Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.

Why did you include that UK link? It's an entirely anecdotal, unsubstantiated piece about the rise of poverty in the UK and people not being able to afford to buy basic food items and resorting to stealing amongst other tactics. The nearest it gets to mentioning violence is when it quotes a worker saying,

“You’re in a uniform, they don’t see you as a person, they see you as an extension of this company you work for, so people shout at you.” Customers annoyed that a product is no longer on special offer will shout at him, he says. “Fuses of people are short. People are under pressure.”
 
Last edited:
Why did you include that UK link? It's an entirely anecdotal, unsubstantiated piece about the rise of poverty in the UK and people not being able to afford to buy basic food items and resorting to stealing amongst other tactics. The nearest it gets to mentioning violence is when it quotes a worker saying,

Did you miss these bits?

Thefts have increased, she says, and the supermarket has started to employ a security guard

Supermarket workers tell of people getting to know the time when items get reduced and using physical force to get to them.

There has been a change in atmosphere, James says. Customers are ruder and more aggressive.
 
Did you miss these bits?

No, not at all but it's a bit of stretch to hold them up as evidence of violence and sexual assault, which is what we were talking about.

Thefts have increased, she says, and the supermarket has started to employ a security guard

Said security guard to stop thefts, I'll wager and since there is no mention of violent thefts I'm confident I'm right.

Supermarket workers tell of people getting to know the time when items get reduced and using physical force to get to them.

Close, but I know exactly what is going on here. This is when perishables get discounted (commonly called "whoopsies"), they are put in a specific section of the fresh produce aisle. Some customers will lift things off the trolley before they are re-priced and shelved, some will push past other customers and perhaps staff to get that reduced morsel first. It's not even handbags at 20 paces level of "violence".

There has been a change in atmosphere, James says. Customers are ruder and more aggressive.

As I said, a bit of a stretch to equate this to the level of potential violence we're talking about in this thread.

Anyhow, don't mind me. I don't know why I feel the need to be so picky about this.
 
Last edited:
This misrepresents the nature of legal sex work.

As has been mentioned previously, nothing happens until money changes hands. I'll tell you another thing that nothing happens until: an agreement is made between the sex worker and the client as to the exact nature of the service provided. There is no such thing as "whatever sexual ends he deems fair to him". Everything is agreed to up-front. Any deviation from that constitutes a breach of contract.

This is a strange response. You seem to think that a potential assaulter would be deterred by his contractual agreement? And I'm not sure how such an agreement would be worded so as to be clear enough in advance. Is there a safeguard against how many foot pounds of thrust he can deliver before she considers things abusive? Your argument seems to rely on the guy's personal integrity an awful lot.

You think a cashier is immune to assault? I have a friend who is a retail manager who was assaulted just a few weeks ago.

This is an even stranger reply. I suggested nothing about immunity. I said, and quite clearly, that a naked woman alone in a room performing sex acts is far closer to being sexually assaulted than a cashier in a public place. Bit of a chasm in difference, that.

To an American ear, yes. We're telling you what it sounds like to an Australian and a New Zealand ear, where the industry is legal and regulated. Are you saying that you don't believe us?

Yet another strange reply. Of course I believe you, and especially in the case of NZ, which is world-renowned for its highly unique treatment of sex workers. But there are cultural differences at play, which is the perspective I am working from. NZ has sane gun restriction; the States don't. NZ has approx 3500 sex workers, and in the States it is a $14billion/year industry, mostly operating at the not exactly $500/HR end of the cost spectrum. This is not going to be an apples for apples comparison.

Basically (and I intentionally offer this as a counterpoint from the perspective of a different culture), I don't think it would work here. It sounds like prices would have to be driven very high to make it taxable and fair to the women. There are likely very few Johns interested in paying much more than their customary $50-$100 illicit tryst with a hooker, so either the illegal end rides on as-is, or a new low-end illegal market emerges, perhaps of more decadent tastes.

In the States, we have prostitution legal in some rural counties in Nevada. There are something like two dozen currently operating, many closed and seized for their various criminal activity (The Mustang Ranch is well-known for its legal troubles). Take a gander at the pics of these places. They look about as seedy as you get. The Mustang Ranch itself was originally a couple double wide trailers. So in our real world evidence, it does not appear very successful in the States. The streetwalkwrs are racking the billions, not the $500/hr workers.

I think it's fair to say that quite a lot of the activity of organised criminals is in the area of drugs and prostitution, where those things are illegal. No, it certainly won't make the gangs go away, but it will take away an appreciable percentage of their business.

For a few minutes, sure. A few minutes later we'd see how resourceful they are in creating new markets. Just how dark those possible new markets could be is not a reassuring musing. Did the rum runners go down dramatically darker and more violent paths after repeal.of prohibition, and expand exponentially? I do believe they did. History has an annoying habit of repeating itself.
 
To our Aussie and Kiwi parents: did you discuss prostitution as a good way to make screaming good money working part time, with little to no experience at all? The Atheist, to his credit, has acknowledged that he did not.

And no weaseling, please. I'm not asking if they showed an interest in that line of work as a career. I'm asking if you suggested to your teenage daughter or son that sucking a few strangers' cocks a week is a stellar way of getting yourself off to a good financial start. I mean, since it is no big deal and all. You can sell your labor as a burger flipper for minimum wage in near sweatshop conditions, or casually get boned on your own terms for many times more. If you are sincere in your assertion that it is no big deal, why not suggest it as a valid opportunity (and no, I don't mean to advocate it any more highly than any other possibility, but simply mention it as a viable possibility if they might be ok with it)?

Eta: oh, and im not asking for the mindlessly generic "I support my child's career decisions" thing. I'm asking if you said to your own children, who were starting out looking for a good paying job : "Have you considered prostitution?"
 
Last edited:
To our Aussie and Kiwi parents: did you discuss prostitution as a good way to make screaming good money working part time, with little to no experience at all? The Atheist, to his credit, has acknowledged that he did not.

And no weaseling, please. I'm not asking if they showed an interest in that line of work as a career. I'm asking if you suggested to your teenage daughter or son that sucking a few strangers' cocks a week is a stellar way of getting yourself off to a good financial start. I mean, since it is no big deal and all. You can sell your labor as a burger flipper for minimum wage in near sweatshop conditions, or casually get boned on your own terms for many times more. If you are sincere in your assertion that it is no big deal, why not suggest it as a valid opportunity (and no, I don't mean to advocate it any more highly than any other possibility, but simply mention it as a viable possibility if they might be ok with it)?

Eta: oh, and im not asking for the mindlessly generic "I support my child's career decisions" thing. I'm asking if you said to your own children, who were starting out looking for a good paying job : "Have you considered prostitution?"

.... and if not, why not? Even during tertiary educational years it means you can support a very good lifestyle working on your own terms and hours.
 
.... and if not, why not? Even during tertiary educational years it means you can support a very good lifestyle working on your own terms and hours.
I hear tell that it is even possible to do this before tertiary education. Schools should be supporting these budding entrepreneurs. This could be just the kick the economy needs.
 
Since sex work is work, can bosses include performing sexual acts as part of a person's job duties? Some might argue oral pleasure is not part of a traditional office job, but maybe that's an oppressive, close-minded tradition we need to challenge. Anyway, let the free market decide. Advanced capitalism moves toward increased specialization, so a corporation would probably contract that work out. Instead of doing trust falls, we can strengthen morale by giving everyone blowjobs. "Colleagues" can be upgraded to "Eskimo siblings."
 
I find it intriguing how many people in this thread seem unable to contemplate a legalised, controlled and safe prostitution system. We have it in Australia and New Zealand. Does that mean there are no prostitutes in illegal, unsafe brothels? Of course not. But most can do what they do safely. And do people imagine there is not security only a button away?

And this nonsense about parents having a sit down discussion with their daughters about prostitution as a career. Do any of those spouting this stuff have daughters?

Pretty much every parent endeavours to raise their children to be intelligent, resourceful, resilient and independent. If those objectives have been met, their children make life decisions without great input from parents. Have my wife and I had deep and meaningful discussions with our daughters about sexual health, drug taking, sexuality, prostitution as a career etc etc? **** no! Why not? Because we don’t need to. They are adults and make their choices.

Is it conceivable that a daughter may have made money as a prostitute? Of course. But does anyone seriously think they would come to me to seek my blessing?

Some of you guys have no idea of parenthood.
 
Have my wife and I had deep and meaningful discussions with our daughters about sexual health, drug taking, sexuality, prostitution as a career etc etc? **** no! Why not? Because we don’t need to. They are adults and make their choices.

Really?

Sex, sexual health, relationships, drugs and lots of other important subjects are & were subjects for discussion from a young age.
 
Since sex work is work, can bosses include performing sexual acts as part of a person's job duties? Some might argue oral pleasure is not part of a traditional office job, but maybe that's an oppressive, close-minded tradition we need to challenge. Anyway, let the free market decide. Advanced capitalism moves toward increased specialization, so a corporation would probably contract that work out. Instead of doing trust falls, we can strengthen morale by giving everyone blowjobs. "Colleagues" can be upgraded to "Eskimo siblings."
Indeed, and why not? Giving your boss a blowie is really no more significant than doing some photocopying for him.
 
Really?

Sex, sexual health, relationships, drugs and lots of other important subjects are & were subjects for discussion from a young age.

Sure, but not when they became adults. We were happy that we did enough to raise them as responsible individuals and are always there if they want to discuss anything. Beyond that, their call.
 
I find it intriguing how many people in this thread seem unable to contemplate a legalised, controlled and safe prostitution system. We have it in Australia and New Zealand. Does that mean there are no prostitutes in illegal, unsafe brothels? Of course not. But most can do what they do safely. And do people imagine there is not security only a button away?

And this nonsense about parents having a sit down discussion with their daughters about prostitution as a career. Do any of those spouting this stuff have daughters?

Pretty much every parent endeavours to raise their children to be intelligent, resourceful, resilient and independent. If those objectives have been met, their children make life decisions without great input from parents. Have my wife and I had deep and meaningful discussions with our daughters about sexual health, drug taking, sexuality, prostitution as a career etc etc? **** no! Why not? Because we don’t need to. They are adults and make their choices.

Is it conceivable that a daughter may have made money as a prostitute? Of course. But does anyone seriously think they would come to me to seek my blessing?

Some of you guys have no idea of parenthood.

Thermal wasn't asking if you'd give your daughter your blessing. He was asking if you'd advise it as potential career choice. See, some here seem to be making the case that working as a prostitute, legally, put's the job on a par with any other out there. I think Thermals question is valid.

Would you agree that there is a certain stigma to the job? Y'know in answer to...

"So, tell me what does your daughter do?"

What would you prefer, "she's in the legal field, in HR", or "she's a sex", worker, in legalised prostitution"?

I'm happy to admit that if prostitution was legal in the UK and my son (hey, boys can be sex workers too LK) came to me years ago asking for career advice, I'd steer him clear of selling his arse being a sex worker, no matter how much money he could make and I think that makes me a good parent in that regard.
 
Last edited:
It’s always different when it’s your own kid. We can have a conversation in the abstract about the legitimacy of sex work, but I’m pretty dang sure none of us would recommend it as a career choice for our own kids. Forget any inherent dangers; it’s just the basic stigma of it. And possibly knowing that your own friends could potentially be clients of your kid. Money isn’t everything.

If my daughter told me she was working the brothels of Nevada, I’d be unhappy about it. It’s not my place to tell her (as a fully grown adult) what to do, but I’d be unhappy and would rather not talk about it or hear about it, even though I do think, in the abstract, sex work should be perfectly legal and even if I may have indulged in some aspects of sex work myself (strip bars, say).
 
Thermal wasn't asking if you'd give your daughter your blessing. He was asking if you'd advise it as potential career choice. See, some here seem to be making the case that working as a prostitute, legally, put's the job on a par with any other out there. I think Thermals question is valid.

I don't.

Does anyone have a discussion with their daughter about whether cleaning toilets at McDonald's is "valid career choice"?

No, why would you?

Now, if your daughter came to you and said she was considering taking a job cleaning toilets at McDonalds, you might have a discussion with her to make sure that she has really considered all her options. I would figure the same thing would happen with prostitution.

The question to me does not seem to come from anything based in reality when it comes to parenting. I don't sit down with my kids and give them a list of acceptable careers that I recommend or approve.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom