Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

:bigclap
Slimething you have showed everybody here the real nature of Schneibster. You completely beat him and he just does what every religious fanatic does: He tell yow how mean to he you are (BUAHAHAHAHAHA) and them refuses to acknowledge any point. And since this point is central to the AGW alarmisn (remember that the sea level will go up 20ft and destroy lots of cities and countries?) he simply runs away like a little yellow chicken.

Congratulations!

Rubbish. He just demonstrated the limits of science specialisation. Don't ask a chemist to explain global warming to you, he won't understand a lot of the science.
 
:bigclap
Slimething you have showed everybody here the real nature of Schneibster. You completely beat him and he just does what every religious fanatic does: He tell yow how mean to he you are (BUAHAHAHAHAHA) and them refuses to acknowledge any point. And since this point is central to the AGW alarmisn (remember that the sea level will go up 20ft and destroy lots of cities and countries?) he simply runs away like a little yellow chicken.

Congratulations!

Thanks for the support, LR, but that wasn't my goal. Schneibster does know his physics but his education is not well rounded. He seems to believe that physics formulae can be context-free. In the case of the expansion of the oceans, he believes that an assumption that oceans are solids and that a calorie input at the surface will result in a calorie at the nadir is within reason and I don't accept that. That's why we boil water by putting pots on burners, not under broilers.

I have no idea what ails the man. All I know is that I'll get my science elsewhere until he learns how to deal with reality over books.
 
Rubbish. He just demonstrated the limits of science specialisation. Don't ask a chemist to explain global warming to you, he won't understand a lot of the science.

Is this how you really feel, AUP? When a chemist asks a question based on documented physical constants that a pseudo-physicist reacts to negatively, that's proof that the chemist is ignorant? Simple question: how can the thermal expansion of oceans contribute much to flooding? Radiative warming will only penetrate so far (need a composite extinction coefficient for IR in water here to calculate) and water just doesn't expand that much. (Must you use a gallon pot to contain one half gallon water that you'ver brought to a simmer?)

So, really, instead of reading so many reports, you should think about what they're saying and compare what they are hypothesizing with everyday-life microcosms of those phenomena. This really isn't rocket-science! At least, not the sea-expansion bit. I reserve judgment on the AGW bit in its entirety.
 
I merely asked how this can possibly be the case as seas are primarily water and water doen't expand that much with temperature. Can you explain it?

It's explained by the fact that there's so much water in the oceans. it doesn't have to expand by much to make a significant difference in human terms. An extra metre, say, on all those kilometres of average depth isn't much at all. But up here where we live - above the surface - it has an impact. East Anglia becomes an archipelago, and Bangladesh becomes mostly history.

The question then becomes how much of the oceans warms, and how quickly, if we're considering the next century. A metre over a thousand years, not a problem, that'll be a different world anyway (in human terms); a metre over a century is a very different matter.

You've reduced the problem (as I understand it) to Beer's Law, which assumes that the warming will be entirely down to ocean absorption of radiation through its surface. To my mind it's rather more complicated than that. Firstly there's conduction (from atmosphere to ocean and down from there, thermal inversion notwithstanding), then there's the constant churning of the first few hundred metres by weather and currents, and then there's the steady overturning of surface and deep-water.

It seems to me that you're treating the ocean as a solid slab, which it isn't. It's nowhere near as responsive as the atmosphere to energy accumulation, but it's far more mobile than a solid, such as the Earth's land-surface - which is itself sufficiently responsive to provide a measurable record of local climate change via boreholes.
 
It's explained by the fact that there's so much water in the oceans. it doesn't have to expand by much to make a significant difference in human terms. An extra metre, say, on all those kilometres of average depth isn't much at all.

No, no, no. IR does not penetrate kilometers. IR will only heat the very top of the ocean. Conduction makes little sense as far as warming oceans because the heat capacity of water is huge compared to air.

The question then becomes how much of the oceans warms, and how quickly, if we're considering the next century. A metre over a thousand years, not a problem, that'll be a different world anyway (in human terms); a metre over a century is a very different matter.

I agree that a meter over a thousand years is not a problem. However, that's still a whopping temperature difference. Really, I have no clue as to how much expansion leads to what rise in the mean tide but, frankly, I don't buy that it's going to account for 50% of the total change in sea level, especially over less than 10C. You've seen the chart. The expansion of water over 10C is negligible.

You've reduced the problem (as I understand it) to Beer's Law, which assumes that the warming will be entirely down to ocean absorption of radiation through its surface. To my mind it's rather more complicated than that. Firstly there's conduction (from atmosphere to ocean and down from there, thermal inversion notwithstanding), then there's the constant churning of the first few hundred metres by weather and currents, and then there's the steady overturning of surface and deep-water.

I've reduced the heating of the sea to Beer's Law which is plainly how much IR the water will absorb. Don't tell me the air will heat the sea efficiently as that doesn't happen due to the difference in heat capacity. It would take a monstrous amount of air contacting a very small amount of ocean to impart detectable heat in said water. Remember my example of one mole of water taking up 0.018 L at room temp but 22.4 L as gas? That's what you're looking at. Is the ocean temperature the same as the air temperature where you live?

It seems to me that you're treating the ocean as a solid slab, which it isn't. It's nowhere near as responsive as the atmosphere to energy accumulation, but it's far more mobile than a solid, such as the Earth's land-surface - which is itself sufficiently responsive to provide a measurable record of local climate change via boreholes.

No, I'm not treating it as a solid. That's what Schneibster did and I challenged him on it. (And why he stalked off.) Even if you were to heat the ocean km deep, all the heat would rise to the top because it's a fluid. Same as when you boild water for tea. That's why ice floats. Cool water is denser than hot water.

Anybody have any numbers for me?
 
Is this how you really feel, AUP? When a chemist asks a question based on documented physical constants that a pseudo-physicist reacts to negatively, that's proof that the chemist is ignorant? Simple question: how can the thermal expansion of oceans contribute much to flooding? Radiative warming will only penetrate so far (need a composite extinction coefficient for IR in water here to calculate) and water just doesn't expand that much. (Must you use a gallon pot to contain one half gallon water that you'ver brought to a simmer?)

So, really, instead of reading so many reports, you should think about what they're saying and compare what they are hypothesizing with everyday-life microcosms of those phenomena. This really isn't rocket-science! At least, not the sea-expansion bit. I reserve judgment on the AGW bit in its entirety.

Would I ask an obstetrician to do open heart surgery?
 
Would I ask an obstetrician to do open heart surgery?

Your alternatives being? You'd have a lot better chance with an obstetrician than a chemist, that's for sure. However, let's not leave medicine to physicians, shall we? The just don't understand it as they're overspecialized. ;)
 
You dodged the point. ;)

Don't think so. You like simple scenarios with lotsa assumptions. I asked for more detail. Then I poked a little fun at you "logic".

This is too fun. Do you have any facts, logical arguments or calculations to share or do you just want to stop at "this science which I understand is too complicated for scientists"? :confused:
 
Don't think so. You like simple scenarios with lotsa assumptions. I asked for more detail. Then I poked a little fun at you "logic".

This is too fun. Do you have any facts, logical arguments or calculations to share or do you just want to stop at "this science which I understand is too complicated for scientists"? :confused:

I didn't say that. All I said was, science is so specialised these days, the ordinary, everyday scientist who is very clever cannot hope to move out of his specialisation very far without having to face up to the fact that he is out of his depth as far as knowing as much as the experts in that field. :confused:
 
Don't think so. You like simple scenarios with lotsa assumptions. I asked for more detail. Then I poked a little fun at you "logic".

This is too fun. Do you have any facts, logical arguments or calculations to share or do you just want to stop at "this science which I understand is too complicated for scientists"? :confused:

Didn't you know it's written in Latin and that only the anointed few can understand or interpret it?

Physicists, chemists, meteorologists, geologists, biologists, statisticians, mathematicians, engineers and just plain smart people are not qualified to comment because they aren't "climate" scientists. ;)
 
I didn't say that. All I said was, science is so specialised these days, the ordinary, everyday scientist who is very clever cannot hope to move out of his specialisation very far without having to face up to the fact that he is out of his depth as far as knowing as much as the experts in that field. :confused:

Well, AUP, if that's what you said, I fully agree. That's why I've chosen to discuss what I know about. Please note that I"ve only discussed coring for gases and the density of water (vis a vis, it's ability to expand). You won't catch me saying that the scientists at IPCC or whatever your favorite pro-AGW forum are idiots/ charlatans/ incompetent. I know that these scientists know climate better than moi but that doesn't mean that I can't kick the tires.

However, mhase has pointed out that this 50% contribution to flooding from thermal sea expansion occurs exclusively in the political debriefing section meant for decisionmakers. If, indeed, this claim does not occur in the scientific portion, I find that very suspect. Isn't a synopsis supposed to be a condensation of the long-winded technical part?

So, I think we understand each other. I agree with you I'm not a climatologist. And I'm grateful for that. Frankly, there are so many variables in predicting day-to-day weather let alone wholesale climate changes that I wish them all the luck in the world. Theirs is no easy task but I also think they're not close enough to good confidence for any of us to be too frightened about what is to come.

Don't be part of the problem (if there is a problem) but don't take the overly-dire predictions too much to heart either.
 
Didn't you know it's written in Latin and that only the anointed few can understand or interpret it?

Physicists, chemists, meteorologists, geologists, biologists, statisticians, mathematicians, engineers and just plain smart people are not qualified to comment because they aren't "climate" scientists. ;)

Hi, David!

AUP has clarified that is not what was meant. (That is what I took it to be but I was wrong.) Scientifically speaking, the whole damned mess (read multiverse) is supposed to fit together. Climatologists can't make water expand any more than I can make it contract.

See, this is what's great about this Forum! We can all come together and discuss this stuff rationally (or at least most of us). I don't really bring that much to the table here but I do know what I know and, by gum, I wanna know what's going on! Scaremongers like Gore really, really, really bother me and anything he champions smells to me.

So, we know for sure that industry is pumping all types of exhaust into the environment. AGW or no, wouldn't it be great if that stopped? Of course, but would you buy the more expensive regulated widget at Wal-Mart rather than the 20% cheaper widget from the non-regulated factory right next to it? Would enough people do that? (If not, the regulated business goes bust and the unregulated business now has total market share.)
 
Didn't you know it's written in Latin and that only the anointed few can understand or interpret it?

Physicists, chemists, meteorologists, geologists, biologists, statisticians, mathematicians, engineers and just plain smart people are not qualified to comment because they aren't "climate" scientists. ;)

A complete misrepresentation of what I said.
 
However, mhase has pointed out that this 50% contribution to flooding from thermal sea expansion occurs exclusively in the political debriefing section meant for decisionmakers. If, indeed, this claim does not occur in the scientific portion, I find that very suspect. Isn't a synopsis supposed to be a condensation of the long-winded technical part?

Here's a novel idea, why don't you go and read it to find out? Mhaze hasn't exactly been outstanding so far with his "interpretation" of the various reports on this subject that have been discussed.

Instead of gnashing your teeth you could go and read what they did, go to the papers where the methodology is stated and then you could see if there was a problem or not with it. My guess is that you'll find that your concerns are unfounded.
 
A complete misrepresentation of what I said.

Then we can expect no more ad hom attacks of authors of papers simply based on their title or nobility, right?

In other words for example, if a mathematician finds a grievous error in the calculations of a climate article, he is not disqualified because he is not a "climatologist". That's my point.
 
I have a pretty good idea:
To be really catastrophic, AGW should raise sea level in a catastrophic way. If it doesn't, then there is no reason to worry THAT MUCH about it and there can be adaptative changes that can minimize the problem. That's completely unacceptable in AGW religion so the theme is clearly avoided.
I was totally surprised when I saw that message from Schneibster. You were developing a very interesting discussion about sea level change, and suddenly with a lame excuse he manages to left your post unanswered. That says a lot about the robustness of his position, because, as Mhaze and others have realized, many of the AGW proponents here use a predefined script to deal with objections to the theory. They tend to minimize auditing, they defend the censure of the data, they attack the scientist who raises doubts about AGW instead of the science and they defend the threats and firing of scientifics who express doubts about AGW.

You can see the script they use searching in Google for "How to deal to a Global Warming sceptic".

Outside that, you can catch them with their pants down, and that's what you did.

I was in doubt of AGW because models are weak, they aren't validated (there are literally thousands of models, each one with a different outcome and predictions. When something happens, they can claim that "the model" predicted that, but they don't tell you which model and under what assumptions) and because the input data has been showed to be wrong due to errors in the methodology (Hockey Stick), errors in the data (proxies, Urban Heath effect and so on), bad programming, cherry picking, data torture and illegal data transformations.

By analyzing the real effect of increased heath in the ocean you have just showed that even if Hansen model is correct the outcome of the model is in error or there is a lot more explaining to do.



Thanks for the support, LR, but that wasn't my goal. Schneibster does know his physics but his education is not well rounded. He seems to believe that physics formulae can be context-free. In the case of the expansion of the oceans, he believes that an assumption that oceans are solids and that a calorie input at the surface will result in a calorie at the nadir is within reason and I don't accept that. That's why we boil water by putting pots on burners, not under broilers.

I have no idea what ails the man. All I know is that I'll get my science elsewhere until he learns how to deal with reality over books.
 
Some basic facts on Greenland.

Ice area. 1.71 m sq km
Ice volume. 2.85 m cu km
average thickness 1.67 km

Average altitude of ice above sea level 2135 meters
Lapse rate (decrease in temperature with altitude) 6.49C/1000 m
Avg. difference in C of ice sheet from sea level temps = 13.86C



These Greenland temperature recording stations are of course all on the coastlines. I don't have handy information as to whether they are at sea level or higher, but it seems plausible that they are all pretty much close to sea level.

Anyone want to take a bite at how enough energy could be put on that ice sheet to melt it down? How much of a "greenhouse effect?" What the effect of an increase in air temperature over this ice sheet of 5C would do?

Keep in mind that the north of Greenland is truly Arctic, the south can have somewhat temperate summertime, but overall, any increase in temperature is going to extend the number of days during which melting can occur fractionally. In other words if now there are 60 days in which melting can occur, after a 5C air temperature increase there might perhaps be 75-90 such days. Also note that increased temps mean increased snow, so the central ice sheet gets thicker.

Greenland temperatures
http://www.wunderground.com/global/GL.html

Temperatures in central Greenland
http://ff.org/centers/csspp/library/co2weekly/2005-09-15/trends.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom