Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

That publication is not research-grade. It seems to be part of a squabble. Didn't read it but noted that two of the scenarios deviated signficantly from observations while one seemed to track pretty well.

Nice publication. As you can see in the Executive Summary, long-term forecasting is still a work in progress. Didn't look at much else as this is a long, long chapter in the IPCC report.

Nice publication, indeed. I've admired the graphic arts work.

Forecasting based on incorrect assumptions can be tuned to hindcast correctly, but futurecasting will dismally fail. 2007 seems to be a year in which there is significantly new areas of understanding. Here is a study by Ramanathan. For those not familiar with this scientist, the IPCC's own number of 4 watts/sq meter for greenhouse effects is from his work. Thus for AGW Believers, the sequence of scientists studying the greenhouse effect was Arrhenius - Callender - Plass - Ramanathan.

Was the 1940-1970 "cooling period" caused by aerosols, and the cessation of that cooling period due to our pollution legislation getting them under control? No. Here is the proof. In turn that supports the theory that the 1940-1970 cool period was part of a natural 60-80 year climate cycle.

[FONT=arial, helvetica, sans serif][FONT=arial, helvetica, sans serif]New data contradicts aerosol cooling hypothesis (full downloadable pdf!):[/FONT][/FONT]

[FONT=arial, helvetica, sans serif][FONT=arial, helvetica, sans serif]Ramanathan 2007: Atmospheric aerosols compete with carbon dioxide as an agent of warming.

[/FONT]
[/FONT] [FONT=arial, helvetica, sans serif][FONT=arial, helvetica, sans serif]... As much as half of the recent warming trend attributed to CO2 and other greenhouse gases is thought to have been cancelled out by cooling from aerosols. But new observations show that in some regions black carbon is as culpable as CO2 for the warming, and in some cases, has a greater effect.

[/FONT]
[/FONT]What is the effect of Ramanathan's findings on the IPCC Radiative Forcing Chart? Yet another category of Radiative Forcings is completely wrong.
(Findings are supported by Hansen 2000).
 
No, it does not merit attention. As illustrated in post #19 above, both new scientific findings, and findings that were ignored in the production of that tome, invalidate conclusions reached that were specious even when they were asserted.

No reason to bother "reading the IPCC report". And suggesting that one do so (without any specific chapter or page citation) appears to be your most convenient answer to any logical, technical or factual issue encountered.

I have a friend who is a scientist who is actively researching this area. When I ask him questions, he is happy to answer them, but if I want more information than you can get in a conversation, he directs me to the IPCC reports. It's the obvious answer, there is the accumulation of all the research that has been conducted. It's the first port of call for any questions. If you have questions in depth, and haven't read the report, then there isn't any way to help you, really.

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html

These are the chapters

Historical Overview of Climate Change Science
Changes in Atmospheric Constituents and in Radiative Forcing
Observations: Surface and Atmospheric Climate Change
Observations: Changes in Snow, Ice and Frozen Ground
Observations: Oceanic Climate Change and Sea Level
Palaeoclimate
Couplings Between Changes in the Climate System
and Biogeochemistry
Climate Models and their Evaluation
Understanding and Attributing Climate Change
Global Climate Projections
[FONT=&quot] Regional Climate Projections

I have spent a fair bit of time with the TAR, so the 4ar is still new to me. But the information is comprehensive. If you choose to not read it, when it is the basis of the claims, on a very serious subject, then I don't know what to say to you.
[/FONT]
 
Serious Flaws in Models Says Hansen Himself

http://pubs.giss.nasa.gov/abstracts/inpress/Hansen_etal_1.html
Principal model deficiencies include unrealistically weak tropical El Nino-like variability and a poor distribution of sea ice, with too much sea ice in the Northern Hemisphere and too little in the Southern Hemisphere. Greatest uncertainties in the forcings are the temporal and spatial variations of anthropogenic aerosols and their indirect effects on clouds.
​
More Principal Model Deficiencies
ModelE [2006] compares the atmospheric model climatology with observations. Model shortcomings include ~25% regional deficiency of summer stratus cloud cover off the west coast of the continents with resulting excessive absorption of solar radiation by as much as 50 W/m2, deficiency in absorbed solar radiation and net radiation over other tropical regions by typically 20 W/m2, sea level pressure too high by 4-8 hPa in the winter in the Arctic and 2-4 hPa too low in all seasons in the tropics, ~20% deficiency of rainfall over the Amazon basin, ~25% deficiency in summer cloud cover in the western United States and central Asia with a corresponding ~5°C excessive summer warmth in these regions. In addition to the inaccuracies in the simulated climatology, another shortcoming of the atmospheric model for climate change studies is the absence of a gravity wave representation, as noted above, which may affect the nature of interactions between the troposphere and stratosphere. The stratospheric variability is less than observed, as shown by analysis of the present 20-layer 4°x5° atmospheric model by J. Perlwitz [personal communication]. In a 50-year control run Perlwitz finds that the interannual variability of seasonal mean temperature in the stratosphere maximizes in the region of the subpolar jet streams at realistic values, but the model produces only six sudden stratospheric warmings (SSWs) in 50 years, compared with about one every two years in the real world. ...

​
Climate simulations for 1880-2003 with GISS modelE -- Hansen et al. 2007, in press.
 
No rebuttals to a scientific or logical argument by ad hominem attack on the principal scientists or individuals linked to or principal to the discussion. Attack the argument, not the arguer (Rule 12).
OK then. Is it fair to assume that you will read and consider on merit alone articles published by EnvironmentalDefense.org, Friends of the Earth and the like? ;) I hear Greenpeace has a 299 page report that explains everything you want to know about A/GW and then some.

There's charts and graphs! And even though the writer isn't a climatologist, or even a scientist, he did take some science classes in college. No prob, right?
 
Economics is not relevant to whether or not global warming is occuring, the degree to which it is and will occur, and what is causing it. But it is absolutely central to the argument of what to do about any of it.

That would be a policy matter, so take it to Politics.

And frankly, many climate scientists are poorly positioned to figure that out.

They're even less well-positioned to implement policies. That's what governments do. Take it to Politics.
 
Good challenges. I'm not convinced about AGW one way or the other but I get very nervous when politicians ...

If it's not science, please take it to Politics. It's not just that this is the Science forum, but look at the thread title and show some respect. mhaze is trying to do science here. Don't distract him. Science is hard.
 
We don't need a third thread on global warming ...

Tell me about it ... :rolleyes:

... so I won't partake in this one, except to say that I'm dead tired of strawmen from both sides.

I'm tired of thread-sprouting by contrarians.

mhaze is no more interested in the science on this thread than he is on any other. He's just not having a terribly good time on the others. And is increasingly alone.

So I too will partake no more.
 
http://www.livescience.com/environment/070504_new_particles.html

This is definitely weird, but it is one more thing that's not in the climate models.
Recent satellite observations have found a zone of “in-between particles” in the air around clouds that was previously considered clear. Scientists have been aware of an indistinct “halo” surrounding individual clouds, but the newly detected zone is much more extensive, taking up as much as 60 percent of the atmosphere previously labeled as cloud-free.

The previously unknown ingredient in the atmospheric mixture of particles will have to be factored into models that try to predict how the atmosphere influences the change of global temperatures.

“The effects of this zone are not included in most computer models that estimate the impact of aerosols on climate,” said lead author Ilan Koren of the Weizmann Institute of Science, in Israel. “This could be one of the reasons why current measurements of this effect don’t match our model estimates.”
​
The study was published in the April 18 issue of the journal Geophysical Research Letters.
 
OK then. Is it fair to assume that you will read and consider on merit alone articles published by EnvironmentalDefense.org, Friends of the Earth and the like? ;) I hear Greenpeace has a 299 page report that explains everything you want to know about A/GW and then some.

There's charts and graphs! And even though the writer isn't a climatologist, or even a scientist, he did take some science classes in college. No prob, right?

Clue me in a bit: Is there some radical fringe AGW Alarmist concept promoted by EnvironDef, Friends, or Greenpeace that has not been promoted on JREF?

I doubt it.
 
I posted this on another forum a while back, and I wanted to know what people thought of this point:

Bjarne Andresen says, an expert of thermodynamics. "A temperature can be defined only for a homogeneous system. Furthermore, the climate is not governed by a single temperature. Rather, differences of temperatures drive the processes and create the storms, sea currents, thunder, etc. which make up the climate.” He explains that while it is possible to treat temperature statistically locally, it is meaningless to talk about a global temperature for Earth. The Globe consists of a huge number of components which one cannot just add up and average. That would correspond to calculating the average phone number in the phone book."
 
I posted this on another forum a while back, and I wanted to know what people thought of this point:

He's wrong, quite simply. It is a sample of the temperatures, that gives us a nomial temperature to measure any changes against. It is a chaotic system, but if the temperature was high enough to make the seas boil, would someone say, "We can't tell if the earth is hotter, because it is a chaotic system".

If you jack up the overall temperature of the planet by some means, the sampled temperatures, at various sites, in the chaotic system, would rise overall. It's just a case of sophistry that is being presented.

This point of view from realclimate

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/03/does-a-global-temperature-exist/

Does a global temperature exist? This is the question asked in a recently published article in Journal of Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics by Christopher Essex, Ross McKitrick, and Bjarne Andresen. The paper argues that the global mean temperature is not physical, and that there may be many other ways of computing a mean which will give different trends.
The common arithmetic mean is just an estimate that provides a measure of the centre value of a batch of measurements (centre of a cloud of data points, and can be written more formally as the integral of x f(x) dx. The whole paper is irrelevant in the context of a climate change because it missed a very central point. CO2 affects all surface temperatures on Earth, and in order to improve the signal-to-noise ratio, an ordinary arithmetic mean will enhance the common signal in all the measurements and suppress the internal variations which are spatially incoherent (e.g. not caused by CO2 or other external forcings). Thus the choice may not need a physical justification, but is part of a scientific test which enables us to get a clearer 'yes' or 'no'. One could choose to look at the global mean sea level instead, which does have a physical meaning because it represents an estimate for the volume of the water in the oceans, but the choice is not crucial as long as the indicator used really responds to the conditions under investigation. And the global mean temperature is indeed a function of the temperature over the whole planetary surface.

Is this paper a joke then? It is old and traditional knowledge that the temperature measurements made in meteorological and climatological studies are supposed to be representative of a certain volume of air, i.e. the arithmetic mean. Essex et al. argue that it is not really physical, but surely the temperature measurements do have clear practical implications? Temperature itself can be inferred directly from several physical laws, such as the ideal gas law, first law of thermodynamics and the Stefan-Boltzmann law, so it's not the temperature itself which is 'unphysical'. Even though the final temperature of two bodies in contact may not be the arithmetic mean, it will still be a weighted arithmetic mean of the temperatures of the two initial temperatures if no heat is lost to the surroundings. Besides, grid-box sizes for numerical weather models often have a minimum spatial scale of 10-20km, and the temperature may be regarded as a mean for this scale. Numerical weather models usually provide useful forecasts.
And what distinguishes the mean temperature representing a small volume to a larger one? Or do Essex et al. think the limit is at greater scales. For instance at the synoptic spatial scale (~1000 km)? The funny thing then is that the concept of regional mean temperature would also not be meaningful according to Essex et al. And one may also wonder if the problem of computing a mean temperature is meaningful in time, such as the summer-mean temperature or winter-mean temperature?

According to the those who say there is no global mean, their should also not be a regional mean. Yet we get weather forecasts for regions every day, and people know exactly what they mean. It's hotter in summer than in winter.
 
4. A challenge for environmentalists

If you feel it is so easy for humans to cause global warming I want you to put together a PLAN that is implimentable by humans which will raise the global mean temperature by 10 degrees celcius by the year 2050. Since the view of environmentalists is that the climate is fragile and easily manipulated as an unintended side effect of human activities, then it is reasonable to assume that it should be easy to come up with an intentional method of doing so.

I propose these constraints, but feel free to break them if you really have to:

  • Todays technology.
  • Uses only atmospheric emissions of atoms and molecules.
  • By the year 2050.
  • Costs less than $20,000,000,000,000 dollars (US currency).
One thing to note is that you can't get, for example, CO2 from an infinite magic box. You have to account for where it comes from.

I await your plans.

There are various attack lines. First you would be looking at setting fire to underground coal meaures. Cheap and gets you a fair amount of CO2 over the 43 years.

After that. Well takeing bulk production savings into account you could probably paint 1% of earths land area black (with of the self prices you are looking at closer to 0.7%) which would have an interesting effect.

That assumes 8 square meters per liter and an of the shelf price of 13.8$ per liter.


Next up we have sulfur hexafluoride. At 20$ per pound you could afford 45359237000kg for the amount mentioned. Over 43 years that would be the equiv of over 680,000,000,000 tonnes of CO2.

Oh another thing to try is nukeing certian bits of permafrost in an attempt to release methane. Something simular might work with some volcanos.
 
Last edited:
He's wrong, quite simply. It is a sample of the temperatures, that gives us a nomial temperature to measure any changes against. It is a chaotic system, but if the temperature was high enough to make the seas boil, would someone say, "We can't tell if the earth is hotter, because it is a chaotic system".

I never thought of myself as a physical chemist but I guess I'm turning into one in my dotage. AUP, the statement that there is no adequate method for adjudging the temperature of the Earth at the moment is correct. You suggest a statistical treatment of various measurements around the planet and that would work if the method were standardized. That would solve a great many problems and it would make it a lot easier to not only devise models but also to validate them. At this point in time, we basically have to wait until temperature values at a particularly vulnerable part of the planet accumulates enough history (datapoints) that we can tell whether or not a prediction was correct within a desired confidence level. This type of verification would be almost instantaneous if there were an accurate method of assessing a standard temperature for the planet.

I alluded earlier that there are ways but they are very new and would not fit in well with old measurements. A device far enough in space to measure the black-body radiation of the planet would give us a good indication of the net temperature of the Earth. I suspect that a far-orbit satellite could probably do this if equipped with a good IR spectrophotometer and a standardized method of where to sample each and every time it made a measurement. Statistical data manipulation of those data would be better performed here on the ground. Maybe this is already being done but I haven't read about it.

So, for now, we watch and wait. I agree that it's high time to become a lot more concerned about despoiling our environment. This is true whether or not AGW turns out to be true or not. If you think about the issue in its entirety, the only thing that will allow us to manage the problem, if it can be managed, is hard data and accurate predictions therefrom.

If you jack up the overall temperature of the planet by some means, the sampled temperatures, at various sites, in the chaotic system, would rise overall.

That's very true but, tell me, how would you know it was happening due to increased temperature if you can't measure it? Unusual activity in any terrestrial system could have a very different cause.


Nice article but I can't agree with it. Their reasoning is circular. If someone devised a method of measureing the planet's mean measurement tomorrow, the world would beat a path to their door, believer and "denialist" alike. It's no good arguing that we don't need to measure the primal cause of what ails us.

According to the those who say there is no global mean, their should also not be a regional mean. Yet we get weather forecasts for regions every day, and people know exactly what they mean. It's hotter in summer than in winter.

That's an over-simplification. Measuring a global mean is significantly more challenging than predicting the air temperature of a region based on tracking the movement of fronts across the Earth's surface.
 
There are various attack lines. First you would be looking at setting fire to underground coal meaures. Cheap and gets you a fair amount of CO2 over the 43 years.

After that. Well takeing bulk production savings into account you could probably paint 1% of earths land area black (with of the self prices you are looking at closer to 0.7%) which would have an interesting effect.

That assumes 8 square meters per liter and an of the shelf price of 13.8$ per liter.

Next up we have sulfur hexafluoride. At 20$ per pound you could afford 45359237000kg for the amount mentioned. Over 43 years that would be the equiv of over 680,000,000,000 tonnes of CO2.

Oh another thing to try is nukeing certian bits of permafrost in an attempt to release methane. Something simular might work with some volcanos.


1. All fossil fuels burned is supposedly inadequate to double atmospheric co2 , and doubling it would get 2.5-6.5 c. Seems a no go there.

2. For sulfer hexaflouride
Man's contribution will be 43x27B = 1161 B Ton your 680B would yield perhaps 1.5-4 c increase.

3, Painting the planet. A big happy face maybe?

A big program like that would need lots of graduates. Maybe degree programs in Warmology?

But H bombing volcanoes, a fellow named Hubbard already came up with that.:)
 
I never thought of myself as a physical chemist but I guess I'm turning into one in my dotage. AUP, the statement that there is no adequate method for adjudging the temperature of the Earth at the moment is correct. You suggest a statistical treatment of various measurements around the planet and that would work if the method were standardized.

And a lot of work has gone into doing just that. The result is that you can see the temperature gradients. If we had worthless data, instead of gradients you would be seeing ad hoc jumps in temperature all over the system.

That would solve a great many problems and it would make it a lot easier to not only devise models but also to validate them. At this point in time, we basically have to wait until temperature values at a particularly vulnerable part of the planet accumulates enough history (datapoints) that we can tell whether or not a prediction was correct within a desired confidence level. This type of verification would be almost instantaneous if there were an accurate method of assessing a standard temperature for the planet.

I alluded earlier that there are ways but they are very new and would not fit in well with old measurements. A device far enough in space to measure the black-body radiation of the planet would give us a good indication of the net temperature of the Earth. I suspect that a far-orbit satellite could probably do this if equipped with a good IR spectrophotometer and a standardized method of where to sample each and every time it made a measurement. Statistical data manipulation of those data would be better performed here on the ground. Maybe this is already being done but I haven't read about it.

So, for now, we watch and wait. I agree that it's high time to become a lot more concerned about despoiling our environment. This is true whether or not AGW turns out to be true or not. If you think about the issue in its entirety, the only thing that will allow us to manage the problem, if it can be managed, is hard data and accurate predictions therefrom.



That's very true but, tell me, how would you know it was happening due to increased temperature if you can't measure it? Unusual activity in any terrestrial system could have a very different cause.
It can, that is why there are two distinct steps, measuring what is happening, attributing the reasons for the change.

Nice article but I can't agree with it. Their reasoning is circular. If someone devised a method of measureing the planet's mean measurement tomorrow, the world would beat a path to their door, believer and "denialist" alike. It's no good arguing that we don't need to measure the primal cause of what ails us.
If you have enough samples, it doesn't matter if the system is chaotic, a rise in the overall temperature of the chaotic system will be detected. I think the scientsts refer to it as looking for a signal. That is, they are way ahead of you, and know how to handle the issue.

ETA

I would also ad that this chaotic system works within very well understood and observed boundaries. That is, we have seaons every year, for example, we don't have cyclones all over the place, the equator is hotter than the poles.
 
Last edited:
And a lot of work has gone into doing just that. The result is that you can see the temperature gradients. If we had worthless data, instead of gradients you would be seeing ad hoc jumps in temperature all over the system.

I didn't write that the data we have now are bogus. I don't believe that. The data are generally good although some mistakes have been made in gathering some of the data. (Changes in methodology, placement of devices, etc). In measuring a chaotic system, consistency is essential. One can use an artifactual measurement given that the underpinning data are collected consistently. There was a reason I wrote earlier that the dispute is not over data but interpretation. Ambiguity and confusion is what you get when you put the cart (hypotheses) before horse (metrics).

It can, that is why there are two distinct steps, measuring what is happening, attributing the reasons for the change.

Yes, and that is why it's essential to have the accurate measurement at your disposal. There must be a consitently high correlation between effect and cause. If you can't measure cause, you can't even begin to determine where an effect came from. So, we're back at the beginning, aren't we? Some system of accurately determining thermal changes on the planet must be devised in order to make accurate predictions and to gauge how effective corrective measures are.

If you have enough samples, it doesn't matter if the system is chaotic, a rise in the overall temperature of the chaotic system will be detected. I think the scientsts refer to it as looking for a signal.

True. Don't forget that "enough" depends on how chaotic the system is. How do you know when you have "enough" samples if you have to keep guestimating changes in the metrics? The problem with what you wrote is that different scientists are looking for different signals because they don't have a proper and consistent metric. Your problem still reduces to measuring the temperature of a chaotic system. There's no getting away from it.

That is, they are way ahead of you, and know how to handle the issue.

If so, they're doing a very good job of hiding it. The IPCC chapter you posted yesterday is very good evidence that "they" are still struggling with this issue. If you read it carefully, you will see many admissions that certain model compartments are being abandoned due to poor correlation with actual measurements, some are being adjusted and some new compartments are being added.

So, no, this planet is still befuddling the best of us. That's what I meant when I wrote that this area has been politicized. The only people announcing that the science is settled and all scientists are of one mind are politicians, special interests and idiots. Frankly, if anyone tells you that all scientists agree on anything, they are probably high, deluded or lying. Witness the discussion on this Forum as to whether or not light has mass. I know a Ph.D. in chemistry who doesn't believe in isotopes. (Go figure!) There's an old adage that, given n chemists in a room, you have n+1 opinions. Don't ever swallow that pill.
 
I didn't write that the data we have now are bogus. I don't believe that. The data are generally good although some mistakes have been made in gathering some of the data. (Changes in methodology, placement of devices, etc). In measuring a chaotic system, consistency is essential. One can use an artifactual measurement given that the underpinning data are collected consistently. There was a reason I wrote earlier that the dispute is not over data but interpretation. Ambiguity and confusion is what you get when you put the cart (hypotheses) before horse (metrics).

The consistency isn't too bad, and the results have been independently replicated around the world. For a set of temperatures, theres a consistent rise at different locations around the world. To be technically accurate, rather than a global average temperature, they refer to anomolies. That is, changes from the base line average for a site. Average global temperature is still an interesting figure, if you want to compare the present climate with past ones.

To get you started, Eli will point out that there are no global temperature measurements, there are global temperature ANOMALY measurements. As is pointed out at the GISS website:
Our analysis concerns only temperature anomalies, not absolute temperatures. The temperature anomaly tells us how much warmer or colder than normal it is at a particular place and point in time, the 'normal temperature' being the mean over many (30) years (same place, same time of year). It seems obvious that to find the anomaly, you first have to know the current and normal absolute temperatures. This is correct for the temperature at one fixed spot (the location of one thermometer), but not true at all for regional mean temperatures.
Whereas the individual reading represents just this spot but can be very different from nearby readings, the anomaly computed from those readings is much less dependent on location, elevation, wind patterns etc; it turns out to be representative for a region that covers several square miles. Hence we can combine anomalies from various stations to find regional mean anomalies. Regional absolute temperatures however cannot be obtained from observations alone. For a more detailed discussion, see The Elusive Absolute Surface Air Temperature.



​
Yes, and that is why it's essential to have the accurate measurement at your disposal. There must be a consitently high correlation between effect and cause. If you can't measure cause, you can't even begin to determine where an effect came from. So, we're back at the beginning, aren't we? Some system of accurately determining thermal changes on the planet must be devised in order to make accurate predictions and to gauge how effective corrective measures are.



True. Don't forget that "enough" depends on how chaotic the system is. How do you know when you have "enough" samples if you have to keep guestimating changes in the metrics? The problem with what you wrote is that different scientists are looking for different signals because they don't have a proper and consistent metric. Your problem still reduces to measuring the temperature of a chaotic system. There's no getting away from it.

If so, they're doing a very good job of hiding it. The IPCC chapter you posted yesterday is very good evidence that "they" are still struggling with this issue. If you read it carefully, you will see many admissions that certain model compartments are being abandoned due to poor correlation with actual measurements, some are being adjusted and some new compartments are being added.

[/quote]

They have always been upfront about the limits of what they can deduce from their research. Nevertheless, it's warming.

So, no, this planet is still befuddling the best of us. That's what I meant when I wrote that this area has been politicized. The only people announcing that the science is settled and all scientists are of one mind are politicians, special interests and idiots. Frankly, if anyone tells you that all scientists agree on anything, they are probably high, deluded or lying. Witness the discussion on this Forum as to whether or not light has mass. I know a Ph.D. in chemistry who doesn't believe in isotopes. (Go figure!) There's an old adage that, given n chemists in a room, you have n+1 opinions. Don't ever swallow that pill.[/quote]

Sure, but that is where consensus comes into it. Without that, in this case, we would never reach a conclusion. The nutcases and contrarians are weeded out. It would be nice if they didn't have to do that, but the issue is important enough that we have to be told the best information that is available, despite the drawbacks that result.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom