Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

I love how we hear for 8 years and counting: Americans are stupid because of how they vote (since they voted for Bush)

And now we hear: you guys need to have more voting power
 
Yes, we probably won't be able to change it...

So? Does that somehow make this discussion moot?

That's what a moot point is; an argument about something that's never going to happen. Stuff like IRV and proportional representation for third parties in the USA have a much higher likelihood of happening. Of course, .001% is greater than .000001%.
 
dudalb said:
I think the basic argument is against Federalism.
You're wrong.

Politics ,above all, is the art of the practical..something ideologues seem to forget.
Sometimes a misquote can be instructive.

I love how we hear for 8 years and counting: Americans are stupid because of how they vote (since they voted for Bush)

And now we hear: you guys need to have more voting power
On the contrary; democratic reform would collectively give 'you guys' (the red states) less voting power. Need I remind you that Bush would not have been elected at all without disproportionate representation? If that were a predictably repeatable occurrence, I could hardly think of a better argument for reform.
 
This is incoherent

Well, take it up with Adams, Jefferson, Franklin, and the rest of the no-good incoherent idiots who set up this absurd federalist system.

If you were only there, you would've tould them to their face it's an unfair, evil, undemocratic system that woud NEVER work in practice.

I'm sure they would've listened to you.
 
Last edited:
Well, take it up with Adams, Jefferson, Franklin, and the rest of the no-good incoherent idiots who set up this absurd federalist system.

If you were only there, you would've tould them to their face it's an unfair, evil, undemocratic system that woud NEVER work in practice.

I'm sure they would've listened to you.
Amazingly dishonest, but thank you for making the ancestor worship I'm criticizing explicit.
 
So admiring great men of the past is Ancestor Worship?
Then count me as a Worshiper.
ANd do you have any idea of how arrogant that sounds?
 
So admiring great men of the past is Ancestor Worship?
No. Deferring to the great men of the past where they lack 220 years of hindsight is ancestor worship.

It's perfectly possible to admire Adams, Jefferson, Madison and the rest and still believe that the political compromises they made then are no longer appropriate today.
 
And he has, for example here:

No, he didn't. He doesn't like the Senate because it doesn't do what it wasn't designed to do. Well, neither does the greeter at Walmart. Any argument opposing the Senate's current purpose needs to address the incorrectness of its current purpose head-on.
 
(still disputable)
Not remotely, except among wing-nuts.

jsfisher said:
He doesn't like the Senate because it doesn't do what it wasn't designed to do.
It's only necessary to read what he wrote to see that this is not true. You're evading the fact that the thing it was designed to do, the thing it does, and the thing being deplored are one and the same.

Well, neither does the greeter at Walmart.
If the Walmart greeter were hired to punch 60% of customers in the face every time they walked through the door, I would be singularly unimpressed by the tautological truth that he was hired to do so. I'd instead say things like "Hey, maybe they should change his job description" and "Ow, my nose."
 
It's only necessary to read what he wrote to see that this is not true. You're evading the fact that the thing it was designed to do, the thing it does, and the thing being deplored are one and the same.

Nonsense. The greeter at Walmart is just as "undemocratic" as the Senate (assuming we even accept this rather stilted view of what undemocratic means). So what? Pointing out such a state of affairs is not the basis for a debate or discussion. You need something with more substance if you want to argue Walmart greeters need to be chosen by popular election.
 
If the Walmart greeter were hired to punch 60% of customers in the face every time they walked through the door, I would be singularly unimpressed by the tautological truth that he was hired to do so. I'd instead say things like "Hey, maybe they should change his job description" and "Ow, my nose."

I am at a loss as to how you think this relates to whether the Senate should represent the states or the populace.
 
It's only necessary to read what he wrote to see that this is not true. You're evading the fact that the thing it was designed to do, the thing it does, and the thing being deplored are one and the same.
No he's deploring for a dumb reason. It's pretty evident to everyone else as to why the government is set up the way it is. It is set up to make it harder for people to trounce upon other people's rights. It is ridiculously easy to see how the will of the majority can run rough shot over what the minority wants where you live in a state where they were opposed to maternal.

No. Deferring to the great men of the past where they lack 220 years of hindsight is ancestor worship.

It's perfectly possible to admire Adams, Jefferson, Madison and the rest and still believe that the political compromises they made then are no longer appropriate today.
But they still are because unlike you I read books from that era. Not much has changed in two hundred years. And sadly Cain and you are so ignorant you can't even realize that some of us are forming arguments that are a couple thousand years old. :)
 
Last edited:
Nonsense. The greeter at Walmart is just as "undemocratic" as the Senate (assuming we even accept this rather stilted view of what undemocratic means). So what? Pointing out such a state of affairs is not the basis for a debate or discussion. You need something with more substance if you want to argue Walmart greeters need to be chosen by popular election.
I do not see how this even addresses what I wrote.

Regardless, there is no expectation that the Walmart greeter be hired by popular election because he does not have the power to make public policy.

I am at a loss as to how you think this relates to whether the Senate should represent the states or the populace.
It's a simple analogy. Harm is done by in both cases, and the harm itself is sufficient motivation for reform. The usual argument that it neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg is not available to you, since it does in fact pick my pocket.

technoextreme said:
No he's deploring for a dumb reason. It's pretty evident to everyone else as to why the government is set up the way it is. It is set up to make it harder for people to trounce upon other people's rights. It is ridiculously easy to see how the will of the majority can run rough shot over what the minority wants where you live in a state where they were opposed to maternal.
As has already been said, the senate was set up this way as a political compromise. There is no coherent political philosophy backing it, and it simply does not work as intended. Even if it did work, what's so great about violating the rights of the majority to protect the rights of the minority?

Furthermore, it's an absurdly ill-targeted way of protecting minorities. Imagine that I suggested that we give disproportionate voting power to women (for example), in order to "make it harder for people to trounce upon other people's rights." Here we have a real history of the rights of a political minority being violated, rather than counterfactual speculation about big states bullying small states. The contention between demographic groups is a much more serious force in modern political life than that between states. But my proposal would (correctly) be regarded as an outrage.

For some reason, I'm supposed to take it seriously when we're talking about nothing more than a matter of residency, where there is no specific history of populous states violating the rights of residents of less populous states.

Not much has changed in two hundred years.
Keep on reading! I don't want to post any spoilers.
 
As has already been said, the senate was set up this way as a political compromise.

No, the bicameral Congress was set up by compromise, with one house to represent the populace and one house to represent the states.

There is no coherent political philosophy backing it, and it simply does not work as intended.

It's the same philosophy behind the General Assembly of the United Nations and, if I am not mistaken, the European Union.

Even if it did work, what's so great about violating the rights of the majority to protect the rights of the minority?

This it does not do. The states are represented equally in the Senate.

Furthermore...rather than counterfactual speculation about big states bullying small states....

Talk to Cain about that point. It's his straw man, after all. Or maybe it's yours, now.
 
It's painful to see how these threads always devolve into restatement of the current state of affairs: the senate is comprised of two senators from each state, the constitution says so, etc.

Does it ever occur to anyone that this it is exactly this state of affairs being called into question? That X is insufficient justification for X? That the constitution can and might need to be amended with regard to the election of senators?

This is an almost exclusively American disease. I watched some British show on YouTube recently, a debate on the state of faith schools. I'm deeply envious, first that this kind of format for debate exists at all in other countries, and second that throughout the entire conversation, nobody said anything remotely like "The constitution says...!" I wonder if people here even realize the degree to which they've venerated a bunch of dead lawyers.
How would you apportion the number of Senators per state if you didn't have that damned Constitution standing in your way? Speaking of the British, does the "House of Lords" ring a bell?
 
For some reason, I'm supposed to take it seriously when we're talking about nothing more than a matter of residency, where there is no specific history of populous states violating the rights of residents of less populous states.
Yeah because you frame in such a moronic fashion. There are plenty of times where a populous group of people have trounced upon minorities in the United States via a democratic process. It happens very rarely because of the fact that referendums are so rare but bloody dam hell did California provide the perfect example of it. The fact that it has happened one too many times in a lot of seperate states alone rings the warning bells that direct democracy is a moronic idea. Is our current structure perfect in that manner? No but your idea will be worst.
PS: If referendums didn't exist then the issue of Prop 8 wouldn't have come up in the first place. Duhhh... Duh... Duh Duh Duhhh...
 
Last edited:
No, the bicameral Congress was set up by compromise, with one house to represent the populace and one house to represent the states.
This is not inconsistent with what I said, and imparts no relevant information.

It's the same philosophy behind the General Assembly of the United Nations and, if I am not mistaken, the European Union.
The European Parliament is proportionally representative, and neither of them is a state at all. They are both intergovernmental organizations.

And of course the UN is a woefully undemocratic organization. India gets the same number of votes in the General Assembly as Andorra with >10,000 times the population. Totally ludicrous.

This it does not do. The states are represented equally in the Senate.
You can't have it both ways. If the Senate protects the rights of the minority of citizens by granting power in the Senate disproportionate to population and proportional to statehood, then it is necessarily true that wherever the rights of the majority are violated as a result of this scheme, the Senate violates the rights of the majority in the same way. Since the Senate does, in fact, systematically violate the rights of the majority, there's nothing more to be said. You're trading the rights of the minority for the rights of the majority. How does that make any sense?

Talk to Cain about that point. It's his straw man, after all. Or maybe it's yours, now.
Or maybe this is a hollow objection.
 
If we follow the "proportionality" argument to it's absurd conclusion then since Obama was the only person elected by the entire country and the results were 53% to 46% A proportional Senate AND house would be 53% Democrat and 46% GOP. That would reflect the actual population of voters regardless of states.
 
So admiring great men of the past is Ancestor Worship?
Then count me as a Worshiper.

That's not half of it.

Don't tell anybody, but I admire Galileo and his scientific method, too.

New-agers keep telling me that's stupid ancestor worthip, or, as they call it, "closed-minded fixation in the white male eurocentric paradigm of knowlege". They thinks that 300 years of unimaginable success is no reason to think he was on to something.

They much prefer that inquiry proceed according to systems they just dreamt up last night -- you know, systems that are so much FAIRER and BETTER and MORE DEMOCRATIC than the mean ol' scientific method. I laugh at them and tell them that their beef is with Galileo: they should've asked him to work their way instead of looking for truth systematically as he did. That's when they give me up as a hopeless reactionary.

Of course the whole discussion is usually on bulletin boards, between computers -- inventions not even imaginable, let alone possible, before Galileo's disgustingly unfair method got into high gear. But they seem totally blind to the evidence that surrounds them from all over as to WHY I am such a "reactionary".

The exact same thing, mutatis mutandis, is true for those who have no idea why I support federalism -- while living in a country that became the richest and most powerful and freest on earth, to a large degree, because of that failed, undemoctratic system. Why do I refuse to recognize their own greatness, and realize they know better than those stupid founding fathers? Why do I not worship them, and prefer to "worship ancestors" instead?

The whole thing, in both cases, seems to me to have very little to do with reforming either government or science, and everything to do with self-imortant narcissism.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom