Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Forgot to give credit for the graph, so here it is along with the interesting article it is from.

A recent study by Peter Chylek et al. (2006) put all of these Greenland temperature records together in one place (Figure 8 ), and commented:
Although there has been a considerable temperature increase during the last decade (1995 to 2005) a similar increase and at a faster rate occurred during the early part of the 20th century (1920 to 1930) when carbon dioxide or other greenhouse gases could not be a cause. The Greenland warming of 1920 to 1930 demonstrates that a high concentration of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases is not a necessary condition for period of warming to arise. The observed 1995–2005 temperature increase seems to be within a natural variability of Greenland climate.
​



Chylek and colleagues went on to comment as to how the impacts of these recent warm temperatures on glacier movements likely compared to impacts that probably resulted in the past from similarly warm (or warmer) conditions:
The glacier acceleration observed during the 1996–2005 period has probably occurred previously. There should have been the same or more extensive acceleration during the 1920–1930 warming as well as during the Medieval Warm period in Greenland when Greenland temperatures were generally higher than today.
​
http://www.worldclimatereport.com/i...land-climate-now-vs-then-part-i-temperatures/
 
Need to be careful with Wikipedia, someone went to a lot of trouble to type in the IPPC 3rd report stuff (2001), but we are now up to the IPCC 4th, or the 5th ??? released over the weekend.

Wikipedia will not be accurate...

I did check, and also provided a link to the IPCC report. Wiki appears to be accurate in this case, and provides a decent summary of the report. The 4th report isn't fully released yet, and I don't have time to dig through it all to find the relevant information. I doubt that it has changed so much that they now claim thermal expansion is irrelevant.

I merely asked how this can possibly be the case as seas are primarily water and water doen't expand that much with temperature. Can you explain it?

As CapelDodger said, there is a hell of a lot of water. 0.1-0.4m compared to an average depth of nearly 4km. That's 0.0025%. You use the word "negligible". That depends very much on the context. The trouble is, we are essentially comparing two different scales, the total water in oceans on a very large scale, and the height above sea level we live, which is very small scale. 0.0025% is negligible compared to the large, but when it is transferred to the small it becomes very ligible indeed.

As an analogy, think of an astronomical unit. If you're looking at cosmology, 93 million miles is pretty much nothing when you're measuring the distance between galaxies, but you'd be hard pressed to argue it's negligible compared to distances on Earth. Similarly, a few millimetres is nothing compared to the whole ocean, but compared to the land we're living on, it's the difference between being toasty and dry and being dunked under water.

I've reduced the heating of the sea to Beer's Law which is plainly how much IR the water will absorb. Don't tell me the air will heat the sea efficiently as that doesn't happen due to the difference in heat capacity. It would take a monstrous amount of air contacting a very small amount of ocean to impart detectable heat in said water. Remember my example of one mole of water taking up 0.018 L at room temp but 22.4 L as gas? That's what you're looking at. Is the ocean temperature the same as the air temperature where you live?

The ocean may not be the same temperature as the air, but it certainly does heat up a significant amount. Do you live by the sea? If so, check the temperature around September and then again around April/May. Then try claiming that it doesn't heat up.

That aside, the important point you seem to be missing is that efficiency is actually irrelevant. If the average global temperature increases by 1oC, eventually the ocean will as well. It might not do so as quickly as the air or the land, but it will heat up. And that warming may not cause it to expand much at all, but it only needs to expand by a thousandth of a percent to be one of the biggest, if not the biggest, causes of increase in sea level.

I think you're also ignoring a lot of the complexities of heat transfer by only considering radiation. Conduction from air to ocean may not be huge, but it will happen. More important will be conduction from the land to the ocean. I also haven't noticed any mention of currents. There can be no doubt that the equator is hotter than the poles. Warm currents flow from the hotter areas to the colder ones, and carry a hell of a lot of heat with them, not always at the surface.
 
That aside, the important point you seem to be missing is that efficiency is actually irrelevant. If the average global temperature increases by 1oC, eventually the ocean will as well. It might not do so as quickly as the air or the land, but it will heat up. And that warming may not cause it to expand much at all, but it only needs to expand by a thousandth of a percent to be one of the biggest, if not the biggest, causes of increase in sea level.
it only needs to expand by a thousandth of a percent to be one of the biggest, if not the biggest, causes of increase in sea level.
​
For 3000m of depth that would create a sea level rise of 3cm. And that would be over what period of time if it were possible?
 
I did check, and also provided a link to the IPCC report. Wiki appears to be accurate in this case, and provides a decent summary of the report. The 4th report isn't fully released yet, and I don't have time to dig through it all to find the relevant information. I doubt that it has changed so much that they now claim thermal expansion is irrelevant.



As CapelDodger said, there is a hell of a lot of water. 0.1-0.4m compared to an average depth of nearly 4km. That's 0.0025%. You use the word "negligible". That depends very much on the context. The trouble is, we are essentially comparing two different scales, the total water in oceans on a very large scale, and the height above sea level we live, which is very small scale. 0.0025% is negligible compared to the large, but when it is transferred to the small it becomes very ligible indeed.

As an analogy, think of an astronomical unit. If you're looking at cosmology, 93 million miles is pretty much nothing when you're measuring the distance between galaxies, but you'd be hard pressed to argue it's negligible compared to distances on Earth. Similarly, a few millimetres is nothing compared to the whole ocean, but compared to the land we're living on, it's the difference between being toasty and dry and being dunked under water.



The ocean may not be the same temperature as the air, but it certainly does heat up a significant amount. Do you live by the sea? If so, check the temperature around September and then again around April/May. Then try claiming that it doesn't heat up.

That aside, the important point you seem to be missing is that efficiency is actually irrelevant. If the average global temperature increases by 1oC, eventually the ocean will as well. It might not do so as quickly as the air or the land, but it will heat up. And that warming may not cause it to expand much at all, but it only needs to expand by a thousandth of a percent to be one of the biggest, if not the biggest, causes of increase in sea level.

I think you're also ignoring a lot of the complexities of heat transfer by only considering radiation. Conduction from air to ocean may not be huge, but it will happen. More important will be conduction from the land to the ocean. I also haven't noticed any mention of currents. There can be no doubt that the equator is hotter than the poles. Warm currents flow from the hotter areas to the colder ones, and carry a hell of a lot of heat with them, not always at the surface.

That aside, the important point you seem to be missing is that efficiency is actually irrelevant. If the average global temperature increases by 1oC, eventually the ocean will as well. It might not do so as quickly as the air or the land, but it will heat up.

Oceans are the heat sinks, not land and air. Global surface temperatures cannot continue to rise, and currently they are not, if ocean heat content is not increasing, which it is not.
 
Last edited:
By analyzing the real effect of increased heath in the ocean you have just showed that even if Hansen model is correct the outcome of the model is in error or there is a lot more explaining to do.

Ignore the model, go and look at the measurements over the last 50 years or so. They have temperature measurements and they have sea level measurements. They go up and down a lot. Some people wonder whether this is in fact possible. The problem is though it has already happened, so on balance I'm gonna side with "it is possible." No need to invoke Hansen or his model, just the work of those scientists who have done the number crunching with the real life data.

If you want to pick holes in their methodology, perhaps those scientists are clueless after all :eek:, be my guest. Until someone does that convincingly, I would withhold judgement on whether anyone here has shown that what has already been observed happening can't in fact happen.
 
Last edited:
I just did that and found this in Wikipedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise

Are islands "drowning"?

IPCC assessments have suggested that deltas and small island states may be particularly vulnerable to sea level rise. Relative sea level rise (mostly caused by subsidence) is currently causing substantial loss of lands in some deltas.[citation needed] While sea level changes have not yet been directly implicated in any substantial environmental, humanitarian, or economic losses to small island states, the IPCC and other bodies have found this a serious risk scenario in coming decades.[32] Some media reports have focused the island nations of the Pacific, notably the Polynesian island of Tuvalu, which based on more severe flooding events in recent years, was thought to be "sinking" due to sea level rise.[33] A scientific review in 2000 reported that based on University of Hawaii gauge data, Tuvalu had experienced a negligible increase in sea-level of 0.07 mm a year over the past two decades, and that ENSO had been a larger factor in Tuvalu's higher tides in recent years.[34] A subsequent study by John Hunter from the University of Tasmania, however, adjusted for ENSO and the movement of the gauge (which was thought to be sinking). Hunter concluded that Tuvalu had been experiencing sea-level rise of about 1.2 mm per year.[35][36] The recent more frequent flooding in Tuvalu may also be due to an erosional loss of land during and following the actions of 1997 cyclones Gavin, Hina, and Keli.[37]
Reuters has reported other Pacific islands are facing a severe risk including Tegua island in Vanuatu. Claims that Vanuatu data shows no net sea level rise, are not substantiated by tide gauge data. Vanuatu tide gauge data[38] show a net rise of ~50 mm from 1994-2004. Linear regression of this short time series suggests a rate of rise of ~7 mm/y, though there is considerable variability and the exact threat to the islands is difficult to assess using such a short time series.
Numerous options have been proposed that would assist island nations to adapt to rising sea level.[39]
Also
By the time of the IPCC TAR, attribution of sea-level changes had a large unexplained gap between direct and indirect estimates of global sea-level rise. Most direct estimates from tide gauges give 1.5–2.0 mm/yr, whereas indirect estimates based on the two processes responsible for global sea-level rise, namely mass and volume change, are significantly below this range. Estimates of the volume increase due to ocean warming give a rate of about 0.5 mm/yr and the rate due to mass increase, primarily from the melting of continental ice, is thought to be even smaller. One study confirmed tide gauge data is correct, and concluded there must be a continental source of 1.4 mm/yr of fresh water. (Miller 2004)
and also

The sum of these components indicates a rate of eustatic sea level rise (corresponding to a change in ocean volume) from 1910 to 1990 ranging from –0.8 to 2.2 mm/yr, with a central value of 0.7 mm/yr. The upper bound is close to the observational upper bound (2.0 mm/yr), but the central value is less than the observational lower bound (1.0 mm/yr), i.e., the sum of components is biased low compared to the observational estimates. The sum of components indicates an acceleration of only 0.2 (mm/yr)/century, with a range from –1.1 to +0.7 (mm/yr)/century, consistent with observational finding of no acceleration in sea level rise during the 20th century. The estimated rate of sea-level rise from anthropogenic climate change from 1910 to 1990 (from modeling studies of thermal expansion, glaciers and ice sheets) ranges from 0.3 to 0.8 mm/yr. It is very likely that 20th century warming has contributed significantly to the observed sea-level rise, through thermal expansion of sea water and widespread loss of land ice.[16]
A common perception is that the rate of sea-level rise should have accelerated during the latter half of the 20th century, but tide gauge data for the 20th century show no significant acceleration. We have obtained estimates based on AOGCMs for the terms directly related to anthropogenic climate change in the 20th century, i.e., thermal expansion, ice sheets, glaciers and ice caps... The total computed rise indicates an acceleration of only 0.2 (mm/yr)/century, with a range from -1.1 to +0.7 (mm/yr)/century, consistent with observational finding of no acceleration in sea-level rise during the 20th century.[18] The sum of terms not related to recent climate change is -1.1 to +0.9 mm/yr (i.e., excluding thermal expansion, glaciers and ice caps, and changes in the ice sheets due to 20th century climate change). This range is less than the observational lower bound of sea level rise. Hence it is very likely that these terms alone are an insufficient explanation, implying that 20th century climate change has made a contribution to 20th century sea level rise.[5]
 
Last edited:
I have a pretty good idea:
To be really catastrophic, AGW should raise sea level in a catastrophic way.

I was in doubt of AGW because models are weak, they aren't validated (there are literally thousands of models, each one with a different outcome and predictions. When something happens, they can claim that "the model" predicted that, but they don't tell you which model and under what assumptions) and because the input data has been showed to be wrong due to errors in the methodology (Hockey Stick), errors in the data (proxies, Urban Heath effect and so on), bad programming, cherry picking, data torture and illegal data transformations.

Can anyone point to a website where there is a list of the climate models, and for each, a specific list of parameters; along with valid and suggested ranges for said parms?

Secondly, can anyone show the specific choices of parameters for a single historical climate model? Just for one run, the specific inputs and the output.
 
As CapelDodger said, there is a hell of a lot of water. 0.1-0.4m compared to an average depth of nearly 4km. That's 0.0025%. You use the word "negligible". That depends very much on the context. The trouble is, we are essentially comparing two different scales, the total water in oceans on a very large scale, and the height above sea level we live, which is very small scale. 0.0025% is negligible compared to the large, but when it is transferred to the small it becomes very ligible indeed.

Thanks for the numbers. Do you have any estimate on how much sea levels will rise per volume of expansion or even water? That's the numbers we need.

The ocean may not be the same temperature as the air, but it certainly does heat up a significant amount. Do you live by the sea? If so, check the temperature around September and then again around April/May. Then try claiming that it doesn't heat up.

I didn't say it didn't heat up. I said the air isn't doing that much. It's the sunshine!

That aside, the important point you seem to be missing is that efficiency is actually irrelevant. If the average global temperature increases by 1oC, eventually the ocean will as well. It might not do so as quickly as the air or the land, but it will heat up. And that warming may not cause it to expand much at all, but it only needs to expand by a thousandth of a percent to be one of the biggest, if not the biggest, causes of increase in sea level.

So, how long would an immediate 1C rise in air and land surface temperature would it take to suffuse through the oceans? As you've pointed out, that's a lot more water than air and surface combined. Would it take ten, twenty, fifty years? Would that expansion even be noticeable to a normal human? Where is the 20-foot wall of water coming from, then? It sure won't be from thermal expansion.

I think you're also ignoring a lot of the complexities of heat transfer by only considering radiation. Conduction from air to ocean may not be huge, but it will happen. More important will be conduction from the land to the ocean. I also haven't noticed any mention of currents. There can be no doubt that the equator is hotter than the poles. Warm currents flow from the hotter areas to the colder ones, and carry a hell of a lot of heat with them, not always at the surface.

All these phenomena are already happening and have been happening from time immemorial. So, they will drop out of the equation as they will be additive or multiplicative to both sides (before and after). That leaves us with considering the temperature of the atmosphere and land surface. Also, don't forget that heat carried from the tropics means less heat in the tropics, too.
 
Here's a novel idea, why don't you go and read it to find out? Mhaze hasn't exactly been outstanding so far with his "interpretation" of the various reports on this subject that have been discussed.

Instead of gnashing your teeth you could go and read what they did, go to the papers where the methodology is stated and then you could see if there was a problem or not with it. My guess is that you'll find that your concerns are unfounded.

I've spent a lot of time on the IPCC report already. It's ruining my life on all fronts. I really don't want to go back.

That part of my post was my way of asking for help to see if anyone had a direct quote or something tangible to offer on that claim. If you don't, then you don't. No worries. No need to post under those circumstances.
 
I've spent a lot of time on the IPCC report already. It's ruining my life on all fronts. I really don't want to go back.

That part of my post was my way of asking for help to see if anyone had a direct quote or something tangible to offer on that claim. If you don't, then you don't. No worries. No need to post under those circumstances.

Ok, so the very same table that Mhaze has pulled his figures from is in Chapter 5 of the report. It's table 5.3. It's right there for anyone to look at if they so care to on the IPCC site. I'm not sure that that was the claim that Mhaze was trying to make anyway.

ETA: Really I just find it kind of weird that you take Mhaze at his word and then editorialise about how suspicious the implications of his statement make you feel without actually bothering to find out whether what he said has any basis in reality or not. I don't see how it advances the discussion at all, other than it muddies the waters further than they already are.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure Slime's questions are directly related to my assertions. You may be reading too much into it. The simple question is, where does the alarming 20 foot sea level rise actually come from?

The 20 foot sea level rise that Hansen pontificates about doesn't come from thermal expansion of water. He has to be imagining some serious ice sheet melting.

From Wiki - a rehash of what we went into in more depth. Bold is mine.
The current rise in sea level observed from tide gauges, of about 1.8 mm/yr, is within the estimate range from the combination of factors above[5] but active research continues in this field. The uncertainty in the terrestrial storage term is particularly large.

Since 1992 the TOPEX and JASON satellite programs have provided measurements of sea level change. Current data are available.[6] The data show a mean sea level increase of 2.9±0.4 mm/yr. However, because significant short-term variability in sea level can occur, this recent increase does not necessarily indicate a long-term acceleration in sea level changes.
​
 
Ok, so the very same table that Mhaze has pulled his figures from is in Chapter 5 of the report. It's table 5.3. It's right there for anyone to look at if they so care to on the IPCC site. I'm not sure that that was the claim that Mhaze was trying to make anyway.

ETA: Really I just find it kind of weird that you take Mhaze at his word and then editorialise about how suspicious the implications of his statement make you feel without actually bothering to find out whether what he said has any basis in reality or not. I don't see how it advances the discussion at all, other than it muddies the waters further than they already are.

Could you post a link, please? I tried finding it in the 1991 report that Cuddles linked to but that's obviously the wrong one.

Don't take this personally but I'm not a debunker or psychic. I take people's claims at face value unless they've been shown to be less than claimed. Up to this point, no one has effectively rebutted mhaze's assertion and it's been a while since he made it. You're the first one who seems to be trying, though I need a linkie. If you are still dissatisfied, send me a postage-paid self-addressed envelope, I'll send you all your money back.
 
Last edited:
ETA: Really I just find it kind of weird that you take Mhaze at his word and then editorialise about how suspicious the implications of his statement make you feel without actually bothering to find out whether what he said has any basis in reality or not. I don't see how it advances the discussion at all, other than it muddies the waters further than they already are.

You noticed that too?
 
I'm not sure Slime's questions are directly related to my assertions. You may be reading too much into it. The simple question is, where does the alarming 20 foot sea level rise actually come from?

The 20 foot sea level rise that Hansen pontificates about doesn't come from thermal expansion of water. He has to be imagining some serious ice sheet melting.

Thanks for clarifying. At this point, I'm not doing too well on keeping claims separate in my pointy little head. I'm working with a 20-ft wall of water, 50% of which is due to thermal expansion thereof. The second part is what I'm dubious about. I don't believe enough of the ocean will be affected in enough time to be part of that wall.

Don't get me wrong. I have nothing against walls of water. Some of my best friends are mostly water. :D
 
No, no, no. IR does not penetrate kilometers. IR will only heat the very top of the ocean. Conduction makes little sense as far as warming oceans because the heat capacity of water is huge compared to air.

Leave a pan of cold water in the dark exposed to warm air as it's only source of heat energy and see how quickly it warms. The conduction effect may be small, but it's not negligible. (Make sure the pan's not in a draught.)

I agree that a meter over a thousand years is not a problem. However, that's still a whopping temperature difference.

Not when you consider what a vast amount of water is involved. That metre is the merest skim on the surface - but it's more than half my height, and about 15% of my current positon above mean high-tide level. Ocean turnover is on the order of a thousand years apart from the deepest trenches, and they'll gain heat-energy from conduction within the ocean.


Really, I have no clue as to how much expansion leads to what rise in the mean tide but, frankly, I don't buy that it's going to account for 50% of the total change in sea level, especially over less than 10C. You've seen the chart. The expansion of water over 10C is negligible.

Again, consider the volume involved. I'm not concerned with the proportion here, just the absolute amount. Is a metre credible for a 2C increase in surface temperatures? I don't see why it's incredible.

If it only turns out to be half a metre that's not nothing.

I've reduced the heating of the sea to Beer's Law which is plainly how much IR the water will absorb. Don't tell me the air will heat the sea efficiently as that doesn't happen due to the difference in heat capacity.

It will heat the sea, efficiently or not.

It would take a monstrous amount of air contacting a very small amount of ocean to impart detectable heat in said water. Remember my example of one mole of water taking up 0.018 L at room temp but 22.4 L as gas?

Another complication to the Beer's Law reductive model : consider the throughput of water from ocean (liquid-phase) to atmosphere (gas-phase) back to ocean (warmer rain from a warmer atmosphere). It's quite a lot - 24,000 times 70 million tons per diem, IIRC. Tiny in comparison to total ocean volume, no doubt, but not so much in comparison to the volume directly warmed by radiation.

That's what you're looking at. Is the ocean temperature the same as the air temperature where you live?

Sometimes warmer, sometimes cooler. If both are below body-temperature the water will feel cooler (absent any wind) because it conducts heat more rapidly. Thermometers are impartial and tell the true story.

No, I'm not treating it as a solid. That's what Schneibster did and I challenged him on it. (And why he stalked off.) Even if you were to heat the ocean km deep, all the heat would rise to the top because it's a fluid. Same as when you boild water for tea. That's why ice floats. Cool water is denser than hot water.

Why, then, hasn't all the heat-energy currently in the oceans risen to the surface? In reality there's a temperature gradient across depth, and I see no reason to think there wouldn't be a similar gradient at a warmer average temperature. The only reason we've got liquid oceans at all is the greenhouse effect, so that's nothing new in itself, not would there be anything special about an increased effect.

Anybody have any numbers for me?

Forty-two :).

If my physics is at fault in principle I'm sure Schneibster will put me right on it. I am (relatively speaking) a dilettante, but a well-informed one.
 
Thanks for clarifying. At this point, I'm not doing too well on keeping claims separate in my pointy little head. I'm working with a 20-ft wall of water, 50% of which is due to thermal expansion thereof.

To save me having to plough back the thread, where do you get that from?

As I understand it numbers like seven (metres) come from the melting of land-locked ice on a major scale, which is only marginally (:)) related to ocean temperatures.

The second part is what I'm dubious about. I don't believe enough of the ocean will be affected in enough time to be part of that wall.

Whatever increase there is, there will be a thermal component. The greater the contribution of land-locked ice-melt, the lower the proportion of the thermal component, and I see no mechanism by which the latter will always be equivalent to the former. Surely nobody would claim that ice-melt can be reduced to Beer's Law, and no other linkage is obvious.
 
Leave a pan of cold water in the dark exposed to warm air as it's only source of heat energy and see how quickly it warms. The conduction effect may be small, but it's not negligible. (Make sure the pan's not in a draught.)

Now, all I have to do is to make sure that this pan of water is in a pan that's only as conductive as earth and exposes only the water's surface to air. Simple. ;)

Not when you consider what a vast amount of water is involved. That metre is the merest skim on the surface - but it's more than half my height, and about 15% of my current positon above mean high-tide level. Ocean turnover is on the order of a thousand years apart from the deepest trenches, and they'll gain heat-energy from conduction within the ocean.

Please stop with this argument. It's useless. I know there's a lot of water in the ocean. I am not convinced it will be wholly involved with warming. I can't put it much more succinctly than that. We'll work only with that amount of water that will reasonably keep pace with the warming of the surface.

If it only turns out to be half a metre that's not nothing.

Great. There's a tree near you that's grown that much in the last five years. Did you notice?

It will heat the sea, efficiently or not.

I didn't say that air would not heat the sea. I said it would be negligible heating.

Another complication to the Beer's Law reductive model : consider the throughput of water from ocean (liquid-phase) to atmosphere (gas-phase) back to ocean (warmer rain from a warmer atmosphere). It's quite a lot - 24,000 times 70 million tons per diem, IIRC. Tiny in comparison to total ocean volume, no doubt, but not so much in comparison to the volume directly warmed by radiation.

Oh, dear. Evaporation cooling the sea and the water returning as precipitation for a net gain of energy?
 
More than a few of us have :). Not every source gets the McIntyre Treatment (if I can so eponymise) of intimate inspection, just the discomforting ones. Pseudo-scepticism, I calls it.

Same offer for you, CD. You gets all your money back if for any reason I'm not living up to your lofty standards.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom