadow Government.

Everyone check out Urbandictionary's word for the day. It's important you stay cool, hip.

---

"Skeptic," - are you saying the Senate is the backbone of our country?

I think your post says more about you than it does me. I like to recall W.'s contingency plans for a case where Gore wins the Electoral College but he wins the popular vote, which is what most people expected. The campaign worker said (paraphrasing, I can get the exact quote), "one thing we don't do is roll over." They had a whole talk radio campaign planned, and even the slogan "Democrats for democracy."

I'm pretty sure I've never voted a Democrat for Senator since the two representing my state are particularly loathsome. For the presidency (the whole Electoral College deal) I've voted for a third party candidate every time.

Maybe if enlightened elite Leftists actually did run the country via undemocratic institutions, I wouldn't care about the will of the people. And I do have contempt for the typical person, and especially most of the persons I meet (or encounter on the Internet) Maybe I don't actually believe the principles I'm espousing and I am a "would-be dictator." So?

You see what I just did? I assumed your baseless allegations were true, and they still proved nothing, which suggests they're completely irrelevant. Bracket out the personalities involved and deal with the arguments at hand. If you can. How is anything in your post an argument against one person, one vote, or any of the principles brought up in this thread? You're attacking a person rather than ideas, which makes perfect sense considering your position of weakness.

the vast majority of them thinks the bicameral system, with both the house and the senate, is a very good system? Who cares!

I'll bet most of that is due to status-quo bias. If you asked people, "Should we amend the Constitution to replace our unicameral legislature with a bicameral legislature" most people would say No. Something like three times as many Americans believe in the Virgin Birth than the scientific account for the origins of life.

The main problem is that these institutions are sacred cows that people would prefer not to question. So you get blather about the "world's most successful and free country" which makes me want to quote "Ozymandias." Grow the **** up.

---------
jsfisher writes:
So where does this leave us? You haven't advanced your argument at all.

Your undisguised contempt for truth and understanding has never been as charming. I especially like this fine touch: "Skeptic [sic] provided an excellent summary many posts back."
 
Okay. Now that I've read a bit further, I'd like someone to explain to me why states (which, despite Cain's comments about being weaker, still have signifcant autonomy) should be unrepresentated in a legislative body. Since, you know.

Federalism?

Simple. Some states vote in ways Cain doesn't like.

His highness emperor Cain I doesn't like it when the will of the people is subverted this way, you know.
 
aah thanks for the answer, its indeed the arrogance.
 
Your undisguised contempt for truth and understanding has never been as charming. I especially like this fine touch: "Skeptic [sic] provided an excellent summary many posts back."

I see you continue to substitute vitriol and histrionics for argument and reason.
 
I just like my governmental philosophy to be based on some premises, and not just hodge-podged together with what they had at the time and however they could get people to agree to it and then worshiping that as a new Revelation from the Lord.
Snarky me is coming out again but unfortunatly the government is perfectly based off a philosophy. It is a liberal government which for all intents and purposes can't be democratic.
Ha ha, see, this is what our Fathers thought! The common unclean filth are too stupid to vote as freely as us educated people! Why, give them equal say and they'll vote to turn our mansions into common housing and make beer free to all! I say the blacks would turn us into slaves!
Only someone who has failed basic history would make that assinine argument. I've read the material from that time period about liberalism. These people were not elitist like you idiotically think. I was reading a book on liberalism written 200 years ago and it came disturbingly on target about some modern day issues like suicide. The tyranny of the majority basically refers to the issues like Prop 8. Protect the unpopular opinion. Freedom to do whatever you want without trouncing upon others freedom. Is it perfect in the United States? No. Will democratizing the process help? No. It will drive the United States backwards.
 
Last edited:
Maybe if enlightened elite Leftists actually did run the country via undemocratic institutions, I wouldn't care about the will of the people.

"Maybe"? That's your dream -- a dictatorship of people who agree with you.

100 years ago, people like you would rant in cheap cafes and beer halls in central Europe about the "evil government system" that "ignores the will of the people" and gives WAAAAAAAAAAAY too much power to those evil plutocrats, I mean communists, I mean atheists, I mean Catholics, I mean Jews, I mean landowners, I mean... you fill in the blanks.

Those would-be dictators disagreed between themselves about what "the people" want, but they all, from Hitler to Lenin to Ho Chi Minh to Franco, all agreed that (a) the current system must be smashed, and (b) there will only be REAL justice and democracy and freedom and equality (and so on) once, after the existing system is smashed, a system where people THEY LIKE will be in power.

You're just like those guys, only using modern technology -- you rant on the internet instead of ranting in beer halls, which, I suppose, is an improvement (from the point of view of combating alcoholism, if nothing else) -- and with a slightly different "evil group X" that must be smashed (in your case, Republicans).

Now, one of the main reasons the USA never experienced the havoc these folks from the beer hall and cafes later wrecked in Europe (and elsewhere) is precisely institutions like the Senate, the electoral college -- in short, the federal system of government -- which makes it harder for demagogues and "revolutionaries" to gain power.

The fact that you hate the senate and consider it evil is proof, if any was needed, of one of the main reasons the senate was set up in the first place: it's there, inter alia, to protect the Republic and its freedoms from the likes of you.
 
Last edited:
I love people who want to totally scrap a system which, although flawed, has worked pretty well for over a couple of hundred years on the basis that it disagrees with a totally abstract thesis that the Senate and Check and Balances between the Feds and the State are somehow "undemocratic".
 
I love people who want to totally scrap a system which, although flawed, has worked pretty well for over a couple of hundred years on the basis that it disagrees with a totally abstract thesis that the Senate and Check and Balances between the Feds and the State are somehow "undemocratic".

Would this be any better if they still taught basic American history and civics in the public schools? I really think so much of it is pure ignorance. Ignorance begets surprise when things work out differently than assumed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom