Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

My reality trumps your anectdotes

I dont really care about proportional representation for electing leaders, but I DO have a strong objection to mob rule in order to ignore or violate constitutional protections

I'll say it and I'm not afraid to:

People are stupid. People are by and large, stupid, conformist sheep. Furthermore, they are greedy.

I dont want stupid, greedy, conformist sheep in charge of my rights. This directly gives whoever can afford the most TV and Radio advertisement direct control over my rights.

No thanks, I'll take a constitution that protects me from the idiocy of the herd
Yeah, don't let those Epsilons and Deltas get equal representative voting. They can't be trusted with power, ever. In fact, we should get rid of as much power from them as possible.

...

Wait. This sounds familiar.

Skeptic said:
You're angry, like all self-important would-be dictators, because the world -- or at least those stupid hicks who vote for the other guy -- doesn't recognize your obvious intellectual superiority to all those stupid people you disagree with. Ah well.

Skeptic said:
Simple. Some states vote in ways Cain doesn't like.

His highness emperor Cain I doesn't like it when the will of the people is subverted this way, you know.

Hmmmmm.

$20 that Skeptic will suddenly spontaneously forget all of his arguments and ignore Pipelineaudio's line of reasoning just because they happen to fall on the same "side".

Which argument is it that seems like it can most be used to support a dictatorship, as Skeptic was ranting and raving and waving his arms all around about?

BTW: My reality trumps your reality, and your anecdotes. So there. ;)
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to point out that it is an actual, live issue. I only injected the snark after getting it directed my way a couple of times. I'm only human (and sleep-deprived too).
I'm sleep deprived as well, and going to march into an Archery class that I'm already making a C in without much sleep. Yay. :( (Stupid insomnia)

There's way too much snark all throughout this thread, from the beginning to the end, as well as wild speculations as to why someone could dare disagree with them... while Cain isn't the most humble man around and quick on the personal attacks, it's been my experience that he's often being given about as much as he's dealing out. But then, most schoolyard fights can be seen the same way, even with an instigator, so perhaps that's too simplistic an assumption.

Either way, there's always going to be a little bit of snark that comes off on you when the issue is already charged as it is. Still, one can't really blame you if you reciprocate.

I'm interested in talking about different ways to deal with what I think is a very real issue. I also happen to be right in the midst of reading about this stuff, including some important American Supreme Court cases. (See e.g. Reynolds v. Simms 377 US 533 and Baker v. Carr 369 US 186). Tsukasa might not think it's a live issue, but American jurists sure seem to.

(The relevant Canadian cases for anyone who's interested include Reference re Prov. Electoral Boundaries (Sask.), [1991] 2 SCR 158 and Raiche v. Canada (Attorney General), [2005] 1 F.C. 93)

I honestly don't know enough to say one way or the other, I admit that. I would think that it would be a real issue, as it's a question of power in the process that exists.
 
In the house, the people are equally reprsented
In the state, the states are equally represented.
It's no good to keep repeating this mantra; implicit in the criticism of the way things are is recognition of the way things are. I understand that it work this way, and I'm saying that it ought not to. Political equality of the citizenry is backed by strong arguments; political equality among states is merely asserted.

Federalist #51

It explains it much clearer than I can, and lays out an argument.
Have you read it? It's notable that Madison does not argue for equal state suffrage in the senate anywhere in this document, which nicely underscores the point I'm making. Assume for the sake of argument that I'm the world's most committed federalist--now justify malapportionment to me. This is why I say it is insufficient to simply say "federalism." It's not necessary for a federalist to support this arrangement of the legislature, and as I said earlier, Madison was opposed to it, given that it was 'evidently unjust'. You simply are not engaging the argument.

You are right, at least, that Madison lays out an argument at all (one that does not touch on the relevant question), which puts him one step ahead of the senate's defenders in this thread. Unfortunately, much of what he says is speculative, and (with the benefit of hindsight) manifestly untrue. Madison fails to predict the rise of political parties, incorrectly asserts that power will necessarily accrue in the legislature, and if that weren't enough, we now have dozens of examples of democratically elected uni- and bicameral legislatures around the world (in democratic republics, no less!), which do not have a stronger tendency towards tyranny than our own system.

This is why it's frustrating to see people portray themselves as the defenders of enlightenment values. You cannot do so while blinding yourself to evidence and reason, liberty and equality.

mumblethrax said:
This is not inconsistent with what I said [...]
jsfisher said:
It is dead-on consistent.
Golf clap.

You alleged that the Senate alone was an addition out of compromise.
A blatant falsehood.
 
Yeah, don't let those Epsilons and Deltas get equal representative voting. They can't be trusted with power, ever. In fact, we should get rid of as much power from them as possible.

Maybe I can put this in a way you can understand:

We have a constitution that defines some of our rights and who/why/how is in charge of them

We have legislators turning over ballots to mob rule, to rescind the rights directly given to us in the constitution, in violation of the constitution

Here are some quotes on the issue from dumb, dead guys:

“A democracy is nothing more than mob rule, where fifty-one percent of the people may take away the rights of the other forty-nine.”

"Democracy is three wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch"
 
Maybe I can put this in a way you can understand:

We have a constitution that defines some of our rights and who/why/how is in charge of them

We have legislators turning over ballots to mob rule, to rescind the rights directly given to us in the constitution, in violation of the constitution

Here are some quotes on the issue from "dumb, dead guys" (your words, not mine, although I love the way you slip in that strawman):

“A democracy is nothing more than mob rule, where fifty-one percent of the people may take away the rights of the other forty-nine.”

"Democracy is three wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch"
Here's what a dead dumb guy said as well:

"Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote."

(OMG! It's actually possible for someone to disagree with you and recognize your quotes, and ACTUALLY HAVE HEARD THEM BEFORE! Perhaps you should work on another way for this Delta to "understand", because he has to agree with you to truly understand after all!)

So, if we had more representation based on population as opposed to state, it would get rid of the Constitution? Is that the claim?
 
Last edited:
Here's what a dead dumb guy said as well:

"Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote."

So, if we had more representation based on population as opposed to state, it would get rid of the Constitution? Is that the claim?

No, like I said, I have no opinion on the issue of electing leaders. I have no good argument against porportional representation when it comes to electing leaders

My issue is mob rule when it comes to taking rights away from individuals. The draconian mods stuck my post in this thread, so I suppose my issue must be related which is what I'm arguing.
 
No, like I said, I have no opinion on the issue of electing leaders. I have no good argument against porportional representation when it comes to electing leaders
Oh. Uh, okay.

My issue is mob rule when it comes to taking rights away from individuals.
Oh. Well, the thing is, the "taking rights away" can be undertaken by anyone of any ability to Statecraft -- by "mob rule", through a dictator, or through an oligarchy. The point of the Bill of Rights is to counter all those possibilities.

The draconian mods stuck my post in this thread, so I suppose my issue must be related which is what I'm arguing.

They did? This thread doesn't seem to be about the same thing. Huh.

Well, accept my apology? I guess I got your stance wrong on this.
 
Last edited:
C'mon, such a good thread shouldn't die yet! Wait, I know...

Only anti-Zionists want to keep the Senate!

That should guarantee at least five more pages.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom