Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

How would you apportion the number of Senators per state if you didn't have that damned Constitution standing in your way?
Proportionally.

Speaking of the British, does the "House of Lords" ring a bell?
Yes.

If we follow the "proportionality" argument to it's absurd conclusion then since Obama was the only person elected by the entire country and the results were 53% to 46% A proportional Senate AND house would be 53% Democrat and 46% GOP. That would reflect the actual population of voters regardless of states.
No. A vote for Obama is not a vote for a Democratic congress.

technoextreme said:
There are plenty of times where a populous group of people have trounced upon minorities in the United States via a democratic process.
Which utterly fails to make the case for bracketing out the specific minority in question, or for this particular scheme for protecting those minority rights. Otherwise, you are committing yourself to the view I described earlier: the way to protect the rights of gay people is to give them disproportionate voting power. We aren't talking about the merits of representative democracy vs. direct democracy, but of proportional representation vs. disproportionate representation.
 
Nonsense. The greeter at Walmart is just as "undemocratic" as the Senate (assuming we even accept this rather stilted view of what undemocratic means). So what? Pointing out such a state of affairs is not the basis for a debate or discussion. You need something with more substance if you want to argue Walmart greeters need to be chosen by popular election.

You can't even keep your own wrongheaded analogies straight -- or in this case, the intention (design) behind having a greeter.

------
TechnoXTREME:

Yeah because you frame in such a moronic fashion. There are plenty of times where a populous group of people have trounced upon minorities in the United States via a democratic process. It happens very rarely because of the fact that referendums are so rare but bloody dam hell did California provide the perfect example of it. The fact that it has happened one too many times in a lot of seperate states alone rings the warning bells that direct democracy is a moronic idea. Is our current structure perfect in that manner? No but your idea will be worst.
PS: If referendums didn't exist then the issue of Prop 8 wouldn't have come up in the first place. Duhhh... Duh... Duh Duh Duhhh...

This simply does not follow. In this case we're talking about having representative institutions, not empowering institutions to repress minority rights. As mumblethrax observed, this is proportional representation vs. disproportionate representation, not representative democracy vs. direct democracy. You have to somehow to demonstrate that a representative Senate would possess and exercise the authority to curb gay rights (for example) in ways that are off limits to a non-representative Senate.

Would you prefer it if the populace clamored for gay rights only to be over-ruled by unelected elites? As I have said in previous related-threads, there's always this soft-charm of "tyranny by the minority" for the hopeless reactionaries who participate in these discussions.

----------
Texas, you're totally clueless:

If we follow the "proportionality" argument to it's absurd conclusion then since Obama was the only person elected by the entire country...

No. Read your Constitution.

and the results were 53% to 46% A proportional Senate AND house would be 53% Democrat and 46% GOP.

This does not follow.
---------------
"Skeptic":
And "playing along with my ad hominem" made you post that you'd support a dictatorship by people you like?

No, it was to demonstrate that you committed an irrelevance fallacy. A person's only motive for arguing in favor of equality for gays could be a burning desire to win power via elected office and one day become the supreme dictator of the earth... but assuming she makes her case for gay rights on equality grounds, her "real" motives, which only you seem to know, are completely irrelevant.

the first word of the sentence you reference was "maybe."
When someone will MAYBE support a dictatorship by people he likes, that means he WILL support a dictatorship by people he likes.

You play in the mud because you can't generate rational arguments.
 
This is incoherent--giving equal representation to one necessarily entails denying equal representation to the other. Furthermore, there is no good reason to give arbitrarily determined political entities rights of equal representation, and saying "federalism" does not immunize against charges of arbitrary discrimination. It is possible, for example, to form a federal government without egregiously unrepresentative legislatures.

Urgh. I'm sorry, I assume people arguing in here stayed awake in Civics class. I will never do that again.

Okay.


It does not. It works like this

In the house, the people are equally reprsented
In the state, the states are equally represented.

In this way, the legislature balances the states interest, and the people's interest.

.. at least, that was the original thought. Then someone passed an Amendment forcing popular vote of the Senate...


As for why I just said federalist?

Federalist #51

It explains it much clearer than I can, and lays out an argument.
 
You can't even keep your own wrongheaded analogies straight -- or in this case, the intention (design) behind having a greeter.

I see your rebuttals are as without substance as your base arguments.
 
LOL. The irony of that statement is breath taking.

What the irony in this non-reply of yours. You just demonstrated that you don't know how the president is elected, which is by the Electoral College. Then you had a howler of a non sequitur.
----
Rika:

Urgh. I'm sorry, I assume people arguing in here stayed awake in Civics class. I will never do that again.

Okay.


It does not. It works like this

In the house, the people are equally reprsented
In the state, the states are equally represented.

In this way, the legislature balances the states interest, and the people's interest

One small problem: you're ignoring his argument -- indeed, the central argument at hand, which is normative in nature. Nobody disputes how the Senate does work, and there's not much dispute on how it was intended to work. The inclusion of the 3/5ths compromise is also reasonably well-understood: few of us probably dispute the power interests at play, or the intentions of the Founders. What's disputed is the moral-political legitimacy of the idea.

------------
jsfisher:
I see your rebuttals are as without substance as your base arguments.

Your "replies," such as they are, would probably only impress four year olds just discovering rubber and glue.
 
A bit OT, I suppose:

It's interesting to note that of all our institutions the SCOTUS is the most undemocratic, and yet is the most likely to be appealed to in order to protect our rights under a democratic system of government.

The people-the electoral college-the president-advice and consent from the Senate-SCOTUS.

Or, the people-the state legislatures-the Senate's advice and consent-the President's selection-the SCOTUS.

Life tenure, complete independence, utter finality of their decisions (until they themselves wish to revisit the matter).
 
This wasn't an issue when the Federal Government wasn't so powerful.


Hmmmm. Maybe that's the real problem. Everybody sitting around arguing how to distribute the spoils and loot the nation "democratically". How to control governmental intrusion into every aspect of human life, as driven by the latest demagogue preaching to cheering crowds.







Here's a hint to all of you, who for whatever reason, believe only pure democracy gives legitimacy: It's just as legitimate as pure democracy in science, art, or weight lifting.

But with a million times worse consequences.






I'm also stunned how "everybody" voting for how to control everything, and turning 100% of said control to the one who can scrape up 50.01% of the vote or less "legitimizes" anything.

Freedom is the only legitimate form of government because jamming your ideas down other people's throats at the point of a gun is illegitimate. A huffing and puffing demagogue's siren call affecting the population for a few moments is no legitimatizer of anything.




I predict this will be ignored or downplayed as people never have a problem jamming ideas down other people's throats as long as they're the one behind the gun, or behind the guy behind the gun.



How do I get off this ****** up planet?

Do not circumvent the auto-censor by disguising swear words.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What's disputed is the moral-political legitimacy of the idea.

Oscillating between bare statements of "it's illegitimate" and "the people are not equally represented" isn't the basis for a discussion. You need to advance your argument (without any more straw, please).
 
Cain HAS no argument. The whole thread is:

Cain: "The senate doesn't proportionally rerpesent the population!"
Everybody else: "Duh. That's the idea... besides, it's been true for 200 years; where have you been?"
Cain: "But I DON'T LIKE IT!"
Everyvody else: "So?"
Cainl "UFAIR! WAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!!"
 
Last edited:
Oh noes, the smaller states will be overwhelmed! Heavens to Betsy!

The idea that democracy has to be inefficient to be good is silly.
Only to an idiot.

Tyranny and despotism are, by design, efficient. They are concentrations of power. The whole point of checks and balances is to diffuse power, and that is a deliberate move to inefficiency to avoid tyranny/despotism.

You are welcomed to them both, tyrrany and despotism, which is all the foolish deserve.

DR
 
Only to an idiot.

Tyranny and despotism are, by design, efficient. They are concentrations of power. The whole point of checks and balances is to diffuse power, and that is a deliberate move to inefficiency to avoid tyranny/despotism.

You are welcomed to them both, tyrrany and despotism, which is all the foolish deserve.

DR
It's too, too much to go into here, but there is something to the fact that the presidencies virtues, as seen by Hamilton and Madison, were secrecy, energy, and dispatch. According to Rossiter and Mansfield the presidency is a kind of tamed dictatorship, extraordinarily powerful and yet severely limited. Limited not in extent of its powers, but in scope. That's one of the reasons why re-eligibility for election was important; the kind of men who ran for the presidency were also the kind of men who would be interested in fame (meant in the highest sense) and so the argument was that they would limit themselves as a result. My favorite book on this is Nichols' Myth of the Modern President.

In any case, the legislative vortex that draws all power to itself was seen as the real ripe area for abuse, which is why the legislative branch is so hamstrung. Two branches, two means of election, two schemes of representation, two lengths of tenure, with the popular branch being in control of the money, while the elitist branch has a hand in treaties and the manning of the executive branch.

While it's certainly not metaphysically true that every pure democracy is a mob (Socrates or not), the Founders seemed to be rather assured, and The Federalist Papers are chock full of historical examples, that is was so highly likely that discretion and caution were the orders of the day.
 
Cain HAS no argument. The whole thread is:

Cain: "The senate doesn't proportionally rerpesent the population!"
Everybody else: "Duh. That's the idea... besides, it's been true for 200 years; where have you been?"
Cain: "But I DON'T LIKE IT!"
Everyvody else: "So?"
Cainl "UFAIR! WAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!!"

What was it you said about weak sarcasm, Skeptic? Something about it meaning that you had a valid point and obviously should be listened to, and have your points disseminated?

Oh wait. No.

Point the finger, don't notice the three fingers pointing back, I guess.
 
dudalb said:
dudalb said:
I love people who want to totally scrap a system which, although flawed, has worked pretty well for over a couple of hundred years on the basis that it disagrees with a totally abstract thesis that the Senate and Check and Balances between the Feds and the State are somehow "undemocratic".

Would this be any better if they still taught basic American history and civics in the public schools? I really think so much of it is pure ignorance. Ignorance begets surprise when things work out differently than assumed.

I still think they are taught, but taught so badly that the facts do not take hold.
I think the real problem is it's a new version of a old disease which I..and most people..have suffered from in our youth: 17 to 23 year old "Know It All Disease". You when you are that age, you often consider yourself a freaking genius who knows it all, who has a uniquely brilliant mind, and knows better then all those old fogies who have been teaching him.
Usually this is cured once you get out of school into The Real World.

:dl:

Okay, history time. Does anyone remember this thing called the Civil War? Well, the entire time leading up to that is a history of the Senate and Slave States. The Senate didn't work too well. And even after that the Senate was still used to block Civil Rights laws until they finally broke a fillibuster in 1964. The Senates own website admits so, Linky.

So how is that for it protecting minorities from the mob of the majority?

Treating the Constitution as imperfect is not new. The angrier abolitionists saw it, in William Lloyd Garrison's words, as "a covenant with death and an agreement with hell." Walter Bagehot (and a prominent American admirer of his, Professor Woodrow Wilson) thought it deeply flawed. Charles A. Beard considered it mainly an instrument for the protection of property rights, an analysis that he did not intend as a compliment.
Even so grotesque and obvious an injustice as apartheid in the public schools was beyond the ability of the national government to correct. And when, after ninety years, formal, official school segregation was outlawed the deed was not done by the elected representatives of the people. It was done through the exercise of unelected, unaccountable, unchecked, quasi-legislative judicial power—one of the numerous features of the American constitutional system that the framers had no idea they were creating.
Linky.

The Senate has not worked well at all, its notable history is largely one of blocking the Civil Rights movement. Any claim to the contrary is complete BS.

Its record, especially over the past century and a half, makes disheartening reading. A partial list of the measures that—despite being favored by the sitting President, an apparent majority of the people, and, in most cases, the House of Representatives to boot—have been done to death in the Senate would include bills to authorize federal action against the disenfranchisement of blacks, to ban violence against strikers by private police forces, to punish lynching, to lower tariffs, to extend relief to the unemployed, to outlaw the poll tax, to provide aid to education, and (under Presidents Truman, Nixon, and Carter as well as Clinton) to provide something like the kind of health coverage that is standard in the rest of the developed world. The rejection of the Versailles treaty and the League of Nations after the First World War and then of preparedness on the eve of the Second are only the best known of the Senate's many acts of foreign-policy sabotage, which have continued down to the present, with its refusal to ratify international instruments on genocide, nuclear testing, and human rights.
As for the silly claims of "federalism" or "checks and balances between the federal and the states", the second is just butchering your own sacred cow and the first is merely hiding behind a word. There is no reason why a federation necessarily requires an unequal upper house in the legislature, and indeed many of the founders thought so. As for people citing "The Federalist", please follow the history a tad more:

This is often referred to as a "concession" to the small states, but in truth it was more like surrender to blackmail. The small states saw it as a deal-breaker, and they would brook no compromise. Dahl notes that Gunning Bedford, Jr., of Delaware, told his fellow-delegates to the Constitutional Convention that, unless the big states yielded, "the small ones will find some foreign ally of more honor and good faith, who will take them by the hand and do them justice." The Senate was formed less by rational argument than by threats of treason and war. You've probably never heard of Gunning Bedford, Jr. (I hadn't, until Dahl introduced me to him.) When it came to the composition of the Senate, though, the Gunning Bedford types exerted far more influence than James Madison or Alexander Hamilton, who were then left holding the bag. It was Madison and Hamilton, along with John Jay, who got the assignment of defending every last detail of the various Philadelphia compromises in the series of long op-ed pieces later collected as "The Federalist" and treasured to this day by columnists and speechwriters composing encomiums to the providential perfection of the framers' handiwork. Dahl points out, amiably but sharply, that the Federalist Papers were an exercise in spin. "If we employ a dictionary definition of propaganda as 'information or ideas methodically spread to promote or injure a cause, nation, etc.,' then the Federalist Papers were surely propaganda," he writes. Madison and Hamilton had a job to do. It was a perfectly honorable job, but it obliged them to defend things they did not believe in. Madison had been the Constitutional Convention's most passionate advocate of giving the big states more senators than the small ones. Hamilton had been almost as adamant. "As states are a collection of individual men," he harangued his fellow-delegates, "which ought we to respect most, the rights of the people composing them, or of the artificial beings resulting from the composition? Nothing could be more preposterous or absurd than to sacrifice the former to the latter. It has been said that if the smaller states renounce their equality, they renounce at the same time their liberty. The truth is it is a contest for power, not for liberty. Will the men composing the small states be less free than those composing the larger?"
[emphasis mine]

I can quote many more founders against the Senate. But I think I've made my point. "The Founders" weren't a cohesive whole with grand philosophical foresight.
 
Last edited:
Only to an idiot.

Tyranny and despotism are, by design, efficient. They are concentrations of power. The whole point of checks and balances is to diffuse power, and that is a deliberate move to inefficiency to avoid tyranny/despotism.

You are welcomed to them both, tyrrany and despotism, which is all the foolish deserve.

DR

:rolleyes: Yes, I suppose the poor people of Ireland, Denmark, France, Israel, Norway, New Zealand, Finland, Sweden, etc. are all living horribly under their respective tyranny of the majority.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes: Yes, I suppose the poor people of Ireland, Denmark, France, Israel, Norway, New Zealand, Finland, Sweden, etc. are all living horribly under their respective tyranny of the majority.

Try comparing geographical size and population distribution between those countries and the USA. Not the same pressures on geographical vs. proportionate representation at all. Comparing the USA and the EU is more accurate.

In my country (Canada), the unfairness problem of rep by pop is really exacerbated.

Ontario pop. = 13,000,000
Prince Edward Island pop. = 140,000

Canadians living in PEI would have essentially no voice for regional concerns in a strict rep by pop system. Geographical representation in a Senate is just one solution to this problem. There are others (including departing from strict rep by pop in the legislature, which Canada also does), but the problem is real and the Senate (American or Canadian) is a legitimate attempt to deal with it. One can debate the effectiveness of the attempt, but pretending there is no issue is silly.
 
Last edited:
Try comparing geographical size and population distribution between those countries and the USA. Not the same pressures on geographical vs. proportionate representation at all. Comparing the USA and the EU is more accurate.

In my country (Canada), the unfairness problem of rep by pop is really exacerbated.

Ontario pop. = 13,000,000
Prince Edward Island pop. = 140,000

Canadians living in PEI would have essentially no voice for regional concerns in a strict rep by pop system. Geographical representation in a Senate is just one solution to this problem. There are others (including departing from strict rep by pop in the legislature, which Canada also does), but the problem is real and the Senate (American or Canadian) is a legitimate attempt to deal with it. One can debate the effectiveness of the attempt, but pretending there is no issue is silly.

And why should only geographic minorities be "protected"? Hey, lets have a Black Senate too! After all, since Black people only make up 12% of the population, their concerns are shoved aside by popular representation. I know, lets have a Gay Senate too! After all, GLBTQ concerns etc. etc. Why, these are even better than geography, because people can easily move but they can't change these things!
 
I can quote many more founders against the Senate. But I think I've made my point. "The Founders" weren't a cohesive whole with grand philosophical foresight.

Soaring and competing rhetoric about liberty is all well and good during an exercise in nation-building. However, actual governance tends to boil down to pragmatic concerns. Smaller regions of a federation would likely take cold comfort in their "liberty" when they have little or no voice on the national stage.
 
And why should only geographic minorities be "protected"? Hey, lets have a Black Senate too! After all, since Black people only make up 12% of the population, their concerns are shoved aside by popular representation. I know, lets have a Gay Senate too! After all, GLBTQ concerns etc. etc. Why, these are even better than geography, because people can easily move but they can't change these things!
Better yet, let's have electoral reform so dispersed demographic minorities are better represented in the legislature. Or, perhaps we could have the rule of law under a rights-based constitution. Or both.

Back on topic...

Canadian experience shows that geographical voting blocs in the legislature (e.g. Bloc Quebecois, Reform Party, Canadian Alliance), are not healthy for national unity. The pressure for geographical representation in large federations won't go away simply because you reform/abolish the Senate. It would just manifest itself in some other unpredictable way.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom