Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

There was no instantaneous change of thermal expansion from say, 25% of total sea level increase to 50% as of 1993 at the exact moment when the method of measurement of the supposedly identical phenomena changed from tide-based to satellite radar atimetry.

The changes in 1993 were both in the item measured and the method of measurement -
  1. Areas measured - the wide ocean not the shores
  2. Method - Satellite instead of tide gauge
Here's the thing, if you go and look at Chapter 5 of the report, you will see that they have three sets of data that all pretty much agree. Two from tide gauges and one from the satellite. They point out themselves the discrepencies between the satellite and the tide gauge results. In anycase they don't need to include the satellite data to say that the rate of thermal expansion from 1993 - 2003 is greater than that from 1963 - 2003, they could do it just fine with data from tide gauge measurements because they have it and they show it fully referenced from the papers they pull it from.

Pretty substantial changes would you not agree? By the way. Your assertion that there could be a hidden "hokey stick" in the table is false, unless there was virtually no sea level rise until 1993.
I guess it's pretty lucky that I explicitly said that I wasn't saying that the sea level rise was like a hockey stick then isn't it? The post is right there in the thread for anyone to go back and read. Why try and make out I said something I didn't?:confused:

Here it is in fact.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3144780&postcount=817

Lets for arguments sake take a "hockey stick" shaped graph. It isn't "that" hockey stick, just any old hockey stick shape will do. I am not saying that sea level rise is hockey stick shaped, just that I want to describe the shape of a curve that is easily recognisable by us all.
I've bolded the relevent part for you so you don't miss it. I actually wrote that bit specifically so that I could not be accused of saying that sea level rise was like a hockey stick and yet here we are anyway. It's quite sad really.

Noting the above, we agree that the actual scientists do qualify and caution their work, do note that it is too early to hold that there is an accelerating rate of sea level rise and that decadal changes are very significant.
No. Please inform yourself by reading the report. The conclusion is that the increased rate of global mean sea level rise seen during 1993 - 2003 could be just down to decadal variations, but at century long time scales an increase in the rate of sea level rise is observable. If you disagree, why don't you pull up the paper they reference and point out it's shortcomings to us?
 
Thanks for the linky. You're right, if I read the report first, I wouldn't need to argue with a lot of the extreme misrepresentations of what that report says. I found it to be a much more tempered analysis than what I've gotten from most here. For example:

Well the interesting parts about the discussion to me are when people start talking about the IPCC reports, saying they are wrong for whatever reason, that they scaremonger etc. If that can be shown then that is fairly important I think. So that's why I get involved when people make specific verifiable claims about what the report does or doesn't say. With a fairly reasonable e-journal subscription and the free availability of the IPCC report it's fairly straightforward to go and check things out in those dull moments.

Basically I think if you are going to argue about something you should atleast have some idea of what the various positions are about.



Also, the report makes it fairly plain that it's primarily the top 700 m of ocean that are involved in thermal expanson. (Just because the water column data is taken for the top 3 Km, does not mean that the entire water column is involved.)
They do say this though and incorporate it into the results.

From the results of
Antonov et al. (2005) for thermal expansion, the
difference between the trends in the upper 3,000
m and the upper 700 m for 1961 to 1998 is about
0.1 mm yr–1
Given the numbers involved it seems like a signifcant contribution to me. 0-700m from 1955 - 2003 of 0.33 mm/yr and then 0-3000m from 1955 - 1998 of 0.4 mm/yr give or take the range of uncertainty which is similar for each.

There is some speculation in the report, though, but it's plainly admitted. One cannot ascribe a cause for sea level rise from observation alone. Frankly, I get the feeling that thermal expansion of the seas is being used as a fudge factor to account for sea level rise that is not accounted for from land ice melt. I seriously question the quadrupling of the rate presented for shorter time periods as seen in the Table 5.2. (I will always believe a trend measured over fifty years more than a trend measured over ten, especially if the claimed difference between rates is four-fold.)
The 50 year trend graph does show quite a lot of variation within it, and that's the point I've been trying to make with Mhaze. If they pulled out figures for 1970-1980 it would look just as alarming when compared to the 1955-2003 number. It doesn't mean it isn't possible though. According to the data that's how they think it behaves. I'm not in a position to argue with them.
​
 
Last edited:
IPCC Sea Level Rates: Another hockey stick?

when people start talking about the IPCC reports, saying they are wrong for whatever reason, that they scaremonger etc. If that can be shown then that is fairly important I think.
First, please note that in my saying the IPCC were wrong on this issue, I quoted more recent research. This is very different than saying that as of the date of publication, the IPCC method and conclusions are wrong. Second note that criticizing the IPCC Summary for Policymakers is a very different matter than criticizing the individual chapters.

So where do you want to go with that exactly? Of course more recent research invalidates or changes conclusions in prior work. Of course the SPM is bent politically when it is compared to the IPCC individual chapters. Surely you do not disagree with that?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3144780&postcount=817

I've bolded the relevent part for you so you don't miss it. I actually wrote that bit specifically so that I could not be accused of saying that sea level rise was like a hockey stick and yet here we are anyway. It's quite sad really.

If I have misquoted you, I certainly did not intend to and do apologize. But if you will look at the below snip from a post succeeding your "i'm not saying it looks like a hockey stick" post, this being my response to Schneib after he accused me of, who knows what, photoshopping the IPCC report or something -
Table 5.3 says in the left hand column, for 1961 - 2003 thermal expansion was 0.42 mm/year. Total for 41 years: 18.06 mm.

Right hand column, for 1993 - 2003 thermal expansion was 1.6 mm/year. Total for 11 years: 17.6 mm. There's a basic problem with the numbers not adding up here too nicely here.

Which as I've stated already, was caused by changing measurement methodologies in 1993 when the satellite radar altimeter came to be used. What is so difficult about understanding that?

Unless you'd like to maintain that for 1961 - 1992 there was only 0.46 mm total of sea level rise due to thermal expansion? That is, 0.015 mm per year? Take your pick.
​


Your saying that you are not saying it is a hockey stick does not change the basic nature of the data, that being data items being presented in the form of a hockey stick. If you don't want to say it, then I will do so:
"Yet another hokey stick".
​
(But, hey, give them credit for not drawing the stupid thing out.) Could you point me to a section of the IPCC report where it is specifically stated that satellite radar altimeter measures a different thing than the tide gauges? Namely, the wide oceans versus the shore based gauges?

Slime suggests that the 1.6 mm for thermal expansion looks a bit like a fudged number. I thought instead there might be something of too much of a bias towards jumping on the exciting new satellite radar altimetry bandwagon, without a careful examination of the errors in that method.

Suppose you had to make your components of sea level melt suddenly add up to a number of 2.8 instead of 1.8 or so. Glacier melt, land based runoff, and other numbers are known within error bounds. These are pretty much invariable. Thermal expansion is the item that must be "corrected" isn't it?
 
First, please note that in my saying the IPCC were wrong on this issue, I quoted more recent research. This is very different than saying that as of the date of publication, the IPCC method and conclusions are wrong. Second note that criticizing the IPCC Summary for Policymakers is a very different matter than criticizing the individual chapters.

So where do you want to go with that exactly? Of course more recent research invalidates or changes conclusions in prior work. Of course the SPM is bent politically when it is compared to the IPCC individual chapters. Surely you do not disagree with that?

O...K...

Firstly, you didn't "quote" any research. What you did was drastically misinterprate the research. You went as far as misrepresenting what they actually did. Satellite vs tide gauges.

Secondly, it was you who thought you had scored a big point over the IPCC by saying they were wrong. Of course more recent research may change what we think about how things work. That is science afterall, but from your original post you certainly gave the impression that you thought you had got one over the IPCC. Again, anyone can go back and read your post. I mentioned this earlier in the thread, where I likened it to the IPCC needing a time machine to be right in your eyes. In any case when you look at the error estimates from the IPCC data and the Woppelmann figures, they nicely overlap.

Thirdly, when they make a point of adding the levels of uncertainty about the measurements, and then say that the 1993 -2003 rates might just be decadal variation, in the SPM no less, how is that trying to be alarmist? And, if you criticise the summary of the IPCC report for skimping on the details of the science, why don't you start criticising the abstracts of journal papers for not going into enough detail either?

If I have misquoted you, I certainly did not intend to and do apologize. But if you will look at the below snip from a post succeeding your "i'm not saying it looks like a hockey stick" post, this being my response to Schneib after he accused me of, who knows what, photoshopping the IPCC report or something -
Table 5.3 says in the left hand column, for 1961 - 2003 thermal expansion was 0.42 mm/year. Total for 41 years: 18.06 mm.

Right hand column, for 1993 - 2003 thermal expansion was 1.6 mm/year. Total for 11 years: 17.6 mm. There's a basic problem with the numbers not adding up here too nicely here.

Which as I've stated already, was caused by changing measurement methodologies in 1993 when the satellite radar altimeter came to be used. What is so difficult about understanding that?

Unless you'd like to maintain that for 1961 - 1992 there was only 0.46 mm total of sea level rise due to thermal expansion? That is, 0.015 mm per year? Take your pick.
​
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_142244731ed7796761.png

Your saying that you are not saying it is a hockey stick does not change the basic nature of the data, that being data items being presented in the form of a hockey stick. If you don't want to say it, then I will do so:
"Yet another hokey stick".​
How is it possibly being presented as a hockey stick? The nature of the data is there in the figures in chapter 5 for everyone to see. The table in the summary is referenced back to the chapter. And again I will repeat that they say that the increase in rate during the 1993 - 2003 period might just be due to decadal variations and not a new trend. If they say that expilicitly in the SPM how can you possibly say "hockey stick?" There is a nice subsection dealing with it in the chapter. If they don't have enough space to go into it in detail in the summary at least they present the conclusions.

Besides as I pointed out, and as you can see from looking at chapter 5 the rate increase is not to do with the change in measurement technique at all. The observed decadal variations give the lie to that.

(But, hey, give them credit for not drawing the stupid thing out.) Could you point me to a section of the IPCC report where it is specifically stated that satellite radar altimeter measures a different thing than the tide gauges? Namely, the wide oceans versus the shore based gauges?
For one thing it is implicit in the methodology, for another thing in section 5.5.2.1 when talking about sea level from tide gauges

Holgate and Woodworth
(2004) estimated a rate of 1.7 ± 0.4 mm yr–1 sea level change
averaged along the global coastline during the period
1948 to
2002, based on data from 177 stations divided into 13 regions.
and in section 5.5.2.2

Altimetry from T/P allows the mapping of the geographical
distribution of sea level change (Figure 5.15a). Although
regional variability in coastal sea level change had been reported
from tide gauge analyses (e.g., Douglas, 1992; Lambeck, 2002),
the global coverage of satellite altimetry provides unambiguous
evidence of non-uniform sea level change in open oceans,
with some regions exhibiting rates of sea level change about
fi ve times the global mean.
They directly compare the two in that paragraph.

And of course they give references so you can go and look at the methodology in more detail if you want to. It'd be a strange review paper that just copy and pasted the entirety of the papers it included and added them to the report instead of using the referencing system.

Slime suggests that the 1.6 mm for thermal expansion looks a bit like a fudged number. I thought instead there might be something of too much of a bias towards jumping on the exciting new satellite radar altimetry bandwagon, without a careful examination of the errors in that method.

Suppose you had to make your components of sea level melt suddenly add up to a number of 2.8 instead of 1.8 or so. Glacier melt, land based runoff, and other numbers are known within error bounds. These are pretty much invariable. Thermal expansion is the item that must be "corrected" isn't it?
Well the problem with that idea is that in that very same table from the SPM, they happily do the sums for you and give you the difference between the measured sea level rise and the sum of the estimated componants. It really looks like they are trying to hide something there doesn't it? It also seems that there is less of a difference when they use the satellite data than when they don't. Something to do with the accuracy of the measurements perhaps? You know the conspiracies forum is down the hall on the right.
 
Last edited:
If packed in earth, yes.

Why? Ceramic is earth in the first place, and a damn' fine insulator.


I'm surprised there's no direct mention of salinity there, although it is mentioned tangentially :

"These overflows form up into a deep current also flowing back to the subtropics (purple), but beneath the Labrador Sea Water. The green pathway also indicates cold waters--but so influenced by continental runoff as to remain light and near the sea surface on the continental shelf"

The salinity increases the density of the surface current over and above the increase in density from cooling, so the sinking water is relatively warm. As I recall, the water then cools further as it flows away south at depth, which would mean a transfer of heat-energy from surface water to deep water. The cold deep water eventually upwells, keeping the surface water cooler than if it just sat there basking in the sunshine To me that reads like transfer of heat-energy from the surface to depth by oceanic overturning. I could be wrong, of course.



No, you don't have to assume it to make Beer's Law viable. The absorption of IR radiation by sea water will occur whether or not air heats water negligibly or predominantly. What you and I disagree on is to what degree air warms the oceans, regardless of radiative warming.

That's fair enough. I get the impression you think it's negligible. Again, I could be wrong.

They would be two separate and independent mechanisms. Two additive terms in the equation, if you will. Conduction would be yet another term. To me, Beer's Law would be used to predict the penetration of IR into the ocean's surface, not the warming thereof. The warming is easy as you can assume 100% absorption due to the sea's depth.

opint of interest : why only IR? Why not higher wavelengths, which also represent energy and are also absorbed (it's not just cold down there, it's very dark).

Nice hypothesis. Too bad the heat of vaporization of water is about nine times the heat of fusion. IOW, the raindrop would have to be eight times warmer than it left to give you your zero-sum system, as advertised above. One might even wonder why it doesn't rain everywhere all the time!

Heat of fusion involves the freezing of water, not its condensation. Perhaps you need to clarify this point. It seems to involve a transgression of Conservation of Energy - which is taken very seriously in some parts.
 
CD may have missed that the warm water mixes with cold water before it sinks.

Mine is a very broad-brush understanding of the subject :).


It may take awhile but the oceans will warm all the way through

Given that the properties of air and water won't change substantially, it seems to me that the temperature gradient from atmosphere down to the ocean depths will remain pretty much the same. Which would imply warming all the way down once equilibrium is reached - which, as you say, will take a while.
 
Last edited:
Very true but there are some on this thread who believe that conduction from air is going to significantly compete with IR absorption. Maybe not your claim but it has been made.

I (for one) have suggested that conduction from air might significantly add to the IR absorption warming. I don't see where competition comes into it.
 
Mine is a very broad-brush understanding of the subject :).




Given that the properties of air and water won't change substantially, it seems to me that the temperature gradient from atmosphere down to the ocean depths will remain pretty much the same. Which would imply warming all the way down once equilibrium is reached - which, as you say, will take a while.


We've had oceans for billions of years. They have not obtained equilibrium yet.
 
Last edited:
We've had oceans for billions of years. They have not obtained equilibrium yet.

There are degrees of disequilibrium, and associated timescales. There's a daily disequlibrium - the Sun comes up, the Sun goes down, the Sun comes up again. There's an annual disequilibrium - the Sun comes up low in the sky, the Sun gets higher in the sky, the Sun gets lower in the sky. (Sometimes it don't come up at all.) There's a glacial-interglacial disequilibrium on the order of a hundred thousand years. There are ice-epoch/non-ice-epoch disequibria on no particluar timescale, since they're determined by continental drift and other geological processes unrelated to climate or the Sun. There's a longer-scale disequilbrium between the time when bolide bombardent was a major influence on the oceans and the time when it became minor, which was mostly determined by Jupiter.

So you're right. What you're not doing is making a point.
 
Why? Ceramic is earth in the first place, and a damn' fine insulator.

Yes, but the insulating quality depends on its thickness. We could be talking eggshell china or the stuff I made in Art class. (The latter could shield you form an A-bomb blast.) Just added that fine touch.

I'm surprised there's no direct mention of salinity there, although it is mentioned tangentially
:

Salinity would affect the water's density but not all that much. Sea water is 0.9% salt, weight to weight. Minor fluctuations wouldn't really have much effect. What makes water sink or rise would be its density and density varies mostly with temperature in this case. (There are instances where you can load so much of a salt into water that it makes it kinda gelatinous but that's not what's happening in the oceans.)

The salinity increases the density of the surface current over and above the increase in density from cooling, so the sinking water is relatively warm. As I recall, the water then cools further as it flows away south at depth, which would mean a transfer of heat-energy from surface water to deep water. The cold deep water eventually upwells, keeping the surface water cooler than if it just sat there basking in the sunshine To me that reads like transfer of heat-energy from the surface to depth by oceanic overturning. I could be wrong, of course.

The more probable scenario, though, is that a tropical current (such as the Gulf Stream) imparts heat to colder surface waters. Even if you are correct about deep currents, do you really think those deep currents are over 1 km deep? I don't think surface currents are that deep. Of course, I also could be wrong.

That's fair enough. I get the impression you think it's negligible. Again, I could be wrong.

I have no data, CD. I also could be wrong. It's my impression based on my view of the planet. Which might be ersatz.

opint of interest : why only IR? Why not higher wavelengths, which also represent energy and are also absorbed (it's not just cold down there, it's very dark).

IR is heat. The other portions of the spectrum give us light and suntans but not heat.

Heat of fusion involves the freezing of water, not its condensation. Perhaps you need to clarify this point. It seems to involve a transgression of Conservation of Energy - which is taken very seriously in some parts.

You're right, CD. Damn! I hate to be wrong. Of course, the energy put into vaporization must be equal to the energy of condensation. I just looked it up and I had mistaken the notion of condensation with crystallizaton/fusion. My bad. I apologize for that. So, pay no attention to that man behind the curtain! :blush:

So, you could be right. Rainfall could be warmer than the source water and warm the seas.
 
I (for one) have suggested that conduction from air might significantly add to the IR absorption warming. I don't see where competition comes into it.

Again, you're right. Competition is not the right word. Relative contribution is what I was after. That is, which one is predominant? Or are any of the three (radiation absorption, conduction, convection) really predominant. My thinking is that, as there's a lot more open ocean than shore, it would be radiation absorption. I don't think conduction from one water horizon to a deeper horizon really counts for much as someone else has pointed out that the expansion of water per degree increases with temperature. Therefore, conduction would decrease the expansion of the seas.
 
Last edited:
Well the interesting parts about the discussion to me are when people start talking about the IPCC reports, saying they are wrong for whatever reason, that they scaremonger etc. If that can be shown then that is fairly important I think. So that's why I get involved when people make specific verifiable claims about what the report does or doesn't say. With a fairly reasonable e-journal subscription and the free availability of the IPCC report it's fairly straightforward to go and check things out in those dull moments.

fsol, you are absolutely correct. I have strayed from what I also would consider good practice. One should always go to the raw data (in this case, the IPCC report itself) when a controversy erupts. In my own defense, I proclaimed my almost complete lack of bona fide knowledge about AGW when I entered this thread. I chose to question claims about AGW (based on IPCC or not) based on my understanding of science and probability. I do have some personal experience in environmental science but it's only applicable to a few scenarios like coring.

Reading the IPCC report, I see it as a fairly tentative work. Not tentative in the sense that the science isn't good but in the manner that scientists would write when they realize they've not got enough data to make sweeping statements about what they've found or think they've found. At least for Chapter 5, I believe the report to be truthful and intellectually honest.

That brings me to a broader point. There are people who are genuinely scared for planet Earth based on the IPCC reports. I see reason for concern but not reason for worry or panic therein. The IPCC report is being abused by special interests to try to sway political systems one way or another, in my opinion. Even when I read the portions about CO2 in a different chapter, the language was not so inflammatory as proclaiming that humankind was decidedly responsible for GW. The language was more measured and cautious.

Basically I think if you are going to argue about something you should atleast have some idea of what the various positions are about.

Yeppers.

Given the numbers involved it seems like a signifcant contribution to me. 0-700m from 1955 - 2003 of 0.33 mm/yr and then 0-3000m from 1955 - 1998 of 0.4 mm/yr give or take the range of uncertainty which is similar for each.

Can't argue with you there. My doubt falls on the quadrupling of the rate based on a ten-year sample. I now see where people get the 50% contribution thing as, if you take the 1.6 mm/yr rate and total increase of 0.1 m over 110 years, the putative thermal expansion would equal about half of that tidal increase. Taking a statistical minimum and combining it with a statistical maximum is really, really, really foolish and dishonest, though. I ran into this problem about a year ago working with a synthetic chemist who decided to ignore QSR for the composition of a formulation because of what he needed to do if all the other compenents were at ther absolute statistical minima but it's a long, boring story and I won't post it here.​


The 50 year trend graph does show quite a lot of variation within it, and that's the point I've been trying to make with Mhaze. If they pulled out figures for 1970-1980 it would look just as alarming when compared to the 1955-2003 number. It doesn't mean it isn't possible though. According to the data that's how they think it behaves. I'm not in a position to argue with them.
​

Yes, the noise present in those measurements is one wonderful reason to base prognoses on the longest possible sampling interval. The quadruple rate of change for the last ten years may or may not be artifactual. It's not possible to tell from eyeballing due to the breadth of the uncertainty.

I once read a stat book on correlation theory. (Yes, I'm a boring geek.) One of the pet peeves the author had was of misrepresentation of statistical trends. He cited one instance when a preacher would rail at the lawlessness induced into society once "god was taken out of the classroom". His graph was an accurate graph of the rate of increase in the per capita crime rate since that Supreme Court decision. What the book's author pointed out that the preacher had decided to exclude the larger graph that led up to that point in time. When the years preceding the court action were added to the picture, it was easy to see that the rate of increase in crime had not changed at all. Not really a direct example and maybe you might think it's irrelevant to this case but I felt like writing it.

Thanks.
 
I (for one) have suggested that conduction from air might significantly add to the IR absorption warming. I don't see where competition comes into it.

Thinking about this a bit (and having the advantage of a little point and shoot laser temperature thingy) I've got a solid 10C difference between floor and ceiling in various rooms. That's just over two or three meters. Heat rises.

Suppose a mass of warm air went out over the ocean. The laminar layer next to the ocean surface is cooler due to local evaporation and as, CD mentions, some heat transfer into the ocean. That layer reaches equilibrium, and then no further heat transfer would occur. The exception is turbulance flow, which could move new layers of hotter air next to the ocean surface.

Air to ocean is hotter to colder in a thermodynamic sense but the hotter air does not want to stay down and the colder air does not want to be pushed above it. The net forces seem to work against a 2nd law temperature push to equilibrium conditions.

Exceptions, maybe???: Conditions during medium to high winds, where spray from wave tops might go into the air, was warmed, and dropped back into the ocean. But higher winds means more evaporation and more cooling...

At least from this simple analysis, air does not heat the oceans.
 
Thinking about this a bit (and having the advantage of a little point and shoot laser temperature thingy) I've got a solid 10C difference between floor and ceiling in various rooms. That's just over two or three meters. Heat rises.

Suppose a mass of warm air went out over the ocean. The laminar layer next to the ocean surface is cooler due to local evaporation and as, CD mentions, some heat transfer into the ocean. That layer reaches equilibrium, and then no further heat transfer would occur. The exception is turbulance flow, which could move new layers of hotter air next to the ocean surface.

Air to ocean is hotter to colder in a thermodynamic sense but the hotter air does not want to stay down and the colder air does not want to be pushed above it. The net forces seem to work against a 2nd law temperature push to equilibrium conditions.

Exceptions, maybe???: Conditions during medium to high winds, where spray from wave tops might go into the air, was warmed, and dropped back into the ocean. But higher winds means more evaporation and more cooling...

At least from this simple analysis, air does not heat the oceans.

Agreed. In calm weather, I can's see much conductance from the atmosphere to the ocean (and vice versa) because of laminar insulation and the fact that air is such a poor conductor of heat. The only thing that can penetrate the cool layer above the seas is light (IR radiation). I still believe that it is the predominant mechanism for ocean warming but I can't come out and state it must be because I don't have the data.

I disagree about the spray. I know of no instance where a water spray does not cool through evaporation. The only way the water would warm is for the temperature differential to impart more heat into the droplets of water that do no vaporize as it does for the water that does vaporize. Due to the latent heat of vaporization being so high, I don't think this is possible.
 
I disagree about the spray. I know of no instance where a water spray does not cool through evaporation. The only way the water would warm is for the temperature differential to impart more heat into the droplets of water that do no vaporize as it does for the water that does vaporize. Due to the latent heat of vaporization being so high, I don't think this is possible.

Sheesh. Just ignore that part of my comment (Just thing "cooling tower"....duhhh...)

But if the water was warmer than the air, as the air next to the water was heated up, it would rise, and more heavier, cold air would replace it, which would really move some heat.

So very crudely, it looks like strictly for convection -

Hotter water --> heat transfer to air
Hotter air--> no significant heat transfer

Then we have evaporative and condensive processes in addition to convection and radiative transfer. Warmer air causing faster sublimation of ice or evaporation of water when it moves over such masses.
 
Sorry, mhaze, wasn't trying to be difficult. I thought of another good illustration of the lack of conduction. That is, robust conduction of heat from/to air and water would make fog impossible, wouldn't it? Isn't fog an illustration that air doesn't conduct heat well (it's a friggin' cloud on the ground)?

Does anyone know of a natural phenomenon that depends on air conducting heat efficiently?
 
Sorry, mhaze, wasn't trying to be difficult. I thought of another good illustration of the lack of conduction. That is, robust conduction of heat from/to air and water would make fog impossible, wouldn't it? Isn't fog an illustration that air doesn't conduct heat well (it's a friggin' cloud on the ground)?

Does anyone know of a natural phenomenon that depends on air conducting heat efficiently?

Yes. The "heatpipe effect" whereby warmer air is lifted up into the upper trophosphere where it can dissipate a larger fraction of it's energy into space than close to the ground.

OOooppss...that has implications for the famous "greenhouse effect".:D
 
did we ever get a citation to Tsonis making such claims? (sorry if i missed it).
while he has been quite fond of chaos and linear analysis of cycles since the early nineties, and his linear algebra is at times a bit interesting, i know of no "its purely natural" claims by him then or now.
Tsonis didn't claim that "most or all of the recent temperature increase is due to natural variations" that I saw; he in fact specifically indicated that global warming could be the signal behind the results he got using his networking and chaos oriented methodology. In what paper do you claim that was said? In addition, the mechanism behind the "teleconnections" he talks about is unspecified.
in terms of his work in Nature (on climate and cycles) back in 1992, there was no a priori mechanism; it was time series analysis proposing cycles (or shooting down proposed cycles) in search of mechanisms.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom