Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

All of the CO2 series databases, modern and in the last century, are compiled and available to you at Beck's website. Here is the reference.

http://www.biokurs.de/treibhaus/180CO2_supp.htm

Why don't you load the appropriate series up in a spreadsheet and check it yourself?

Let us know what you find out.

The surface layer is snow in various forms, with air gaps between snowflakes. As snow continues to accumulate, the buried snow is compressed and forms firn, a grainy material with a texture similar to granulated sugar. Air gaps remain, and some circulation of air continues. As snow accumulates above, the firn continues to densify, and at some point the pores close off and the air is trapped. Because the air continues to circulate until then, the ice age and the age of the gas enclosed are not the same, and may differ by hundreds of years. The gas age–ice age difference is as great as 7 kyr in glacial ice from Vostok. [2]

From wikipedia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core

Tell that nutcase to RTFW.
 
Jaworowski, a nutcase? You're way over the edge with that.

Beck, a screwball with a website?

My my, let's not get agitated.

All I suggested was that you download the data sets, put them into excel and see if you agree with the "data quilting".

It's like giving a baby razor blades to play with. As the wiki link says, the gas content has to be adjusted because for the first several decades or so, it is still mixing with the atmosphere. I found that in about 60 seconds, this amateur can't even do that. He then accuses them of fraud because they have to do that adjustment.
 
It's like giving a baby razor blades to play with. As the wiki link says, the gas content has to be adjusted because for the first several decades or so, it is still mixing with the atmosphere. I found that in about 60 seconds, this amateur can't even do that. He then accuses them of fraud because they have to do that adjustment.

You've definitely hit upon a subject in which Wikipedia, written by amateurs often as not like yourself, is not going to work as an authoritative reference on the subject.

Want to try another again?
 
You've definitely hit upon a subject in which Wikipedia, written by amateurs often as not like yourself, is not going to work as an authoritative reference on the subject.

Want to try another again?

Try what? Using your logic, Your source is some anonymous hacker on a web page, with no credibility, not even worth considering.

Why did I bother?
 
Try what? Using your logic, Your source is some anonymous hacker on a web page, with no credibility, not even worth considering.

That kind of talk doesn't help. Jaworowski and Beck are both noted, published scientists.
 
That kind of talk doesn't help. Jaworowski and Beck are both noted, published scientists.

Beck is a biologist. It's like asking a brain surgeon a question about a triple bypass. He jumps to accusations of fraud when the reason the data is shifted is obvious and available even on a site like Wikipedia. That 'paper' is only published on a web page.
 
Beck is just where I suggested you go to get the data files to proof the matter. Beck does not jump to accusations of fraud, apparently you are in error there. Beck does not have papers only published on a web page, again, either that is an error or made up.

Jaworowski discussed this problem and used this chart in a presentation to US Congress. The use of words like "nutcase" and "screwball" by you are out of line. You have said you are a rank amateur, and you are clearly showing not only the limits of your understanding, but quite an attitude.

Data sets are clearly indicated in the block at the base of the chart. Additional information is available.

What exactly is going on, does the chart upset you? If so, why?

To me it is just some numbers from scientific instruments and some data quilting to get a nice curve. Go ahead, take the data sets from Beck's archives and build an Excel model and check it out.

Let us know what you find out. Why get all emotional about it?
 
Beck is just where I suggested you go to get the data files to proof the matter. Beck does not jump to accusations of fraud, apparently you are in error there. Beck does not have papers only published on a web page, again, either that is an error or made up.

Jaworowski discussed this problem and used this chart in a presentation to US Congress. The use of words like "nutcase" and "screwball" by you are out of line. You have said you are a rank amateur, and you are clearly showing not only the limits of your understanding, but quite an attitude.

Data sets are clearly indicated in the block at the base of the chart. Additional information is available.

What exactly is going on, does the chart upset you? If so, why?

To me it is just some numbers from scientific instruments and some data quilting to get a nice curve. Go ahead, take the data sets from Beck's archives and build an Excel model and check it out.

Let us know what you find out. Why get all emotional about it?

It's like a nightmare fighting off the zombies. No matter how many mindless oafs you fight off and bludgeon, there's always another one after you. What's the point?

The chart doesn't upset me, it's 'raw' data that has to be adjusted for the reasons stated on wikipedia article, that make perfect sense. The scientists doing the analysis of the cores aren't complete idiots, or frauds.
 
It's like a nightmare fighting off the zombies. No matter how many mindless oafs you fight off and bludgeon, there's always another one after you. What's the point?

The chart doesn't upset me, it's 'raw' data that has to be adjusted for the reasons stated on wikipedia article, that make perfect sense. The scientists doing the analysis of the cores aren't complete idiots, or frauds.

I don't see any nightmares or zombies.
 


Then again, perhaps the reason you got so upset was that these facts on the data quilting of Mauna Loa contradict your assertions made shortly ago in the Global Warming thread. Your own words -
1268 - Have you got your beer goggles on? If you look at the ice core samples, leading directly onto the Mauna Loa, the curve is a perfect trend.

1275 - The CO2 measuring jumps all over the place, until we start measuring it at Mauna Loa. Then all of a sudden, it doesn't jump all over the place.

1276 - One of the attractions of Mauna Lao is that it provides a "well mixed" consistent reading. The dove-tail from ice core to Mauna Loa shows the match up and consistency between the two.
​
Perhaps you just have a problem with being wrong every now and then? Then you react by going into a childish rampage. Your nice dove-tail from ice core to Mauna Loa is actually the result of some nice data quilting.

Next we need to consider the implications this has for the probable amount of CO2 in the atmosphere in the last two centuries.

By, the way, these references refute your Wikipedia assertions. But then you would not care about actual science, would you?
Zaworowski, Z., Ancient atmosphere - validity of ice records. Environ. Sci. & Pollut. Res., 1994. 1(3): p. 161-171.

Schwander, J., et al., The age of the air in the firn and the ice at Summit, Greenland. J. Geophys. Res., 1993. 98(D2): p. 2831-2838.​
 
The internet zombies, faceless, unheard of, infected with doubt, but devoid of any brains. You can wack em down with a fly swatter, and another one gets up to take their place.

How does one know if a given internet junkie is an internet zombie of the dangerous sort?
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1422447013a2077a34.pnghttp://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1422446f05b27a581d.png

Then again, perhaps the reason you got so upset was that these facts on the data quilting of Mauna Loa contradict your assertions made shortly ago in the Global Warming thread. Your own words -
1268 - Have you got your beer goggles on? If you look at the ice core samples, leading directly onto the Mauna Loa, the curve is a perfect trend.

1275 - The CO2 measuring jumps all over the place, until we start measuring it at Mauna Loa. Then all of a sudden, it doesn't jump all over the place.

1276 - One of the attractions of Mauna Lao is that it provides a "well mixed" consistent reading. The dove-tail from ice core to Mauna Loa shows the match up and consistency between the two.
​
Perhaps you just have a problem with being wrong every now and then? Then you react by going into a childish rampage. Your nice dove-tail from ice core to Mauna Loa is actually the result of some nice data quilting.

Next we need to consider the implications this has for the probable amount of CO2 in the atmosphere in the last two centuries.

By, the way, these references refute your Wikipedia assertions. But then you would not care about actual science, would you?
Zaworowski, Z., Ancient atmosphere - validity of ice records. Environ. Sci. & Pollut. Res., 1994. 1(3): p. 161-171.

Schwander, J., et al., The age of the air in the firn and the ice at Summit, Greenland. J. Geophys. Res., 1993. 98(D2): p. 2831-2838.​

You presented nothing. The air at the surface mixes in with the upper level of the ice core. So the ice core is always going to be several decades out of sync. I don't know what you think Scwander is saying in his paper. Perhaps if you explained what you mean :confused:.

Jaworoski is just another nutter. His paper is patent nonsense. That CO2 could jump around like a mexican bean for a few decades, then follow a very smooth curve for the next, is lunacy. The matter has already been discussed to death. Any discomfort on my part is merely the nightmare of having to kill the zombie again, when I know it's only going to rise up, as dumb and dead as ever.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zbigniew_Jaworowski



Can anything else say "nutter" so simply and decidedly? Any self respecting scientist would rather be dead than be associated with such distasteful group as the LaRouches.

From the first post in this thread-
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).
​
Please follow these restrictions or take your nutter comments elsewhere. You have been politely asked.
 
Soo, I interpret the above chart to say: the longer air stays frozen in ice, the lower the CO2 levels get.

Seems to me that chemical reactions are ongoing. It's a random universe. CO2 would combine with water and make some hydocarbons (or carbohydrates?). Which could then remain HCO's due to the coldness? But the CO2 could keep combining into HCO's. Thereby lowering the CO2 levels in the ice over time.

Of course, really deep ice core might be warmer than ice closer to the surface, being closer to the warm earth. This would allow more reverse activity, making for Higher CO2 levels in "Ice Age" cores...
 
Soo, I interpret the above chart to say: the longer air stays frozen in ice, the lower the CO2 levels get.

Seems to me that chemical reactions are ongoing. It's a random universe. CO2 would combine with water and make some hydocarbons (or carbohydrates?). Which could then remain HCO's due to the coldness? But the CO2 could keep combining into HCO's. Thereby lowering the CO2 levels in the ice over time.

Of course, really deep ice core might be warmer than ice closer to the surface, being closer to the warm earth. This would allow more reverse activity, making for Higher CO2 levels in "Ice Age" cores...

Thank you for dispelling any doubts that could linger...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom