Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fascinating mindset.
Edited by Darat: 
Moderated content removed.
, as opposed to her believing in Jesus.

And herein we find an encapsulation of the whole problem. Not only misogynistic but also misandronistic, and profoundly ignorant of how the sex industry operates, as well as the reasons people engage with sex workers in the first place.


Let me put it this way...if I am paying for sex, I am putting that woman (or man, if you wish) to work. I'm not the only one, and don't be naive.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Let me put it this way...if I am paying for sex, I am putting that woman (or man, if you wish) to work. I'm not the only one, and don't be naive.
Exactly as if you were hiring an Uber. Would you use such derogatory language to refer to your Uber driver?
 
Let me put it this way...if I am paying for sex, I am putting that woman (or man, if you wish) to work. I'm not the only one, and don't be naive.

Doesn't the same apply if I'm paying a taxi driver?

Which incidentally is also a profession at high risk of being murderized to death by a client, just to get that argument out of the way. E.g., in the USA taxi drivers are 30 TIMES above the national average workplace homicide rate, well above cops and security guards.

But if the question were "would you let your daughter be a taxi driver?" nobody would bat an eye if you said "yes."
 
Is there something admirable about prioritizing abstract truth over psychological well-being?

You're "caining" me, right. You have to be! Christianity is abstract truth? Really? Christianity supplies psychological well-being? Really?

I would never have picked you as someone with a theological bent

What do I want for my hypothetical daughter: The unpleasant, dangerous, low-status job of being a prostitute OR being part of a community where she's honored and loved? Most people probably say they'd prefer to be a dissatisfied Socrates rather than a satisfied pig, but what about a dissatisfied talking monkey versus a satisfied pig?

What ever makes you think that being a prostitute is unpleasant, dangerous, low-status? This is New Zealand we are talking about here, not 'Murica.

Unpleasant?
I know a couple of local prostitutes. They don't have to do what they do, they CHOOSE to do what they do. They love the work, they enjoy the pleasures of sex with no commitment and no strings, and are quite picky about which clients they will accept and which they decline. They are two of the most well adjusted people I know. One of them was a high-school teacher, and one was a chartered accountant. They quit their jobs because what they do now suits them better... and it pays better (I have been offered on several occasions and always declined.)

Dangerous?
This is just laughable. In order, the nine most dangerous jobs in New Zealand are farming, building, truck driving, rubbish collection, line mechanic, structural steel & iron worker, roofer, commercial fisherman and logging contractor/worker. The lowest ACC (Accident Compensation Corporation) Business Industry Code (BIC, which indicates the measure of how likely you are to be injured, maimed or killed in your job) is...
S953440 for Prostitutes.
S953410 for Brothel Keepers.
S953420 for Escorts.
S953425 for Massage Parlour Workers and Operators.

These are the very lowest risk BICs, way down there with office workers and administrative staff. *

Low-status:
I don't think so. The few that I know personally, earn in the 2½K - 3K a week bracket. One of them owns a $1.5 million house on the Port Hills, another, a million dollar home in Brougham Street, one of the richest neighbourhoods in Nelson - so no, low-status...definitely not. Literally no-one I know regards professional sex workers as "low-status".

Being part of a community where she's honored and loved?
OK, now I KNOW you must be "caining" me. Women? Honoured in the Christian church? Really... I mean REALLY? Bwhahahaha! To quote a famous former tennis star... "you cannot be serious!"

*NOTE: I should point out that these BICs are not just classifications pulled out of the air. They are adjusted to account for the number and seriousness of claims made to the ACC. Sex workers were first added to the ACC levies register in 2004 after prostitution was made legal by the NZ Parliament. 18 years has passed since then, so any errors in the system have been well ironed out by now.
 
Last edited:
Unpleasant?
I know a couple of local prostitutes. They don't have to do what they do, they CHOOSE to do what they do. They love the work, they enjoy the pleasures of sex with no commitment and no strings, and are quite picky about which clients they will accept and which they decline. They are two of the most well adjusted people I know. One of them was a high-school teacher, and one was a chartered accountant. They quit their jobs because what they do now suits them better... and it pays better (I have been offered on several occasions and always declined.)


"Outlier is the norm", strikes again.

Honestly, it sounds so ******* stupid that it can't be quantified. But I guess it is always possible to create a supporting anecdote for anything. Good stuff.
 
Last edited:
"Outlier is the norm", strikes again.

Honestly, it sounds so ******* stupid that it can't be quantified. But some people have a supporting anecdote for everything. Good stuff.

Except, its not an outlier, it IS the norm in this country. Since 2003, the vast majority of prostitutes in this country do what they do by choice, NOT because they are forced to. It's what happens when you make prostitution legal... when the gangs and the criminals no longer have control of the industry and their girls - when brothels can apply for government registration, and their workers are protected by piloce, not prosecuted by them.

https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/20...antastic_for_new_zealand_prostitutes_say.html
 
I'm not paying my Uber to **** me, bro. Usually.
Irrelevant. You are hiring them to provide a service.

Incidentally, I chose Uber as my example because Uber and sex work are both gig economy jobs. They get paid for each time they are hired, as opposed to drawing a regular salary, so they are quite analogous. It is only the service that they provide that is different.

Or do you disagree?
 
It is not. We have a similar situation where I live, though it is legal only in certain locations here. The industry is not controlled by organised crime. They are legitimate workers, with all the legal protections that other workers have.



And then we come back full circle. Where you say I don't understand the sex industry in the US, and I tell you that when I am paying, I am going to town on those privates.

Are you disputing my position, or that most prostitutes are abused in my own country? Or also, do you think that worldwide most prostitutes are happy, good-earners, and well-adjusted? How about SC's stories...are most living in $1M homes?
 
Last edited:
Are you disputing my position, or that most prostitutes are abused in my own country? Or also, do you think that worldwide most prostitutes are happy, good-earners, and well-adjusted? How about SC's stories...are most living in $1M homes?
I'm saying that in places where it's legal, they are. In places where it is not legal, sex workers are routinely abused and exploited by pimps and organised criminals. This alone is a very good reason sex work should be legal. I repeat my earlier statement:

You can't ban sex work. You can only ban safe sex work.
 
I'm saying that in places where it's legal, they are. In places where it is not legal, sex workers are routinely abused and exploited by pimps and organised criminals. This alone is a very good reason sex work should be legal. I repeat my earlier statement:


My position is that "sex work" will never be safe. The animalistic nature of the transaction, and indeed the very concept of treating women or men as sex objects will not allow it.

This isn't like hiring an Uber, as you suggested.
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 12 removed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My position is that "sex work" will never be safe. The animalistic nature of the transaction, and indeed the very concept of treating women or men as sex objects will not allow it.
You are wrong about that, and this goes into the reasons why I said that you were ignorant of the reasons that people engage with legitimate sex workers in the first place.

I don't blame you for your ignorance - you're clearly from a part of the world where sex work has been criminalised and delegitimised for ages, and you just haven't had any experience with legal sex work. Making it legal changes the industry a lot. You'd probably have to vote a lot of conservatives out of office before you'd see it, though.
 
You are wrong about that, and this goes into the reasons why I said that you were ignorant of the reasons that people engage with legitimate sex workers in the first place.

I don't blame you for your ignorance - you're clearly from a part of the world where sex work has been criminalised and delegitimised for ages, and you just haven't had any experience with legal sex work. Making it legal changes the industry a lot. You'd probably have to vote a lot of conservatives out of office before you'd see it, though.


You are entirely wrong in the concept that treating people as sex objects has a desirable outcome. This is disgusting.

Do not preach to me about ignorance. Remove that plank from your eye.
 
Last edited:
Moved a few posts to AAH for over-heated bickering. The thread is getting rather heated so this is a reminder to stop the personalisation and get back to the topic, which is not each other.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Just dropped in to point out that, from what I hear, the term "sex worker" is preferred over "prostitute" due to the historical negative connotations associated with the latter. Thus the thread title may be a little behind the times, at least within some circles. Of course, in a thread in which "whore" has made a misogynistic appearance, me writing this post is probably the equivalent of serving as my own sex worker.
 
You are entirely wrong in the concept that treating people as sex objects has a desirable outcome. This is disgusting.

1. Even if I'm to accept the premise that it's not a desirable job, driving a garbage truck is also a rather undesirable job. Coal miner is a very undesirable job. Soldier, well, ask all those Iraqi tank crews -- or more recently the Russian ones -- how that worked for them. I don't see much of a drive to ban those jobs, though.

2. But here's a very conservative idea: the market decides, no? Value and desirability being measured in how much the customer is willing to pay and how many do? Supply, demand, price, that kinda thing? Adam Smith's invisible hand? Austrian School of economics? I hear conservatives and libertarians love that kinda stuff.

Well, from the whole whine going on about a lack of people who want to flip burgers and such, that actually tells you right there which is the less desired job (at the offered price.) A LOT of people would rather literally eat a bag of dicks than work minimum wage. (Presumably because the former ISN'T minimum wage.) THAT is how you determine which job is less desirable :p
 
Last edited:
Just dropped in to point out that, from what I hear, the term "sex worker" is preferred over "prostitute" due to the historical negative connotations associated with the latter. Thus the thread title may be a little behind the times, at least within some circles. Of course, in a thread in which "whore" has made a misogynistic appearance, me writing this post is probably the equivalent of serving as my own sex worker.

Err... that's in the wording of a law from 1413. I know keyboard warriors love to be offended, but you're not gonna get people from 1413 to change that wording no matter how hard you're offended. You know, cone of causality and all that.

Well, not unless you're sexy enough to be worth taking along in my TARDIS, anyway ;)
 
I prefer the descriptor of "sex worker" because it includes others in the business of selling sex, like strippers and porn stars.

As I mentioned above, you can pay someone to have sex as long as you film it (and commercialize it) and it's perfectly legal, so it seems to me that drawing the line at prostitution is fairly arbitrary.

That would be my basis for using "sex workers."
 
As for sex workers automatically being abused because that 'is what happens', that argument doesn't hold water in a situation where the sex work is legal and the workers can choose their clients and have legal recourse if a client abuses them.
 
Sex workers always being abused is what some people "want" to happen. That's why it doesn't make sense to sane people who live in reality and actually care about other people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom