Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
I got to wondering, and not ending up with an an obvious answer:

If a hooker agrees to have sex with someone on payment of amound X; and then, if after the deed is done, that someone either doesn't pay at all, or else insists on paying less; then what's actually going on here? Is this rape, or is this some lesser essentially financial misdemeanor?


(Not saying this is directly related to the condom case that the thread's about. I can see how that condom business is a whole different thing. Just got to wondering about this particular what-if, is all.)
 
Last edited:
I got to wondering, and not ending up with an an obvious answer:

If a hooker agrees to have sex with someone on payment of amound X; and then, if after the deed is done, that someone either doesn't pay at all, or else insists on paying less; then what's actually going on here? Is this rape, or is this some lesser essentially financial misdemeanor?


(Not saying this is directly related to the condom case that the thread's about. I can see how that condom business is a whole different thing. Just got to wondering about this particular what-if, is all.)

Can't really call it rape if she was a consenting adult in the gig. It's strictly a payment default gig. I think that sex workers require the money be up front, specifically to duck this issue.

Like, she agreed to willingly do the actions. Payment is just money then owed, like an outstanding account balance.
 
The discussion related to condoms and consent was split off to it's own thread, here.
Posted By: xjx388
 
Legalize and regulate. Licence Sex Workers, and they have to agree to be checked every few months for VDs to keep their licence.
 
And while we're doing that, how about we adopt a more professional language? Sex workers and clients, not hookers and johns.

I can't speak for all prostitutes, but the ones I know have no issue with being called hookers. Maybe it's a rugby thing and not the same overseas.

I vote yes for whores.

That's not ok, though. Deliberately demeaning.

Nice.

If a hooker agrees to have sex with someone on payment of amound X; and then, if after the deed is done, that someone either doesn't pay at all, or else insists on paying less; then what's actually going on here?

The person is an idiot.

No sane prostitute does anything unless the money changes hands first.

Legalize and regulate. Licence Sex Workers, and they have to agree to be checked every few months for VDs to keep their licence.

The girls themselves have a much more vested interest in being disease-free than the clients, and imposing rules like that isn't going to happen, and nor should it.
 
The girls themselves have a much more vested interest in being disease-free than the clients, and imposing rules like that isn't going to happen, and nor should it.
Just a side note here, and I'm sure you're aware of this, but there are male sex workers as well, and they deserve the same rights as their female colleagues.
 
The girls themselves have a much more vested interest in being disease-free than the clients, and imposing rules like that isn't going to happen, and nor should it.


The above doesn't make sense. Why would the person who provides the service not be reasonably required to maintain a health standard to protect the consumer? Relatively speaking, they are operating a revolving door of risk.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
I got to wondering, and not ending up with an an obvious answer:

If a hooker agrees to have sex with someone on payment of amound X; and then, if after the deed is done, that someone either doesn't pay at all, or else insists on paying less; then what's actually going on here? Is this rape, or is this some lesser essentially financial misdemeanor?


(Not saying this is directly related to the condom case that the thread's about. I can see how that condom business is a whole different thing. Just got to wondering about this particular what-if, is all.)

Theft of services.
 
I heard it once said "If you think prostitutes are selling their bodies and people who work in coal mines aren't, your view of labor is clouded by a toxic view of sexuality." and don't have much to add to that.
 
I heard it once said "If you think prostitutes are selling their bodies and people who work in coal mines aren't, your view of labor is clouded by a toxic view of sexuality." and don't have much to add to that.
Toxic is in the eye of the beholder.
 
I heard it once said "If you think prostitutes are selling their bodies and people who work in coal mines aren't, your view of labor is clouded by a toxic view of sexuality." and don't have much to add to that.

"Would you want your daughter to be a sex worker?"

"No, and I don't want my daughter to make a living cleaning toilets at McDonald's, either, but I'm not going to make the job illegal."

Remember, paying someone for sex with you is perfectly legal as long as you film it and have people pay to watch it on the internet.
 
Just a side note here, and I'm sure you're aware of this, but there are male sex workers as well, and they deserve the same rights as their female colleagues.

Yes, good point, and they are, of course, covered by the same legislation.

What's the source for that? Seems to be plenty of news reports about pimps and gangs running these places.

Where?

Maybe you're reading old stories? They were heavily owned by gangs until legalisation, but since they're now an obvious business, the tax department demands records and gangs aren't good at that.

They try to muscle in on street workers now and then, but that's it, and the street workers do themselves no favours by mostly being addicts that a brothel wouldn't hire.

I had a bit of a look. I found this story:
https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PO2...ted-shortcomings-ignored-denied-or-hidden.htm

The report it is talking about is here:
http://familyfirst.org.nz/wp-conten...ion-of-Prostitution-in-New-Zealand-Report.pdf

I've no idea how reliable it is, but it might at least be a good source of links to data.

I'll tell you exactly how reliable it is.

Family First is an organisation run by one fundy christian nutcase and had their charitable status removed some time ago. They appealed and failed:

Family First lacked balance and objectivity, the court decided.

Bob McCoskrie and Family First are anti-gay, anti-abortion, anti-prostitution and are pieces of **** who have tried every trick in the book to fail to get anyone interested and they're never covered by sane media.

"Would you want your daughter to be a sex worker?"

I've said on many occasions I'd rather she was a prostitute than a christian.

Remember, paying someone for sex with you is perfectly legal as long as you film it and have people pay to watch it on the internet.

If you have a look at any porn site and see an actual prostitute who's working in a legal brothel in NZ on it, I'll buy you a box of chocolate fish. It's prohibited in all the brothels I know of.
 
The above doesn't make sense. Why would the person who provides the service not be reasonably required to maintain a health standard to protect the consumer? Relatively speaking, they are operating a revolving door of risk.

If I thought there were any chance at all that you wanted to be educated and weren't just being a typical anti, following a stupid fundy agenda, I'd answer.
 
IMO Prostitution should be legal, but it certainly needs to be highly regulated because even if it's legal sex workers are still extremely vulnerable.

Yup, 100% agree.

It took America 14 years to wake up to this fact the previous time they tried it, and by the time they did, an organized criminal enterprise had arisen using the prohibition of liquor as its foundation and primary income earner. When prohibition ended in 1933, the financial rug was whipped out from under them so that they had to turn to other types of racketeering as means to make their money..... prostitution, arms smuggling, bet fixing, extortion, theft, financial crimes and drug trafficking.

Idiots never learn from their mistakes!
I wouldn't say that the only reason prostitutes are at risk is because of prohibition but prohibition certainly makes it worse. Much much worse. So, I agree it should be legal and lightly regulated. Subject to age, time, and place restrictions but not much else.
 
Last edited:
Laws on prostitution vary around the world, with New Zealand, as usual, leading the way in how to deal with the world's oldest profession.

We have carte blanche here, with prostitution legal, and the vast majority of it is carried out as taxable activity, and prostitutes have close relations with police - in a good way, that is. Crooks use hookers, cops know it, and the prostitutes themselves are nowadays entirely helpful to cops. Gang and criminal ownership of brothels has decreased to zero, and pimps are almost unknown.

Despite being an attractive target for sex trafficking, the practice here is rare, and usually caught - honest hookers have no truck with illegals taking money from them and there's little demand for illegal hookers anyway.

STD rates among prostitutes is very low, and harm to women has decreased. No non-religious conservative group in NZ is opposed to the law, and that group can go **** itself anyway.

Some countries have made the client a criminal, which is no less idiotic than making the prostitution itself illegal - it drives it underground and into danger.

We had the final confirmation of why legality is the only sensible answer a couple of months ago when a man who had been told not take his condom off went and did so.

He was given 3 years & 9 months in jail for rape.

Disclosure: I don't visit prostitutes, but I have a good [female] friend who owns a brothel.
This is the way Prostitution should be handled in the USA. It might as well be legal as there is no stopping it and to me if a woman wants to make money doing that then let her.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom