Schneib, what initially irritated me about this matter was the thermal expansion. If you look at the right hand column top, you will see that thermal expansion "suddenly jumped" from 0.4mm per year to 1.6mm per year.
That's an illusion. Here's what really happened.
Let's suppose you have a steadily increasing rate of increase. You're going to get one of those ever-increasing curves, a parabola, or an exponential curve, or something like that; something where the slope increases at a relatively constant rate. Or maybe a slightly increasing or slightly decreasing rate, but still, the slope is increasing over time.
What will you measure if you use averaging over time on such a curve?
Averaging is an approximation of the real curve. So what you're going to see is, whatever interval you average over, there's going to be a constant slope over that interval; that's what "averaging" means. But for each successive interval, that slope is going to be higher; that means, the value being plotted will go up faster. And the breaks in the slope are going to be abrupt; it might rise by 0.7mm/yr during this interval, and by 1.3mm/yr during the next one. That just indicates the slope of the curve increasing.
See, that's what everyone's been trying to tell you. There isn't any abrupt change in the real value. It's an artifact of the averaging. But over the long haul, that's what you'll see, so over the long haul of many averages, that's what data that does that means. It's not evidence of fudging the data; it's evidence of averaging over a curve.
The reason I am so irritated with you is that you don't seem able to understand how that can be. I can look at such a curve, and see precisely how that's going to look if you average it, so when I see averaging that does that, I naturally figure that kind of a curve is what I'm looking at in the real data; and so would anyone who's used to looking at curves and at approximations of curves. When you look at it, what you claim you see is evidence someone's faking the data.
It's irritating, but I have to confess that if you were to either just ask questions until you understand what I'm saying, or even just plain admit you can't see why that would be so, I'd be considerably less irritated. Instead, you choose (and you DO choose it) to be what appears to be deliberately obtuse, willfully ignorant, basically what woos do when told how real physics or medicine or chemistry works. And if there's one single thing that I could point to as conclusive evidence you're a woo, that would be it. But I freely admit it may be nothing more than stubbornness and lack of understanding. Why don't you make it clear which it is?
Of course, I've asked this question over and over again of you, and every time, it's come out that you were just being a woo. But I'll keep stepping up to the mound and throwing another pitch; what you do is your choice, but others will know your true nature by it. Remember, when you don't swing at anything, no matter how true it is over the plate, people are eventually going to conclude that's because you don't think you can hit it.
That's not in accordance with any reputable sources that I've seen. Please note this chart is from the IPCC Summary for Policymakers, which is a political document more than a scientific. The contents of Chapter 5 are more scientific of course.
1.6mm????
Maybe you'll learn something; maybe you already knew it and you're just so stuck on your ideology that you don't care what's true, you just care what you can use in your next argument. I guess this is another chance for us to find out which is true. And I know what I expect, but in the
true spirit of skepticism, I invite you to tell us which it is, and by your response we shall all know clearly.
It's the fattest, roundest fastball you ever did see. Will you swing at it? Or will it just go by like all the rest? It's always your choice.