Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
And then we come back full circle. Where you say I don't understand the sex industry in the US, and I tell you that when I am paying, I am going to town on those privates.

Maybe if you are a sadist securing the services of a tweaker. My impression of legalized prostitution is the same as any other socially regulated transaction; normal behavior is expected. If you hire a guy to clean your yard, you don't get to whip him because "you're paying for it".

Are you disputing my position, or that most prostitutes are abused in my own country? Or also, do you think that worldwide most prostitutes are happy, good-earners, and well-adjusted? How about SC's stories...are most living in $1M homes?

In the largely hookin'-illegal States, sure, it's a criminal business and the Low Life life abounds. Do you seriously think our $1000 high end call girls are getting deliberately mistreated? I think a full-on escort gets more like the sociable girlfriend treatment.
 
In the largely hookin'-illegal States, sure, it's a criminal business and the Low Life life abounds. Do you seriously think our $1000 high end call girls are getting deliberately mistreated? I think a full-on escort gets more like the sociable girlfriend treatment.

I seem to remember a show on HBO a long ass time ago. It followed the actions and business practices of a legal prostitution business outside of Vegas. Everything was cordial, ran just like you'd expect a business to be run.

That being said, they had a few people that got out of line with the ladies. The men that they had there to enforce the policies were not gentle. They were not patient. They did not wait for explanations. When the woman said the man abused her, hurt her, or threatened her, they were gone. Quickly, aggressively, and, often, hilariously.

If it were legal the women who decide to work in the industry would have significantly more options to protect themselves, including the police.
 
I seem to remember a show on HBO a long ass time ago. It followed the actions and business practices of a legal prostitution business outside of Vegas. Everything was cordial, ran just like you'd expect a business to be run.

That being said, they had a few people that got out of line with the ladies. The men that they had there to enforce the policies were not gentle. They were not patient. They did not wait for explanations. When the woman said the man abused her, hurt her, or threatened her, they were gone. Quickly, aggressively, and, often, hilariously.

If it were legal the women who decide to work in the industry would have significantly more options to protect themselves, including the police.

I recall the same, or similar show. I think it was The Mustang Ranch? A guy asks how much services are, and the woman says $1000 for the full treatment. He asks what $100 will get him, and she said something like a warm handshake.

Some posters here seem ok with the idea that they would be ok with their children in this line of work. The potential for even occasional abuse makes me hard pass that. I mean, people can end up in abusive personal relationships in other settings, but just as part of your job when you are already naked and in a presumably vulnerable position is like accepting occasionally being raped as a workplace nuicance. Just not something I could wrap my head around. .
 
I recall the same, or similar show. I think it was The Mustang Ranch? A guy asks how much services are, and the woman says $1000 for the full treatment. He asks what $100 will get him, and she said something like a warm handshake.

Some posters here seem ok with the idea that they would be ok with their children in this line of work. The potential for even occasional abuse makes me hard pass that. I mean, people can end up in abusive personal relationships in other settings, but just as part of your job when you are already naked and in a presumably vulnerable position is like accepting occasionally being raped as a workplace nuicance. Just not something I could wrap my head around. .


No, you have misunderstood this thought experiment.

There is a big difference between "being OK with it" and choosing it as one of only two allowed options because I consider it the better option of those two bad choices.

In this case I posited, after being provoked by one of our resident misogynists, that if I HAD to choose between my daughters "going on the game", or being in a Christian church, I would choose the former because I consider Christianity (all like dogmatic theism) to be far more evil than prostitution. Make no mistake, I despise religions like Judaism, Christianity and Islam - religions that promote the mental and emotional abuse of women, that treat them like chattels and second class citizens, and that demand undying devotion to the church.
 
Last edited:
I recall the same, or similar show. I think it was The Mustang Ranch? A guy asks how much services are, and the woman says $1000 for the full treatment. He asks what $100 will get him, and she said something like a warm handshake.

Some posters here seem ok with the idea that they would be ok with their children in this line of work. The potential for even occasional abuse makes me hard pass that. I mean, people can end up in abusive personal relationships in other settings, but just as part of your job when you are already naked and in a presumably vulnerable position is like accepting occasionally being raped as a workplace nuicance. Just not something I could wrap my head around. .

No, you have misunderstood this thought experiment.

There is a big difference between "being OK with it" and choosing it as one of only two allowed options because I consider it the better option of those two bad choices.

In this case I posited, after being provoked by one of our resident misogynists, that if I HAD to choose between my daughters "going on the game", or being in a Christian church, I would choose the former because I consider Christianity (all like dogmatic theism) to be far more evil than prostitution. Make no mistake, I despise religions like Judaism, Christianity and Islam - religions that promote the mental and emotional abuse of women, that treat them like chattels and second class citizens, and that demand undying devotion to the church.

This is something that I've seen quite a bit. Saying that banning some thing is worse than allowing the thing is not the same saying that I approve of the thing or that I think it would be a fine thing for my children to do.

I don't want my kids using meth. Banning Meth means that the dealers will all be gangster that can't resort to non violent means of resolving business disputes.* It means the dealers and users are all far more at risk of being victims of violence or other crimes. So, banning meth, means my kids are in more danger than if meth were legal.

Banning prostitution, same thing. Now, I by no means think that being a prostitute is as bad for my kids as being a meth addict but in both case, prohibition is worse for those involved directly and for society generally than legalization.
 
I'm approaching it more from the perspective that people past an age are allowed to make their own choices. They don't have to be my favourite choices. But if they don't harm anyone (and no, religious busybodies getting offended doesn't count as harm), meh, do whatever you wish.

I mean, equally I mutton wouldn't be my choice for a meal (no, seriously, I can't stand the taste.) And I find mould on cheese disgusting. But you don't see me trying to legislate against either.

It's funny, really. Well, not really. But anyway, supposedly conservatives are all for smaller government and responsible spending... except when it comes to inflated military budgets, building a wall on the border, extra police and prison spending to keep you from getting an abortion, or to tell you what you can smoke, what you can do with your body, what can you talk about (see the Florida law), etc, etc, etc. Seems to me like the whole "smaller government" thing kinda falls off and apart beyond being code speak for "don't give healthcare and unemployment benefits to <insert racial expletive>". When it comes to anything else, they're actually all for MORE government.
 
Last edited:
Just dropped in to point out that, from what I hear, the term "sex worker" is preferred over "prostitute" due to the historical negative connotations associated with the latter.

I think it's a bit wide-ranging, and the thread is specifically about prostitution, not acting in porno movies, strippers, dominatrices, or the myriad of other sex work.

Some posters here seem ok with the idea that they would be ok with their children in this line of work.

No, I said I'd prefer she became a prostitute than a christian.

I haven't recommended it as a job to my daughter, but I wouldn't try to talk her out of it if she chose to do it.

Is it any worse to sell your genitals than your labour? Is it worse to sell your genitals than take on a really high-risk occupation, like commercial diver? A lot of wage slaves would love to earn the money prostitutes do.

The potential for even occasional abuse makes me hard pass that. I mean, people can end up in abusive personal relationships in other settings, but just as part of your job when you are already naked and in a presumably vulnerable position is like accepting occasionally being raped as a workplace nuicance. Just not something I could wrap my head around. .

Except we have strong evidence that isn't the case after legalisation, and rape isn't an inherent danger. It's punished by the full force of law, and in the case of a brothel, where very high levels of security exist and cameras are pointed at men as they enter, I think the chances of being raped on the job are probably less than at any other time of a woman's life. The woman chooses who she *****, what sex acts she will perform, and at every stage has the right to decline, just as any woman does in any sexual situation.

I don't feel the need to point out the abuses that happen within churches. They're no sanctuary.
 
No, you have misunderstood this thought experiment.

There is a big difference between "being OK with it" and choosing it as one of only two allowed options because I consider it the better option of those two bad choices.
As a parallel from someone who answered the same way but for a different reason, and since my response to the question (which I think is entirely relevant and on-topic, and not bickery) was swept up with the spring cleaning, I say yes, I would be quite happy with a child of mine being a sex worker so long as it is voluntary, legal and safe. If that's the career they choose, I would support them in whatever way I could.
 
No, you have misunderstood this thought experiment.

There is a big difference between "being OK with it" and choosing it as one of only two allowed options because I consider it the better option of those two bad choices.

In this case I posited, after being provoked by one of our resident misogynists, that if I HAD to choose between my daughters "going on the game", or being in a Christian church, I would choose the former because I consider Christianity (all like dogmatic theism) to be far more evil than prostitution. Make no mistake, I despise religions like Judaism, Christianity and Islam - religions that promote the mental and emotional abuse of women, that treat them like chattels and second class citizens, and that demand undying devotion to the church.

No, I got it the first time. but by comparing the best case scenario for prostitution and the worst case scenario for being a christian...is that really a fair comparison?

For example, I've been around people that call themselves/identify as Christians all my life. The overwhelming majority either don't do anything at all with their church, except local stuff with the local community. The Catholic nun who helps me direct appliances and construction jazz to community members in need is my oft repeated example, as well as my kids who would spend a few hours on the weekend making up sandwiches and box lunches for distribution by this same nun to elderly people (the woman is a damn saint).

For the other end of prostitution, do I really need to point out how decadent that goes? You want to talk about the hideous abuses and human trafficking?

See, comparing prostitutes to christians is meaningless, due to the spectrum of each. Cherry-picking the caricature that suits your narrative of each is not the most robust of arguments.

And I'd still maintain that choosing to put your daughter in a situation where sexual abuse is "part of the job" (referring to plague311's example that we were discussing) says...something, for sure.
 
I got to wondering, and not ending up with an an obvious answer:

If a hooker agrees to have sex with someone on payment of amound X; and then, if after the deed is done, that someone either doesn't pay at all, or else insists on paying less; then what's actually going on here? Is this rape, or is this some lesser essentially financial misdemeanor?


(Not saying this is directly related to the condom case that the thread's about. I can see how that condom business is a whole different thing. Just got to wondering about this particular what-if, is all.)

I would say that it is fraud or theft, but not rape. Most sex workers insist on getting the money first, to prevent this sort of thing from happening. Of course, she might take the money and not hold up her end of the bargain. I would hope it would got without saying that this does not justify raping her. She would be guilty of fraud or theft in this case.
 
No, I said I'd prefer she became a prostitute than a christian.

I haven't recommended it as a job to my daughter, but I wouldn't try to talk her out of it if she chose to do it.

Is it any worse to sell your genitals than your labour? Is it worse to sell your genitals than take on a really high-risk occupation, like commercial diver? A lot of wage slaves would love to earn the money prostitutes do.

True enough. Do you think these guys might have second thoughts about the glamor of that gig if they were doing other men for that good money? Would you? See, it is very different than providing work with more tangible results that add value to your community.

I think it boils down to the associations we have in the States. A prostitute is usually a streetwalker, often with drug issues (Atlantic City/New York area boy here). We don't really have clean/safe sex workers around here. It's a sordid gig for sordid people.

Although, technical sidebar time: what in the ever loving hell could she do to be worth $500/hour? Sex is free and easy in the right places, and throwing $500 around at the right bar where I live will have you going home with two hotties for the night that will let you film them and upload it to Pornhub. Are these women that talented, or is do they cater to unusually well-off yet lonely clientele? not being snarky or anything. I just don't get it.

Except we have strong evidence that isn't the case after legalisation, and rape isn't an inherent danger. It's punished by the full force of law, and in the case of a brothel, where very high levels of security exist and cameras are pointed at men as they enter, I think the chances of being raped on the job are probably less than at any other time of a woman's life. The woman chooses who she *****, what sex acts she will perform, and at every stage has the right to decline, just as any woman does in any sexual situation.

I don't feel the need to point out the abuses that happen within churches. They're no sanctuary.

Right, but again: in the States it is largely reversed. Haven't heard of any nearby church with abuses, but dead prostitutes are a real and ongoing thing.
 
And I'd still maintain that choosing to put your daughter in a situation where sexual abuse is "part of the job" (referring to plague311's example that we were discussing) says...something, for sure.
Let me be extremely clear. In cases where prostitution is legal and regulated, sexual abuse is absolutely not "part of the job".
 
And I'd still maintain that choosing to put your daughter in a situation where sexual abuse is "part of the job" (referring to plague311's example that we were discussing) says...something, for sure.

Let me be extremely clear. In cases where prostitution is legal and regulated, sexual abuse is absolutely not "part of the job".

Did I miss me saying something in this thread? I don't think I ever claimed that sexual abuse or harassment was part of the job. My example explicitly showed that it wasn't, as if the men got unruly at all they were aggressively, and quickly dealt with by security on-hand. Which was a general rarity on the show.

So I'm not sure how this got attributed to me, but I just wanted to make my own position clear. When prostitution is legal you do not see those problems, at least not as frequently as if it were not legal.
 
Did I miss me saying something in this thread? I don't think I ever claimed that sexual abuse or harassment was part of the job. My example explicitly showed that it wasn't, as if the men got unruly at all they were aggressively, and quickly dealt with by security on-hand. Which was a general rarity on the show.

So I'm not sure how this got attributed to me, but I just wanted to make my own position clear. When prostitution is legal you do not see those problems, at least not as frequently as if it were not legal.

Really don't know how else to interpret your words then, unless I am supposed to ignore them? Look:

I seem to remember a show on HBO a long ass time ago. It followed the actions and business practices of a legal prostitution business outside of Vegas. Everything was cordial, ran just like you'd expect a business to be run.

That being said, they had a few people that got out of line with the ladies. The men that they had there to enforce the policies were not gentle. They were not patient. They did not wait for explanations. When the woman said the man abused her, hurt her, or threatened her, they were gone. Quickly, aggressively, and, often, hilariously.

If it were legal the women who decide to work in the industry would have significantly more options to protect themselves, including the police.

Kind of means that the abuse...um...happened? No? And I see you used the plural, indicating that it was a frequent enough occurrence to be a part of the show.
 
Really don't know how else to interpret your words then, unless I am supposed to ignore them? Look:

Kind of means that the abuse...um...happened? No? And I see you used the plural, indicating that it was a frequent enough occurrence to be a part of the show.

I mean, in the context that any unruly customer is part of any service job. It isn't anymore inherent in their job, in fact I'd say significantly less so, than in your typical waitress or bar tender gig.

The show I watched served alcohol, so it would occasionally happen. I certainly didn't mean to imply that it's anymore "part of the job" than in literally any other job that exists on the face of this planet.

Which was my point of clarification.
 
Yeah I mean "Sex workers won't be treated transcendently perfectly" isn't exactly a point.

And besides by no possible logic is keeping a job "off the grid" and underground going to help that.
 
Irrelevant. You are hiring them to provide a service.

Incidentally, I chose Uber as my example because Uber and sex work are both gig economy jobs. They get paid for each time they are hired, as opposed to drawing a regular salary, so they are quite analogous. It is only the service that they provide that is different.

Or do you disagree?

Well, as someone who did it for a while, I can confidently say that Uber drivers get ****** all the time. Mainly by Uber.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom