Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

I think you're also ignoring a lot of the complexities of heat transfer by only considering radiation. Conduction from air to ocean may not be huge, but it will happen.

The only question being : is it negligible? Slimething thinks so; I've yet to be convinced one way or the other.

More important will be conduction from the land to the ocean.

Milking the pun again, will this be more than marginal?

Recalling days on the beach, the family theory (aka my Dad's, passed on from his Dad) was that the high-tide sea would be warmer than the low-tide, and it seemed to be borne out be experience (although for all I know that was a placebo effect). And there's a lot of land between low- and high-tide marks. But is it enough to have a significant effect?

I also haven't noticed any mention of currents. There can be no doubt that the equator is hotter than the poles. Warm currents flow from the hotter areas to the colder ones, and carry a hell of a lot of heat with them, not always at the surface.

Slimething's argument is based (as I understand it) on the heat-energy input to the ocean, not its redistribution. Currents and overturning affect the surface ocean temperature, but I don't think that's relevant to Beer's Law. It's relevant when we consider conduction from atmosphere and land to ocean - the steeper the heat-gradient, the greater the heat-flow (one of Newton's Laws) - which brings us back to whether that's negligible. If so, Beer's Law is a good approximation; if not, it ain't.

I don't have the numbers available to judge - and I don't think Slimething has either.
 
Same offer for you, CD.

You're offering something? Apart from easy openings? I'm agog.

You gets all your money back ...

I don't recall letting slip my grip on any of it.

... if for any reason I'm not living up to your lofty standards.

Nobody lives up to my standards, not even me. I try, though, and when I come to a firm conclusion - as I occasionally do - I'm very seldom wrong. The older and wiser I get, the more occasional the conclusions and the less often wrong. It's a motto of mine that almost every statement should contain some degree of equivocation.

I haven't nailed my flag to AGW without due consideration. It exposes me to being proved wrong, and I really hate that. Only events will prove me wrong, though, and they haven't come close yet. Nor will they in the next three-to-eight years (and beyond). Mark my words.

Events won't prove me right, to the satisfaction of you and your ilk, but that doesn't concern me. They won't put me on the defensive, and that's the position those of the anti-AGW persuasion has been in for two decades now.
 
http://www.ecd.bnl.gov/steve/pubs/HeatCapacity.pdf

This is Schwartz's paper, Heat Capacity, in which he backs out climate sensitivity to 1.1C plus or minus a bit.

Opening himself up to being proved wrong by events - to his credit.

He uses only the top 110 meters of the ocean in his analysis and doesn't think the deeper waters are relevant.

Which is where he'll be proved wrong, if that's the only assumption he's depending on. Climate sensitivity (for the standard doubling of CO2) is about 2.5C.

Has Schwartz's paper been subject to the McIntyre Treatment? Or are you happy with it anyway?
 
Opening himself up to being proved wrong by events - to his credit.

Which is where he'll be proved wrong, if that's the only assumption he's depending on. Climate sensitivity (for the standard doubling of CO2) is about 2.5C.

Has Schwartz's paper been subject to the McIntyre Treatment? Or are you happy with it anyway?

Subject matter of Schwartz isn't allowed on CA, for the most part.

No thermo or CO2 discussion, except to identify interesting references.

The idea seems to be that if no one can identify where...
Climate sensitivity (for doubling of CO2) is about 2.5C.
​
Came from, there is simply no reason to discuss it.

It's a belief, not science?
 
Now, all I have to do is to make sure that this pan of water is in a pan that's only as conductive as earth and exposes only the water's surface to air. Simple. ;)

Any ceramic bowl will do for that.

Please stop with this argument.

You first.

It's useless. I know there's a lot of water in the ocean. I am not convinced it will be wholly involved with warming. I can't put it much more succinctly than that. We'll work only with that amount of water that will reasonably keep pace with the warming of the surface.

I'm considering the amount of water that will respond to surface warming, which means taking into account ocean overturning which transports warmed water into the ocean depths and brings cold water to the surface.

Great. There's a tree near you that's grown that much in the last five years. Did you notice?

The relevance eludes me. I have two pear trees and a holly tree that I cut back about half a metre every year, lest they dominate everything. I cut back my bay-tree every few weeks - they grow like smoke.

I didn't say that air would not heat the sea. I said it would be negligible heating.

The assumption we differ on. You have to assume it to make a reduction to Beer's Law viable. I've yet to see the assumption justified.

Oh, dear. Evaporation cooling the sea and the water returning as precipitation for a net gain of energy?

Yes. Condensation returns the energy of evaporation to the atmosphere, and in the meantime the gas-phase water has absorbed energy by conduction from the atmosphere. When you think about it, two of those terms cancel out, leaving the external warming of the atmosphere to transfer energy to water-vapour. Which is why a warmer atmosphere delivers warmer rain.
 
Any ceramic bowl will do for that.

If packed in earth, yes.

I'm considering the amount of water that will respond to surface warming, which means taking into account ocean overturning which transports warmed water into the ocean depths and brings cold water to the surface.

Nope. Linkie.

The assumption we differ on. You have to assume it to make a reduction to Beer's Law viable. I've yet to see the assumption justified.

No, you don't have to assume it to make Beer's Law viable. The absorption of IR radiation by sea water will occur whether or not air heats water negligibly or predominantly. What you and I disagree on is to what degree air warms the oceans, regardless of radiative warming. They would be two separate and independent mechanisms. Two additive terms in the equation, if you will. Conduction would be yet another term. To me, Beer's Law would be used to predict the penetration of IR into the ocean's surface, not the warming thereof. The warming is easy as you can assume 100% absorption due to the sea's depth.

Yes. Condensation returns the energy of evaporation to the atmosphere, and in the meantime the gas-phase water has absorbed energy by conduction from the atmosphere. When you think about it, two of those terms cancel out, leaving the external warming of the atmosphere to transfer energy to water-vapour. Which is why a warmer atmosphere delivers warmer rain.

Nice hypothesis. Too bad the heat of vaporization of water is about nine times the heat of fusion. IOW, the raindrop would have to be eight times warmer than it left to give you your zero-sum system, as advertised above. One might even wonder why it doesn't rain everywhere all the time!
 
Last edited:
Subject matter of Schwartz isn't allowed on CA, for the most part.

Why would this matter to a normal person? I explicitly eponymised McIntyre, not ClimateAudit.

No thermo or CO2 discussion, except to identify interesting references.

I think you're mistaking supportive for interesting.


The idea seems to be that if no one can identify where...
Climate sensitivity (for doubling of CO2) is about 2.5C.​
Came from, there is simply no reason to discuss it.

There's historical evidence for it. I thought you put a lot of store by historical evidence.

It's a belief, not science?

It's certainly not an assumption. It's derived, just as Schwartz's 1.1C is derived but without any need to assume that consideration be limited to the top 110m of the ocean. In fact it doesn't need any assumption of how much of the ocean is considered. Which makes it a lot more robust than Schwartz's derivation.
 
Subject matter of Schwartz isn't allowed on CA, for the most part.

No thermo or CO2 discussion, except to identify interesting references.

The idea seems to be that if no one can identify where...
Climate sensitivity (for doubling of CO2) is about 2.5C.
​
Came from, there is simply no reason to discuss it.

It's a belief, not science?

It's more a case of, he has no idea of climate science, so he'll just ignore it.
 
Nope. Linkie.

QUOTE]

from your linkie to the next link

Linkie

Tim Osborne; said:
The water cools, mixes with cold water coming from the Arctic Ocean, and becomes so dense that it sinks, both to the south and east of Greenland.
If we zoom out, we see that this current is part of a larger system, connecting the North Atlantic...
...the tropical Atlantic...
...the South Atlantic...
...the Indian and Pacific Oceans...
...and the Southern Ocean. Further sinking of dense water occurs near to Antarctica.


If we look below the surface, water from the two main sinking regions spreads out in the subsurface ocean...
...affecting almost all the world's oceans at depths from 1000m and below...
The cold, dense water gradually warms and returns to the surface, througout the world's oceans.
The surface and subsurface currents, the sinking regions, and the return of water to the surface form a closed loop, the thermohaline circulation or global thermohaline conveyor belt.

CD may have missed that the warm water mixes with cold water before it sinks.


It may take awhile but the oceans will warm all the way through
 
I'm not sure Slime's questions are directly related to my assertions. You may be reading too much into it. The simple question is, where does the alarming 20 foot sea level rise actually come from?

The 20 foot sea level rise that Hansen pontificates about doesn't come from thermal expansion of water. He has to be imagining some serious ice sheet melting.

From Wiki - a rehash of what we went into in more depth. Bold is mine.
The current rise in sea level observed from tide gauges, of about 1.8 mm/yr, is within the estimate range from the combination of factors above[5] but active research continues in this field. The uncertainty in the terrestrial storage term is particularly large.

Since 1992 the TOPEX and JASON satellite programs have provided measurements of sea level change. Current data are available.[6] The data show a mean sea level increase of 2.9±0.4 mm/yr. However, because significant short-term variability in sea level can occur, this recent increase does not necessarily indicate a long-term acceleration in sea level changes.
​

The Summary for Policy makers says pretty much the exact same thing. Funny that if they were trying to made it all scaremongery don't you think?

Global average sea level rose at an average rate of 1.8
[1.3 to 2.3] mm per year over 1961 to 2003. The rate
was faster over 1993 to 2003: about 3.1 [2.4 to 3.8]
mm per year. Whether the faster rate for 1993 to 2003
reflects decadal variability or an increase in the longerterm
trend is unclear.
There is high confidence that
the rate of observed sea level rise increased from the
19th to the 20th century. The total 20th-century rise is
estimated to be 0.17 [0.12 to 0.22] m. {5.5}
http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-spm.pdf

Bolding mine. :p I don't know why you've suddenly seemed to accept that "significant short-term variability in sea level can occur" now you've read it at wikipedia, when I've been trying to tell you that for the last couple of pages or so based on the IPCC report and journal papers.
 
Could you post a link, please? I tried finding it in the 1991 report that Cuddles linked to but that's obviously the wrong one.

Don't take this personally but I'm not a debunker or psychic. I take people's claims at face value unless they've been shown to be less than claimed. Up to this point, no one has effectively rebutted mhaze's assertion and it's been a while since he made it. You're the first one who seems to be trying, though I need a linkie. If you are still dissatisfied, send me a postage-paid self-addressed envelope, I'll send you all your money back.

Oh, I thought I had spent the last couple of pages or so showing with quotes and references that his claims weren't all they were cracked up to be. My mistake obviously. Anyway, the IPCC reports are all accessable from the IPCC website surprisingly enough.

http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-chapter5.pdf

Table 5.3 bottom of page 419, or 38 of the pdf.

The 50% contribution to sea level rise from thermal expansion is taken from observations. it's what they think is hapening now, or happened over the last ten years or so. Figure 5.19, top of page 31 of the pdf shows the variation in sea level rise due to thermal expansion for the last 50 years or so. It varies quite a lot. Mhaze seems to think this is impossible, yet it has already happened. Figure 5.1, bottom of page 6 of the PDF show variation in heat content of the ocean for the top 700 m for the past 50 years or so. It also seems to vary a fair amount.

At the very least if you follow some of the references back it might give you an idea of the methodology used for taking the temperature measurements and the sea level measurements and calculating the amount of thermal expansion. They probably summarise it in that chapter of the report itself somewhere, the appendices are usually good for that.
 
Thanks for the numbers. Do you have any estimate on how much sea levels will rise per volume of expansion or even water? That's the numbers we need.

I'm not sure what you mean. "Per volume of expansion or even water"?

I didn't say it didn't heat up. I said the air isn't doing that much. It's the sunshine!

If you agree that it does heat up, I don't see that it really matters what that is due to.

So, how long would an immediate 1C rise in air and land surface temperature would it take to suffuse through the oceans? As you've pointed out, that's a lot more water than air and surface combined. Would it take ten, twenty, fifty years? Would that expansion even be noticeable to a normal human? Where is the 20-foot wall of water coming from, then? It sure won't be from thermal expansion.

I have no idea about any 20 foot wall of water. The figures I quoted from the IPCC clearly state a total sea level increase of between 0.1-0.8m (from 1990 to 2100). As for whether it is noticeable to a normal human, it depends very much on the situation. Someone living in Switzerland, for example, wouldn't notice a change of several metres. On the other hand, a friend at work recently had his house flooded, but would not have if the water had been just a couple of centimetres lower.

All these phenomena are already happening and have been happening from time immemorial. So, they will drop out of the equation as they will be additive or multiplicative to both sides (before and after). That leaves us with considering the temperature of the atmosphere and land surface. Also, don't forget that heat carried from the tropics means less heat in the tropics, too.

It is irrelevant that these things have always been present. The air has always been present, but you're not ignoring that. This comes to the time it would take for any increase in temperature to spread throughout the ocean. You seem to be assuming that only the surface will be heated and that the heat transfer within the ocean is solely conduction and is very slow. This is not the case. There is a lot of mixing, with various different currents, upwellings and so on. I don't know how fast the whole ocean will heat up, but you are ignoring several factors, all of which are likely to speed this up.
 
The 50% contribution to sea level rise from thermal expansion is taken from observations. it's what they think is hapening now, or happened over the last ten years or so. Figure 5.19, top of page 31 of the pdf shows the variation in sea level rise due to thermal expansion for the last 50 years or so. It varies quite a lot. Mhaze seems to think this is impossible, yet it has already happened. Figure 5.1, bottom of page 6 of the PDF show variation in heat content of the ocean for the top 700 m for the past 50 years or so. It also seems to vary a fair amount.

There was no instantaneous change of thermal expansion from say, 25% of total sea level increase to 50% as of 1993 at the exact moment when the method of measurement of the supposedly identical phenomena changed from tide-based to satellite radar atimetry.

The changes in 1993 were both in the item measured and the method of measurement -
  1. Areas measured - the wide ocean not the shores
  2. Method - Satellite instead of tide gauge
Pretty substantial changes would you not agree? By the way. Your assertion that there could be a hidden "hokey stick" in the table is false, unless there was virtually no sea level rise until 1993.

Noting the above, we agree that the actual scientists do qualify and caution their work, do note that it is too early to hold that there is an accelerating rate of sea level rise and that decadal changes are very significant.
 
I'm not sure what you mean. "Per volume of expansion or even water"?



If you agree that it does heat up, I don't see that it really matters what that is due to.



I have no idea about any 20 foot wall of water. The figures I quoted from the IPCC clearly state a total sea level increase of between 0.1-0.8m (from 1990 to 2100). As for whether it is noticeable to a normal human, it depends very much on the situation. Someone living in Switzerland, for example, wouldn't notice a change of several metres. On the other hand, a friend at work recently had his house flooded, but would not have if the water had been just a couple of centimetres lower.



It is irrelevant that these things have always been present. The air has always been present, but you're not ignoring that. This comes to the time it would take for any increase in temperature to spread throughout the ocean. You seem to be assuming that only the surface will be heated and that the heat transfer within the ocean is solely conduction and is very slow. This is not the case. There is a lot of mixing, with various different currents, upwellings and so on. I don't know how fast the whole ocean will heat up, but you are ignoring several factors, all of which are likely to speed this up.

From the Encyclopedia of Geomorphology
  • 1C increase upper 500m of oceans == sea level rise of about 100mm
  • 1C increase entire ocean depth == 200 mm10C increase entire ocean depth == 8 meters
My guess: A 10 foot sea level increase due to thermal expansion might require heating the entire ocean depth 5C.

20 foot walls of water cannot be predicated on thermal expansions.
 
20 foot walls of water cannot be predicated on thermal expansions.
I scanned the last few pages and so far as I can tell, this 20 ft wall of water -- 80 ft by 2050 according to Hansen according to you -- is a tag-team strawman creation. About 4 pages ago you start piling up the straw, sans link of course. It looks so fun that Lucifuge joins in. And then Slimething adds the amusing little "wall" touch, like a tsunami I guess, which you merrily echo back.

I'm sure you'll tell me if I got this wrong. Please include a link this time so I can see for myself if Hansen predicted an 80' sea level rise by 2050, wall or otherwise.
 
Oh, I thought I had spent the last couple of pages or so showing with quotes and references that his claims weren't all they were cracked up to be. My mistake obviously. Anyway, the IPCC reports are all accessable from the IPCC website surprisingly enough.

http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-chapter5.pdf

Table 5.3 bottom of page 419, or 38 of the pdf.

The 50% contribution to sea level rise from thermal expansion is taken from observations. it's what they think is hapening now, or happened over the last ten years or so. Figure 5.19, top of page 31 of the pdf shows the variation in sea level rise due to thermal expansion for the last 50 years or so. It varies quite a lot. Mhaze seems to think this is impossible, yet it has already happened. Figure 5.1, bottom of page 6 of the PDF show variation in heat content of the ocean for the top 700 m for the past 50 years or so. It also seems to vary a fair amount.

At the very least if you follow some of the references back it might give you an idea of the methodology used for taking the temperature measurements and the sea level measurements and calculating the amount of thermal expansion. They probably summarise it in that chapter of the report itself somewhere, the appendices are usually good for that.

Thanks for the linky. You're right, if I read the report first, I wouldn't need to argue with a lot of the extreme misrepresentations of what that report says. I found it to be a much more tempered analysis than what I've gotten from most here. For example:


For the period 1961 to 2003, the average contribution of thermal expansion to sea level rise was 0.4 ± 0.1 mm yr
–1. As reported in the TAR, it is likely that the sum of all known contributions for this period is smaller than the observed sea level rise, and therefore it is not possible to satisfactorily account for the processes causing sea level rise.

Also, the report makes it fairly plain that it's primarily the top 700 m of ocean that are involved in thermal expanson. (Just because the water column data is taken for the top 3 Km, does not mean that the entire water column is involved.)

There is some speculation in the report, though, but it's plainly admitted. One cannot ascribe a cause for sea level rise from observation alone. Frankly, I get the feeling that thermal expansion of the seas is being used as a fudge factor to account for sea level rise that is not accounted for from land ice melt. I seriously question the quadrupling of the rate presented for shorter time periods as seen in the Table 5.2. (I will always believe a trend measured over fifty years more than a trend measured over ten, especially if the claimed difference between rates is four-fold.)

So, again I ask, how on earth can anyone with a brain believe that flooding from GW will be a huge problem and that thermal expansion of about half a mm per year will be a significant contributor to that problem?​
​
​

 
I'm not sure what you mean. "Per volume of expansion or even water"?

I meant that, if we calculate the expansion of the ocean, that result will be in cubic measure. How do we convert that to a one-diimensional result of mean tidal increase? That last bit of sloppy writing is supposed to ask how we differentiate thermal expansion from addition of water from terrestrial ice melt.

If you agree that it does heat up, I don't see that it really matters what that is due to.

Very true but there are some on this thread who believe that conduction from air is going to significantly compete with IR absorption. Maybe not your claim but it has been made.

I have no idea about any 20 foot wall of water. The figures I quoted from the IPCC clearly state a total sea level increase of between 0.1-0.8m (from 1990 to 2100).

Fine. I'm not disputing their estimate there because I haven't studied how they came up with it. (And I don't intend to.) I'm disputing that thermal expansion will be a significant contributor. I forget who but someone posted that thermal expansion of water is supposed to contribute about half to the total sea level rise. That's not credible to me.

As for whether it is noticeable to a normal human, it depends very much on the situation. Someone living in Switzerland, for example, wouldn't notice a change of several metres. On the other hand, a friend at work recently had his house flooded, but would not have if the water had been just a couple of centimetres lower.

Tell him next time to put ice cubes around his house. ;)


It is irrelevant that these things have always been present.

No it's not irrelevant. These mechanisms have always been around so they're not being introduced by GW. You would have them contributing to both the pre and post scenarios and would, therefore, cancel out. They would have to change due to GW and then you would consider only the change.

The air has always been present, but you're not ignoring that.

Yes, air temperature would change, therefore it would contribute to the warmth of the planet. Unlike sea currents that would not change, air becomes a variable.

This comes to the time it would take for any increase in temperature to spread throughout the ocean. You seem to be assuming that only the surface will be heated and that the heat transfer within the ocean is solely conduction and is very slow. This is not the case. There is a lot of mixing, with various different currents, upwellings and so on. I don't know how fast the whole ocean will heat up, but you are ignoring several factors, all of which are likely to speed this up.

So, again I ask you, how much time would that be. I can also ask you why I should care. Heat is heat and you can only expand so much water at a time. If you did the math, you'd find out that assuming that only the top of the ocean warms better fits a cataclysmic flooding scenario. But, have it your way. Calculate the sea rise from the entire ocean aborbing the incident radiation. No cheating, though. Don't use temperature measurments. Use Joules. You'll see what I mean.

BTW, the IPCC report states that only the top 700 m of ocean make a significant contribution to thermal expansion. Tell them they're nuts too.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom