Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
NJ, of all states, does not exactly have one stop shopping or one click websites for all the information you are looking for. Some, as I said is contract law, some is in motor vehicle law, some on DCAs site, which to be honest, I visit once a year at renewal time but haven't had to do anything new there in a decade and a half. Not sure if they've fixed that train wreck yet.
Yeah, like I said, lawyers are the ones that get the big bucks.

Anyway, once again thanks for the opportunity to look into a little bit of your relevant legislation.
 
You really don't need to appeal to religion to recognize that sex really does have special status. Even from a purely psychological perspective, sex is different than most activities, and for very good evolutionary reasons, especially for women. Pretending that sex is not special isn't enlightened, it's delusional.

Funny, I feel exactly the opposite, that it's as childish and naive to think sex and love are something special as it is to believe an invisible sky-fairy made humans and that we're special.

Ho hum.

But it doesn't reduce the exploitation.

It's not a question of "perfect being the enemy of good". It's a matter of snake oil glossing over the illness, and everyone just smiles about how great the snake oil is.

Whereas You're just completely wrong.

I note you still haven't answered why you think you have a better insight into prostitutes lives than they do, and why you think your views should be enforced on women who don't live as you want them to.

Not that it will make a blind bit of difference to your inbuilt bias - the Prostitution Law reform took place under Helen Clark's Prime Ministership. Easily the strongest feminist ever involved in NZ politics and I think infinitely more credible on the subject than some woman on a discussion site.
 
Newsflash for Thermal. This was much more rife before the PRA. Less so now.



You understand that the case you appear to be talking about was from almost 20 years ago in 2004 - only 8 months after the PRA was enacted, right? This was also a case of a family prostituting their daughter - her father had coached her to have sex for money from a very early age.

There is also another case where a girl of 16 was found working in a brothel. She had provided the owner with fake documentation, including a fake birth certificate and driver's license. Do you expect brothels to have a forensic forgery detection unit at hand?

Legalizing sex-work was never intended to deal with this sort of reprehensible behaviour. The purpose was to decriminalize prostitution - while not endorsing or morally sanctioning prostitution or its use, to create a framework that safeguarded the human rights of sex workers and helped to protect them from exploitation, as well as promoting the welfare and occupational health and safety of sex workers. In the 20 years since the PRA it was enacted, it has largely succeeded in what it set out to do - largely but not entirely. Given the nature of humans, it was never going to eliminate all illegal prostitution - there is simply no way to do that. If you're going to try to adapt the US gun nut model of "don't do anything to fix a problem if it won't fix it 100% of the time" then you are going to be disappointed - we don't do things that way in Australia and New Zealand - never have, and never will!
I don't think that poster is really interested in facts that contradict his existing opinions.
 
"You know, we've got a problem with child labor in this country. There are quite a few kids who are coerced into having to work, either by abusive adults or by financial circumstances. Many of them are homeless and have histories of abuse. And they end up being placed into a position where they illegally take jobs under the table just so they can get by. It's really a sad state, a lot of these kids are physically and emotionally abused too, and a lot of them turn to drugs to ease the mental trauma of their situation. We really need to do something about it."

"Oh, I know, I know! We should remove the age limit on work. Then those unfortunate kids in dire situations can work legally, and they can even get some paid time off! It's brilliant, it will be a vast improvement in the lives of kids who have to work when they ought to be in school so they can get by and make ends meet and not starve to death."

That's how I end up seeing the NZ Model. It's a solution to a side effect of the problem, but it doesn't actually address the problem. It makes it legal to exploit people in poverty and in dire situations, in a way that would be unacceptable in any other line of work, period. It doesn't address the underlying reason that people end up being prostituted in the first place, and it doesn't prevent them continuing to be exploited. It just makes the exploitation legal to do in the first place, and it gives a veneer of empowerment to those who are exploited - now they're allowed to talk about their exploitation!

But it doesn't reduce the exploitation.

It's not a question of "perfect being the enemy of good". It's a matter of snake oil glossing over the illness, and everyone just smiles about how great the snake oil is.
Yet more nonsensical strawmannery. Try harder.
 
Nah, it just renames them as "managers" and nothing else changes really. I mean, sure there will be a few brothels that become up-and-up establishments... but there's no real change to most of them. It legitimizes the same behaviors that happened pre-legalization.
:rolleyes:
Will you be supporting this opinion with actual evidence?
 
Who in the world said anything like this?
God Botherers?

QUOTE=pipelineaudio;14160235]And baseball for men carries the possibility of getting beaned in the nuts, so what?[/QUOTE]
Most of the variations on 'football' have a significnt risk of concussion or brain injuries.
 
I am increasingly reminded of the old saw about Puritan opposition to bear-baiting.
A little OT but it's becoming increasingly obvious how uptight USAia is. Specifically wrt films.
Take Passages; in the US it ws released without a rating,to avoid the dreaded "NC-17", here it got a'16'.
Oppenheimer received an R certificate in the US; here it was rated '15A'.
Last year Andrew Dominik’s Blonde got and NC-17 in USAia but a '16' here.
Earlier pretty harmless films, like Richard Linklater’s Boyhood and Bo Burnham’s Eighth Grade ended up with an 'R' in the US, but mere '15A' here.

The USAians seems to have a nasty obsesson with sex.
 
You don't think a sex worker has good reason to be concerned about a breach of their privacy?

Woah. Déjà vu again. I feel like we've had this privacy discussion before.

Oh wait, we have!
Here we're having concerns about the data of underage football players.
Though the FAI is involved so concern is probably merited,
 
Obviously not, or abortion wouldn't be a thing. But it also doesn't matter. Our brains didn't evolve to respond to sex with birth control in mind.
Compared to USAia countries with decdent sex education and access to contraception (here it's available free to anyone under 30) have low abortion rates. I rather suspect professions would take greater care than the majority.
 
Funny, I feel exactly the opposite, that it's as childish and naive to think sex and love are something special as it is to believe an invisible sky-fairy made humans and that we're special.

Sounds like you are going to fall back on quibbling about what constitutes "special". But even purely in terms of neurotransmitters there is indeed something special going on.

Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP> for rule 12.



Posted By: zooterkin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom