"You know, we've got a problem with child labor in this country. There are quite a few kids who are coerced into having to work, either by abusive adults or by financial circumstances. Many of them are homeless and have histories of abuse. And they end up being placed into a position where they illegally take jobs under the table just so they can get by. It's really a sad state, a lot of these kids are physically and emotionally abused too, and a lot of them turn to drugs to ease the mental trauma of their situation. We really need to do something about it."
"Oh, I know, I know! We should remove the age limit on work. Then those unfortunate kids in dire situations can work legally, and they can even get some paid time off! It's brilliant, it will be a vast improvement in the lives of kids who have to work when they ought to be in school so they can get by and make ends meet and not starve to death."
That's how I end up seeing the NZ Model. It's a solution to a side effect of the problem, but it doesn't actually address the problem. It makes it legal to exploit people in poverty and in dire situations, in a way that would be unacceptable in any other line of work, period. It doesn't address the underlying reason that people end up being prostituted in the first place, and it doesn't prevent them continuing to be exploited. It just makes the exploitation legal to do in the first place, and it gives a veneer of empowerment to those who are exploited - now they're allowed to talk about their exploitation!
But it doesn't reduce the exploitation.
It's not a question of "perfect being the enemy of good". It's a matter of snake oil glossing over the illness, and everyone just smiles about how great the snake oil is.