Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

From the first post in this thread-
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).​



Seriously? Jaworowski's credibility is an important issue. Publication in the peer reviewed literature imparts credibility. Publication in a LaRouche fanzine diminishes it.

Is it really argumentum ad hominem to that point out?

The way I see it, the quality of evidence can be evaluated, indirectly, by scrutiny of the source. If if comes from a peer reviewed article, one at least has the assurance that it was acceptable to other scientists. The journal in which it was published can also add or detract from the credibility of the research, as some attract better submissions and better reviewers than others. Presenting evidence that is peer reviewed would go a long way to preventing the criticisms that you want to avoid.

At the very least, if you are going to show a figure, say where it comes from. It matters. If Jaworowski's figure came from a peer reviewed publication, say where, and you will have a better chance of having it evaluated on its merits. No citation? The fact that Jaworowski gets his publication count up from Lyndon Larouche will weigh against it. Defray that criticism by showing that it was peer reviewed. If it wasn't peer reviewed, perhaps you should ask yourself why not, and assess it more critically. I certainly would.

Please follow these restrictions or take your nutter comments elsewhere. You have been politely asked.


Sure, but if AUP left, you'd be talking to yourself.​
 
Seriously? Jaworowski's credibility is an important issue. Publication in the peer reviewed literature imparts credibility. Publication in a LaRouche fanzine diminishes it.

Is it really argumentum ad hominem to that point out?

The way I see it, the quality of evidence can be evaluated, indirectly, by scrutiny of the source. If if comes from a peer reviewed article, one at least has the assurance that it was acceptable to other scientists. The journal in which it was published can also add or detract from the credibility of the research, as some attract better submissions and better reviewers than others. Presenting evidence that is peer reviewed would go a long way to preventing the criticisms that you want to avoid.

At the very least, if you are going to show a figure, say where it comes from. It matters. If Jaworowski's figure came from a peer reviewed publication, say where, and you will have a better chance of having it evaluated on its merits. No citation? The fact that Jaworowski gets his publication count up from Lyndon Larouche will weigh against it. Defray that criticism by showing that it was peer reviewed. If it wasn't peer reviewed, perhaps you should ask yourself why not, and assess it more critically. I certainly would.

What exactly are you talking about? Here is one of the several citations I mentioned. Is that insufficient? Or do you just want to continue the Larouche smear that AUP thought she would start (yet again). I provided sources for the data series.

Perhaps you should critically review your post, and review it against the peer reviewed published citations by Jaworowski, which I have cited one of which is relevant to the discussion.

Have some problem with the journal, Environmental Science and Pollution Research?

Zaworowski, Z., Ancient atmosphere - validity of ice records. Environ. Sci. & Pollut. Res., 1994. 1(3): p. 161-171.
 
From the first post in this thread-
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).
​
Fair enough.

At the activist site stopglobalwarming.org, there is a link to a video about GW from indie rock musician Eric Harvey and I hope to discuss every aspect with you in painstaking depth, as surely we skeptics can learn a great deal from a topic expert such as the esteemed Mr. Harvey. ;) Right?
 
Fair enough.

At the activist site stopglobalwarming.org, there is a link to a video about GW from indie rock musician Eric Harvey and I hope to discuss every aspect with you in painstaking depth, as surely we skeptics can learn a great deal from a topic expert such as the esteemed Mr. Harvey. ;) Right?

I'm sure you will appreciate that I started this thread specifically to have a debate about the merits of the scientific issues, including starting with the basic premises and looking at them critically, without the continual derailing and sidetracking by certain individuals with strong opinions.

That's all.

If you can win the argument that you choose using Mr. Harvey as your support, go for it. Do us all a big favor though and cite the minute and second mark in the video for the comments you reference.:)
 
What exactly are you talking about? Here is one of the several citations I mentioned. Is that insufficient? Or do you just want to continue the Larouche smear that AUP thought she would start (yet again). I provided sources for the data series.

Perhaps you should critically review your post, and review it against the peer reviewed published citations by Jaworowski, which I have cited one of which is relevant to the discussion.

Have some problem with the journal, Environmental Science and Pollution Research?

Zaworowski, Z., Ancient atmosphere - validity of ice records. Environ. Sci. & Pollut. Res., 1994. 1(3): p. 161-171.


Review your own posts. They are not sufficient.

Post #98. You write "Analysis of the problem by Jaworowski -...." But fail to provide a reference for said analysis.


Post #144. You provide two references, "for the purpose of refuting your Wikipedia assertions", as you put it. But you also show two figures. Are the references the sources for those two figures, or were you just making an argument by citation?

Rule 4, note 1 of the membership agreement:

The JREF has adopted a policy of considering all published material copyrighted, including articles, images and other media, it is not the responsibility of the JREF to determine whether or not the work is in the public domain or if the work may be republished without explicit permission of the copyright holder. Copyrighted content may be posted within the doctrine of "fair use" therefore quoting of brief portions of articles, books, emails, or bulletin board messages, relevant to discussion, is permitted. All quoted material should be credited to the original author or publisher and a link provided (when available) to the original work. It is not possible to declare precisely how much material may be quoted, as it will vary from article to article. We suggest quoting no more than a paragraph. Authors of copyrighted material may post their own work, provided they hold publishing rights to the material.


Cite your sources. It's a win-win. You get to stay within the membership agreement, and your readers will be better able to evaluate the evidence that you provide.
 
Soo, I interpret the above chart to say: the longer air stays frozen in ice, the lower the CO2 levels get.

Seems to me that chemical reactions are ongoing. It's a random universe. CO2 would combine with water and make some hydocarbons (or carbohydrates?). Which could then remain HCO's due to the coldness? But the CO2 could keep combining into HCO's. Thereby lowering the CO2 levels in the ice over time.

Of course, really deep ice core might be warmer than ice closer to the surface, being closer to the warm earth. This would allow more reverse activity, making for Higher CO2 levels in "Ice Age" cores...

Oh, casebro, now you've done it! Excellent post! It kick started the ganglia that I call a brain. Really, I had never considered this type of possible bias in those measurements. Perhaps I should read news reports as critically as I read publications and study reports (but by the time I get to the news, the ganglia are out for the night.)

You are absolutely correct. Carbon dioxide is one of the more active gases where water is concerned. Diffusion and absorption will occur in ice, albeit more slowly than at surface temperatures. The pressure of overlying ice would also tend to warm up the deeper ice horizons.

Does anyone have one of these studies they can share so that we can examine the sampling and bias-control steps taken?
 
Sure, but if AUP left, you'd be talking to yourself.

Seconded. As a fence-sitter (no, not a denier!! :mad:), I have learned a lot from the exchanges on this thread. I have to tip my hat to both mhaze and AUP for their mastery of this subject. Maybe this thread has run its course but I hate to see a good argument ruined by small but important details like attribution.

I don't agree that a mere presence on LaRouche's rags reflects negatively on the content of a publication. On the author, yes, but we're supposed to rise above such mundane cares. :rolleyes: Hell, if I wanted something I wrote to be widely read, I would submit it to Mad Magazine.
 
Oh, casebro, now you've done it! Excellent post! It kick started the ganglia that I call a brain. Really, I had never considered this type of possible bias in those measurements. Perhaps I should read news reports as critically as I read publications and study reports (but by the time I get to the news, the ganglia are out for the night.)

You are absolutely correct. Carbon dioxide is one of the more active gases where water is concerned. Diffusion and absorption will occur in ice, albeit more slowly than at surface temperatures. The pressure of overlying ice would also tend to warm up the deeper ice horizons.

Does anyone have one of these studies they can share so that we can examine the sampling and bias-control steps taken?


Critical thinking lives... kudos to you.

That's an excellent idea.
 
Seconded. As a fence-sitter (no, not a denier!! :mad:), I have learned a lot from the exchanges on this thread. I have to tip my hat to both mhaze and AUP for their mastery of this subject. Maybe this thread has run its course but I hate to see a good argument ruined by small but important details like attribution.

I don't agree that a mere presence on LaRouche's rags reflects negatively on the content of a publication. On the author, yes, but we're supposed to rise above such mundane cares. :rolleyes: Hell, if I wanted something I wrote to be widely read, I would submit it to Mad Magazine.

http://www.warwickhughes.com/icecore/
http://www.warwickhughes.com/icecore/zjmar07.pdf
http://folk.uio.no/tomvs/esef/esef0.htm
http://icecap.us/images/uploads/EE_18-2_Beck.pdf
 
Review your own posts. They are not sufficient.

Post #98. You write "Analysis of the problem by Jaworowski -...." But fail to provide a reference for said analysis.

Post #144. You provide two references, "for the purpose of refuting your Wikipedia assertions", as you put it. But you also show two figures. Are the references the sources for those two figures, or were you just making an argument by citation?

I disagree, but I am willing to have you explain where I may be unclear. You reference Post 144 - I assume you mean 114.

Chart on the left.

Already stated in this thread to be from Zaworowski in testimony to US Congress. Reference to peer reviewed literature with same material provided.

Chart on the right.

Previously several times posted on JREF and noted to be from Beck's website and published papers. Beck has been previously mentioned in this thread and everyone is familiar with the chart. The chart comes right up on the posted reference -
All of the CO2 series databases, modern and in the last century, are compiled and available to you at Beck's website. Here is the reference.
http://www.biokurs.de/treibhaus/180CO2_supp.htm
Why don't you load the appropriate series up in a spreadsheet and check it yourself?

​
Do you still have a problem? If so, what?
 
I disagree, but I am willing to have you explain where I may be unclear. You reference Post 144 - I assume you mean 114.
i8
Already stated in this thread to be from Zaworowski in testimony to US Congress. Reference to peer reviewed literature with same material provided.

Do you still have a problem? If so, what?

Oops, yes, 114. At least the link went to the right place.

Do you have a direct link to the Zaworowski quote?
 
Fair enough.

At the activist site stopglobalwarming.org, there is a link to a video about GW from indie rock musician Eric Harvey and I hope to discuss every aspect with you in painstaking depth, as surely we skeptics can learn a great deal from a topic expert such as the esteemed Mr. Harvey. ;) Right?


When are we going to start this exciting debate?

I've found my matching authoritative reference here.;)

http://glowarmers.blogspot.com/2007/09/11-ways-to-deal-with-glowarmers.html
 
Beck makes a lot of 3% accuracy of chemical methods, but that's a red herring. If you are measuring the wrong thing it doesn't matter how accurately you can measure.

A common ploy of Creationists back in the day was to radiocarbon-date the shells of living marine shell creatures. The date results they got back were typically many thousands of years. "Aha!", they would exclaim, "this living creature cannot be thousands of years old! this proves that radiodating is not accurate at all and cannot be trusted to show the earth is billions of years old!"

But actually the radiocarbon dating was accurate, it's just that they wee measuring the age of the carbon that made up the shell of the marine organisms, not the age of the organism itself. Regardless of the good accuracy of the method, they got the age wrong because they were measuring the wrong thing.

In a similar manner Beck is claiming chemical measuring methods accurate to 3%, but leaves out what they were measuring. co2 variates a lot at the surface, the surface is afterall the point where hundreds of billions of tons of co2 are being emitted and absorbed each year. Measurements taken in and around cities are subject to large variations in surface co2 that can be carried by the wind. co2 concentration can differ by location by as much as 100ppm. The measurements from decades ago which were performed in such locations cannot be claimed to be as accurate as if they were taken in lab conditions for this reason.

Beck's paper is all about the history of co2 measurements so it's odd that he misses out key developments in that history and doesn't mention about this long running difficulty in obtaining atmospheric co2 concentration.

He doesn't answer the obvious question: Why would Keeling expend so much effort to set up the first long term co2 monitoring station in remote Hawaii if he could have just monitored it accurately from somewhere more local? Keeling sought such a remote location precisely to avoid the contamination issues that plagued co2 measurements elsewhere.

Beck just graphs them all anyway and then quite amazingly he simply runs a line through every single datapoint. I guess he has to, he can hardly start smoothing trends if he wants to maintain the claim that each datapoint is within 3% (perhaps he even actually believes this is so)

Another good reason for Beck's reconstruction not being correct is that the record since Mauna Loa came online has shown co2 rising steady and smooth with less than 3ppm change from year to year, yet we are expected to believe that before the 60s co2 was jumping about year to year like crazy? As if it knew to start behaving once we started measuring it properly? In one case Beck's reconstruction has it jumping 80ppm and then falling again within a few years.

That raises another reason to doubt Beck's reconstruction. Current understanding of the carbon cycle can't explain how such rapid swings of that magnitude in atmospheric co2 could be possible. co2 in and out of the atmosphere is primarily regulated by some simple factors like temperature, and total plant coverage, neither of which could (or did) swing enough to explain such wild swings in co2.

The fact that the ice core records disagree is just the icing on the cake of reasons to believe the reconstruction is not correct. Addressing his citation of Jaworowski would make this post even longer. Suffice to say that Jaworowski arguing over the finer details of icecores is in a similar vein to creationists arguing over the finer points of radiodating. A lot of technical talk but that's the point - to confuse.

Beck's paper was published in "Energy and Environment". Remember the name of that journal, it comes up a lot. Whenever you hear of an AGW skeptic paper you can put money on it being published, or soon to be published in Energy and Environment. You will win the bet more often than not.
 
Slime and Pipirr have hit the nail on the head in 126 and 128, based on Casebro's comment.

That rings a bell.

There were lots of problems with the ice core dating methods and that supposedly these were recently - at least to some degree - ironed out. But the quilting of the Mauna Loa data to the modern (Keelings) data was done very early in the 1950s. Way before modern ice core handling methods. This is detailed to some extent in Beck's paper, along with interesting errors in the methods of Keeling and Calender, including odd ways that they pulled outliers from the data sets under consideration.

So, Oponol, you may be missing a good point while making another one. Beck's compilation is a resource, not an argument to be refuted. (At least as I see it). He has compiled all the historical studies, and has put the data sets in downloadable format, so that if there are questions about them, they can be answered. He has then written a paper about the findings.

I brought Beck up in the context of this discussion about Jaworowski as a resource of the historical data sets only.

To try then to summarize the question: Was the decision to offset the data by 83 years a valid one? Would it be done the same way today?

If so, then yes, you have a nice curve for Mauna Loa. If not, the variations in CO2 historically may not have been a nice curve at all.
 
Soo, I interpret the above chart to say: the longer air stays frozen in ice, the lower the CO2 levels get.

Where does the carbon go?

Seems to me that chemical reactions are ongoing.

And entropy keeps increasing.

It's a random universe.

Entropy is a stochastic phaenomenon. Which is to say, agreed, but lets not forget entropy. Because, be assured, it will not forget you.

CO2 would combine with water and make some hydocarbons (or carbohydrates?).

That would be swimming up the entropy stream. Life can do that, but it's a lot more complicated than ice-pack that's cold and way out of reach of the sun.

Which could then remain HCO's due to the coldness? But the CO2 could keep combining into HCO's. Thereby lowering the CO2 levels in the ice over time.

Hydrocarbons are volatile - unless you're talking tar - so they'd show up in the mass-spectrometer readings as hydrocarbons spikes. Which would draw attention. No such attention having been drawn, I think your thought-experiment has run out of legs.

Of course, really deep ice core might be warmer than ice closer to the surface, being closer to the warm earth. This would allow more reverse activity, making for Higher CO2 levels in "Ice Age" cores...

Heat-flux from Planet Earth's internal processes is miniscule, and ice is a good insulator. Heat-flux from the Sun - the stuff the surface gets - is immense. The only "of course" involved is that you're talking nonsense.

I only bring this up because Slimething found it thought-provoking. It's very clear that neither of you have even the vaguest understanding of physics.
 
From the first post in this thread-
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).
​
Please follow these restrictions or take your nutter comments elsewhere. You have been politely asked.

You can present science if you want, a person who would have LaRouche publish his work is not a scientist.
 
Seconded. As a fence-sitter (no, not a denier!! :mad:), I have learned a lot from the exchanges on this thread. I have to tip my hat to both mhaze and AUP for their mastery of this subject. Maybe this thread has run its course but I hate to see a good argument ruined by small but important details like attribution.

I don't agree that a mere presence on LaRouche's rags reflects negatively on the content of a publication. On the author, yes, but we're supposed to rise above such mundane cares. :rolleyes: Hell, if I wanted something I wrote to be widely read, I would submit it to Mad Magazine.

Mastery? You would have to refer to a scientist for that, and even then, the topic covers several fields of specialisation so that you really should be referring to several scientists for mastery. In fact, it would be good if several scientists who are specialists in their fields to put together a report that covers the whole span of the topic.

We've already prepared one before the show, and here it is. http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html.

That someone has to go to as looney a bunch of nutcases as LaRoche to get his work publised tells you a lot about the author, IMHO.

Similarly Hans Oeschger [2] states that "...Some of (Jaworowski's) statements are drastically wrong from the physical point of view".

A simple and easily understood reason is given for the need to move the dates, the air still mixes with the upper layers. We know that Mauna Loa is a valid reading, because it has been verified with the Cape Grimes site.

And Oponol says it better anyway.
 
Another good reason for Beck's reconstruction not being correct is that the record since Mauna Loa came online has shown co2 rising steady and smooth with less than 3ppm change from year to year, yet we are expected to believe that before the 60s co2 was jumping about year to year like crazy? As if it knew to start behaving once we started measuring it properly? In one case Beck's reconstruction has it jumping 80ppm and then falling again within a few years.

That raises another reason to doubt Beck's reconstruction. Current understanding of the carbon cycle can't explain how such rapid swings of that magnitude in atmospheric co2 could be possible. co2 in and out of the atmosphere is primarily regulated by some simple factors like temperature, and total plant coverage, neither of which could (or did) swing enough to explain such wild swings in co2.

The coup de grace.

Beck is a prime example of someone taking refuge in the past. Before we accurately measured what was going on, anything could have been going on :eek:! Massive CO2 fluxes, with not even the hint of a mechanism suggested, followed by quiescence entirely coincidental with the establishment of dependable monitoring? Not bloody likely.

The fact that the ice core records disagree is just the icing on the cake ...

Well yes, from a rational point of view, but from another they represent the past, and in the past anything could have been going on :eek:!

Suffice to say that Jaworowski arguing over the finer details of icecores is in a similar vein to creationists arguing over the finer points of radiodating.

When you think about it, the difference between "living" and "dead" is not a fine detail to creationists. It is to various worm species, but hey, what do they know? Or imagine?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom