Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

Soaring and competing rhetoric about liberty is all well and good during an exercise in nation-building. However, actual governance tends to boil down to pragmatic concerns. Smaller regions of a federation would likely take cold comfort in their "liberty" when they have little or no voice on the national stage.

And that is my problem with the Anti Federalists here. They are really arguing from an abstract position as opposed to political facts of life.
 
And that is my problem with the Anti Federalists here. They are really arguing from an abstract position as opposed to political facts of life.

Yup, the Civil War and the Civil Rights Movements were just abstract philosophy and had nothing to do with the facts of life...

Do you read the thread, or just insult the participants?
 
Oscillating between bare statements of "it's illegitimate" and "the people are not equally represented" isn't the basis for a discussion. You need to advance your argument (without any more straw, please).

It's almost as though your consistent misrepresentations, and irony-free invocation of straw, is a subtle but caustic satirization of the position you claim to defend. Or, more likely, i's a case-study in proof-by-assertion mediocrity.
 
Soaring and competing rhetoric about liberty is all well and good during an exercise in nation-building. However, actual governance tends to boil down to pragmatic concerns. Smaller regions of a federation would likely take cold comfort in their "liberty" when they have little or no voice on the national stage.

Again, what makes "regional" minorities so special as to deserve an entire entire house in the legislature to over-represent them? I can think of many other minorities more deserving on the national stage.
 
Yup, the Civil War and the Civil Rights Movements were just abstract philosophy and had nothing to do with the facts of life...

Do you read the thread, or just insult the participants?

I don't think dudalb is much of a fan of reading people's positions and considering them. He's demonstrated at least twice a complete ignorance of simple facts I've stated multiple times, including what country I am a citizen of.
 
Again, what makes "regional" minorities so special as to deserve an entire entire house in the legislature to over-represent them? I can think of many other minorities more deserving on the national stage.
Federalism. Both of our countries are unions of smaller states. The union only works, in part, because those states are allowed to maintain a significant degree of independence and clout. Geographic representation is one of the mechanisms that does that. Canada wouldn't exist without that particular mechanism, and I suspect it has nearly the same importance for the USA.
 
It's almost as though your consistent misrepresentations, and irony-free invocation of straw, is a subtle but caustic satirization of the position you claim to defend. Or, more likely, i's a case-study in proof-by-assertion mediocrity.

...and still devoid of argument or substance.
 
I am now convinced that what we are dealing with is a few ideologues who Know their programs have no chance of suceeding with the present system,and therefore want to scrap the system.
Good luck with that.
 
:rolleyes: Yes, I suppose the poor people of Ireland, Denmark, France, Israel, Norway, New Zealand, Finland, Sweden, etc. are all living horribly under their respective tyranny of the majority.
Hey, not so smart one, those systems too are based on diffusion of political powers, in a slightly different mode than is ours. See what it takes to become a prime minister.

You have learned nothing.

You waste bandwidth, yet again.

DR
 
I am now convinced that what we are dealing with is a few ideologues who Know their programs have no chance of suceeding with the present system,and therefore want to scrap the system.
Good luck with that.

Amazing how you announce these conclusions without giving or recognizing any arguments.
 
Federalism. Both of our countries are unions of smaller states. The union only works, in part, because those states are allowed to maintain a significant degree of independence and clout. Geographic representation is one of the mechanisms that does that. Canada wouldn't exist without that particular mechanism, and I suspect it has nearly the same importance for the USA.

And no one has told me why federalism requires an unequal upper chamber of the legislature. The Constitution is Federal because it makes a limited central government that has authority over the States, and since it is limited the States have authority in their own affairs outside of what is allowed for the Federal government.

None of that has anything to do with representation in the legislature. And many founders of the federal government as we know it thought so. And as you said when you denied protecting other minorites, the States have their rights protected in the Bill of Rights too. So back again to why they are so much more special than other minorities?
 
And no one has told me why federalism requires an unequal upper chamber of the legislature. The Constitution is Federal because it makes a limited central government that has authority over the States, and since it is limited the States have authority in their own affairs outside of what is allowed for the Federal government.

None of that has anything to do with representation in the legislature. And many founders of the federal government as we know it thought so. And as you said when you denied protecting other minorites, the States have their rights protected in the Bill of Rights too. So back again to why they are so much more special than other minorities?
*facepalm*

How much plainer can I be? A bi-cameral legislature with a rep-by-pop lower house and a rep-by-region upper house (among other things) made the bloody federal union possible in the first place. And it sustains it. Sheesh.

If that isn't an important reason, I don't know what is.
 
*facepalm*

How much plainer can I be? A bi-cameral legislature with a rep-by-pop lower house and a rep-by-region upper house (among other things) made the bloody federal union possible in the first place. And it sustains it. Sheesh.

If that isn't an important reason, I don't know what is.

That's just a fallacy. That's the way it was/is, so it is the way it should be. We might as well make the same argument for any and all election reform that can be had.

Federalism doesn't require the Senate be so and many other Federations don't follow the same model. Indeed, there is plenty of variation in how unequal the upper house is, and how representatives are chosen.

And I don't see how one could claim that the Senate somehow helps balance geographic concerns or maintains the Union when you look at the history of the Civil War, which so many people here seem to want to ignore.
 
I am now convinced that what we are dealing with is a few ideologues who Know their programs have no chance of suceeding with the present system,and therefore want to scrap the system.
Good luck with that.

Nice guess.

Now go off and play.
 
That's just a fallacy. That's the way it was/is, so it is the way it should be. We might as well make the same argument for any and all election reform that can be had.

Federalism doesn't require the Senate be so and many other Federations don't follow the same model. Indeed, there is plenty of variation in how unequal the upper house is, and how representatives are chosen.

And I don't see how one could claim that the Senate somehow helps balance geographic concerns or maintains the Union when you look at the history of the Civil War, which so many people here seem to want to ignore.

I made subtler arguments earlier, but you weren't listening.

If you want to argue that the USA can manage regional representation in some other fashion, I won't dispute that. I don't have enough expertise. But you're kidding yourself if you think it is no longer an important issue.

Canadian Federalism requires regional representation in the Upper House. That was one of the core compromises that brought the smaller colonies on board. It cannot be taken away. The ineffectiveness of our Senate currently is one of the forces driving representation in the House of Commons away from rep by pop. The other is the simple fact that we are a geographically huge country with a far-flung population and distinct regional differences. Any system of representation here in the House or the Senate will have to take regions into account or the country will disintegrate.

We even have a "Senate Floor" law that states that no province can be allocated less HOC seats in an electoral district redistribution than they have Senate seats.

American federalism faces similar challenges. Your much larger population mitigates the problems somewhat. But tell your smaller states that they no longer get their 2 Senate seats and see what happens. Go ahead. I'll wait.
 
D'rok said:
American federalism faces similar challenges. Your much larger population mitigates the problems somewhat. But tell your smaller states that they no longer get their 2 Senate seats and see what happens. Go ahead. I'll wait.
You know, I really don't understand this line of reasoning. It seems to center around, "You won't convince these people that you're correct or that something needs to be done, ergo, you should cease discussing the issue (or that there's some negative consequence as a result, or the argument wouldn't be brought up in the first place)".

Maybe I'm wrong, but I'm not sure why else to bring this up. I have a question. If we lived under a Monarch, would that mean that we shouldn't discuss the merits of a republic, if it was so certain that we couldn't institute a republic? Should we discuss potential freedoms or lost abilities? Negatives and positives? That would get rid of quite a few works by Machiavelli...

Looking through this thread, I read (not by you, D'rok) "Californians are crazy so shouldn't be listened to because of <Arbitrary Personal Beliefs>", or "You're elitist, ergo you don't have a single point", or like dudalb, "You're just doing this because of some hidden agenda to make the country what you want it to be!!11111 Ergo your points shouldn't be taken into consideration."

Meh, I usually respect your posts, D'rok, so maybe I got you wrong here. I probably do, as I'm barely awake currently and seriously need to get to bed.
 
Last edited:
You know, I really don't understand this line of reasoning. It seems to center around, "You won't convince these people that you're correct or that something needs to be done, ergo, you should cease discussing the issue (or that there's some negative consequence as a result, or the argument wouldn't be brought up in the first place)".

I'm trying to point out that it is an actual, live issue. I only injected the snark after getting it directed my way a couple of times. I'm only human (and sleep-deprived too).

I'm interested in talking about different ways to deal with what I think is a very real issue. I also happen to be right in the midst of reading about this stuff, including some important American Supreme Court cases. (See e.g. Reynolds v. Simms 377 US 533 and Baker v. Carr 369 US 186). Tsukasa might not think it's a live issue, but American jurists sure seem to.

(The relevant Canadian cases for anyone who's interested include Reference re Prov. Electoral Boundaries (Sask.), [1991] 2 SCR 158 and Raiche v. Canada (Attorney General), [2005] 1 F.C. 93)
 
Last edited:
In my own life, the tyranny of the majority has resulted in:

the complete decimation (or worse) of our thriving arts and music scene

RAMPANT environmental devastation, even in areas protected by law, even worse in areas donated to the people on conditional environmental protection

Massive increase in coyotees, human trafficing and kidnapping

Closure of trails donated for trail use

Quit pretending that mob rule is a good thing
 
In my own life, the tyranny of the majority has resulted in:

the complete decimation (or worse) of our thriving arts and music scene

RAMPANT environmental devastation, even in areas protected by law, even worse in areas donated to the people on conditional environmental protection

Massive increase in coyotees, human trafficing and kidnapping

Closure of trails donated for trail use

Quit pretending that mob rule is a good thing

Those poor, poor souls trapped under mobocracy in Norway, New Zeland, Ireland, Denmark, etc. where they have proportional representation. Let us take a moment of silence for these failed States where human rights are removed right and left by the irrational mob.
 
Those poor, poor souls trapped under mobocracy in Norway, New Zeland, Ireland, Denmark, etc. where they have proportional representation. Let us take a moment of silence for these failed States where human rights are removed right and left by the irrational mob.

My reality trumps your anectdotes

I dont really care about proportional representation for electing leaders, but I DO have a strong objection to mob rule in order to ignore or violate constitutional protections

I'll say it and I'm not afraid to:

People are stupid. People are by and large, stupid, conformist sheep. Furthermore, they are greedy.

I dont want stupid, greedy, conformist sheep in charge of my rights. This directly gives whoever can afford the most TV and Radio advertisement direct control over my rights.

No thanks, I'll take a constitution that protects me from the idiocy of the herd
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom