Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

I live in a state where the majority was able to dominate the minority through ballot measures (aka elected representatives being too chicken to do their job so they hand it to the mobs), precisely the thing the constitution wanted to prevent

it SUCKS

Run away democracy is exactly the same as mob rule, not a happy way to live when you fall out of favor with the conformist drones

Ha ha, see, this is what our Fathers thought! The common unclean filth are too stupid to vote as freely as us educated people! Why, give them equal say and they'll vote to turn our mansions into common housing and make beer free to all! I say the blacks would turn us into slaves!

This is the original elitism.

C'mon, any examples of proportional representation leading to "mobocracy"?
 
And as such what? What's your jumping off point? Suppose we transform the Senate into a democratic institution, is the threat of tyranny more likely?
So basically you want another House of Representatives? Why don't you just abolish the Senate entirely?

What's amusing is that we can easily re-write this story in conservative terms, extolling virtues of excellence, and merit. You have big states and small states. Why? In some cases because some states are just better than others. A lot of people prefer to live in America than pick-some-dumb-third-world country because, well, America is better. America's the best. Similarly, a lot of people choose to live in New York and California because they're dreamers and they want to make something of themselves. They want to succeed. Yet, in America, right now, tax dollars flow from the populous states to the not-so-populous states. You're taking our tax dollars for dumb pet projects and stupid Homeland Security protocols (as if any self-respecting terrorist is going to attack ****in' Wyoming).
And there's that California-elitist self-righteous class-warfaring Cain we all know!

Why don't you just lobby to have California secede from the union? Then you won't have all those flyover country hicks to worry about. You know, the ones that produce the food you eat?
 
Excellent question hidden behind that straw man you erected. Maybe you'd consider starting a new thread with just such a question so as to not derail this one.

What straw man? Before this thread was split someone else used the word "tyranny." I would really like to know how the large states will tyrannize the small states, and how it's any different than the current tyranny of the many: the small states thwarting and extorting the large states.


Wildcat:
Why don't you just lobby to have California secede from the union?

I am not unopposed to regionalism. After all, California's one of the ten biggest economies in the world.


Then you won't have all those flyover country hicks to worry about. You know, the ones that produce the food you eat?

Not that it matters in a globalized world... but California is also the leading agricultural state :rolleyes: It's also home of Ronald Reagan, Pete Wilson, Richard Nixon, and Prop. 13. Our governor is Ahnold, and despite popular misperception, we're plenty enough conservative.

I do not personally mind if California tax dollars, on net, flow of the state, especially if it's to help the poorer states build their infrastructure. The earlier Harrison Bergeron style argument appeals directly to the elitist sentiments of the libertarian-Republicans on these forums -- the sort of people who probably resent rural electrification and Great Society programs aimed relieving poverty in Appalachia.

I live in a state where the majority was able to dominate the minority through ballot measures (aka elected representatives being too chicken to do their job so they hand it to the mobs), precisely the thing the constitution wanted to prevent

Pipelineaudio:
I live in a state where the majority was able to dominate the minority through ballot measures (aka elected representatives being too chicken to do their job so they hand it to the mobs), precisely the thing the constitution wanted to prevent

Really? The Constitution was designed to protect states from internal democratic pressure -- "mobocracy"? Really? Can you identify the article(s) in the Constitution with that aim?

The Constitution, borne out of fears of revolution (e.g., Shays' Rebellion) moved the country toward greater centralization. States lost autonomy to print their own currency, engage in tariff wars and so on. Frickin' jackasses need to read their Constitution along with Supreme court cases from McCulloch v. Maryland to incorporation theory and Gitlow v. New York.

-----
People forget the Constitution was the result of elite compromises. Hell, when Jefferson drafted the Declaration of Independence years earlier he had language condemning King George for imposing the "wicked" institution of slavery upon the colonies. That was dropped because some states had slave-based economies.

Anyway, I am still interested in learning how a democratically reformed or abolished Senate will lead to larger states "tyrannizing" smaller states.
 
he USA is NOT a democracy -- it is a REPUBLIC.
Oh God, it's you. Of course you believe such nonsense.

Well, so did Washington, Jefferson, Adams, Franklin, and a few other people. Buuuuuuut, what the heck did THEY know?

After all, it's the natural right of the "Chosen People" to oppress the Palestinian hordes.

Huh? I believe the USA is a Republic because I'm a Jew?

That's a new one. Paranoid today, aren't we?

And what does America being a Republic or a Democracy have to do with the Israeli-Arab conflict, anyway?

Nothing -- but, in the "progressive" camp, shouting "zionist!", like shouting "racist!", long ago ceased to have any meaning; it is just an ejaculation meaning, roughly, "you disagree with me and that makes me angry! Shame on you!".
 
Well, so did Washington, Jefferson, Adams, Franklin, and a few other people. Buuuuuuut, what the heck did THEY know?

No... you don't know what a republic is. You're contrasting terms without having the slightest understanding of their definitions. Communist countries called themselves republics.

Huh? I believe the USA is a Republic because I'm a Jew?

No again.

That's a new one. Paranoid today, aren't we?

Paranoid, indeed.

And what does America being a Republic or a Democracy have to do with the Israeli-Arab conflict, anyway?

Nothing -- but, in the "progressive" camp, shouting "zionist!", like shouting "racist!", long ago ceased to have any meaning; it is just an ejaculation meaning, roughly, "you disagree with me and that makes me angry! Shame on you!".

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Maybe you can answer the question posed directly to you: Assuming the Senate is reformed along democratic lines (or abolished), how would the U.S. cease to be a republic?

"Republic, not a democracy" is a dumb slogan endlessly repeated by mouthbreathers not interested in serious scrutiny.
 
Whilw it may be the result of elitist trades (Although, I'm dying to know how the word elitist is useful there), they were there for a reason.

The Constitution, remember, was drafted in secret (they were supposed to be reforming the AoC). The men who wrote it came from wealthy classes. Cited in nearly all American history textbooks is Charles Austin Beard's An Economic Interpretation of the U.S. Constitution. It's not difficult to find quotes from Founding Fathers claiming government is instituted for the protection of private property, and men are unequal in faculties conducive to property acquisition. There were serious fears of what was called "leveling."

The mob stuff glorified today involves throwing tea into the harbor and terrorizing loyalists with tars and feathers.

Namely, if you want proof of larger states ruling over smaller states, look at the electoral college map.

This is a joke, right? Now the Electoral College is too democratic an institution?? It's another one that needs to be abolished. Jesus.

Wyoming has THREE electoral votes. California has, what, fifty-five electoral votes? That's only an 18 times difference when California has 70X as many people.
 
The Constitution, remember, was drafted in secret (they were supposed to be reforming the AoC). The men who wrote it came from wealthy classes. Cited in nearly all American history textbooks is Charles Austin Beard's An Economic Interpretation of the U.S. Constitution. It's not difficult to find quotes from Founding Fathers claiming government is instituted for the protection of private property, and men are unequal in faculties conducive to property acquisition. There were serious fears of what was called "leveling."


I've read Madison's diary. Sorry, no.

This is a joke, right? Now the Electoral College is too democratic an institution?? It's another one that needs to be abolished. Jesus.

Wyoming has THREE electoral votes. California has, what, fifty-five electoral votes? That's only an 18 times difference when California has 70X as many people.


Tha.. no, that's not what I was claiming.
 
I've read Madison's diary. Sorry, no.

Well there you go. That seems to sum you up.

Tha.. no, that's not what I was claiming.

Oh, well by all means, please explain. You're doing such a brilliant job expressing yourself, crafting arguments and anticipating counterarguments. I'm just... amazed.
 
Now the Electoral College is too democratic an institution?? It's another one that needs to be abolished. Jesus.

It is an curious result of debate and compromise, but it doesn't need to be abolished.

Wyoming has THREE electoral votes. California has, what, fifty-five electoral votes? That's only an 18 times difference when California has 70X as many people.

You are right; that is unfair to Wyoming. California should have fewer votes.
 
The USA is NOT a democracy -- it is a REPUBLIC. It deliberately created a balance between proportional representation (in the House of Representatives) and one where each state of the Union has the same number of senators (the Senate).


You appear to NOT KNOW the meanings of the words "democracy" and "republic." They are not mutually exclusive. A republic, roughly speaking, is a country without a monarch. The United States is a democratic republic.

Most, perhaps all, democratic countries have some form of representative democracy, as opposed to totally direct democracy. Thus the states of the United States, the people of whom elected their senators directly, are represented in Senate. The people, in roughly equal proportion, are represented in the House of Representative (thus the moniker: "People's House").

Before the 17th admendment, there was another representative layer in this senator selection process, where the elected state legislatures selected senators.
 
The USA is a Representative Democracy. Our founding fathers made it this way. If you don't like it, urge your Congressmen to change it.

By the way, China and Russia and Venezuela and Iran are also...Republics. Big deal.
 
Oh noes, the smaller states will be overwhelmed! Heavens to Betsy!

The idea that democracy has to be inefficient to be good is silly. Furthermore, the idea that it should be so based on geography is even dumber. The government is made for the people, not invisible entities called States. And thanks for reading my mind.

At the time, the small states were not going to ratify the constitution without this compromise, which was called the Great Compromise. If the small states hadn't ratified the constitution, the United States would not have been formed. Since it would take an amendment to the constitution to change it, and since to get to 3/4 of the state legislatures would require that many small states agree to this amendment, this discussion is purely academic. Besides, the current set up has worked well enough so far.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom