Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Hansen promotes an erroneous theory of glacial and Greenland ice being "lubricated from below" by increased water runoff, then these huge masses of ice being slid faster downhill into the ocean until they are all gone.

Obviously he never understood plastic creep and it's relation to temperature.

So to answer your question

1. There are unscientific theories being promoted by the likes of Hansen, Lovelock and Gore on cryosphere dynamics
2. Using "tipping points", unproven hypthetical positive feedbacks, these incorrect theories are asserted to cause 20 foot sea level rise before 2050 (now I think Hansen is babbling about 80 foot sea level rise before 2050).

That's not pretty, but I think it's accurate.

PS: All of Greenland being added to the oceans would be a 7 meter or 20 some foot sea level rise.

from http://www.whoi.edu/oceanus/viewArticle.do?id=9126

Enlarge Image
Two glaciers that bring about 10 percent of the Greenland Ice Sheet to the ocean—the Jakobshavn Glacier on the west coast and the Kangerdlugssuaq Glacier on the east coast— have flowed two to three times faster in recent years. (Local ice caps and ice domes are shown in green. Ice-free areas are shown in dark gray). (United States Geological Survey)

So why are the glaciers in Greenland flowing faster in recent years?

And where and how big is Lake Vostok?
 
from http://www.whoi.edu/oceanus/viewArticle.do?id=9126

Enlarge Image
Two glaciers that bring about 10 percent of the Greenland Ice Sheet to the ocean—the Jakobshavn Glacier on the west coast and the Kangerdlugssuaq Glacier on the east coast— have flowed two to three times faster in recent years. (Local ice caps and ice domes are shown in green. Ice-free areas are shown in dark gray). (United States Geological Survey)

So why are the glaciers in Greenland flowing faster in recent years?

And where and how big is Lake Vostok?

Well, this is interesting indeed.

You have posted an article that asserts the "lubricated slide" theory is the effective mechanism.

Let's dig into this a bit.
 
from http://www.whoi.edu/oceanus/viewArticle.do?id=9126

Enlarge Image
Two glaciers that bring about 10 percent of the Greenland Ice Sheet to the ocean—the Jakobshavn Glacier on the west coast and the Kangerdlugssuaq Glacier on the east coast— have flowed two to three times faster in recent years. (Local ice caps and ice domes are shown in green. Ice-free areas are shown in dark gray). (United States Geological Survey)

So why are the glaciers in Greenland flowing faster in recent years?

And where and how big is Lake Vostok?

That was two years ago. What's it doing now?

What is the Arctic doing now?
http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.cfm?release=2007-131
"Our study confirms many changes seen in upper Arctic Ocean circulation in the 1990s were mostly decadal in nature, rather than trends caused by global warming," said Morison.

Hmm.
 
Last edited:
Schneib, what initially irritated me about this matter was the thermal expansion. If you look at the right hand column top, you will see that thermal expansion "suddenly jumped" from 0.4mm per year to 1.6mm per year.
That's an illusion. Here's what really happened.

Let's suppose you have a steadily increasing rate of increase. You're going to get one of those ever-increasing curves, a parabola, or an exponential curve, or something like that; something where the slope increases at a relatively constant rate. Or maybe a slightly increasing or slightly decreasing rate, but still, the slope is increasing over time.

What will you measure if you use averaging over time on such a curve?

Averaging is an approximation of the real curve. So what you're going to see is, whatever interval you average over, there's going to be a constant slope over that interval; that's what "averaging" means. But for each successive interval, that slope is going to be higher; that means, the value being plotted will go up faster. And the breaks in the slope are going to be abrupt; it might rise by 0.7mm/yr during this interval, and by 1.3mm/yr during the next one. That just indicates the slope of the curve increasing.

See, that's what everyone's been trying to tell you. There isn't any abrupt change in the real value. It's an artifact of the averaging. But over the long haul, that's what you'll see, so over the long haul of many averages, that's what data that does that means. It's not evidence of fudging the data; it's evidence of averaging over a curve.

The reason I am so irritated with you is that you don't seem able to understand how that can be. I can look at such a curve, and see precisely how that's going to look if you average it, so when I see averaging that does that, I naturally figure that kind of a curve is what I'm looking at in the real data; and so would anyone who's used to looking at curves and at approximations of curves. When you look at it, what you claim you see is evidence someone's faking the data.

It's irritating, but I have to confess that if you were to either just ask questions until you understand what I'm saying, or even just plain admit you can't see why that would be so, I'd be considerably less irritated. Instead, you choose (and you DO choose it) to be what appears to be deliberately obtuse, willfully ignorant, basically what woos do when told how real physics or medicine or chemistry works. And if there's one single thing that I could point to as conclusive evidence you're a woo, that would be it. But I freely admit it may be nothing more than stubbornness and lack of understanding. Why don't you make it clear which it is?

Of course, I've asked this question over and over again of you, and every time, it's come out that you were just being a woo. But I'll keep stepping up to the mound and throwing another pitch; what you do is your choice, but others will know your true nature by it. Remember, when you don't swing at anything, no matter how true it is over the plate, people are eventually going to conclude that's because you don't think you can hit it.

That's not in accordance with any reputable sources that I've seen. Please note this chart is from the IPCC Summary for Policymakers, which is a political document more than a scientific. The contents of Chapter 5 are more scientific of course.

1.6mm????
Maybe you'll learn something; maybe you already knew it and you're just so stuck on your ideology that you don't care what's true, you just care what you can use in your next argument. I guess this is another chance for us to find out which is true. And I know what I expect, but in the true spirit of skepticism, I invite you to tell us which it is, and by your response we shall all know clearly.

It's the fattest, roundest fastball you ever did see. Will you swing at it? Or will it just go by like all the rest? It's always your choice.
 
That's just bizarre. I was going off my knowledge of the density of water vs temperature as reflected here. Water is densest at 4 C but it never really gets too far away from 1 g/cc, so where is this expansion coming from?
OK, let's play with the numbers.

What's the volume of all the world's oceans? Here's an answer from MSN Encarta; bring another reference you like better, it was the second hit from google for "ocean volume." So that's 1,370 million km^3. Now, what's the surface area? 361.1 million km^2. How about the average depth? 3,790m.

Let's suppose that all that water is a rectangular solid, with that depth, and that surface area; dividing the volume by the depth should give the surface area, so we'll check our figures by that.

Comes out about right both ways (that is, volume divided by surface area equals average depth, and volume divided by average depth equals surface area, or pretty close).

OK, so how much is that expansion going to affect that volume? Let's use the most detailed table from your link, the one at the bottom. And let's say it's 10C. If it goes up by 3C, from 0.999700, to 0.999377, as indicated by the 10C and 13C points on your table, then the volume will increase by 0.999700/0.999377 = 1.0003232013544438184989248301692. Multiply the volume by this, and you get 1370442785.8555880313435270173318. Divide by the surface area, and you get 3.7951891051110164257644060297197. That's 3795.2m average depth. (The other figures are in km; you have to divide by 1000.) So, more or less, you get 5m for each 3C. Of course, that's a pretty non-conservative estimate; you'll actually get less, because the surface area will increase as well; you have to figure the calculus to get an intermediate answer, and it's going to be complicated because the coastlines are complicated. But you can see from this that the thermal expansion of 3C is at least 3m, and probably more.

So the figures seem reasonable, anyway. Not really bizarre.

Comments?

Agreed. My comment was more directed at storm surge which is that part of a hurricane/typhoon that kicks our ape butts.
That's an ape of a different color; figuring storm surge is probably a numerical integration job (like the previous calculation isn't!) and I wouldn't care to hazard a guess; it's your turn anyhoo. Have fun. :D
 
Well, this is interesting indeed.

You have posted an article that asserts the "lubricated slide" theory is the effective mechanism.

Let's dig into this a bit.

OK, here is another expert, from Greenpeace

from http://www.commondreams.org/headlines05/0725-02.htm

MKruger; said:
Martina Krüger, Greenpeace's expedition leader, said there were signs that the glacier was both retreating and moving faster at the same time.

"The speed up of the glacier is due to increased surface melting, which generates meltwater that trickles down to the glacier bed and lubricates the bedrock," Ms Krüger said.

"This decreases the friction and the glacier slides more easily. This is accompanied by a thinning of the glacier, because the glacier stretches more.

from the same article

Steve Conner; said:
Measurements taken in 1988 and in 1996 show the glacier was moving at a rate of between 3.1 and 3.7 miles per year. The latest measurements taken this summer show it is now moving at 8.7 miles a year.

I think that is a little faster than would be expected from creep, or as I understand it from your source, more of a plastic deformation type of movement. May have to resaearch that too.
 
That was two years ago. What's it doing now?

What is the Arctic doing now?
http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.cfm?release=2007-131


Hmm.

http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?articleID=0004F545-037C-13F5-837C83414B7F0000&chanID=sa028


http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/01/16/news/warm.php

still in retreat

but that wasn't my point.

My point was that water can accumulate on the surface of a glacier and then percolate down to the bottom, where the water can allow the glacier to move.
 
OK, here is another expert, from Greenpeace

from http://www.commondreams.org/headlines05/0725-02.htm

I think that is a little faster than would be expected from creep, or as I understand it from your source, more of a plastic deformation type of movement. May have to resaearch that too.

I am not an expert on glaciers but it would appear that the "experts" you cite are flat wrong (as I have said Gore and Hansen were on this issue).

That was the reason I posted the original link, because it appeared to simply and clearly explain the fundamental plastic flow of glaciers, and because it did seem that there was wide misunderstanding of this issue.

Plastic creep really is Materials Science 101...Let's be precise. We're discussing Greenland melting down or rushing into the sea, right?

That can't happen because the land under Greenland is shaped like a bowl and glacier ice escapes through what is basically mountain passes. The top of the Greenland glacier is far too high and too cold to melt. Around the edges of Greenland where the ice meets the sea there could be a retreat, yes. The some 50,000 people living in Greenland would probably benefits from that, not dangers and disadvantages.

From the article -
Hansen has a model of an ice sheet sliding along an inclined plane, lubricated by meltwater, which is itself increasing because of global warming. The same model is adopted in many copy-cat papers. Christoffersen and Hambrey (2006) and Bamber et al. (2007). are typical papers, a popular article based on the same flawed model appeared in the June 2007 issue of National Geographic, and the idea is present in textbooks such as The Great Ice Age (2000) by R.C.L. Wilson et al.

Hanson’s model, unfortunately, includes neither the main form of the Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets, nor an understanding of how glaciers flow. The predicted behaviour of the ice sheets is based on melting and accumulation rates at the present day, and on the concept of an ice sheet sliding down an inclined plane on a base lubricated by meltwater, which is itself increasing because of global warming. The idea of a glacier sliding downhill on a base lubricated by meltwater seemed a good idea when first presented by de Saussure in 1779, but a lot has been learned since then.
​
Google. "Greenland sub-ice geomorphology".

Side note. The tremendous internal pressures of these mile high ice formations create internal water pools such as you have mentioned, although that context was Antartica. So if the ice does create it's own water pools down deep, how would surface meltwater ever get down there? The pressure gradients are in the opposite direction.

That ain't gonna happen.
 
OK, let's play with the numbers.

What's the volume of all the world's oceans? Here's an answer from MSN Encarta; bring another reference you like better, it was the second hit from google for "ocean volume." So that's 1,370 million km^3. Now, what's the surface area? 361.1 million km^2. How about the average depth? 3,790m.

Let's suppose that all that water is a rectangular solid, with that depth, and that surface area; dividing the volume by the depth should give the surface area, so we'll check our figures by that.

Comes out about right both ways (that is, volume divided by surface area equals average depth, and volume divided by average depth equals surface area, or pretty close).

OK, so how much is that expansion going to affect that volume? Let's use the most detailed table from your link, the one at the bottom. And let's say it's 10C. If it goes up by 3C, from 0.999700, to 0.999377, as indicated by the 10C and 13C points on your table, then the volume will increase by 0.999700/0.999377 = 1.0003232013544438184989248301692. Multiply the volume by this, and you get 1370442785.8555880313435270173318. Divide by the surface area, and you get 3.7951891051110164257644060297197. That's 3795.2m average depth. (The other figures are in km; you have to divide by 1000.) So, more or less, you get 5m for each 3C. Of course, that's a pretty non-conservative estimate; you'll actually get less, because the surface area will increase as well; you have to figure the calculus to get an intermediate answer, and it's going to be complicated because the coastlines are complicated. But you can see from this that the thermal expansion of 3C is at least 3m, and probably more.

So the figures seem reasonable, anyway. Not really bizarre.

Comments?

:D

Well. your figures ignore the thermoclines. Seems the whole ocean won't warm up, only the top 500-1000 meters. Let's call it 20%? Soo, let's divide your 3m by about 5, to get about 24 inchs. Or two feet, for a three degree c rise. At the rate of ONE degree per century of global warming, in 300 years the ocean will swell two feet. Pretty inconsequential, isn't it?
 
That's an illusion. Here's what really happened.

Let's suppose you have a steadily increasing rate of increase. You're going to get one of those ever-increasing curves, a parabola, or an exponential curve, or something like that; something where the slope increases at a relatively constant rate. Or maybe a slightly increasing or slightly decreasing rate, but still, the slope is increasing over time.

What will you measure if you use averaging over time on such a curve?

Averaging is an approximation of the real curve. So what you're going to see is, whatever interval you average over, there's going to be a constant slope over that interval; that's what "averaging" means. But for each successive interval, that slope is going to be higher; that means, the value being plotted will go up faster. And the breaks in the slope are going to be abrupt; it might rise by 0.7mm/yr during this interval, and by 1.3mm/yr during the next one. That just indicates the slope of the curve increasing.

Nonsense.

Table 5.3 says in the left hand column, for 1961 - 2003 thermal expansion was 0.42 mm/year. Total for 41 years: 18.06 mm.

Right hand column, for 1993 - 2003 thermal expansion was 1.6 mm/year. Total for 11 years: 17.6 mm.

There's a basic problem with the numbers not adding up here too nicely here.

Which as I've stated already, was caused by changing measurement methodologies in 1993 when the satellite radar altimeter came to be used. What is so difficult about understanding that?

Unless you'd like to maintain that for 1961 - 1992 there was only 0.46 mm total of sea level rise due to thermal expansion? That is, 0.015 mm per year?

Take your pick.

 
Nonsense.
Unfortunately, because you don't have any personal integrity, you don't manage to prove that here. See, what you have to do is actually address what I said, not just repeat what you said. And you ignored it.

That's not argument. That's propaganda.

Table 5.3 says in the left hand column, for 1961 - 2003 thermal expansion was 0.42 mm/year. Total for 41 years: 18.06 mm.

Right hand column, for 1993 - 2003 thermal expansion was 1.6 mm/year. Total for 11 years: 17.6 mm.
If thermal expansion is a curve, what shape does this imply that curve has?

There's a basic problem with the numbers not adding up here too nicely here.
There's a basic problem with someone not understanding how graphs work here. I think this post demonstrates that this lack of understanding is not a matter of stupidity, but of dishonesty.

Which as I've stated already, was caused by changing measurement methodologies in 1993 when the satellite radar altimeter came to be used. What is so difficult about understanding that?
Ummm, the fact that it's wrong? And that would be because you are deliberately avoiding understanding how mathematics works, because it doesn't say what you want. Like I said, dishonest.

Unless you'd like to maintain that for 1961 - 1992 there was only 0.46 mm total of sea level rise due to thermal expansion? That is, 0.015 mm per year?
Screw the graph, what do the tabulated data look like? I'm betting you know, and I'm betting they show a steadily increasing curve, with some glitches.

It's particularly significant that you should choose 1961 as the starting point, giving you ten years of the end of the aerosols to play with so you can make misleading statements like the above.

Let's see the tabulated data, since you can't read the graph.

Take your pick.
I pick the tabulated data, right out in front of everyone, not some graph with averaging that hides the individual data points.

Where's the data?

How do you sleep at night? I mean, seriously. There's no way you can be doing this and not know, absolutely for certain, the science is right. Your ploys are too slick, too cognizant of the details, for you not to be already fully aware of all the points being made here. You have to know that the evidence against AGW is manufactured, cherry-picked, and misrepresented. If you didn't, you wouldn't be using rhetoric like, "nonsense." And you wouldn't be afraid to engage in a conversation where you admitted you screwed up. Another pitch goes by, right over the plate, and again you refuse to swing. What are we to conclude?
 
I wasn't talking about that, instead I was talking about Mann's HS "validations" I have seem in some places. But since you have brought that blog entry to the table, what do you think about that specific entry?

If you are talking about this then you are wrong.

http://www.climateaudit.org/?p=859

So maybe if you read it, and then compared it to, I don't know, at the very least if you compared it to the measuring devices I was talking about, or perhaps the timescale I was talking about you would see your mistake. What Mann has to do with it is anyones guess of course but I suppose we all have our obsessions.
 
That's not argument. That's propaganda.

If thermal expansion is a curve, what shape does this imply that curve has?

Screw the graph, what do the tabulated data look like? I'm betting you know, and I'm betting they show a steadily increasing curve, with some glitches.

It's particularly significant that you should choose 1961 as the starting point, giving you ten years of the end of the aerosols to play with so you can make misleading statements like the above.

Let's see the tabulated data, since you can't read the graph.

I pick the tabulated data, right out in front of everyone, not some graph with averaging that hides the individual data points.

Where's the data?

You go get the data, Schneib. I didn't pick the start date of the data, in fact I wondered why they picked 1961. It's out of the IPCC. AUP can help you find it. You don't get help from someone when you insult them repeatedly. And the reverse. Just be nice, and you'll get lots of little linkies that you can use to your liking, either to disprove your opponent or concede your point.

If you go back to when I posted the original note, I said the table was misleading.

That was my point, that the IPCC Summary for Policymakers chopped uncertainty and detail out of the science.

Get it?
 
I wasn't talking about that, instead I was talking about Mann's HS "validations" I have seem in some places. But since you have brought that blog entry to the table, what do you think about that specific entry?

So whilst we were discussing sea level change you decided to join in to harp on about Mann? Public forum I guess.

As for the blog post, I think it was a grand waste of time that doesn't tell anyone anything they didn't already know. The blog post admits that the authors of the graph he looks at knew and addressed the discontinuities and the reasons for them. As far as doing his analysis by drawing lines on a graph in a CAD package, not exactly ideal, but he is straight up about his method so you can't fault him for that.

I get the feeling that if the original authors had smoothed that data then he would have had a problem with them "tampering" with the data. As it is, they presented the data they had and explained why it was that there were discontinuities. In short everything you would expect of them.

Do people claim that the TOPEX data shows an increase in rate of sea level change. I don't think they actually do. I think if you read the literature they all say that 10 years or so is too short a period of time to determine changes in rate. The IPCC actually say that "Interannual or longer variability is a major reason why no long-term acceleration of sea level has been identified using 20th-century data alone." So the blog post tells us nothing that we didn't already know.

Well, as far as I know.
 
Well. your figures ignore the thermoclines. Seems the whole ocean won't warm up, only the top 500-1000 meters. Let's call it 20%? Soo, let's divide your 3m by about 5, to get about 24 inchs. Or two feet, for a three degree c rise. At the rate of ONE degree per century of global warming, in 300 years the ocean will swell two feet. Pretty inconsequential, isn't it?

This must be why they use temperature data from as far down as 3000m because umm...only the top 500-1000m actually warms up.
 
You go get the data, Schneib. I didn't pick the start date of the data, in fact I wondered why they picked 1961. It's out of the IPCC. AUP can help you find it. You don't get help from someone when you insult them repeatedly. And the reverse. Just be nice, and you'll get lots of little linkies that you can use to your liking, either to disprove your opponent or concede your point.

If you go back to when I posted the original note, I said the table was misleading.

That was my point, that the IPCC Summary for Policymakers chopped uncertainty and detail out of the science.

Get it?

This post?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3131128&postcount=794

If I remember, this is where you said the IPCC was wrong even though for them to be right would probably have required them to have a time machine. The fact that you were wrong is something you have been retreating from ever since, Now you find yourself here agreeing with the IPCC about thermal expansion measurements made using a combination of in situ measurements and the satellite altimetry.

Chapter 5 - 5.5.3 said:
It is presently unclear why the latter two estimates are significantly larger than the thermosteric rates based on temperature data alone. It is possible that the in situ data underestimate thermal expansion because of poor coverage in Southern Oceans, and it is interesting to note that a model based on assimilation of hydrographic data yields a somewhat higher estimate of 2.3 mm yr–1 (Carton et al., 2005). Published estimates of the steric sea level rates for 1955 to 2003 and 1993 to 2003 are shown in Table 5.2.

The point remains though, that the table is correct as far as the published data goes. There is no contradiction between the figures. You might as well say that the 1965 - 1980 rate of sea level rise due to thermal expansion cannot possibly be as high as it was because the 1961 - 2003 rate is so much lower. There is no problem with a sudden change in measurement method there, yet there the rate of sea level change is much higher. You can see for yourself by looking at Figure 5.19 from Chapter 5.

If you actually don't understand this concept, then I am sorry my attempts at explaining it to you have failed.

If all your point has come down to is that the summary of the main report is not sufficiently detailed with regards to methodology and uncertainty levels of the data presented, I invite you to level similar complaints about the executive summaries or abstracts of any number of journal papers. It is a ridiculous complaint.
 
OK, let's play with the numbers.

So the figures seem reasonable, anyway. Not really bizarre.

Comments?

I had started doing that calculation but I stopped when I caught myself having to make the assumption that a temperature increase at the earth's crust would affect the entire volume of the ocean instantaneously. I don't have data against that assumption except for a reasonable conclusion that the oceans are too massive and water is too dense for that type of phenomenon to occur. I'm not sure how quickly an increase at the Earth's surface would diffuse throught the water that makes up the oceans but I would guess that the superstorms we've been discussing lately would slow down that process considerably.

So, I don't agree with your assumptions. I still find the figures bizzare.

I also agree with mhaze that a quadrupling of a global rate over a few years is stunning. The exponent in the Arrhenius equation for that sort of thing would have to be very extreme for such jump, even if you were averaging the curve during those two intervals. Have you any reference to what rate they're using that would lead to such surprising conclusions?
 
You go get the data, Schneib.
It's not my point. It's yours. I'm just trying to make some sense out of it. If you don't care, I'll take it as an admission you've got nothing and are just making it all up. That's pretty much what I think anyway, and it's already been demonstrated you do that, so it's not all that big a deal, I guess.

I didn't pick the start date of the data,
You made the argument, you support it.

You don't get help from someone when you insult them repeatedly. And the reverse. Just be nice, and you'll get lots of little linkies that you can use to your liking, either to disprove your opponent or concede your point.
I have no intention of being nice to someone who comes on a science forum on a skeptical web site and promulgates woo by lying, using every imaginable rhetorical trick and logical fallacy known to man, and consistently denies science. If you don't have the data to back up what you say, that's not my problem. You seemed genuinely confused; I tried to help. I'll make a note not to try to help you when you're being an idiot in the future.

If you go back to when I posted the original note, I said the table was misleading.
And haven't proved it yet, and just came up with a great excuse to claim you don't have to, or tried to any way. "He was mean to me." Bummer, dude. Get over it.

That was my point, that the IPCC Summary for Policymakers chopped uncertainty and detail out of the science.
No, they used a standard statistical smoothing technique, and you are trying to make out they faked the data. And you STILL haven't proved it.

Oh, I figured you out long ago. You're a woo, and not only that, you're a nasty woo.
 
I had started doing that calculation but I stopped when I caught myself having to make the assumption that a temperature increase at the earth's crust would affect the entire volume of the ocean instantaneously.
I don't see why that would be. It seems to me that given the rate of temperature increase in the ocean that's documented there would be decades for the heat to percolate.

I don't have data against that assumption except for a reasonable conclusion that the oceans are too massive and water is too dense for that type of phenomenon to occur.
Over decades? I think that's unreasonable; you're welcome to your opinion, but the data on both sea level rise and ocean temperature increase seem to indicate that we've already seen increases in that order of magnitude in similar time periods.

I'm not sure how quickly an increase at the Earth's surface would diffuse throught the water that makes up the oceans but I would guess that the superstorms we've been discussing lately would slow down that process considerably.
I'm not convinced of that. That would be something I think we should discuss.

So, I don't agree with your assumptions. I still find the figures bizzare.
OK, but I think I've shown reason to question that judgment. I'd like you to consider it a bit more carefully.

I also agree with mhaze that a quadrupling of a global rate over a few years is stunning. The exponent in the Arrhenius equation for that sort of thing would have to be very extreme for such jump, even if you were averaging the curve during those two intervals. Have you any reference to what rate they're using that would lead to such surprising conclusions?
I don't agree that mhaze has shown anything of the kind, and I've basically restated fsol's point on where that might come from; it's an artifact of smoothing the data. We haven't had a response on that, at least not one that makes any reference to the actual data. There's been a lot of rhetoric slung around. I offered to have a look at it and see whether I could figure out what was going on; you saw the response. Quite frankly, it's mhaze's point, it's not been proven, and when data were requested they were refused, and that's generally not a good sign as to the reliability of a point.

I'll also point out that without data to oppose my back-of-the-envelope calculation, you haven't said anything conclusive about it. I think there's a discussion to be had, and I think you're dismissing it with insufficient evidence. I'm willing to be convinced it's unreasonable, but not by a bald unsupported statement that that's so. Back your stuff up, bud. Let's see where this goes instead of just having a he-said-she-said match that goes nowhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom