mhaze
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2007
- Messages
- 15,718
The physics behind CO2 and the greenhouse effect is really extremely simple.
Like all gasses CO2 is transparent to most wavelengths and 'opaque' to only a small range of wavelengths.
When it's not transparent to a wavelength of light it absorps a photon which excites one of the atoms in the molecule, later this atom will collapse back into a lower shell and the molecule will reemit a photon but in a random direction.
The reason that CO2 is a greenhouse gas is that the wavelengths to which it is not transparent are in the infrared and infrared is more common in the light being radiated back into space than it is in light being radiated towards the earth.
Now let's do a simplified calculation about what this means:
We have an amount of CO2 in the air that absorps and reflects 5% of the light of the appropiate wavelengths (of this light, which is reemitted in a random direction 50% is send out into space and 50% to earth.)
Light in: Contains 5% of relevant wavelengths for absorption.
Light out: Contains 10% of relevant wavelengths for absorption
Light in: 50% of 5% of 5% is reflected back into space (0.125%): 99.875% goes to earth.
Light out: 50% of 5% of 10% is reflected back to earth: 0.250%, so the total of heat recevied is 100.125% of the actual sunlight.
Now we raise the amount of CO2 so 10% is absorped rather than 5%.
Light in: 50% of 10% of 5% is reflected back into space (0.25%): 99.75% to earth
Light out: 50% of 10% of 10% is reflected back to earth: 0.5%, so the total of heat received goes up to 100.25%
There's your causation.
The general physical basis you describe is sound. But the question is about showing an actual relationship, in the real world, where there are other factors at play in a dynamic and somewhat chaotic atmosphere.
That is, can you pick a range of years, and for that range of years, show that temperature tracks with CO2? That would be a correlation. A causative relationship would seem to be implied if there was a lag between the initial CO2 rise and the temperature rise. Or visa versa, if temperature rises caused CO2 increases.