Excellent question hidden behind that straw man you erected. Maybe you'd consider starting a new thread with just such a question so as to not derail this one.
What straw man? Before this thread was split someone else used the word "tyranny." I would really like to know how the large states will tyrannize the small states, and how it's any different than the current tyranny of the many: the small states thwarting and extorting the large states.
Wildcat:
Why don't you just lobby to have California secede from the union?
I am not unopposed to regionalism. After all, California's one of the ten biggest economies in the world.
Then you won't have all those flyover country hicks to worry about. You know, the ones that produce the food you eat?
Not that it matters in a globalized world... but California is also the leading agricultural state

It's also home of Ronald Reagan, Pete Wilson, Richard Nixon, and Prop. 13. Our governor is Ahnold, and despite popular misperception, we're plenty enough conservative.
I do not personally mind if California tax dollars, on net, flow of the state, especially if it's to help the poorer states build their infrastructure. The earlier Harrison Bergeron style argument appeals directly to the elitist sentiments of the libertarian-Republicans on these forums -- the sort of people who probably resent rural electrification and Great Society programs aimed relieving poverty in Appalachia.
I live in a state where the majority was able to dominate the minority through ballot measures (aka elected representatives being too chicken to do their job so they hand it to the mobs), precisely the thing the constitution wanted to prevent
Pipelineaudio:
I live in a state where the majority was able to dominate the minority through ballot measures (aka elected representatives being too chicken to do their job so they hand it to the mobs), precisely the thing the constitution wanted to prevent
Really? The Constitution was designed to protect states from internal democratic pressure -- "mobocracy"?
Really? Can you identify the article(s) in the Constitution with that aim?
The Constitution, borne out of fears of revolution (e.g., Shays' Rebellion) moved the country toward greater centralization. States lost autonomy to print their own currency, engage in tariff wars and so on. Frickin' jackasses need to read their Constitution along with Supreme court cases from
McCulloch v. Maryland to incorporation theory and
Gitlow v. New York.
-----
People forget the Constitution was the result of elite compromises. Hell, when Jefferson drafted the Declaration of Independence years earlier he had language condemning King George for imposing the "wicked" institution of slavery upon the colonies. That was dropped because some states had slave-based economies.
Anyway, I am still interested in learning how a democratically reformed or abolished Senate will lead to larger states "tyrannizing" smaller states.