Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

mhaze

Banned
Joined
Jan 10, 2007
Messages
15,718
This is a thread on the scientific issues of global warming.

NO religion, Exxon, politics, Kyoto. Economics acceptable. No extemporaneous "proofs" (eg "it's been terribly rainy here it must be AGW"). Links and references will be summarized periodicially and posted.

No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).

For starters here is the short list of "unanswered questions", but by no means is this intended to limit scope.

Unanswered Questions and Challenges
1. A challenge for AGW believers to cite a scientific atmospheric study that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2 in the atmosphere.

2. This is a link to a summary of Singer's theory of the 1,500 year climate cycle, excerpted from his book. Debunk Singer's core theory, of the 1,500 year climate cycle.

3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?
​
 
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).

I hope you understand what an ad hominem fallacy actually is, otherwise this wish will likely not come true...
 
Why would you allow economics? Maybe because that's the real basis for the anti-AGW position, and it has very little basis in science?
 
Rockoon's Challenge to Environmentalists from 2004

4. A challenge for environmentalists

If you feel it is so easy for humans to cause global warming I want you to put together a PLAN that is implimentable by humans which will raise the global mean temperature by 10 degrees celcius by the year 2050. Since the view of environmentalists is that the climate is fragile and easily manipulated as an unintended side effect of human activities, then it is reasonable to assume that it should be easy to come up with an intentional method of doing so.

I propose these constraints, but feel free to break them if you really have to:

  • Todays technology.
  • Uses only atmospheric emissions of atoms and molecules.
  • By the year 2050.
  • Costs less than $20,000,000,000,000 dollars (US currency).
One thing to note is that you can't get, for example, CO2 from an infinite magic box. You have to account for where it comes from.

I await your plans.
 
Why would you allow economics? Maybe because that's the real basis for the anti-AGW position, and it has very little basis in science?

Economics is not relevant to whether or not global warming is occuring, the degree to which it is and will occur, and what is causing it. But it is absolutely central to the argument of what to do about any of it. And frankly, many climate scientists are poorly positioned to figure that out.
 
If people really want to discuss the economics, why not start this thread in politics or one of the other subforums? You can get a really good discussion going over there.

Not that it would be easy, if Kyoto can't be mentioned.
 
Taffer said:
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).

I hope you understand what an ad hominem fallacy actually is, otherwise this wish will likely not come true...


Rule 12 would only apply if the principal scientist was actually participating, in person, in this thread.

And what Taffer said.
 
If people really want to discuss the economics, why not start this thread in politics or one of the other subforums? You can get a really good discussion going over there.

Not that it would be easy, if Kyoto can't be mentioned.

I was on the verge of leaving it out, but tend to look at things from an engineering rather than a "pure science perspective". Issues of cost always enter into engineering solutions, at least as a one factor.

But right, I am not trying to encourage economics, agree with you other forums are more suitable for it, and have not found hardly any on "science and technology" very conversant about it.
 
Well, after I watched Al Gore's movie, my Buddhist friend in Kyoto, who was recently laid off from Exxon, sent me this link.

Warming of the climate system is unequivocal.
Most of (>50% of) the observed increase in globally averaged temperatures since the mid-20th century is very likely (confidence level >90%) due to the observed increase in anthropogenic (human) greenhouse gas concentrations.
Hotter temperatures and rises in sea level "would continue for centuries" even if greenhouse gas levels are stabilized[16], although the likely amount of temperature and sea level rise varies greatly depending on the fossil intensity of human activity during the next century (pages 13 and 18)[12].
The probability that this is caused by natural climatic processes alone is less than 5%.
World temperatures could rise by between 1.1 and 6.4 °C (2.0 and 11.5 °F) during the 21st century (table 3) and that:
Sea levels will probably rise by 18 to 59 cm (7.08 to 23.22 in) [table 3].
There is a confidence level >90% that there will be more frequent warm spells, heat waves and heavy rainfall.
There is a confidence level >66% that there will be an increase in droughts, tropical cyclones and extreme high tides.
Both past and future anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions will continue to contribute to warming and sea level rise for more than a millennium.
Global atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide have increased markedly as a result of human activities since 1750 and now far exceed pre-industrial values over the past 650,000 years
 
Good challenges. I'm not convinced about AGW one way or the other but I get very nervous when politicians and greenies want to take drastic action on the basis of nothing more than suspcion and theory. I especially liked your fourth challenge based on feasibility. Another thing that scares me that gets scant discussion is, if the environment is so fragile, what if AGW does not exist and we screw up something we had overlooked previously?

I've seen the same type of scare tactics used by some AGW promoters (not all) in the medical field. When CAT scanners were introduced, anomalous readings occured at sites where the machinery had been installed and many patients were misdiagnosed with cancer. This "surge" in cancer findings was immediately taken up by greenies and used as proof that environmental pollution was finally going to kill us all dead. Once experience increased in the interpretation of the new technology, misdiagnoses decreased dramatically.

So, is AGW the same thing? Sure hope so. If not, it's scary stuff.
 
Good challenges. I'm not convinced about AGW one way or the other but I get very nervous when politicians and greenies want to take drastic action on the basis of nothing more than suspcion and theory. I especially liked your fourth challenge based on feasibility. Another thing that scares me that gets scant discussion is, if the environment is so fragile, what if AGW does not exist and we screw up something we had overlooked previously?

The evidence is already well and truly rolling in.

http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/content/2007/s2042732.htm

DANIEL HOARE: Scientists have long concluded that hotter, drier temperatures are the result of El Nino, a weather pattern that's usually followed by the high rainfall conditions of La Nina.

But this new Australian study, which is the first of its kind to closely examine a 30-year weather period in the South Pacific, has found that their previous conclusions might not be accurate.

One of the report's authors, Scott Power, from the Bureau of Meteorology, says the changes in Australia's climate could be due to permanent changes in the Walker circulation, which is the atmospheric wind system that sits above Australia.

SCOTT POWER: Changes in the Walker circulation are strongly linked to changes in rainfall and other things around the world. So, for example in Australia, when the Walker circulation weakens, rainfall tends to decrease over much of Australia, over northern and eastern Australia.

DANIEL HOARE: The Bureau of Meteorology's Scott Power says the research points strongly to permanent and ongoing changes in Australia's climate.

SCOTT POWER: The weakening of the Walker circulation and the reduction in rainfall in parts of southern Australia may have a common cause, and that cause may be global warming.

DANIEL HOARE: Is this definitive proof of global warming, or is it yet more evidence that could point to it being global warming?

SCOTT POWER: Ah, no, it's not definitive proof that it's global warming but it is another straw on the camel's back, if you like.

DANIEL HOARE: So what does all of this add up to for our region?

SCOTT POWER: I think this gives us a little bit more information on what is actually happening. I mean, we're starting to see record changes in things that weren't necessarily anticipated. You know, with global warming you would've expected increased temperatures, and if this is global warming, it's starting to reveal things that may not have been completely expected.

DANIEL HOARE: The researchers examined changes in 30-year averages in sea surface temperature, air pressure and wind patterns.

The CSIRO's Ian Smith says the research provides further evidence of permanent changes to Australia's climate.

IAN SMITH: There's no doubt that the climate over the past 30 years is different, very much different to what it was previously, so that …

DANIEL HOARE: In what ways?

IAN SMITH: Well, it's, firstly it's warmer. There's no doubt that the globe's getting warmer, Australia's getting warmer, and in fact parts of Australia we can see quite significant trends in rainfall. We suspect that may all be part of the global warming pattern that's expected to become more and more apparent as we head into the 21st century. So we need to factor these long-term changes into any predictions we'll make on the shorter time scales, such as seasonal predictions.



I've seen the same type of scare tactics used by some AGW promoters (not all) in the medical field. When CAT scanners were introduced, anomalous readings occured at sites where the machinery had been installed and many patients were misdiagnosed with cancer. This "surge" in cancer findings was immediately taken up by greenies and used as proof that environmental pollution was finally going to kill us all dead. Once experience increased in the interpretation of the new technology, misdiagnoses decreased dramatically.

So, is AGW the same thing? Sure hope so. If not, it's scary stuff.[/quote]


It's not. The cost of doing something is high, but the cost of doing nothing is already costing us a lot of money, too.
 
This is a thread on the scientific issues of global warming.

NO religion, Exxon, politics, Kyoto. Economics acceptable. No extemporaneous "proofs" (eg "it's been terribly rainy here it must be AGW"). Links and references will be summarized periodicially and posted.

No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).

For starters here is the short list of "unanswered questions", but by no means is this intended to limit scope.

Unanswered Questions and Challenges
1. A challenge for AGW believers to cite a scientific atmospheric study that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2 in the atmosphere.

2. This is a link to a summary of Singer's theory of the 1,500 year climate cycle, excerpted from his book. Debunk Singer's core theory, of the 1,500 year climate cycle.

3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?
​

Have you read the 4AR yet? http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html
 
Economics is not relevant to whether or not global warming is occuring, the degree to which it is and will occur, and what is causing it. But it is absolutely central to the argument of what to do about any of it. And frankly, many climate scientists are poorly positioned to figure that out.

And it appears just about all the deniers are very poorly positioned to figure out the science.
 
<snip>
.
.
3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?

The physics behind CO2 and the greenhouse effect is really extremely simple.

Like all gasses CO2 is transparent to most wavelengths and 'opaque' to only a small range of wavelengths.

When it's not transparent to a wavelength of light it absorps a photon which excites one of the atoms in the molecule, later this atom will collapse back into a lower shell and the molecule will reemit a photon but in a random direction.

The reason that CO2 is a greenhouse gas is that the wavelengths to which it is not transparent are in the infrared and infrared is more common in the light being radiated back into space than it is in light being radiated towards the earth.

Now let's do a simplified calculation about what this means:

We have an amount of CO2 in the air that absorps and reflects 5% of the light of the appropiate wavelengths (of this light, which is reemitted in a random direction 50% is send out into space and 50% to earth.)
Light in: Contains 5% of relevant wavelengths for absorption.
Light out: Contains 10% of relevant wavelengths for absorption

Light in: 50% of 5% of 5% is reflected back into space (0.125%): 99.875% goes to earth.
Light out: 50% of 5% of 10% is reflected back to earth: 0.250%, so the total of heat recevied is 100.125% of the actual sunlight.

Now we raise the amount of CO2 so 10% is absorped rather than 5%.
Light in: 50% of 10% of 5% is reflected back into space (0.25%): 99.75% to earth
Light out: 50% of 10% of 10% is reflected back to earth: 0.5%, so the total of heat received goes up to 100.25%

There's your causation.
 
Economics is not relevant to whether or not global warming is occuring, the degree to which it is and will occur, and what is causing it. But it is absolutely central to the argument of what to do about any of it. And frankly, many climate scientists are poorly positioned to figure that out.

You mean that very good climate scientists might not be qualified to suggest how the bank account of the world should be managed? Uhh...is it obvious that very good climate scientists can even manage their own bank account?
 
AUP, please it chapter and page references if you wish to invoke IPCC. Be sensible, it is a long document.

I would have thought that if you are going to say that they haven't presented you with evidence, that would look at the evidence first. And I am talking here about a report on the accumulated knowledge of many scientists and reseach papers. That's what scepticism is about, the evidence. If you aren't going to read it, then you can't really criticise it.
 
Feb 2007 IPCC Radiative Forcing Calculation Errors

Taking a look at the chart from the IPCC Summary for Policymakers, Feb 2007, revision 2, page 4, Radiative Forcing.

For "Cloud albedo effect" we have ...
RF in W m2 -0.7 (-1.8 to -0.3) LOSU - Level of Uncertainty "LOW".

The bottom line,
Radiative forcing, Total Net Anthropogenic is +1.6(0.6 to 2.4).

Wentz 2007 "How Much More Rain will Global Warming Bring?" has shown the water put in the atmosphere to be triple what was presumed by the studies used by the IPCC in assembling the chart.

Let us revise the summary for Radiative forcing to include Wentz's correction - one presumption - (mine) that a tripling of water for a given temperature increment causes a proportional tripling of cloud cover.

RF in W m2 -2.1 (-5.4 to -0.9) with a LOSU of (perhaps now Medium),

New bottom line ...
Total net anthropogenic -1.2 (-6.6 to + 1.2)

Does it look like there is still anthropogenic global warming?

So using the IPCC's own method, and more recent science for the water cycle, there would appear to be no net positive feedbacks, but net negative feedbacks. There do not appear to be any negative effects caused by man on the climate.



 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom