Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s always different when it’s your own kid. We can have a conversation in the abstract about the legitimacy of sex work, but I’m pretty dang sure none of us would recommend it as a career choice for our own kids. Forget any inherent dangers; it’s just the basic stigma of it. And possibly knowing that your own friends could potentially be clients of your kid. Money isn’t everything.

If my daughter told me she was working the brothels of Nevada, I’d be unhappy about it. It’s not my place to tell her (as a fully grown adult) what to do, but I’d be unhappy and would rather not talk about it or hear about it, even though I do think, in the abstract, sex work should be perfectly legal and even if I may have indulged in some aspects of sex work myself (strip bars, say).
Is it just stigma? There is no sense in which going into sex work, by becoming a professional at, and commodifying, a rather significant aspect of relationships is damaging to ones capacity to have successful relationships? Would being a prostitute change ones view of men? For the better?
 
I don't.

Does anyone have a discussion with their daughter about whether cleaning toilets at McDonald's is "valid career choice"?

No, why would you?

Now, if your daughter came to you and said she was considering taking a job cleaning toilets at McDonalds, you might have a discussion with her to make sure that she has really considered all her options. I would figure the same thing would happen with prostitution.

The question to me does not seem to come from anything based in reality when it comes to parenting. I don't sit down with my kids and give them a list of acceptable careers that I recommend or approve.
If I thought for a second there was a chance that my daughter was heading towards the sex industry, I would have a conversation with her. To me, it would be like finding out she was contemplating taking crack recreationally. I think it would be hugely damaging.
 
I don't.

Does anyone have a discussion with their daughter about whether cleaning toilets at McDonald's is "valid career choice"?

No, why would you?

Now, if your daughter came to you and said she was considering taking a job cleaning toilets at McDonalds, you might have a discussion with her to make sure that she has really considered all her options. I would figure the same thing would happen with prostitution.

The question to me does not seem to come from anything based in reality when it comes to parenting. I don't sit down with my kids and give them a list of acceptable careers that I recommend or approve.

If I'm wrong I'm sure Thermal will correct me but I'm certain you are misunderstanding the foundation of the question upon which an answer can be built.

He is not asking what advice you would give after your daughter had made a career decision or that you give her a choice of careers, he's asking if you would suggest legalised prostitution as a potential career path when/if asked for advice by your child. Kinda like,

"Well, Uni would be a good option and with your grades you could look at a medical, teaching, law degree or whatever. You could join the police or armed forces on a fast track plan. Perhaps a traditional apprenticeship might suit you better; learn a trade or an artisan career? What about nursing? All of these require you to put some time in yourself and need you to see things through when you won't be earning "top dollar", in fact you might struggle to make your way, independently, in the world until you're qualified. However, if you want a safe, legal method to make a fantastic living, earning around $200 - $500 an hour then you might want to consider being a sex worker. It's, I'm assured, safe, clean and on a par with any other service occupation. You can choose your hours and 8 hours a week will see you, I'm absolutely assured, around $166,000 per annum.
 
Why did you include that UK link? It's an entirely anecdotal, unsubstantiated piece about the rise of poverty in the UK and people not being able to afford to buy basic food items and resorting to stealing amongst other tactics. The nearest it gets to mentioning violence is when it quotes a worker saying,
:rolleyes:
Perhaps these would satisfy you?
Nurses and shop staff in UK face tide of abuse since end of lockdowns

Violence and abuse against shop workers increasing, survey says

Shop workers blame cost of living stress for rising abuse

Majority of retail staff experienced abuse at work last year, study finds
 
If I'm wrong I'm sure Thermal will correct me but I'm certain you are misunderstanding the foundation of the question upon which an answer can be built.

He is not asking what advice you would give after your daughter had made a career decision or that you give her a choice of careers, he's asking if you would suggest legalised prostitution as a potential career path when/if asked for advice by your child. Kinda like,

"Well, Uni would be a good option and with your grades you could look at a medical, teaching, law degree or whatever. You could join the police or armed forces on a fast track plan. Perhaps a traditional apprenticeship might suit you better; learn a trade or an artisan career? What about nursing? All of these require you to put some time in yourself and need you to see things through when you won't be earning "top dollar", in fact you might struggle to make your way, independently, in the world until you're qualified. However, if you want a safe, legal method to make a fantastic living, earning around $200 - $500 an hour then you might want to consider being a sex worker. It's, I'm assured, safe, clean and on a par with any other service occupation. You can choose your hours and 8 hours a week will see you, I'm absolutely assured, around $166,000 per annum.

No, I think I get it. And I stand by my answer: why would I be telling my daughter about every career path?

Would you ever tell your daughter about becoming a congressional staffer out of the blue? I wouldn't do that, either. Nor would I talk to my daughter about career opportunities on an oil rig. Or a zillion other careers.

That's why I consider it a lame question. Even if the answer is no, so what? It means nothing.
 
If I thought for a second there was a chance that my daughter was heading towards the sex industry, I would have a conversation with her. To me, it would be like finding out she was contemplating taking crack recreationally. I think it would be hugely damaging.

If I thought my daughter was considering taking a job cleaning toilets at McDonald's, I would also have a conversation with her.

Why single out sex work in this regard?
 

I didn't look at any of your links, despite the many hours you may have spent looking for some sort of pathetic "gotcha". This is thread about prostitution and the celebration of NZ being a world leader in legalising it (despite them being some 600 odd years late). If you want to start a thread about retail workers being abused, feel free. This is not the place.
 
If I thought my daughter was considering taking a job cleaning toilets at McDonald's, I would also have a conversation with her.

Why single out sex work in this regard?
See my other recent post on this thread. Generally cleaning toilets isn't a critical part of relationships that humans, and human society, have developed around. I would be concerned that professionalising and commodifying an act that is so fundamental would be enormously damaging and very difficult to come back from.
 
No, I think I get it. And I stand by my answer: why would I be telling my daughter about every career path?

Would you ever tell your daughter about becoming a congressional staffer out of the blue? I wouldn't do that, either. Nor would I talk to my daughter about career opportunities on an oil rig. Or a zillion other careers.

That's why I consider it a lame question. Even if the answer is no, so what? It means nothing.

Exactly. I neither need nor want to know every element of my daughters’ (I have four) lives. They probably have secrets I will never be aware of.

Which should not be confused with not always being interested in their welfare and being there to help.
 
No, I think I get it. And I stand by my answer: why would I be telling my daughter about every career path?

Would you ever tell your daughter about becoming a congressional staffer out of the blue? I wouldn't do that, either. Nor would I talk to my daughter about career opportunities on an oil rig. Or a zillion other careers.

That's why I consider it a lame question. Even if the answer is no, so what? It means nothing.

"Every career path"? You may be poorly advising your daughter then. **** knows what a, "congressional staffer", is or any of a "zillion" other jobs might be but, clearly, you put these above, "sex worker". The job is, I'm assured, safe and on a par with any other service job (I think Uber may be a notch or two worse) and can set an enterprising individual up for life, I'm assured, in a very short career.

We are told it's a gig job netting almost $200,000 PA. I hate my father for NOT telling me to go to NZ and rent out my orifices.
 
Exactly. I neither need nor want to know every element of my daughters’ (I have four) lives. They probably have secrets I will never be aware of.

Which should not be confused with not always being interested in their welfare and being there to help.

Which gets back to the bloody question! It doesn't ask, do you need nor want to know every element of your daughters lives? It doesn't ask, do your daughters have secrets you will never be aware of?

It asks you, in earthy language, to consider, if you'd advise legalised prostitution as a career path. I asked, "if not, why not?".
 
Which gets back to the bloody question! It doesn't ask, do you need nor want to know every element of your daughters lives? It doesn't ask, do your daughters have secrets you will never be aware of?

It asks you, in earthy language, to consider, if you'd advise legalised prostitution as a career path. I asked, "if not, why not?".

And I thought I was explaining why I think your question is stupid.
 
See my other recent post on this thread. Generally cleaning toilets isn't a critical part of relationships that humans, and human society, have developed around. I would be concerned that professionalising and commodifying an act that is so fundamental would be enormously damaging and very difficult to come back from.

Everybody is different though. It’s a fact that some women don’t feel any inkling of that whole social bonding kit and kaboodle thing around the sex act. Any such women who find sex aerobic and fun can have a great ******* time capitalizing on that if they live in one of the places that sex work is legal and safe.
 
Which gets back to the bloody question! It doesn't ask, do you need nor want to know every element of your daughters lives? It doesn't ask, do your daughters have secrets you will never be aware of?

It asks you, in earthy language, to consider, if you'd advise legalised prostitution as a career path. I asked, "if not, why not?".

For the same reason I don't advise thousands of other career paths. Why qould I? Just because it's a legal career path doesn't mean I have to talk to my kids about it.
 
I didn't look at any of your links, despite the many hours you may have spent looking for some sort of pathetic "gotcha".

That's rich.

You specifically asked what danger retail staff faced compared to sex workers, you were told, then complained that it wasn't strong enough evidence.

Now that it's been provided in detail you don't want to look.

Brilliant!
 
For the same reason I don't advise thousands of other career paths. Why qould I? Just because it's a legal career path doesn't mean I have to talk to my kids about it.

You're weaseling. Cleaning toilets does not pay 500 ******* dollars an hour. It's a cop out comparison.

For our posters with real or feigned reading comprehension issues, the question is:

Your young daughter is looking for work in a bad economy. Probably the only job on the planet to afford that kind of pay with little to no experience and flexible hours is prostitution (obviously assuming legal for our purposes).

If you think prostitution is no big deal, just like any other kind of work, do you ask her if she has considered it? Or is it only ok if it's someone else's daughter?

For that matter, include your son. Your spouse or partner. Your mom, age permitting.

If you would steer your daughter or spouse away from that profession, despite its incredible pay and easy terms, why are you so happy to have someone else's daughter doing it?
 
Last edited:
Your young daughter is looking for work in a bad economy. Probably the only job on the planet to afford that kind of pay with little to no experience and flexible hours is prostitution (obviously assuming legal for our purposes).

Given that conversations about careers took place when my daughter was 17 and leaving school, the point is moot, because the minimum age is 18.

I didn't suggest any careers to her anyway - I told her where to look at different careers and she figured it out herself. The same applied to my sons who are working now.

As it happens, I did recommend it as a job to a very dear friend of mine when she got into trouble with [legal] loan sharks and needed to increase her income. She was much like a daughter to me at the time and she had no regrets at spending a couple of years getting ****** for money.

If you think prostitution is no big deal, just like any other kind of work, do you ask her if she has considered it? Or is it only ok if it's someone else's daughter?

I'll ask her next time I see her. I suspect her boyfriend would be against it, but I'll let you know.

If you would steer your daughter or spouse away from that profession, despite its incredible pay and easy terms, why are you so happy to have someone else's daughter doing it?

I wouldn't steer her away from it, just as I wouldn't steer her away from being a stevedore or prison officer, two far more dangerous occupations.
 
In the States, we have prostitution legal in some rural counties in Nevada. There are something like two dozen currently operating, many closed and seized for their various criminal activity (The Mustang Ranch is well-known for its legal troubles). Take a gander at the pics of these places. They look about as seedy as you get. The Mustang Ranch itself was originally a couple double wide trailers. So in our real world evidence, it does not appear very successful in the States. The streetwalkwrs are racking the billions, not the $500/hr workers.
There is absolutely no basis for comparison here.
 
Given that conversations about careers took place when my daughter was 17 and leaving school, the point is moot, because the minimum age is 18.

As always, I appreciate your candor.

The premise of the question is set to avoid those kind of "technical" avoidances, though. Say she is of age. Bad economy. No real good paying jobs out there (a very real world scenario for a lot of us right about now). Would you ask her if she had considered this high-paying line of work? Why or why not?

I didn't suggest any careers to her anyway - I told her where to look at different careers and she figured it out herself. The same applied to my sons who are working now.

As it happens, I did recommend it as a job to a very dear friend of mine when she got into trouble with [legal] loan sharks and needed to increase her income. She was much like a daughter to me at the time and she had no regrets at spending a couple of years getting ****** for money.

See, that's interesting. Was there something about this woman that made you think she would be down to do this kind of work, or would you pretty much suggest it to anyone who was in need of cash? If none of my ******* business, just say the word, of course.

I'll ask her next time I see her. I suspect her boyfriend would be against it, but I'll let you know.

I suspect many boyfriends or partners would find themselves not quite so open-minded as they previously thought when faced with that, yeah. When I'm looking for a new car, I don't ask my wife to turn a few tricks to get the luxury package.

I wouldn't steer her away from it, just as I wouldn't steer her away from being a stevedore or prison officer, two far more dangerous occupations.

While we have ricocheted around between job safety and other concerns, I'm thinking here about the double standard in play (women whose well being we are more emotionally invested in). As others have said, tricking seems fine in the abstract, with the usual consenting adults doing so legally caveats. Just can't imagine a frame of mind where I'd bring up the option to my daughters or wife. And if it's not ok for women I love, why should I accept it for others?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom