Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Regardless there's no other context where "The customers might treat the workers badly" is seen as an argument we have to address as to whether or not the job should be legal to perform.
 
Ya an old lady complaining that her soup is cold is totally on the same planet as a naked sex worker being "abused and hurt" by some prick.
 
I think it boils down to the associations we have in the States. A prostitute is usually a streetwalker, often with drug issues (Atlantic City/New York area boy here). We don't really have clean/safe sex workers around here. It's a sordid gig for sordid people.

I agree with that, and it makes a huge difference.

There's also a thing in NZ you probably wouldn't be aware of - if you tell someone here you're a christian, the person you tell will probably walk slowly away shaking their head. Christians are not well-regarded here unless they're old ladies who grew up in the 1950s, when it was acceptable. The country's most-despised person, a piece of walking, talking faeces, is a christian bloke called Brian Tamaki, and that's what people expect a christian to be like.

Although, technical sidebar time: what in the ever loving hell could she do to be worth $500/hour?

I don't know who pays $500 for it - the charge at my friend's brothel is $250 for an hour, plus extras if requested. Extras being golden showers and other not-terribly extreme stuff. Dominatrices may charge more.

Are these women that talented, or is do they cater to unusually well-off yet lonely clientele? not being snarky or anything. I just don't get it.

The typical client is a married man who spends 3/4 of his time talking about what a frigid bitch his wife is.

I have morning tea with the girls now and then and it's the funniest hour of the month every time I go there. It really does make me ask who's exploiting whom, because the clients are universally sad, grey men who wouldn't ever get laid if they weren't already married.

Right, but again: in the States it is largely reversed. Haven't heard of any nearby church with abuses, but dead prostitutes are a real and ongoing thing.

Yes, you really have built an opposite world over there. Given the propensity Kiwi blokes have for murdering their wives/girlfriends/partners, I'd be very surprised if prostitutes had a greater chance of being murdered than any other female.
 
I think what's being disputed is your ability

elmo.gif
 
Did I miss me saying something in this thread? I don't think I ever claimed that sexual abuse or harassment was part of the job. My example explicitly showed that it wasn't, as if the men got unruly at all they were aggressively, and quickly dealt with by security on-hand. Which was a general rarity on the show.
One person I know who worked in a legal brothel told me that they had a Panic Button always very close nearby. If they hit the button, security would be in the room within seconds. And as you said, they were not gentle. The customer would be out on their probably bare ass, and they would not be welcomed back to that establishment afterward.
 
One person I know who worked in a legal brothel told me that they had a Panic Button always very close nearby.

The ABC store I buy my cigars from has a panic button. Every bank... ever has a panic button. The front check-in desk of the Cancer Treatment Center I work at has a panic button.
 
Exactly. Why would a sex worker at a legal brothel not have one?

They should, I just don't get what point beyond that is being made exactly.

Again "Costumers might get violent" is not an argument for an occupation being made illegal.
 
They should, I just don't get what point beyond that is being made exactly.

Again "Costumers might get violent" is not an argument for an occupation being made illegal.
Yes. I'm agreeing with you. And with plague311. Most if not all customer service occupations have practices and policies in place to deal with belligerent or abusive customers.

The point here is that when it is fully legal, there's really nothing special about sex work. It's a job like any other. It can even be one that a person enjoys doing. All of the negative stereotypes exist purely because it has been illegal and therefore a criminal enterprise for so long.

Want to get tough on organised crime? Legalise drugs and prostitution. That'll break their backs. And the best part? Tax revenue. These are two big industries, which could contribute in a big way to the local economy.
 
Yes. I'm agreeing with you. And with plague311. Most if not all customer service occupations have practices and policies in place to deal with belligerent or abusive customers.

In how many of those customer service occupations are you naked and alone with a man who believes he has rented your body for whatever sexual ends he deems fair to him? I mean, prostitution has built-in vulnerabilities not present in most lines of work.

And it's not like comparable damage can happen to a prostitute, compared to a sales associate. It would take a bit longer to be able to sexually assault someone in a public place, compared to the nude woman and client in a private room. The prostitute is physically a hairsbreadth away from the y/n line by the nature of the work. A cashier, not so.

The point here is that when it is fully legal, there's really nothing special about sex work. It's a job like any other. It can even be one that a person enjoys doing. All of the negative stereotypes exist purely because it has been illegal and therefore a criminal enterprise for so long.

That's what I was saying to The Atheist upthread. It sounds to an American ear like suggesting "hey, let's legalize protection rackets. That'll be fine". It's kind of not-fine by it's nature.

Want to get tough on organised crime? Legalise drugs and prostitution. That'll break their backs. And the best part? Tax revenue. These are two big industries, which could contribute in a big way to the local economy.

How'd that work after prohibition got repealed in the US? Dried up that criminal activity, did it? I think they just expand into new territory, rather than go to work at Wal Mart.
 
Sorry. Ethnic bigotry played for laughs isn't really my thing. Do you have anything else?

I got sophmoric toilet humor. That work for you?

Plus it's not ethnic bigotry by any standard. New Jerseyans are not a widely recognized ethnic group. Plus they are my peeps. You don't want me carrying either. Just trust me on that point.
 
One person I know who worked in a legal brothel told me that they had a Panic Button always very close nearby. If they hit the button, security would be in the room within seconds. And as you said, they were not gentle. The customer would be out on their probably bare ass, and they would not be welcomed back to that establishment afterward.

That is 100% correct in all respects.

Damn good thing no one is making such an argument.

You know what occupation is struggling with violent clientele right now?

Supermarket and grocery store workers.

USA - https://retailwire.com/discussion/retail-workers-want-the-right-to-defend-themselves/

UK - https://www.theguardian.com/busines...ers-groceries-or-turning-a-blind-eye-to-theft

NZ - https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/12...useholds-at-least-800-a-year-in-higher-prices
 
In how many of those customer service occupations are you naked and alone with a man who believes he has rented your body for whatever sexual ends he deems fair to him? I mean, prostitution has built-in vulnerabilities not present in most lines of work.
This misrepresents the nature of legal sex work.

As has been mentioned previously, nothing happens until money changes hands. I'll tell you another thing that nothing happens until: an agreement is made between the sex worker and the client as to the exact nature of the service provided. There is no such thing as "whatever sexual ends he deems fair to him". Everything is agreed to up-front. Any deviation from that constitutes a breach of contract.

And it's not like comparable damage can happen to a prostitute, compared to a sales associate. It would take a bit longer to be able to sexually assault someone in a public place, compared to the nude woman and client in a private room. The prostitute is physically a hairsbreadth away from the y/n line by the nature of the work. A cashier, not so.
You think a cashier is immune to assault? I have a friend who is a retail manager who was assaulted just a few weeks ago.

That's what I was saying to The Atheist upthread. It sounds to an American ear like suggesting "hey, let's legalize protection rackets. That'll be fine". It's kind of not-fine by it's nature.
To an American ear, yes. We're telling you what it sounds like to an Australian and a New Zealand ear, where the industry is legal and regulated. Are you saying that you don't believe us?

How'd that work after prohibition got repealed in the US? Dried up that criminal activity, did it? I think they just expand into new territory, rather than go to work at Wal Mart.
I think it's fair to say that quite a lot of the activity of organised criminals is in the area of drugs and prostitution, where those things are illegal. No, it certainly won't make the gangs go away, but it will take away an appreciable percentage of their business.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom