Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation


CNN also had this article about the UN exhorting someone to act today. No real details on exactly who should act and what they should do.

I'm not saying AGW is wrong but I find these pronouncements to be counter-productive and ill-advised. Like Adventists, if you tell someone that X will happen and it doesn't, you just look like a crank. These sources are making recommendations they know full well can't be accepted within the time frames they've specified. And, most probably, nothing will happen. If they are right, the occurences won't be evident for years and the causes will be ambiguous with relation to today's warnings.
 
I am not an expert on glaciers but it would appear that the "experts" you cite are flat wrong (as I have said Gore and Hansen were on this issue).

That was the reason I posted the original link, because it appeared to simply and clearly explain the fundamental plastic flow of glaciers, and because it did seem that there was wide misunderstanding of this issue.

Plastic creep really is Materials Science 101...Let's be precise. We're discussing Greenland melting down or rushing into the sea, right?

That can't happen because the land under Greenland is shaped like a bowl and glacier ice escapes through what is basically mountain passes. The top of the Greenland glacier is far too high and too cold to melt. Around the edges of Greenland where the ice meets the sea there could be a retreat, yes. The some 50,000 people living in Greenland would probably benefits from that, not dangers and disadvantages.

From the article -
Hansen has a model of an ice sheet sliding along an inclined plane, lubricated by meltwater, which is itself increasing because of global warming. The same model is adopted in many copy-cat papers. Christoffersen and Hambrey (2006) and Bamber et al. (2007). are typical papers, a popular article based on the same flawed model appeared in the June 2007 issue of National Geographic, and the idea is present in textbooks such as The Great Ice Age (2000) by R.C.L. Wilson et al.

Hanson’s model, unfortunately, includes neither the main form of the Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets, nor an understanding of how glaciers flow. The predicted behaviour of the ice sheets is based on melting and accumulation rates at the present day, and on the concept of an ice sheet sliding down an inclined plane on a base lubricated by meltwater, which is itself increasing because of global warming. The idea of a glacier sliding downhill on a base lubricated by meltwater seemed a good idea when first presented by de Saussure in 1779, but a lot has been learned since then.
​
Google. "Greenland sub-ice geomorphology".

Side note. The tremendous internal pressures of these mile high ice formations create internal water pools such as you have mentioned, although that context was Antartica. So if the ice does create it's own water pools down deep, how would surface meltwater ever get down there? The pressure gradients are in the opposite direction.

That ain't gonna happen.

done googled

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=40d75d2556aaef87034e578ce09e3d99

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=191d6603ac2e4229b3f4fda26dbf1d59

http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cach...ub-ice+geomorphology&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=9&gl=us

check those out and tell be that they support the position that the ice in Greenland can't melt and flow into the sea.

Also to paraphrase a statement in that blog you so highly believe; I vaguely recall reading somewhere that all the ice in greenland presses down on the land mass pushing down close to sealevel or even below.

But then I only vaguely remember reading that.

As to how the surface water can get to the bottom, well through cracks and what not.

What, you think glaciers are all solid masses of ice?

What is a cravasse? and why is it so dangerous to fall into one?

Its not the sudden stop at the bottom, for a hint, you might drown.

take a walk on one.

Where and how big is lake Vostok again.

Hey and why don't you stop quoting from blogs, they are not reliable you know.
 
done googled

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=40d75d2556aaef87034e578ce09e3d99

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=191d6603ac2e4229b3f4fda26dbf1d59

http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:OuVWdZV6D54J:www.geosc.psu.edu/~dupont/tkd_short_r_and_t.pdf+Greenland+sub-ice+geomorphology&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=9&gl=us

check those out and tell be that they support the position that the ice in Greenland can't melt and flow into the sea.

Also to paraphrase a statement in that blog you so highly believe; I vaguely recall reading somewhere that all the ice in greenland presses down on the land mass pushing down close to sealevel or even below.

But then I only vaguely remember reading that.

As to how the surface water can get to the bottom, well through cracks and what not.

What, you think glaciers are all solid masses of ice?

What is a cravasse? and why is it so dangerous to fall into one?

Its not the sudden stop at the bottom, for a hint, you might drown.

take a walk on one.

Where and how big is lake Vostok again.

Hey and why don't you stop quoting from blogs, they are not reliable you know.

I'll study the links, but what about Vostok? a huge- one of many-lake under the ice down south?

So....?
 
I'll study the links, but what about Vostok? a huge- one of many-lake under the ice down south?

So....?

It's a lake like any other. It just happens to have a lot of ice sitting on top of it. The reason it's a lake is that it's not on an incline - otherwise it would be a river. The ice equivalents to "lake" and "river" are ice-caps and glaciers. Lake Vostok doesn't lubricate ice-movement because the ice it's in contact with isn't flowing, it's just sitting there.
 
It's a lake like any other. It just happens to have a lot of ice sitting on top of it. The reason it's a lake is that it's not on an incline - otherwise it would be a river. The ice equivalents to "lake" and "river" are ice-caps and glaciers. Lake Vostok doesn't lubricate ice-movement because the ice it's in contact with isn't flowing, it's just sitting there.

The reason for such a thing would be is pressure and possibly geothermal heating from below.

The relation of this to the issue of Greenland and/or Antarctica not being meltable due to AGW is...?

You or Bob is not seriously suggesting that melt water formed Vostok?
 
check those out and tell be that they support the position that the ice in Greenland can't melt and flow into the sea.

Some of it, if melted, would form lakes because they're in geographical bowls, like mountain lakes everywhere. That's the ice that will last longest because it will have to melt from the top - a slow process. This explains the much-vaunted "thousand years for all the Greenland ice to melt", which is accurate enough as far as it goes. I'm not talking about much of the ice, any more than mountain lakes hold much of the worlds liquid water.

Most of the ice-melt would flow into the sea because it is on a gradient, and could do it in relatively short order - a few centuries. A lot of it could go in very short order - a century or so.

Also to paraphrase a statement in that blog you so highly believe; I vaguely recall reading somewhere that all the ice in greenland presses down on the land mass pushing down close to sealevel or even below.

Serious ice, on the multi-kilometre scale, does deform the land below it. In the UK, Scotland is still rising ("relaxing" is, I think, the term, though it seems strangely inappropriate for Scotland :)) in response to the last great melt, while Southern England is sinking (as the underlying rock plastically deforms northwards).

The Baltic Sea is getting shallower for the same reason. Given time it might have disappeared had the last great melt stabilised matters. Even with current sea-level rise it's still receding.
 
The reason for such a thing would be is pressure and possibly geothermal heating from below.

The relation of this to the issue of Greenland and/or Antarctica not being meltable due to AGW is...?

I thought you brought it up. bobdroege7 is apparently unsure of where it even is, so I doubt he introduced it, and I certainly didn't. I don't see it as relevant.

You or Bob is not seriously suggesting that melt water formed Vostok?

I thought that's why you brought it up - suggesting that the existence of Vostok (an ancient lake) meant that melt-water wouldn't influence the rate of ice-loss.

I may have gone adrift, I haven't been following the thread closely of late.

Melt-water at the base of glaciers is certainly relevant. It hurries them on their way downhill and ultimately into the oceans.
 
The link I've been using for the density of water is this one. That's for pure water and sea water is probably different but not appreciably. To fine tune the expansion coefficient between two temperatures, take the difference between the two densities and then divide by your present density. Pure water is densest at about 4 C so that's the layer of ocean that will expand the most once heated or cooled.

As far as linearity, that's a good question. I've never plotted the density of water vs temperature but, as you've noted, the expansion coefficient of water is always given at a certain temperature so I doubt it's linear.

From that source, between 4C and 20C there's a density difference of 0.14, between 20C and 40C a difference of 0.64, between 40C and 60C it's 0.53, so it's definitely not linear. An upward curve to 40C followed by a tailing-off. (Since this is all on the range 62.42 to 61.39 a first-approximation seems sufficient).

That doesn't imply that the coldest will expand most. Rather the reverse.
 
I thought you brought it up. bobdroege7 is apparently unsure of where it even is, so I doubt he introduced it, and I certainly didn't. I don't see it as relevant.

I thought that's why you brought it up - suggesting that the existence of Vostok (an ancient lake) meant that melt-water wouldn't influence the rate of ice-loss.

I may have gone adrift, I haven't been following the thread closely of late.

Melt-water at the base of glaciers is certainly relevant. It hurries them on their way downhill and ultimately into the oceans.

No, Bob brought it up... twice.
 
That was two years ago. What's it doing now?

What is the Arctic doing now?
http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.cfm?release=2007-131


Hmm.

""While some 1990s climate trends, such as declines in Arctic sea ice extent, have continued, these results suggest at least for the 'wet' part of the Arctic -- the Arctic Ocean -- circulation reverted to conditions like those prevalent before the 1990s," he added."

Which suggests that the decline in Arctic sea-extent is not connected to the circulation, don't you think? Something else seems to be in play.

"The Arctic Oscillation was fairly stable until about 1970, but then varied on more or less decadal time scales, with signs of an underlying upward trend, until the late 1990s, when it again stabilized. During its strong counterclockwise phase in the 1990s, the Arctic environment changed markedly, with the upper Arctic Ocean undergoing major changes that persisted into this century. Many scientists viewed the changes as evidence of an ongoing climate shift, raising concerns about the effects of global warming on the Arctic. "

I can see how that could happen. I'd have said climate change rather than climate shift, since climate shift has a rather different meaning. It has, for instance, been used in regard to events in Australia as an alternative to climate change. But what the hey.

"Morison said data gathered by Grace and the bottom pressure gauges since publication of the paper earlier this year highlight how short-lived the ocean circulation changes can be. The newer data indicate the bottom pressure has increased back toward its 2002 level. "The winter of 2006-2007 was another high Arctic Oscillation year and summer sea ice extent reached a new minimum," he said. "It is too early to say, but it looks as though the Arctic Ocean is ready to start swinging back to the counterclockwise circulation pattern of the 1990s again."

Back to the circulation pattern that (perhaps) led to the decline in Arctic sea-ice extent during the 90's. So we have a decline during one phase, followed by decline during the opposite phase. Decline seems to be independent of the circulation phase.

'Morison cautioned that while the recent decadal-scale changes in the circulation of the Arctic Ocean may not appear to be directly tied to global warming, most climate models predict the Arctic Oscillation will become even more strongly counterclockwise in the future. "The events of the 1990s may well be a preview of how the Arctic will respond over longer periods of time in a warming world," he said.'

Given the phase change back to the 90's experience we may well have a preview of what's going to happen over the next decade. From a much lower starting-point.

I'm at a loss to distinguish what comfort you derive from this. "Hmm" doesn't really provide many clues.
 
From that source, between 4C and 20C there's a density difference of 0.14, between 20C and 40C a difference of 0.64, between 40C and 60C it's 0.53, so it's definitely not linear. An upward curve to 40C followed by a tailing-off. (Since this is all on the range 62.42 to 61.39 a first-approximation seems sufficient).

That doesn't imply that the coldest will expand most. Rather the reverse.

I was wondering what you were on about until I noticed that you were using the lb/cu. ft column. Most of us use the g/cc or g/mL values. Specific gravity is unitless because it's always based on 1 cc of water.

Anyway, don't be lulled into taking specific gravity as a direct value of expansion. You have to take the reciprocal of the density to give you volume per mass to get a true value of expansion. Water is most dense at 4C (1 g/cc). The density declines on both sides of that temperature which means that a gram of water would take more and more volume.
 
I was wondering what you were on about until I noticed that you were using the lb/cu. ft column. Most of us use the g/cc or g/mL values. Specific gravity is unitless because it's always based on 1 cc of water.

Since you're in the US I automatically assumed the opposite - that you'd use Imperial measures :).

Anyway, don't be lulled into taking specific gravity as a direct value of expansion. You have to take the reciprocal of the density to give you volume per mass to get a true value of expansion. Water is most dense at 4C (1 g/cc). The density declines on both sides of that temperature which means that a gram of water would take more and more volume.

The first approximation is good enough for my purposes, especially late on a Saturday night. The physics of liquid expansion is not something I'm at all familiar with, but I may get around to finding the basics later. That's the sort of activity wet Sundays are made for.
 
If you're not already frustrated enough: http://www.kentucky.com/news/state/story/231346.html

For what it's worth, the whole anti-AGW is a lot like anti-evolutionism to my mind. I've taught enough biology to have touched on both ideas (a general biology class for the evolution part, and a plant physiology course that touched on plant adaptations to climate), and both make me think about the differences between A and C levels students.

C students do well at memorizing facts, but don't synthesize knowledge from facts, at least, not the way A students do. So, when writing a test, about 70% of the test is simple rote memorization - that gives the C students a chance to earn their Cs. But the rest should be essay type questions that force students to think beyond their notes - this gives the A students a chance to shine, and to demonstrate to themselves that they've learned (I remember exams that taught me new things; that was my goal).

So, anyway, it seems to me that C-level people latch onto a few facts, here and there, and use small discrepencies among those facts to discredit a theory. But you really need the A-level background and understanding to see the big picture.

I suppose at times I think that the fact that there is even a debate over evolution or AGW indicates that we, as instructors, just aren't reaching the general population; but then I also sometimes think that, as instructors in a specialized area (well, like plant physiology) that we can only hope to teach just so much.

That is, when I taught plant physiology, most of the students were agronomy majors; many had jobs already and just needed the course to complete their degree. The material might help them do their jobs better (agronomists give farmers advice about plant nutrition, for example); on the other, they really don't need the minutia of the Calvin cycle to be successful in their careers. Anyway, I'm just rambling now.

It is something that's I've considered over the years, when I've been teaching ('cause I've gone back and forth between that and software engineering). Should I teach at the college level, where I can teach more advanced material but reach a more limited audience, or teach at the high school level, where I would teach just the basics, but can reach a broader base of the voting population?
 

That's what happens when you get politicians trying to use science. Unfinished science, in this case.

For what it's worth, the whole anti-AGW is a lot like anti-evolutionism to my mind.

If there were enough evidence for AGW (especially with that A attached), this thread would not exist. (Well, maybe it would if some troll started it.) I've seen enough evidence that the planet is warming but I've seen a lot of evidence that it's not carbon dioxide driving it. To be fair, I've also seen a lot of evidence that carbon dioxide might be driving it. The science is not to a point yet where we should be considering anything more than encouraging people to be better planetary stewards.
 
If you're not already frustrated enough: http://www.kentucky.com/news/state/story/231346.html

For what it's worth, the whole anti-AGW is a lot like anti-evolutionism to my mind. I've taught enough biology to have touched on both ideas (a general biology class for the evolution part, and a plant physiology course that touched on plant adaptations to climate), and both make me think about the differences between A and C levels students.

C students do well at memorizing facts, but don't synthesize knowledge from facts, at least, not the way A students do. So, when writing a test, about 70% of the test is simple rote memorization - that gives the C students a chance to earn their Cs. But the rest should be essay type questions that force students to think beyond their notes - this gives the A students a chance to shine, and to demonstrate to themselves that they've learned (I remember exams that taught me new things; that was my goal).

So, anyway, it seems to me that C-level people latch onto a few facts, here and there, and use small discrepencies among those facts to discredit a theory. But you really need the A-level background and understanding to see the big picture.

Yes, you have describe Al Gore. Thanks.

I suppose at times I think that the fact that there is even a debate over evolution or AGW indicates that we, as instructors, just aren't reaching the general population; but then I also sometimes think that, as instructors in a specialized area (well, like plant physiology) that we can only hope to teach just so much.

That is, when I taught plant physiology, most of the students were agronomy majors; many had jobs already and just needed the course to complete their degree. The material might help them do their jobs better (agronomists give farmers advice about plant nutrition, for example); on the other, they really don't need the minutia of the Calvin cycle to be successful in their careers. Anyway, I'm just rambling now.

It is something that's I've considered over the years, when I've been teaching ('cause I've gone back and forth between that and software engineering). Should I teach at the college level, where I can teach more advanced material but reach a more limited audience, or teach at the high school level, where I would teach just the basics, but can reach a broader base of the voting population?
By the way, it's also pretty ridiculous to see biologists, climatologists and the like pontificating on economics, investments and public policy decisions, where they have no background or understanding of the methods of analysis, or methods of comparing different outcomes.

None of which is helped by politics and lobbying, which is largely from the entrenched environmental interests, isn't it?
 
:bigclap
Slimething you have showed everybody here the real nature of Schneibster. You completely beat him and he just does what every religious fanatic does: He tell yow how mean to he you are (BUAHAHAHAHAHA) and them refuses to acknowledge any point. And since this point is central to the AGW alarmisn (remember that the sea level will go up 20ft and destroy lots of cities and countries?) he simply runs away like a little yellow chicken.

Congratulations!


:confused: When did I refute physics?



:covereyes Oh, dear, he's off his meds again! This from someone who tells others they have no integrity! All I told him was to watch how he addresses me.
:id:
Celebration is ON! :yahoo:wave1:clap::mdance::monkeyr::cheerleader4
 
What I originally stated is that I don't believe that thermal expansion will greatly exacerbate flooding due to warming. Water doesn't expand much with temperature. That' why it's not used in thermometers but it is used in manometers. So, fearing expansion from seawater is basically an exercise in scaring yourself.

According to the IPCC, thermal expansion of the oceans is the single biggest factor in rising sea levels.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom