Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

1. All fossil fuels burned is supposedly inadequate to double atmospheric co2 , and doubling it would get 2.5-6.5 c. Seems a no go there.

You don't do it on it's own. Setting fire to coal seams is cheap you will have a lot of cahs left over.

2. For sulfer hexaflouride
Man's contribution will be 43x27B = 1161 B Ton your 680B would yield perhaps 1.5-4 c increase.[/quote]

Your error is that you assume it will take 40 years to release that much.

3, Painting the planet. A big happy face maybe?

Did you fail highschool physics?

A big program like that would need lots of graduates. Maybe degree programs in Warmology?

What are you gibbering about?

But H bombing volcanoes, a fellow named Hubbard already came up with that.:)

The idea predates him and he was looking at destructive power not CO2 release.
 
Clue me in a bit: Is there some radical fringe AGW Alarmist concept promoted by EnvironDef, Friends, or Greenpeace that has not been promoted on JREF?

I doubt it.

I kinda love it. First you pompously announce in your OP how no ad hominems will be allowed, then you come out with a bog-standard trolling ad hom exercise with no content whatsoever. Way to go, dude, advertise your non-seriousness.
 
You don't do it on it's own. Setting fire to coal seams is cheap you will have a lot of cahs left over.

2. For sulfer hexaflouride
Man's contribution will be 43x27B = 1161 B Ton your 680B would yield perhaps 1.5-4 c increase.

Your error is that you assume it will take 40 years to release that much.
[/quote]

I thought that was what you meant.
 
They have always been upfront about the limits of what they can deduce from their research. Nevertheless, it's warming.

Yup, that we know. Now, all we have to do is to figure out how to improve the situation (even if it's not anthropogenic) without screwing up something else. I don't believe that can be done without a measurement tool. Perhaps all that can be done right now is to study worldwide anomalies but that's a very poor substitute.

Sure, but that is where consensus comes into it. Without that, in this case, we would never reach a conclusion.

Perhaps that's where you and I disagree the most. Science does not depend on consensus, politics do. Science is the history of the consensus being proved wrong. OTOH, once the driving science is defined, consensus has to be reached among those who will implement the changes.

The nutcases and contrarians are weeded out. It would be nice if they didn't have to do that, but the issue is important enough that we have to be told the best information that is available, despite the drawbacks that result.

What you are describing above is politics, not science. Perhaps the politicization of this issue is why the scientific community has not fully endorsed the findings of the IPCC. Politics and science don't make happy bedfellows.
 
The idea predates him and he was looking at destructive power not CO2 release.

Something along these lines perhaps?
There are at least two natural disasters that are believed to be a consequence of Henry's Law. Both occurred in western Africa, about two years apart, and both are believed to have been caused by the same phenomenon.

The first occurred at Lake Monoun, in the western African Republic of Cameroon. On August 16, 1984, officials found 37 people lying dead along a roadside near the lake. Then, on August 26, 1986, a massive disaster occurred near Lake Nyos, killing over 1700 people along with livestock and wildlife.

Both lakes are crater lakes. They are deep water-filled throats of old volcanoes. Although neither volcano is active, carbon dioxide is still being released into these lakes.

A typical lake has a regular seasonal turnover of water in which the warm water on top mixes with the cooler water on the bottom. But there are no such seasonal exchanges operating in these lakes, and water remains essentially uncirculated


In these crater lakes, water at the bottom of the lakes developed high concentrations of dissolved carbon dioxide gas. By a mechanism related to Henry's Law, this gas was trapped in the lower layer of the lake by the high pressure of the water above.

Scientists are not certain as to what triggered the release of the gas. Some speculate that it was volcanic activity, although most scientists dismiss this hypothesis. There may have been a landslide into the lake that stirred up the waters. But no specific trigger mechanism may have even been needed. The carbon dioxide may have just built to a point of saturation where any physical process common to lakes could have triggered the release. Since both releases occurred in August, there is some speculation that reduced air temperatures may have played a role.
Once the release began, it rapidly reached explosive proportions, suffocating human and animal life in its wake.


It is estimated that the volume of carbon dioxide released was approximately equal to 1 km3, or about 2 ? 1012grams (over 2 million tons).

See "The Lake Nyos Disaster" ChemMatters, February 1996 for a complete account of the human and environmental tragedies surrounding this event. These lakes are still considered to be dangerous. Future explosions of a similar nature are possible in the region.
​
 
Yes but...

How accurately is the current temp figured? With all of those zillions of thermometers allover the world, About a two degree range.

How accurate are the 'proxies'? At best about a two degree range.

How much overlap is there in those two ranges? A lot- enough to where I don't believe we can even state unequivocally that we are even hotter today than before.

To sum up the AGW'ers, our average temp used to be between 68 and 70. It is now between 68 and 70. MAN IS DESTROYING THE WORLD!

The following answer is provided at this nasa giss site. It is hard to find, but it is there.
For the global mean, the most trusted models produce a value of roughly 14 Celsius, i.e. 57.2 F, but it may easily be anywhere between 56 and 58 F and regionally, let alone locally, the situation is even worse.
​
There is no explanation of what they mean by models, but one would think this would be the thermometer data transposed onto a global grid (Hansen's line of work). Also, why do they like "anomalies" so much better than the straight temperature? Maybe because the "anomalies" are zeroed on 1950 values and that maximizes the current upward temperature trend?

The link was previously noted by AUP (although I am not sure she saw the answer to your question down in the fine print). Summarizing, then:
  • Eli Rabbit "there are no global temperature measurements, there are global temperature ANOMALY measurements."
  • Realclimate: " the global mean temperature is indeed a function of the temperature over the whole planetary surface. "
  • Bjarne Andresen "....it is meaningless to talk about a global temperature for Earth"
  • Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, (2006 joint paper) argue the same thing.
  • NASA/GISS agrees with Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, but do cough up a number for "global temperature", while stating it is totally useless.
RealClimate isn't on the bandwagon on this one. Rabbit, Andresen, Essex, McKitrick, and NASA agree.
 
The following answer is provided at this nasa giss site. It is hard to find, but it is there.
For the global mean, the most trusted models produce a value of roughly 14 Celsius, i.e. 57.2 F, but it may easily be anywhere between 56 and 58 F and regionally, let alone locally, the situation is even worse.
​
There is no explanation of what they mean by models, but one would think this would be the thermometer data transposed onto a global grid (Hansen's line of work). Also, why do they like "anomalies" so much better than the straight temperature? Maybe because the "anomalies" are zeroed on 1950 values and that maximizes the current upward temperature trend?

The link was previously noted by AUP (although I am not sure she saw the answer to your question down in the fine print). Summarizing, then:
  • Eli Rabbit "there are no global temperature measurements, there are global temperature ANOMALY measurements."
  • Realclimate: " the global mean temperature is indeed a function of the temperature over the whole planetary surface. "
  • Bjarne Andresen "....it is meaningless to talk about a global temperature for Earth"
  • Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, (2006 joint paper) argue the same thing.
  • NASA/GISS agrees with Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, but do cough up a number for "global temperature", while stating it is totally useless.
RealClimate isn't on the bandwagon on this one. Rabbit, Andresen, Essex, McKitrick, and NASA agree.

It's a bit of both. The average temperature is the average as defined, even if people don't like it, it's still a useful idea. It's based on the measurements taken every day, at many sites, in degree C. The actual measurement of warming is based the anomolies, and it shows warming.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_temperature_record
 
Soo, they know the temp is probably between 56 and 58 degrees. So how can they even state that there is a +.5 anomaly? Something like +3 I could see.

And how accurate do you think the 'fossil models" are? They can NOT be any better.

What a bunch of junk science.
 
Soo, they know the temp is probably between 56 and 58 degrees. So how can they even state that there is a +.5 anomaly? Something like +3 I could see.

And how accurate do you think the 'fossil models" are? They can NOT be any better.

What a bunch of junk science.

You have misunderstood the point. The global average, (which can be defined in various ways), gives us an idea of what the average temperature of the planet is. Then we can do things, like see how much warmer we are than absolute zero. Measuring warming is done by measuring the change in temperature for each meaurement site. That is much more easily defined and accurate.
 
You have misunderstood the point. The global average, (which can be defined in various ways), gives us an idea of what the average temperature of the planet is. T

AUP, you may have misunderstood.

NASA dearly says in your link then is no value in the "global temperature concept". RC missed the facts in their rush to discredit Mckitrick et al.
 
AUP, you may have misunderstood.

NASA dearly says in your link then is no value in the "global temperature concept". RC missed the facts in their rush to discredit Mckitrick et al.

RC talked about "Is there a global temperature", yes, there is. Is it much use? It's useful in some ways, but the warming that is happening is measured by the anomolies. RC itself provided the link to Rabett.

NASA itself says

http://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/vis/a000000/a003300/a003375/

Five-Year Average Global Temperature Anomalies from 1880 to 2006

So the matter appears to be one of terminology. The scientists are using average global temperature as a shorthand for "Average Global Temperature Anomalies", kind of like "The bottom line". McIntyre et al appear to have been chasing the wrong rabbit down the hole.
 
Last edited:
RC talked about "Is there a global temperature", yes, there is. Is it much use? It's useful in some ways, but the warming that is happening is measured by the anomolies. RC itself provided the link to Rabett.

NASA itself says

http://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/vis/a000000/a003300/a003375/



So the matter appears to be one of terminology. The scientists are using average global temperature as a shorthand for "Average Global Temperature Anomalies", kind of like "The bottom line".

Sometimes they do. But in the instance mentioned, RC was commenting about an actual global temperature.
 
Sometimes they do. But in the instance mentioned, RC was commenting about an actual global temperature.

Because that was the topic. There is a notional global average temperature, and it's useful for various things, just as a forcast for a large geographic area is useful for the people who live there. If you want to measure global warming, temperature anomolies are used, for the reasons specified.
 
I think we are in agreement on those issues, but you are dodging my specific assertion about RC being wrong. Is there some problem with their being wrong? Everybody is wrong sometimes. Repeating -
The link was previously noted by AUP (although I am not sure she saw the answer to your question down in the fine print). Summarizing, then:
  • Eli Rabbit "there are no global temperature measurements, there are global temperature ANOMALY measurements."
  • Realclimate: " the global mean temperature is indeed a function of the temperature over the whole planetary surface. "
  • Bjarne Andresen "....it is meaningless to talk about a global temperature for Earth"
  • Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, (2006 joint paper) argue the same thing.
  • NASA/GISS agrees with Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, but do cough up a number for "global temperature", while stating it is totally useless.
RealClimate isn't on the bandwagon on this one. Rabbit, Andresen, Essex, McKitrick, and NASA agree.​
 
Soo, they know the temp is probably between 56 and 58 degrees. So how can they even state that there is a +.5 anomaly?


That very question that has occupied www.climateaudit.org and the merry band therein. The current subject "Where's Waldo?" has to do with auditing each geographical area of the world, one after another, in an effort to find where the alleged anomalies are. It's not just Steve McIntyre anymore.

Bunches of amateurs on the Internet, using the R statistics package, downloading the raw and corrected temperature data sets, auditing them, and posting results and discussion at www.climateaudit.org.

The solution to these troublemakers is to shut down the internet.:D
 
That very question that has occupied www.climateaudit.org and the merry band therein. The current subject "Where's Waldo?" has to do with auditing each geographical area of the world, one after another, in an effort to find where the alleged anomalies are. It's not just Steve McIntyre anymore.

Bunches of amateurs on the Internet, using the R statistics package, downloading the raw and corrected temperature data sets, auditing them, and posting results and discussion at www.climateaudit.org.

The solution to these troublemakers is to shut down the internet.:D

Eli is wrong on that point, but only because of a problem with what is actually being discussed. There is a notional global temperature, just as there is a notional temperature for Melbourne. In terms of global warming, and measuring it, it's better to use anomolies, because they are so precise. Once again, it's a matter of what is being addressed, and why. I can't find it now, but there is a temperature graph for the earth in geological terms in Kelvin, so NASA is quite happy to use the idea of a global temperature of a planet when it is appropriate, too. It's not going to be much use for measuring global warming precisely, but it's useful for comparing the global climate over the earth's history. It helps to anchor the temperature in absolute terms, because in absolute terms water will boil or freeze at various temperatures, for example. Anomolies aren't going to tell you that.
 
Anomalies are precise?

Anomalies are precisely insignificant.

AUP you will just have to get over it.

There is no big global warming caused by man, no tipping points, no urgent action required, and no reason to insult people by saying things like
"Do you feel lucky, punk?"
​
From Luboš Motl Pilsen, Czech Republic's exellent website -Gerd Bürger argues the global character of the 20th century warming was not statistically significant.(article published in Science, volume 316)
Bürger: Technical comment on "The Spatial Extent of 20th-Century Warmth in the Context of the Past 1200 Years"
The author explains that the authors of the original article, Osborn and Briffa, didn't take proxy screening into account when they calculated the significance levels. They neglected that proxies may be correlated with the existing temperatures and included among temperature-sensitive proxies by chance.


Once this mistake is corrected the significance of the 20th-century warming anomaly disappears. The 99th percentile is almost never exceeded while the 95th percentile is surpassed in the early 20th century as well as the early 11th century while the 17th century (and the year 1700 in particular) were equally anomalously cold - nothing that would support the AGW theory.​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom