Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Measuring anomolies for each site is much more accurate than stating what an average temperature is. You are only detecting the changes in temperature, not the temperature.

How do you know an anomaly if you don't keep historical records of the subject phenomenon, in this case air temperature?
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
See prior post...referencing

Bürger: Technical comment on "The Spatial Extent of 20th-Century Warmth in the Context of the Past 1200 Years"

Casebro proven right yet again.

​
Because he still doesn't get it.

Repeat, rinse, wash again.

Measuring anomolies for each site is much more accurate than stating what an average temperature is. You are only detecting the changes in temperature, not the temperature.

Since your response shows no clue as to the impact of Burger, want to try again?

Please pay attention in class. No falling asleep and turn the cell phone off.
 
Since your response shows no clue as to the impact of Burger, want to try again?

Please pay attention in class. No falling asleep and turn the cell phone off.

It's a technical comment, not a paper, and he misses the point, the rate of increase is extremely rapid in geological terms. When you ride a rocket, the first few seconds are well within your normal range of speed. The trajectory is up and it's rapid. The feedback mechanisms are coming into play, as predicted, and will contribute to future warming.
 
It's a technical comment, not a paper, and he misses the point, the rate of increase is extremely rapid in geological terms. .... The feedback mechanisms are coming into play, as predicted, and will contribute to future warming.

You are ignoring the content of the reference in a manner that is intellectually dishonest. Quoting the conclusion.
the "highly significant" occurrences of positive anomalies during the 20th century disappear. The 99th percentile is almost never exceeded, except for the very last years for
theta.gif
= 1, 2. The 95th percentile is exceeded mostly in the early 20th century, but also about the year 1000.




​
 
You get it from the temperature record. If there are problems with siting of recordings, etc, the change will still be more consistent.

I thought you had stated earlier that it was not important to measure temperatures unless there was an anomaly. If you hadn't, my bad. That's what confused me.

Here's another one, though. (As I told you I'm a chemist and I deal with some of these situation in miniature.) How do you define "anomaly"? This is seemingly a small point, but it's not. This appears to me to be the first step in going from data to interpreation. That is, an anomaly is in the eye of the beholder.
 
You are ignoring the content of the reference in a manner that is intellectually dishonest. Quoting the conclusion.
the "highly significant" occurrences of positive anomalies during the 20th century disappear. The 99th percentile is almost never exceeded, except for the very last years for http://www.sciencemag.org/math/theta.gif = 1, 2. The 95th percentile is exceeded mostly in the early 20th century, but also about the year 1000. ​

Can't ... help ... myself ...

Only after about 1970 does the signal rise again without a comparable level response. However, that period is very uncertain because it is based on only three to five proxies. As a result, the "highly significant" occurrences of positive anomalies during the 20th century disappear. The 99th percentile is almost never exceeded, except for the very last years for
theta.gif
= 1, 2. The 95th percentile is exceeded mostly in the early 20th century, but also about the year 1000.

After about 1970 ...

Who gives a toss about proxies after 1970? We have instrumental observations going back hundreds of years. The only implications this comment has is about past reconstructions of climate from proxies.

It's an abstruse comment on an abstruse paper. If that - along with accusations of intellectual dishonesty - is your current refuge, your safe place is shrinking fast.

That, by the way, was not an ad hom. The last sentence was a gratuitous poke at someone who throws around "intellectual dishonesty" like confetti and thinks the Sun shines out of Singer's fundament.
 
why don't you dig into that article a bit and see if you can come up with a credible anti Singer-cycles argument? Hint: Be sure to read it all do way through.;)
 
Yes but if we restrict our discussion to anomalies, then what of past anomalies? What kind/frequency were they thousands of years ago? Why would anybody think that today's anomalies are any worse than ancient ones? If they are not, then no big hoo-hoo. And they don't seem to be. All of the models/proxies/series that I have seen, that go back beyond the handle of Mann's hockey stick, show anomalies similar to recent history. Give or take a 90% confidence level, but there is only a 10% chance of that...

So, if anomalies are what is important, then there is no such thing as Global Warming- only regional anomalies, right? Anthropogenic Local Anomalies, anyone? Ummm, L.A. basin smog maybe? That was a climate problem, local anomaly, caused by man. Urban heat island? And the Chinese burning coal had nothing to do with it.
 
I thought you had stated earlier that it was not important to measure temperatures unless there was an anomaly. If you hadn't, my bad. That's what confused me.

Here's another one, though. (As I told you I'm a chemist and I deal with some of these situation in miniature.) How do you define "anomaly"? This is seemingly a small point, but it's not. This appears to me to be the first step in going from data to interpreation. That is, an anomaly is in the eye of the beholder.

You have to remember, you are talking to an amateur here, who is just passing on what he understands from what he has read :). If I am not authoritative and clear, I apologise. I know a scientist who does actual climate research for the CSIRO, and he can't be bothered with arguing the point on the internet, because he has tried it a few times and has come to the conclusion that most of those people who deny AGW will have accept the evidence. For any detailed questions I ask, he refers me to the IPCC. For any points novelists like Crichton might raise, he has nothing but contempt.

Anyway, the technical definition of anomoly in this sense, AFAIK, is deviations from the recorded average for that site. If the site is UHI affected, it's not such an issue, the temperature will still rise and fall with the warming signal, for example.
 
You have to remember, you are talking to an amateur here, who is just passing on what he understands from what he has read :). If I am not authoritative and clear, I apologise. ....

Anyway, the technical definition of anomoly in this sense, AFAIK, is deviations from the recorded average for that site. If the site is UHI affected, it's not such an issue, the temperature will still rise and fall with the warming signal, for example.

The acknowledged experts on temperature anomolies, errors in them and the unraveling of reality from them insofar as it may be possible would of course be Steve McIntyre and www.climateaudit.org.

One thing that was recently noted in a discussion of NASA's work (Hansen) was that it appeared 1950 had been picked as the baseline year in order to emphasize the "trend of things heating up".
 
Yes but if we restrict our discussion to anomalies, then what of past anomalies? What kind/frequency were they thousands of years ago? Why would anybody think that today's anomalies are any worse than ancient ones? If they are not, then no big hoo-hoo. And they don't seem to be. All of the models/proxies/series that I have seen, that go back beyond the handle of Mann's hockey stick, show anomalies similar to recent history. Give or take a 90% confidence level, but there is only a 10% chance of that...

So, if anomalies are what is important, then there is no such thing as Global Warming- only regional anomalies, right? Anthropogenic Local Anomalies, anyone? Ummm, L.A. basin smog maybe? That was a climate problem, local anomaly, caused by man. Urban heat island? And the Chinese burning coal had nothing to do with it.

How about - just for fun - an alternate point of view.

It does not matter one whit if there is or is not there "Global Warming", all that matters and that attention should be put to is regional anomalies. Of course that would focus attention directly on real, not imaginary problems.....

Each area that has serious problems gets cleaned up and CO2 emissions continue unabated - completely ignored.
 
The acknowledged experts on temperature anomolies, errors in them and the unraveling of reality from them insofar as it may be possible would of course be Steve McIntyre and www.climateaudit.org.

:wink8:

He's just had to admit, NASA and the GISS got it right, not that anyone would notice, due to the fact that having got the source code and the classifications, the result of their calculations was just a verification of what was already known. Having fallen flat on his face there, he's off on a cherry picking tour of the Southern Hemisphere, where the climate is not going to warm as quickly as the northern hemisphere. Curiously, he has avoided Australia like the plague.

And since when did McIntyre and pals ever bother to check the Satellite records of Christy et al, which have been shown to have many errors?

One thing that was recently noted in a discussion of NASA's work (Hansen) was that it appeared 1950 had been picked as the baseline year in order to emphasize the "trend of things heating up".

It was the average of the existing record. Look at the trend, that's the signal of interest.
 
Last edited:
He's just had to admit, NASA and the GISS got it right, not that anyone would notice, due to the fact that having got the source code and the classifications, the result of their calculations was just a verification of what was already known. Having fallen flat on his face there, he's off on a cherry picking tour of the Southern Hemisphere, where the climate is not going to warm as quickly as the northern hemisphere. Curiously, he has avoided Australia like the plague.

I have no idea which of your favorite smear websites provided you with these juicy tidbits and don't care.

I am not aware of any conclusions by McIntyre at this point on this work. If you do have some references to conclusions by McIntyre, please provide them. Keep in mind: Assertions by your friends at Realclimate are not conclusions by McIntyre.
 
:wink8:

He's just had to admit, NASA and the GISS got it right, not that anyone would notice, due to the fact that having got the source code and the classifications, the result of their calculations was just a verification of what was already known. Having fallen flat on his face there, he's off on a cherry picking tour of the Southern Hemisphere, where the climate is not going to warm as quickly as the northern hemisphere. Curiously, he has avoided Australia like the plague.

And since when did McIntyre and pals ever bother to check the Satellite records of Christy et al, which have been shown to have many errors?



It was the average of the existing record. Look at the trend, that's the signal of interest.

It's doubtful you are comprehending the subject matter at CA. Please read it carefully.

The satellite records of UAH was corrected by .03, quite a whopping amount in your mind, but was still within the margin of error of +/-.05.

Naturally you don't find it interesting that RSS sat data had a sudden jump beginning in 1992 for no logical reason. This was discussed on Roger Pielke's blog in April.
http://climatesci.colorado.edu/2007...-by-the-university-of-alabama-research-group/
 
Ice core and Mauna Loa data fraud?

Has anyone seen this before? Looks like the data series were changed to make them fit...(double click to enlarge to original size)



Analysis of the problem by Jaworowski -
The problem with Siple data (and with other shallow cores) is that the CO2 concentration found in pre-industrial ice from a depth of 68 meters (i.e. above the depth of clathrate formation) was "too high". This ice was deposited in 1890 AD, and the CO2 concentration was 328 ppmv, not about 290 ppmv, as needed by man-made warming hypothesis. The CO2 atmospheric concentration of about 328 ppmv was measured at Mauna Loa, Hawaii as later as in 1973[8], i.e. 83 years after the ice was deposited at Siple.
​
 
Has anyone seen this before? Looks like the data series were changed to make them fit...(double click to enlarge to original size)

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1422447013a2077a34.png

Analysis of the problem by Jaworowski -
The problem with Siple data (and with other shallow cores) is that the CO2 concentration found in pre-industrial ice from a depth of 68 meters (i.e. above the depth of clathrate formation) was "too high". This ice was deposited in 1890 AD, and the CO2 concentration was 328 ppmv, not about 290 ppmv, as needed by man-made warming hypothesis. The CO2 atmospheric concentration of about 328 ppmv was measured at Mauna Loa, Hawaii as later as in 1973[8], i.e. 83 years after the ice was deposited at Siple.
​

Why don't you provide the link to your source?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom