Pipirr
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2006
- Messages
- 1,433
From the first post in this thread-
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).
Seriously? Jaworowski's credibility is an important issue. Publication in the peer reviewed literature imparts credibility. Publication in a LaRouche fanzine diminishes it.
Is it really argumentum ad hominem to that point out?
The way I see it, the quality of evidence can be evaluated, indirectly, by scrutiny of the source. If if comes from a peer reviewed article, one at least has the assurance that it was acceptable to other scientists. The journal in which it was published can also add or detract from the credibility of the research, as some attract better submissions and better reviewers than others. Presenting evidence that is peer reviewed would go a long way to preventing the criticisms that you want to avoid.
At the very least, if you are going to show a figure, say where it comes from. It matters. If Jaworowski's figure came from a peer reviewed publication, say where, and you will have a better chance of having it evaluated on its merits. No citation? The fact that Jaworowski gets his publication count up from Lyndon Larouche will weigh against it. Defray that criticism by showing that it was peer reviewed. If it wasn't peer reviewed, perhaps you should ask yourself why not, and assess it more critically. I certainly would.
Please follow these restrictions or take your nutter comments elsewhere. You have been politely asked.
Sure, but if AUP left, you'd be talking to yourself.