Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

I am not an expert on glaciers but it would appear that the "experts" you cite are flat wrong (as I have said Gore and Hansen were on this issue).

I don't doubt it often appears to you that experts are dead wrong. Their peers tend not to do so.

That was the reason I posted the original link, because it appeared to simply and clearly explain the fundamental plastic flow of glaciers, and because it did seem that there was wide misunderstanding of this issue.

What you're missing is that there is more than one mode of glacier flow. Ice-dynamics is a massively complex subject, but at least glaciers are a subset. Even then it's complicated, but when it comes to the rate of glacier-flow the glacier can be approximated as a slab moving across a surface in a manner dependent on the coefficient of friction.

The amount of liquidwater at the base of a glacier (and there always is some, just as there is between a skate-blade and the ice beneath it) reduces the coefficient of friction. The thicker the layer of water the lower the coefficient of friction and the quicker the motion.

Meanwhile the plastic deformation of the ice in the glacier goes on, but on a much slower rate. Only the very coldest of glaciers - in the Antarctic highlands, for instance - move principally by deformation.

The idea that ice-scientists and glaciologists are unaware of this is risible. Ice-dynamics as a whole is a far more complicated subject (and inherently so) than climate.

Your (apparently innate) tendency to reduce everything to one influence, simple (understood) or complex (mysterious and unknowable) acording to your needs, goes a long way towards explaining why you're so silly but so persistent. It's very similar to a religious attitude. You don't speculate, you regurgitate.

Which is not an ad hom, before you seek refuge in that claim, it's simply an observation.
 
I don't see why that would be. It seems to me that given the rate of temperature increase in the ocean that's documented there would be decades for the heat to percolate.

Not all the way down, but still into one heck of a lot of water.

Forgive me if I'm asking a question you've already answered, but do you know what kind of function governs the expansion of a liquid with increasing temperature? Linear, logarithmic, something else? (If you don't know, I'm sure you'll find out :).)
 
I don't see why that would be. It seems to me that given the rate of temperature increase in the ocean that's documented there would be decades for the heat to percolate.

Over decades? I think that's unreasonable; you're welcome to your opinion, but the data on both sea level rise and ocean temperature increase seem to indicate that we've already seen increases in that order of magnitude in similar time periods.

I think it would take decades just to get a one-Kelvin difference to reach 500 meters below the surface. I'm not an oceanographer but you can't seriously believe that the ocean will react quickly to surface changes. No way. That's why divers have to wear wet-suits even when deep-diving in the tropics. If you don't believe that, review Beer's Law again. There is a compenent in that equation for the distance light would have to traverse. Water is a wonderful absorber of infra-red. Any chemist who has ever had the misfortune of running an IR spectrum on a moist sample knows that. There is no way heat directly gets below, say, 100 m, and I'm being very conservative with that one as I don't have a breakdown of the extinction coefficients for each major IR band through water. Not only that, there's thingies living in that water consuming some of that energy so we're not dealing with pure water anyway. Next time you're in the surf, take a dive to six feet to see how cool that water is compared to the surface water. Also, the mixing in the oceans is nowhere near efficient. That's the whole story with the oceanic conveyor and the "lakes" where super-deep shells inhabit the "shores".

I'm not convinced of that. That would be something I think we should discuss.

You don't think that tropical storms, Nor-easters etc effectively cool the ocean? If so, they are creating energy.

I don't agree that mhaze has shown anything of the kind, and I've basically restated fsol's point on where that might come from; it's an artifact of smoothing the data.

I've asked a specific question because I'm very familiar with kinetics and kinetic theory. A four-fold increase over a period of a few years would take one heck of an exponent. What is that exponent? That's all I want to know. The Arrhenius Equation rules supreme for this situation. The prediction must be mathematically driven.


I'll also point out that without data to oppose my back-of-the-envelope calculation, you haven't said anything conclusive about it.

Your claim. Your burden of proof. I've given you plenty of reasons why your assumptions are questionable. Even if the oceans were made of some superconductive metal, they wouldn't heat quickly or uniformly.

Back your stuff up, bud. Let's see where this goes instead of just having a he-said-she-said match that goes nowhere.

Ah, the old schneibster returns. I'm not interested in having any type of match with you. Your presumptions are ridiculous and you must realize that. I fully agree with assumptions made where no data exist and an admission thereof but taking the oceans as a whole and calculating a uniform expansion is just silly. Both you and I know it. That's the kind of unscientific guesstimation that makes people skeptical of even your worthwhile science.
 
This must be why they use temperature data from as far down as 3000m because umm...only the top 500-1000m actually warms up.

A new refuge - the deeper ocean - to go along with the past, models, conspiracies, the climate of fear and careerism that governs the world of science, yadda-yadda.

Limiting ourselves to the top 500m, the average expansion across the range that would cause one metre rise in sea-level is 0.2%. How reasonable an increase is that? I confess to being entirely ignorant on this subject.
 
Limiting ourselves to the top 500m, the average expansion across the range that would cause one metre rise in sea-level is 0.2%. How reasonable an increase is that? I confess to being entirely ignorant on this subject.

From my earlier link on water density,

The thermal coefficient of expansion of water is 0.00021 per 1° Celsius at 20° Celsius.



Your multiplier for the incremental contribution from expansion is ten times less than that, or 0.021%
 
Last edited:
I think it would take decades just to get a one-Kelvin difference to reach 500 meters below the surface.

There's nothing magical about a Kelvin. It's just a number on an arbitrary scale. What reason fo you have for thinking the actual increase in temperature across the 500m range isn't significant in terms of expansion?

I'm not an oceanographer but you can't seriously believe that the ocean will react quickly to surface changes. No way. That's why divers have to wear wet-suits even when deep-diving in the tropics.

That's no different, in essence, from the lapse rate in atmosphere. It could be bit warmer all the way up Everest and still be damn' cold most of the way. It could be a bit warmer at 500m depth and still be damn' cold.


f you don't believe that, review Beer's Law again. There is a compenent in that equation for the distance light would have to traverse.

Its not as simple as that. If it were, climate models would have the oceans nailed and only have to deal with the atmosphere.
 
Last edited:
There's nothing magical about a Kelvin. It's just a number on an arbitrary scale. What reason fo you have for thinking the actual increase in temperature across the 500m range isn't significant in terms of expansion?

Actually, the Kelvin scale is anchored in thermodynamic theory. It's zero is that theoretical point where all kinetic energy is zero. One kelvin is equal to one degree Celsius after that.

That's no different, in essence, from the lapse rate in atmosphere. It could be bit warmer all the way up Everest and still be damn' cold most of the way. It could be a bit warmer at 500m depth and still be damn' cold.

Liquids and gases are both fluids but there's quite a difference in how well they react to temperature, mostly because liquids are much more viscous than gases. It's a lot easier to have a near-homogenous gas system than a homogenous liquid system, especially with energetics such as heat. For example, one mole (18 g) of water (one mole) occupy 0.018 L as a liquid but a whopping 22.4 L as a gas. If you had both in suitable pefectly-insulated containers and added one Calorie of heat to each, which one do you think would distribute the added heat most efficiently?

f you don't believe that, review Beer's Law again. There is a compenent in that equation for the distance light would have to traverse.

Its not as simple as that. If it were, climate models would have the oceans nailed and only have to deal with the atmosphere.

No, it's not as simple as all that but Beer's law will still dominate how deep a photon will penetrate water. By my reckonin', the oceans will heat both directly from radiation and by conduction from the air and the land. Beer's law will be the primary predictor of the radiation part. Nothing is fully efficient so there will be mitigators but da law's da law.

I fully agree with you that theory is nice but worthy measurements are much more valuable.
 
From my earlier link on water density [
the thermal coefficient of expansion of water is 0.00021 per 1° Celsius at 20° Celsius.]

Thanks for that.

Your multiplier for the incremental contribution from expansion is ten times less than that, or 0.021%

Not my muliplier, just a speculation.

As you'll appreciate, not all the ocean down to 500m is as warm as 20C. Do you happen to know how the expansion coefficient varies with temperature? Is it effectively linear at this range on the Kelvin scale?
 
Actually, the Kelvin scale is anchored in thermodynamic theory. It's zero is that theoretical point where all kinetic energy is zero. One kelvin is equal to one degree Celsius after that.

And arbitrary. 100 units between the freezing and boiling points of pure water.



Liquids and gases are both fluids but there's quite a difference in how well they react to temperature, mostly because liquids are much more viscous than gases. It's a lot easier to have a near-homogenous gas system than a homogenous liquid system, especially with energetics such as heat. For example, one mole (18 g) of water (one mole) occupy 0.018 L as a liquid but a whopping 22.4 L as a gas. If you had both in suitable pefectly-insulated containers and added one Calorie of heat to each, which one do you think would distribute the added heat most efficiently?

The gas. It's in the nature of the beast. That's why the atmosphere brings us day-to-day weather, and oceans govern climate.

No, it's not as simple as all that but Beer's law will still dominate how deep a photon will penetrate water. By my reckonin', the oceans will heat both directly from radiation and by conduction from the air and the land. Beer's law will be the primary predictor of the radiation part. Nothing is fully efficient so there will be mitigators but da law's da law.

That's all very well when we're considering a theoretical pan of water, but oceans have weather, Coriolis forces, and geography to contend with.

I fully agree with you that theory is nice but worthy measurements are much more valuable.

Worthy measurements? Accurate is good enough for me.

I have no doubt of the coefficient of expansion you presented, but it does refer specifically to 1K at and about 20C. Do you have any worthy reason to present 1K as the average temperature increase over the top 500m of ocean? Quite a lot of it - as you've pointed out - is rather colder than 20C.

Bringing me back to the question of how the coefficient of expansion varies across temperatures - linear? logarithmic? something else? - and introducing the question of how much the top 500m has warmed over the last few decsdes. On average. More than 1K, or less?
 
Ahhh, teh magic thermoclines through which heat cannot penetrate! What are they, asbestos or something?

There are (apparently) more things in Heaven and Earth than are dreamed of in our philosophy :).

Thermoclines. What were we thinking? Of course! It's all so frickin' simple and inherently stable. We can take the oceans as a given and concentrate on the behaviour of the atmosphere. That will simplify the models no end.
 
As you'll appreciate, not all the ocean down to 500m is as warm as 20C. Do you happen to know how the expansion coefficient varies with temperature? Is it effectively linear at this range on the Kelvin scale?

The link I've been using for the density of water is this one. That's for pure water and sea water is probably different but not appreciably. To fine tune the expansion coefficient between two temperatures, take the difference between the two densities and then divide by your present density. Pure water is densest at about 4 C so that's the layer of ocean that will expand the most once heated or cooled.

As far as linearity, that's a good question. I've never plotted the density of water vs temperature but, as you've noted, the expansion coefficient of water is always given at a certain temperature so I doubt it's linear.
 
And arbitrary. 100 units between the freezing and boiling points of pure water.

Right. I was just pointing out that it's not entirely arbitrary as its zero-point does actually mean something.

The gas. It's in the nature of the beast. That's why the atmosphere brings us day-to-day weather, and oceans govern climate.

That's all very well when we're considering a theoretical pan of water, but oceans have weather, Coriolis forces, and geography to contend with.

Yes, and viscosity (mass transfer differentials), biota, depth differentials, and so on. Pretty complicated stuff.

Worthy measurements? Accurate is good enough for me.

Accurate is nice. Precise is better, though.

I have no doubt of the coefficient of expansion you presented, but it does refer specifically to 1K at and about 20C. Do you have any worthy reason to present 1K as the average temperature increase over the top 500m of ocean? Quite a lot of it - as you've pointed out - is rather colder than 20C.

As Schneibster has pointed out, the solution to problem would have to involve calculus. You'd have to imagine the ocean as a series of infinitely-thin layers, each absorbing a constant fraction of the heat available but the heat available would diminish as you got deeper. (This is basically Beer's Law.) Adding up the effect of the layers, you'd come up with the natural log of absorption to whatever depth you'd want to stop at. (I'd stop at the depth where the heat absorbed diminshed to about 0.01% of the original flux. The equation would be:

C0 - Cd = -k ln(d) or 0.9999 = -k x ln (depth), so we need to know what k is and that should be roughly equivalent to the extinction coefficient for heat (infrared light) through sea water. So, that's where your warming due to radiation (and thereby your expansion) would stop.

As you said, there's all types of mitigators here. Heat will also creep into these layers via conduction. Your lower layers will be cooled by the underlying layers, etc. so an actual model may begin with Beer's Law but certainly won't end there.

Bringing me back to the question of how the coefficient of expansion varies across temperatures - linear? logarithmic? something else? - and introducing the question of how much the top 500m has warmed over the last few decsdes. On average. More than 1K, or less?

The answer to all these questions is that I don't know. I suspect that the variation in density over temperature would be non-linear. It's probably a second-degree function because the phenomenon occurs in three dimensions (removing one degree of freedom for your fixed variable gives a square or parabolic function) but there's more involved due to the strong hydrogen bonding in water. As far as the warming over history, you're the climate scholar. I'm just dipping my toes in the water here.
 
I think it would take decades just to get a one-Kelvin difference to reach 500 meters below the surface. I'm not an oceanographer but you can't seriously believe that the ocean will react quickly to surface changes. No way.
The thermal conductivity of water at 273K is 0.561W/mK. That of air is 0.024W/mK for comparison purposes. That means that half a watt of power will flow through a cubic meter of water at a temperature difference of 1K, as compared to 24mW (a quarter of a tenth of a watt, about 1/24 of the rate) for air. I'll also point out that 273.16K is 0C; the rate at more reasonable temperatures is higher, up to 0.68W/mK at 100C and 0.58W/mK at 20C. (For those into dimensional analysis, the actual unit is Wm/m^2/K, that is, watts that flow through a square meter, at a distance of a meter, at a temperature of 1K. The m in the numerator cancels one of the ms in the denominator, so the SI unit only keeps one in the denominator.)

The specific heat of water is 4.187kJ/kgK. That means it takes 4.187kJ of energy to heat 1kg of water 1K. A watt is a flow of a joule every second. At half a watt, half a joule flows through a meter of water every second, at a temperature differential of 1K. That means it takes about 8374s- about 2.3h- for a temperature difference of 1K to move 1m through water. If the average depth is 3000m, more or less, it will take about 6000h for the heat to move that far. That's about 290 days- call it a year. And that ignores convection.

I think you're off by more than an order of magnitude.

That's why divers have to wear wet-suits even when deep-diving in the tropics.
You've just argued that water doesn't conduct heat well enough to draw much heat away from the surface; however, to make you cold, water must conduct a LOT of heat. So, which is it? Does it conduct a lot, or not conduct much? One has to be right. And we know that you're right about divers having to wear wetsuits even in the tropics.

But you're also wrong about the reason they do. The reason that divers have to wear wetsuits even in the tropics is the heat capacity of water, which is also very high compared to air, combined with its high thermal conductivity; that means that it can absorb a lot of heat, and because of its high conductivity, it can do so quickly. And that means you get cold quickly when you're in it.

If you don't believe that, review Beer's Law again. There is a compenent in that equation for the distance light would have to traverse.
You seem to have confused radiation with conduction. Beer's Law concerns only the absorption of radiation; it has nothing to do with conduction. And we still haven't mentioned convection yet.

Water is a wonderful absorber of infra-red. Any chemist who has ever had the misfortune of running an IR spectrum on a moist sample knows that.
Yes, it is; and once the infra-red has been absorbed, the heat doesn't just disappear; it turns into molecular motion, and is subject not to radiation but to conduction. Which has nothing to do with Beer's Law, which is about radiation and absorption, not about conduction.

There is no way heat directly gets below, say, 100 m, and I'm being very conservative with that one as I don't have a breakdown of the extinction coefficients for each major IR band through water.
The transmission of IR through water is totally immaterial to water's ability to conduct heat. And once again I remind you, we haven't even mentioned convection yet. Convection can only make it faster.

Not only that, there's thingies living in that water consuming some of that energy so we're not dealing with pure water anyway.
Slime, I think you had a valid point here; but I want to hear you restate this and make it clear. Your first hint is that I think you are making two different points, and I think only the first one has merit, and I don't think it has a lot. Still, it's a consideration. Please restate this.

Next time you're in the surf, take a dive to six feet to see how cool that water is compared to the surface water.
Again, that's because of the thermal conductivity and heat capacity of water. Humans sense heat flow.

Also, the mixing in the oceans is nowhere near efficient.
It doesn't have to be. The feeling of cold has more to do with water's high thermal capacity and high thermal conductivity than with the temperature. Those two properties are, after all, why it's used to put out fires.

That's the whole story with the oceanic conveyor and the "lakes" where super-deep shells inhabit the "shores".
I have no idea what point you were trying to make here. Please restate this.

You don't think that tropical storms, Nor-easters etc effectively cool the ocean? If so, they are creating energy.
No, hurricanes are moving heat around- and by that I mean, around in circles. Where does the heat in a hurricane go? First Law of Thermodynamics says it can't just disappear. The answer is, it goes into the water that falls as rain, and warms the ocean back up, and it goes into the atmosphere, and warms that up too; and some of it escapes to space. The fact that some of the heat warms the atmosphere, and some escapes from the top of the hurricane into space, accounts for the fact that the water remains liquid as it falls; it would evaporate otherwise, but the heat lost to the atmosphere and to space means there isn't enough to re-evaporate the rain much. But the rain still carries some of the heat back to the ocean's surface, and since the hurricane moves, that adds to the heat that's already in the ocean, absorbed from the Sun, and together that adds up to the feedback mechanism that drives the thermal machine that is a hurricane. That's how they work, Slime. Feel free to google it up; Wikipedia's not a bad source. There are others.

Now, you're correct about it lowering the temperature of the water; but you've missed something else important, which is, it's warming the atmosphere up with that heat, and something further: it puts some of that heat back into the water.

I said nothing about Nor'easters, quite deliberately. It's a different type of storm than a hurricane.

I've asked a specific question because I'm very familiar with kinetics and kinetic theory. A four-fold increase over a period of a few years would take one heck of an exponent. What is that exponent? That's all I want to know. The Arrhenius Equation rules supreme for this situation. The prediction must be mathematically driven.
You've ignored the character of the smoothing process; the question is irrelevant to the data presented, which are not a table but a graph, and specifically one that is smoothed. Furthermore, the Arrhenius equation has only to do with the change in chemical reactivity with temperature- it doesn't talk about radiation, convection, conduction, or heat capacity. And to top it all off, the conversation you're referring to isn't about temperature, it's about volumetric changes, so the Arrhenius equation is doubly inapplicable. I think you just got confused because there are two topics in your post, and I replied to them in one post. Go back and make the point again, if you think there's merit to it.

Your claim. Your burden of proof. I've given you plenty of reasons why your assumptions are questionable.
And I've given you plenty in return why they are not questionable at all. To recap:
1. The question here is thermal conductivity, and the thermal conductivity and thermal capacity of water are such that we can expect a temperature difference of 1K to drive a heat transfer that will heat water 1m deep by that same 1K in about two hours. That translates to about a year to make it to the average bottom of the sea.
2. You've confused formulae that deal with radiation, with those that deal with conduction.
3. We haven't even discussed convection, which can only make the heat transfer faster by mixing the warm and cold water.
4. You've confounded temperature with heat flow in talking about peoples' experiences in water.
I think that meets the burden of proof. Show me why it doesn't, if you still disagree.

Even if the oceans were made of some superconductive metal, they wouldn't heat quickly or uniformly.
Actually, the thermal conductivity of ordinary aluminum is 250W/mK. That means under a temperature difference of 1K, 250W (!!!) flows through a cubic meter of aluminum. The specific heat, however, of aluminum is only 890J/kgK. So it will take only a bit over 3 seconds for that 1K temperature change to move a meter through aluminum, and that means about 10,000s- 2 hours, more or less- to get to the bottom of the sea if the sea were made of aluminum. It would also take only about 1/5 the heat to warm it up 1K as it does the same mass (not volume!) of water.

Ah, the old schneibster returns.
No, actually not. I don't call people I'm dissing "bud." It's short for "buddy," and it is neither challenging nor pejorative, though I can see how you would interpret it that way. Think of it this way: I refer to hangin' out with my buds, throwin' down a few brewskis, and committing unspeakable violence upon small fake ivory balls, when I speak of one of the activities I pursue for amusement; playing pool and drinking beer with my friends. Because I can understand how this could be misinterpreted, I will deliberately overlook any offensive material that follows, and not respond in kind; you need not even apologize, it is an honest mistake. Please keep in mind that that is the way I mean it should I use it in the future.

Your presumptions are ridiculous and you must realize that.
Actually, I think I've shown they are not. Do you agree, or do you have more arguments to present?

I fully agree with assumptions made where no data exist and an admission thereof but taking the oceans as a whole and calculating a uniform expansion is just silly. Both you and I know it. That's the kind of unscientific guesstimation that makes people skeptical of even your worthwhile science.
I disagree that it's unscientific; in fact, estimation of the likely important parameters, and argument over which parameters are important, is the very essence of science. It is not until common ground is agreed upon that any conclusions can be drawn to be tested against phenomena. One must always make assumptions; it is impossible to actually know the exact kinetic energy of every molecule of a single cubic centimeter of water, much less the entire ocean, and any statement of the properties of either one is therefore only an estimate in any case.

I've not pulled any punches here, but I've reviewed this to make sure that I'm not being insulting. Please feel free to critique that part if you feel that way; it's OK, you're doing fine. Just because we disagree doesn't mean we have to have slanging matches; they're honest disagreements. We'll work them out; there is, after all, science to be considered here, and that's a lot more fun than slanging matches.
 
Not all the way down, but still into one heck of a lot of water.

Forgive me if I'm asking a question you've already answered, but do you know what kind of function governs the expansion of a liquid with increasing temperature? Linear, logarithmic, something else? (If you don't know, I'm sure you'll find out :).)
It looks pretty close to linear, with a slight upturn in the rate, according to this. At 4C, it's changing by about 0.02% every 5C; at 95C, it's changing about 0.4% every 5C. Over the range from freezing to boiling, then, the rate of change changes by a factor of about 20; but that's not a very strong upturn at these levels, since even at the maximum it has only changed by about 4%. The density decreases with temperature, of course.

I could probably make an equation to describe it, if you think that's important. I might even be able to find one ready-made.
 
There are (apparently) more things in Heaven and Earth than are dreamed of in our philosophy :).

Thermoclines. What were we thinking? Of course! It's all so frickin' simple and inherently stable. We can take the oceans as a given and concentrate on the behaviour of the atmosphere. That will simplify the models no end.
It's amusing to contemplate an argument over the science of heat transfer with an individual who doesn't even appear to know what thermal conductivity is.

BTW, it's "dreamt of," and my name is not Horatio. ;)
 
Here's alink to a chart showing the ocena temperature vs depth.

<http://www.windows.ucar.edu/tour/link=/earth/Water/temp.html&edu=high>

Note how the warm water stays at the top 300 meters? So making the surface temp warmer will only heat up and expand the top 300 meters. That is the effect of water's natural thermocline. Warmer water, being less dense, floats on top. And the warmer the wateer gets, the more it expands, from a low of .02% for 5 degrees at 20, to 4% at 100 degrees. Heat can only penetrate to depth by conduction, very slow compared to convention. So re-do your math, and see that the expansion of the ocean caused by GW will be the least of your potential worries.
 
The thermal conductivity of water ...That's about 290 days- call it a year. And that ignores convection.

I think you're off by more than an order of magnitude.

I can't quibble with your calculations. I will quibble with your assumptions, though. Bring all the theory you want but, in the end, reality has to take precedence. When dealing with heating a liquid, you can't ignore convection. That's too huge. Even in small fluid systems, convection plays a major role. Lava lamps.

You've just argued that water doesn't conduct heat well enough to draw much heat away from the surface; however, to make you cold, water must conduct a LOT of heat. So, which is it? Does it conduct a lot, or not conduct much? One has to be right. And we know that you're right about divers having to wear wetsuits even in the tropics.

Did I write that? Sorry. You're right. Water conducts heat very well. That's why we have swimming pools and people die of hypthermia so much more quickly in water than on land. What I mean is that heat does not seem to penetrated into deeper water. It stays on top.

You seem to have confused radiation with conduction. Beer's Law concerns only the absorption of radiation; it has nothing to do with conduction. And we still haven't mentioned convection yet.

Yes, it is; and once the infra-red has been absorbed, the heat doesn't just disappear; it turns into molecular motion, and is subject not to radiation but to conduction. Which has nothing to do with Beer's Law, which is about radiation and absorption, not about conduction.

All true but your scenario is also incomplete. There are a number of avenues for the heat to escape the ocean's surface. Evaporation is a huge mechanism because of latent heat of vaporization. Life will also utilize the heat. Conduction in water is kinda self-defeating as water passing on its heat to a deeper bit of water will cool and sink while the water just warmed will rise. .

Slime, I think you had a valid point here; but I want to hear you restate this and make it clear. Your first hint is that I think you are making two different points, and I think only the first one has merit, and I don't think it has a lot. Still, it's a consideration. Please restate this.

What I originally stated is that I don't believe that thermal expansion will greatly exacerbate flooding due to warming. Water doesn't expand much with temperature. That' why it's not used in thermometers but it is used in manometers. So, fearing expansion from seawater is basically an exercise in scaring yourself.

Again, that's because of the thermal conductivity and heat capacity of water. Humans sense heat flow.

It doesn't have to be. The feeling of cold has more to do with water's high thermal capacity and high thermal conductivity than with the temperature. Those two properties are, after all, why it's used to put out fires.

I have no idea what point you were trying to make here. Please restate this.

I'm pointing out a couple of known phenomena that indicate that, due to its scale, the oceans don't mix effectively. There are quiescent "salt lakes" deep in the oceans that acutally have beaches where life gathers around the more viscous water. The global conveyor would not be possible if the oceans were homogenous.

No, hurricanes are moving heat around- and by that I mean, around in circles. Where does the heat in a hurricane go? First Law of Thermodynamics says it can't just disappear. The answer is, it goes into the water that falls as rain, and warms the ocean back up, and it goes into the atmosphere, and warms that up too; and some of it escapes to space.

You wrote a lot of words just to tell me I was right. Net effect is that storms cool the ocean.
You've ignored the character of the smoothing process; the question is irrelevant to the data presented, which are not a table but a graph, and specifically one that is smoothed. Furthermore, the Arrhenius equation has only to do with the change in chemical reactivity with temperature- it doesn't talk about radiation, convection, conduction, or heat capacity. And to top it all off, the conversation you're referring to isn't about temperature, it's about volumetric changes, so the Arrhenius equation is doubly inapplicable. I think you just got confused because there are two topics in your post, and I replied to them in one post. Go back and make the point again, if you think there's merit to it.

The Arrhenius equation is applicable to rates of reaction, even completely physical ones. Try it. You'll find it remarkably accurate. We use if for all kinds of stuff. It's based on the simple mathematics of interaction and rates of change. What equation would you use here?


And I've given you plenty in return why they are not questionable at all. To recap:
1. The question here is thermal conductivity, and the thermal conductivity and thermal capacity of water are such that we can expect a temperature difference of 1K to drive a heat transfer that will heat water 1m deep by that same 1K in about two hours. That translates to about a year to make it to the average bottom of the sea.
2. You've confused formulae that deal with radiation, with those that deal with conduction.
3. We haven't even discussed convection, which can only make the heat transfer faster by mixing the warm and cold water.
4. You've confounded temperature with heat flow in talking about peoples' experiences in water.
I think that meets the burden of proof. Show me why it doesn't, if you still disagree.

I haven't confused anything. I am fully aware of two separate issues here. My point was that the oceans will not contribute much by expansion. Call in all the mitigators you want but you have to deal with Beer's Law to calculate the radiative heating of the upper layers of sea water and you can (but don't have to) use the Arrhenius Equation to track the rate of proposed rates of change in the environment. You can protest all you want but you have offered no alternative mathematics. I've also directly requested the mathematical inputs for the predictions of the swelling of the seas and none have been offered.

No, actually not. I don't call people I'm dissing "bud." It's short for "buddy," and it is neither challenging nor pejorative, though I can see how you would interpret it that way. Think of it this way: I refer to hangin' out with my buds, throwin' down a few brewskis, and committing unspeakable violence upon small fake ivory balls, when I speak of one of the activities I pursue for amusement; playing pool and drinking beer with my friends. Because I can understand how this could be misinterpreted, I will deliberately overlook any offensive material that follows, and not respond in kind; you need not even apologize, it is an honest mistake. Please keep in mind that that is the way I mean it should I use it in the future.

I'm not one of your homies. Keep that in mind.

I disagree that it's unscientific; in fact, estimation of the likely important parameters, and argument over which parameters are important, is the very essence of science.

Science tries to explain nature. That is, observation preceeds the formulation of scientific explanations. I think you're trying to put the cart before the horse here.
 
It's even MORE interesting to talk to someone who doesn't "believe in" heat conduction. Tell me, do you "believe in" physics?
 
It's even MORE interesting to talk to someone who doesn't "believe in" heat conduction. Tell me, do you "believe in" physics?

:confused: When did I refute physics?

The conversation is over, and you are on ignore. If you can't keep a civil tongue in your head, you're not worth the effort. Good bye, I won't bother reading anything you say again.

:covereyes Oh, dear, he's off his meds again! This from someone who tells others they have no integrity! All I told him was to watch how he addresses me.
:id:
Celebration is ON! :yahoo:wave1:clap::mdance::monkeyr::cheerleader4
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom