Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

It is an curious result of debate and compromise, but it doesn't need to be abolished.

Oh, but it does. It's undemocratic and foolish. The people don't elect the president. We don't even have an election for president: we have 51 elections. It's another beyond-stupid American tradition, held in high regard simply because it's old and the way we've always done things. If someone introduced it today he'd look more like Tom Cruise than Jesus Christ.

You are right; that is unfair to Wyoming. California should have fewer votes.

Again, you're caught up in states rather than people. States exist to serve people, and the people are equal: one person, one vote. Why should a Californian have diminished voting power when it comes to choosing the president?
 
You appear to NOT KNOW the meanings of the words "democracy" and "republic."

Of course the USA is democratic. But it isn't a democracy. It's a democratic republic. But let us not quibble over words.
 
Oh, but it does. It's undemocratic and foolish.

You are certainly welcome to that opinion, but as arguments go, you are not presenting a very compelling one.

The people don't elect the president. We don't even have an election for president: we have 51 elections.

That would be by design, yes.

It's another beyond-stupid American tradition, held in high regard simply because it's old and the way we've always done things. If someone introduced it today he'd look more like Tom Cruise than Jesus Christ.

Again, your opinion. What's your opinion on how the EU is set up?

Again, you're caught up in states rather than people.

This is a straw man. Be that as it may, though, if you are so anti-states, why not advocate their dissolution directly rather than beat around the edges with this electoral college red herring.

States exist to serve people, and the people are equal: one person, one vote. Why should a Californian have diminished voting power when it comes to choosing the president?

That's easy: Generally speaking, Californians are too crazy to be allowed to vote.
 
Of course the USA is democratic. But it isn't a democracy. It's a democratic republic. But let us not quibble over words.


No, let's do quibble. What definition or understanding of "democracy" are you operating under, so as to say that the USA is democractic but not a democracy? Do you think that saying a country is a democracy and also saying it's a democractic republic are somehow contradictory?

I suggest you take a quick run past the dictionary before answering.
 
You are certainly welcome to that opinion, but as arguments go, you are not presenting a very compelling one.

Really, the fact it does not treat people as equals is not compelling? I'm sorry, but equality is the disposition in political arguments, and it's incumbent upon those claiming significant moral differences to demonstrate those moral differences.

ETA: Maybe some people should get a larger voting share than others, but why? No doubt your astute "Californians are crazy" observation was anticipated by the Holy Founding Fathers.

That would be by design, yes.

Do you think this is a compelling argument? Not that it's even right: the Electoral College did not work as it was intended because elections were rarely through thrown to the house. There was also the little problem of the rise of political parties, lamented by Washington.

This is a straw man.

I don't think you understand what a straw man is. Are you not insisting upon a state-centric rather than people-centric view?

Be that as it may, though, if you are so anti-states, why not advocate their dissolution directly rather than beat around the edges with this electoral college red herring.

1) I'm not the person who brought up the Electoral College.
2) How am I anti-state when earlier I said I was not unopposed to the idea of California becoming its own country?
3) What's incredible about this post is that you accuse me (wrongly) of precisely what you're doing: dropping a red-herring and erecting a straw man. This takes a special kind of obliviousness. I do not think the existence of states is as fundamentally illegitimate and undemocratic as the Electoral College.

That's easy: Generally speaking, Californians are too crazy to be allowed to vote.

Well, that's a serious political argument that serious people should take seriously. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I guess the idea of "Checks and Balances" just is beyond comprehension of some people.
What amuses me about some of these cool,hip, anti establishment revoultionaries is that although always talking about "The People" and Democracy, they show a constant comtempt for the average voter.
 
I guess the idea of "Checks and Balances" just is beyond comprehension of some people.
What amuses me about some of these cool,hip, anti establishment revoultionaries is that although always talking about "The People" and Democracy, they show a constant comtempt for the average voter.

Ah, here you are popping in again to repeat more of the same irrelevant jibberish while refusing to answer previous arguments. Which is fine, given your paper-thin understanding of the issues, but now it's checks and balances, even appearing in quotes to remind everyone you think in slogans. What do you think checks and balances refers to? How will a more representative, more democratic legislature threaten separation of powers?
 
What amuses me about some of these cool,hip, anti establishment revoultionaries is that although always talking about "The People" and Democracy, they show a constant comtempt for the average voter.

...or at least of for the average voter who, for some incomprehensible reason, votes for someone they dislike.
 
Ah, here you are popping in again to repeat more of the same irrelevant jibberish while refusing to answer previous arguments.

What's to answer? You note the senate is "undemocratic" in the sense that small and large states both have the same number of senators (two).

We note that, yes, that is the whole point behind the senate.

You say you don't like it.

Well... so what? Who cares?
 
Cain,

Are you suggesting we abolish the bicameral legislative branch in favor of a unicameral one?
 
Of course the USA is democratic. But it isn't a democracy. It's a democratic republic. But let us not quibble over words.

Any nation that does not have a ruling monarchy is a Republic. The USSR was a Republic. Nazi Germany was a Republic. North Korea, Cuba, Iran, Russia, and Venezuela are ALL Republics. Calling ourselves a Republic is meaningless.

We are, a Representative Democracy. Its a faulty system..but it could be much worse.
 
Last edited:
Really, the fact it does not treat people as equals is not compelling? I'm sorry, but equality is the disposition in political arguments, and it's incumbent upon those claiming significant moral differences to demonstrate those moral differences.

Nice attempt to shift the burden. It is your position that the status-quo be abandoned, so the obligation falls on you to justify the need for the change. All you have provided so far are histrionics.

Do you think this is a compelling argument?

It was a statement of fact. The electoral college works according to the rules--the design--laid out in the Constitution, as amended.

Not that it's even right: the Electoral College did not work as it was intended because elections were rarely through thrown to the house. There was also the little problem of the rise of political parties, lamented by Washington.

And...? Was there a point you wanted to make, here?

I don't think you understand what a straw man is. Are you not insisting upon a state-centric rather than people-centric view?

I insist only that you haven't made a compelling argument to change the presidential election process. I am under no obligation to take a position in opposition to yours in order to point out your arguments lack substance.

1) I'm not the person who brought up the Electoral College.

No, but you were the first to rant on its illegitimacy. It is fair to give you full credit for the current discussion.

2) How am I anti-state when earlier I said I was not unopposed to the idea of California becoming its own country?

Except you didn't. You said you were unopposed to regionalism. Odd, too, since regionalism generally implies states' rights, a view you seem to oppose. Be that as it may, the "anti-state" proposition was presented as a conditional.
 
Nice attempt to shift the burden. It is your position that the status-quo be abandoned, so the obligation falls on you to justify the need for the change. All you have provided so far are histrionics.

Well, thankfully the above record shows otherwise. The argument against the Senate is that it's a non-representative institution. It arbitrarily gives disproportionate power and influence to smaller states. Now others can say, correctly, that the Senate was never intended to be representative. Sure, but that's not an independent, free-standing argument. The Senate was not supposed to be elective either.

Your charming refusal to offer up the slightest moral-political argument parallels the God debate. Atheists are tasked with pushing against the status-quo by generating arguments, but those arguments basically say that the original reasons favoring the existence of God were not very good at all. And so it goes with the Senate.

Let's suppose white person gets five times as many votes as a black person and I say, "Hey, that's unfair. Each person should have the same number of votes."

You seem to take the track: "That's not compelling."
"Skeptic" says something along the lines: "The Founding Fathers never intended for black people to vote at all!"

And that's what happens when you bracket out the ********. We can talk about the mysterious powers of some unnamed entity, and people will call nonsense upon it. But tell Americans that's it's mentioned in the Bible or described in the Constitution and they will take offense.

And then we go in 'round in circles. Even if you accidentally say something that's true, it also to be, um, relevant.

It was a statement of fact. The electoral college works according to the rules--the design--laid out in the Constitution, as amended.

And...? Was there a point you wanted to make, here?

This is amusing -- I mean, your failed attempt to balkanize related ideas.

I insist only that you haven't made a compelling argument to change the presidential election process. I am under no obligation to take a position in opposition to yours in order to point out your arguments lack substance.

A-not-as amusing evasion.

No, but you were the first to rant on its illegitimacy. It is fair to give you full credit for the current discussion.

Because the person's example of the Electoral College coincidentally has the same problem as the Senate: it fails the one person, one vote standard. If a group of people, by virtue of their geographic location, deserves more power and influence, then you need to offer a morally relevant reason explaining how that works.

Except you didn't. You said you were unopposed to regionalism. Odd, too, since regionalism generally implies states' rights, a view you seem to oppose. Be that as it may, the "anti-state" proposition was presented as a conditional.

How does regionalism imply states' rights? I had something more in mind along the lines of Alexander Cockburn's enviro-political hobbyhorse -- the notion that units should respect natural and social geography. In any case, I am more concerned about the level of government inasmuch as it affects the character of government -- specifically, in this case, giving people equal voting shares.

And people don't have an argument. It's just like the existence of God, or eating dairy with meat -- it's an unexamined faith that melts under the slightest bit of light.

You have failed repeatedly to offer up the slightest reason.
Skeptic has carefully retreated from his republic, not a democracy claims.

--------

To Mortimer on a unicameral legislature:

It's not even whether or not I favor a unicameral body. As I have said, the Senate can be reformed along democratic lines, or it can be abolished.
 
Personally I think it's horribly unfair that it sometimes rains on weekends. But I don't expect it to change. The notion that this can somehow be changed is silly. There are probably about 34 states that benefit from overrepresentation in the Senate, and about 16 that are underrepresented. Now look at the requirements for a constitutional amendment.

You may as well command the tides not to come in.
 
I guess the idea of "Checks and Balances" just is beyond comprehension of some people.
What amuses me about some of these cool,hip, anti establishment revoultionaries is that although always talking about "The People" and Democracy, they show a constant comtempt for the average voter.

Hah, what alternate universe are you living in? The classic argument in favor of limiting democratic control is that the foolish commoners would become a mob etc.

And yay for more personal attacks to strawmen that do nothing to further the discussion.
 
Personally I think it's horribly unfair that it sometimes rains on weekends. But I don't expect it to change. The notion that this can somehow be changed is silly. There are probably about 34 states that benefit from overrepresentation in the Senate, and about 16 that are underrepresented. Now look at the requirements for a constitutional amendment.

You may as well command the tides not to come in.

Yes, we probably won't be able to change it...

So? Does that somehow make this discussion moot?
 
Well, thankfully the above record shows otherwise. The argument against the Senate is that it's a non-representative institution.

Not true. The Senate a representative body. It represents the states.

It arbitrarily gives disproportionate power and influence to smaller states.

Not true. It gives equal power to each state.

Now others can say, correctly, that the Senate was never intended to be representative. Sure, but that's not an independent, free-standing argument. The Senate was not supposed to be elective either.

Others can say what ever they like. They'd be wrong in this case. The Senate was/is representative (of the states) and it was/is elective (elected by the states).

Your charming refusal to offer up the slightest moral-political argument parallels the God debate. Atheists are tasked with pushing against the status-quo by generating arguments, but those arguments basically say that the original reasons favoring the existence of God were not very good at all. And so it goes with the Senate.

I see: Your argument still lacks substance so you continue the attempt to shift the burden.

Let's suppose white person gets five times as many votes as a black person and I say, "Hey, that's unfair. Each person should have the same number of votes."

You seem to take the track: "That's not compelling."
"Skeptic" says something along the lines: "The Founding Fathers never intended for black people to vote at all!"

I see you still have plenty of straw left. Your analogy is a poor one, too, because it attempts to shift the discussion from state representation at the federal level to one of voting rights and race.

And that's what happens when you bracket out the ********. We can talk about the mysterious powers of some unnamed entity, and people will call nonsense upon it. But tell Americans that's it's mentioned in the Bible or described in the Constitution and they will take offense.

Argumentum ad soap box.

...<snip of additional substance-free rants>...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom