Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.

The Atheist

Psychopath
Joined
Jul 3, 2006
Messages
38,203
Laws on prostitution vary around the world, with New Zealand, as usual, leading the way in how to deal with the world's oldest profession.

We have carte blanche here, with prostitution legal, and the vast majority of it is carried out as taxable activity, and prostitutes have close relations with police - in a good way, that is. Crooks use hookers, cops know it, and the prostitutes themselves are nowadays entirely helpful to cops. Gang and criminal ownership of brothels has decreased to zero, and pimps are almost unknown.

Despite being an attractive target for sex trafficking, the practice here is rare, and usually caught - honest hookers have no truck with illegals taking money from them and there's little demand for illegal hookers anyway.

STD rates among prostitutes is very low, and harm to women has decreased. No non-religious conservative group in NZ is opposed to the law, and that group can go **** itself anyway.

Some countries have made the client a criminal, which is no less idiotic than making the prostitution itself illegal - it drives it underground and into danger.

We had the final confirmation of why legality is the only sensible answer a couple of months ago when a man who had been told not take his condom off went and did so.

He was given 3 years & 9 months in jail for rape.

Disclosure: I don't visit prostitutes, but I have a good [female] friend who owns a brothel.
 
It’s a very similar situation in Victoria (prostitution is regulated at a state level in Australia). It is neither a social nor a political issue here.
 
The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread. Anatole France

In some places in the world, the law forbids rich as well as poor to sell sex whether in street, under bridges or in brothels. In other places, the law in its majestic equality, allows rich as well as poor women as well as men to sell sex. In both cases, it is pretty obvious who has to resort to selling sex and who hasn't.
Some people see the opportunity for the state to tax sex workers as beneficial. Some people also see the opportunity to make a business out of women selling sex as beneficial.

Stop blaming sex workers for their murders - they deserve to be safe (Stuff.co.nz, Jan 9, 2020)
Sex workers deserve living conditions and incomes that don't force them to sell sex.
Women are the primary victims of human trafficking. New Zealand's plan to stop slavery forgot them (Stuff.co.nz, Jan 19, 2021)
Does a new plan include them?

I haven't seen statistics on crimes against sex workers in New Zealand. There aren't any references to facts like that in the thread so far. I wonder how much "harm to women has decreased", and in this context harm to sexworkers, in particular. Decreased from what to what? What effect has the law had on this? For instance, do some prostitutes now avoid reporting crimes committed against them because they will then be accused of tax evasion?
 
Yeah, let's hear it for 45 months in prison for pulling off the rubber!
 
Leading the way? Here's a decree from the city of Amsterdam in 1413

Because whores are necessary in big cities and especially in cities of commerce such as ours – indeed it is far better to have these women than not to have them – and also because the holy church tolerates whores on good grounds, for these reasons the court and sheriff of Amsterdam shall not entirely forbid the keeping of brothels.

You guys didn't become a separate colony until 1841 and weren't made self-governing until 1852, 439 years after that decree.

Leading the way.... :p
 
The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread. Anatole France

In some places in the world, the law forbids rich as well as poor to sell sex whether in street, under bridges or in brothels. In other places, the law in its majestic equality, allows rich as well as poor women as well as men to sell sex. In both cases, it is pretty obvious who has to resort to selling sex and who hasn't.
Some people see the opportunity for the state to tax sex workers as beneficial. Some people also see the opportunity to make a business out of women selling sex as beneficial.

Stop blaming sex workers for their murders - they deserve to be safe (Stuff.co.nz, Jan 9, 2020)
Sex workers deserve living conditions and incomes that don't force them to sell sex.
Women are the primary victims of human trafficking. New Zealand's plan to stop slavery forgot them (Stuff.co.nz, Jan 19, 2021)
Does a new plan include them?

I haven't seen statistics on crimes against sex workers in New Zealand. There aren't any references to facts like that in the thread so far. I wonder how much "harm to women has decreased", and in this context harm to sexworkers, in particular. Decreased from what to what? What effect has the law had on this? For instance, do some prostitutes now avoid reporting crimes committed against them because they will then be accused of tax evasion?
Prostitution seems to fall midrange in income dreams.
Probably about par with trades, but I guess the hours are different. I have never been a great morning person....
 
In some places in the world, the law forbids rich as well as poor to sell sex whether in street, under bridges or in brothels. In other places, the law in its majestic equality, allows rich as well as poor women as well as men to sell sex. In both cases, it is pretty obvious who has to resort to selling sex and who hasn't.

More cases of men legislating what women do with their bodies is a good answer.

Sex workers, however, believe the Swedish model puts their lives at risk and undermines their human rights.

Some people see the opportunity for the state to tax sex workers as beneficial. Some people also see the opportunity to make a business out of women selling sex as beneficial.

Shall we just stick to verified, substantive research? Opinions tend to be irrelevant in allegedly moral subjects, but thanks to rigorous oversight of the law, (by a heavily left % female dominated Parliament) we know exactly what the outcomes are:

But research submitted to the review committee by the University of Otago and New Zealand’s Prostitutes’ Collective (NZPC) found that the majority of sex workers “articulated increased power” in their negotiations with clients and management post-decriminalisation, and felt more supported by the legal system.

Of the sex workers who responded to the NZPC survey, 96% said the law made them feel safer.

The researchers concluded that decriminalisation had resulted in “few, if any, negative consequences” in terms of the health and safety of sex workers, and had not led to an increase in their numbers.

“Despite the oft-repeated claims of its shortcomings, the academic evidence that has been gathered so far clearly supports the New Zealand decriminalisation model as an ideal starting point,” says criminology expert Dr Armstrong.

“No law is perfect, but this is the best approach we have so far for supporting sex worker rights and facilitating access to justice,” she adds. “There is no alternative worth pursuing.”
https://www.theweek.co.uk/fact-check/94086/the-truth-about-decriminalising-prostitution

You know this stuff is all online? Google can be your friend when you're trying to make points about a cou8ntry you have zero knowledge of.

Still, some people support the War on Drugs, too, despite centuries of evidence that prohibition is always the worst answer.


Shock, horror! A sex worker was murdered! So were hundreds of other women. I reckon guys should stop killing women. If only we had a law against it, it wouldn't happen.

But you might be right, since no sex workers never get murdered in Denmark.

Sex workers deserve living conditions and incomes that don't force them to sell sex.

Provide evidence that women in NZ are becoming prostitutes through economic necessity.

Every woman who works at my friend's brothel does it through being able to earn 3-5 times what they were earning elsewhere.


Nope - read the report.

I haven't seen statistics...

Now you have.

Yeah, let's hear it for 45 months in prison for pulling off the rubber!

If, as I strongly suspect, you think that's too much, unlike the several sane people who have posted quite correctly that 45 years would be more appropriate, I feel sorry for any actual women you know.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
IMO Prostitution should be legal, but it certainly needs to be highly regulated because even if it's legal sex workers are still extremely vulnerable.
 
Sometimes I confuse what's called
Edited by jimbob: 
redacted due to Rule 9
. Only one of them is illegal in the state of California.

I just looked up escorts in Los Angeles. Great, now that's in my search history. I'm leaving it because Sun Tzu said, "No browser history is always more revealing." I was not tempted, but one of these "VIP" ladies WHORES charges $800 for the first hour, and the $600 for each additional hour -- or, $3400 for 8 hours. She was exceptionally attractive and, fair enough, prostitution is an obscenely dangerous job, but I don't have that kind of coin. Also, her profile was poorly written.

It seems most of them take Venmo, but one said she accepts BitCoin. I'd bet cash more than a few accept payment in the form of cocaine.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Still, some people support the War on Drugs, too, despite centuries of evidence that prohibition is always the worst answer.

Yup, 100% agree.

It took America 14 years to wake up to this fact the previous time they tried it, and by the time they did, an organized criminal enterprise had arisen using the prohibition of liquor as its foundation and primary income earner. When prohibition ended in 1933, the financial rug was whipped out from under them so that they had to turn to other types of racketeering as means to make their money..... prostitution, arms smuggling, bet fixing, extortion, theft, financial crimes and drug trafficking.

Idiots never learn from their mistakes!
 
IMO Prostitution should be legal, but it certainly needs to be highly regulated because even if it's legal sex workers are still extremely vulnerable.
It's only a dangerous job because it's been taboo and illegal for so long that it has become associated with criminality and criminals. If it were legal and subject to the same labour laws as other kinds of work, then sex workers would not be as hesitant to engage with law enforcement as they might otherwise be.

Legalise it, regulate it, develop a set of professional standards that sex workers and their clients are required to uphold, and the industry will carry less inherent risk.

And while we're doing that, how about we adopt a more professional language? Sex workers and clients, not hookers and johns.
 
I vote yes for whores. But please, let us have some health standards to protect consumers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom