Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course, but in Australia the brothel’s books are open to the tax office. And it would be a very brave brothel licensee who ignored these rules. Losing a multi million licence would not be good.

And the value of licences is another thing which keeps brothels here safe and well run. Perfect? Of course not, but better than the non-legalised system.

:boggled: No business has ever kept two sets of books, or falsified their reporting. And licenses being expensive is totally a solution, as evidenced by NYC Taxis.
 
I'd be tempted to agree if I had a magic wand that could make sex work poof out of existence, but that's not the world we live in. We're choosing among the least bad options, and I think it's pretty clear what that is.

An even lesser bad option would be to go after the demand side of the problem, wouldn't you think?

Option 1: Exploiting people is illegal, and both the person doing the exploitation and the person being exploited are held criminally liable.

Option 2: Exploiting people is legal. Some small percent of people will voluntarily engage in the activity and won't see themselves as being exploited. Those who do the exploitation are not longer viewed as being exploitative.

Option 3: Exploiting people is illegal. The person doing the exploitation will be held criminally liable, but the person being exploited will not.
 
Absent the violent coercion and other illegal aspects of pimping, you're describing the normal relationship between the ownership class (or their agents, the bosses) and workers. "Security" is just another aspect of overhead costs that sometimes come with running a business.

I don't see what's really different between this brothel arrangement and say a bar that hires bartenders and also has a bouncer at the door to throw out rowdy clients.

The bouncer doesn't usually get used to force an independent contractor to keep working when they've had enough and want to go home. The bartender doesn't usually charge the wait staff for the ingredients needed to mix the drinks, then take a cut of each tip earned on top of the list price of the drinks.
 
No, it's a major variation. A worker registration, with age and all confirmed by the State, is worlds away from the current NZ model, where a John can pick up any streetwalker with no idea what her age is and bang away. It's actually happened already, and a lot more than once.

If the penalty for commercial sex was made equivalent to rape, instead of the pissant misdemeanor it is now, I think that would be a major deterrent from continuing in the black market.

The argument I was given against this was...get this...sex workers are afraid of a data breach. Oh, and if they tried to make a claim on their accident insurance, they have to list their profession there. Not sure what that had to do with anything.

That's a better proposal than what NZ has, to me.

To be honest though, I still have a serious problem with the premise that people - almost exclusively male people - should ever have a right to acquire sex from others. And that's a lot of what this boils down to: The punter has paid, therefore it's not rape.

If there were a really, really, good and nearly foolproof way to ensure that all prostitutes are there completely voluntarily, love their jobs, and are always in control of their clients, I would probably have a different view. If it truly was 95% comprised of the $2K a night escort driving a maserati, I'd have little complaint.

But that's not the case, and that just keeps getting hand-waved away. The harsh fact is that the majority of prostitutes in NZ are there because they don't have another choice. And the punters who are paying them to literally use their bodies are exploiting that desperation.
 
Evidence is pretty clear that likelihood of being caught has much more deterrent effect than severity of punishment. Doubt your "throw the book at them" approach would have much positive effect.

I suspect you might run into a lot of noncompliance with your "register as a sex worker" plan, especially for the least sophisticated street workers, but that's entirely speculative on my end.

Would it be a less bad option?
 
Go ahead and cite them again if they prove your case, I know from elsewhere that sexual slavery And human trafficking is a far more extensive problem in the US compared to NZ relative to their populations.

Part of that may be because the US still defines it as trafficking, rather than "employees" or "independent contractors".
 
What stops the bad players simply registering the sex workers without their consent or even knowledge? Or forcing them to do it?
Uh huh, but is it a less bad option?

Are you arguing that Thermal's suggestion would fix enough of the problems that remain under the NZ Model, so we shouldn't bother with it at all?

Your idea doesn't seem to address any of the issues with decriminalising sex-work, all it does is provide a legal out for the clients.
:confused: Registering with the state as a prostitute seems to imply decriminalization. What is it that you're inferring?
 
Well one can assume that there will be those who don't want to pay taxes on their work.

For example, with regards to the "Nordic model" as implemented in Sweden, prostituting oneself is perfectly legal. Selling sex is completely legal. And like most forms of income above a certain amount, one is legally obligated to report the income from prostitution in ones tax filings so that one can be taxed.

I don't know if there are any kind of statistics on it but I suspect many prostitutes are not paying their taxes.

The prostitutes aren't paying all their taxes, so let's make it legal to exploit them!
 
So, what is YOUR suggestion?

Given that we do not live in a post scarcity utopia, how would you see things regulated?
And how would that improve the lives of those working in prostitution compared to full legalization?

How about we change the entire narrative and instead focus on teaching males that they do not have a right to sexual intercourse, and that trying to purchase the use of another person's body for sexual gratification is a gross abuse of human rights?

I say males here, because the overwhelming majority of punters are male. There may be a scant few females in there, but this behavior - this expectation of sexual satisfaction - is an almost exclusively male trait. And it's one that has been around, and has been coddled by society, for eons.
 
You wouldn't think that there are some women who would get into this work eyes open and actually OK with it? I can totally see that, although I wouldn't think it applied to the majority.

I mean, not for me and all, and I want very desperately to protect those who would rather do anything else but rent out their asses, but surely some women (and men) are fine with all this and if it hurts no one, live and let live and all that?

Sure, some are probably genuinely into it. But I would bet that for those few, they'd be having nearly as much sex with willing partners for free if it weren't legal to charge for it.

Some people really enjoy being whipped and beaten; making it legal for them to sell the abuse of their bodies to others doesn't reduce the likelihood of those people being whipped or beaten. It does, however, increase the likelihood of someone who does NOT enjoy being whipped and beaten selling their services in order to get by.
 
But it doesn't reduce the exploitation.

How do you know? What's the metric for that?

I don't mean that flippantly. Unlike some here, I think people do get exploited even when they willingly agree to things, and sex work is exploitative. But that's not the end of the story. The whole thing is more complicated than just that. There are harms associated with prostitution which largely come from it being illegal. But there are also harms intrinsic to it, regardless of legality. Legalization reduces some harms and exacerbates others. If you want to find out whether that's a net good or bad on balance, you need to actually be able to define and measure the harm. Neither side seems to really be doing that. It's all abstract claims or unsupported assertions.

I would like to see hard data. I haven't seen any yet.
 
As your quotes keep showing the NZ model of decriminalisation has improved the industry in regards to the safety of the sex workers. Is it perfect? Obviously not. But is it much better than in my country? What's the word - that's it absolutely.

Why do you think this? The people prostituted in brothels, and the streetwalkers don't seem to have seen this massive improvement in safety that you think exists.

It has certainly improved the lives of the top 5% of extremely high end escorts, many of whom already had financial stability, a home, and a solid education when they made the informed decision to become an escort. I don't think you can reasonable extrapolate that to everyone.

If you wish to revise that and say "The NZ model of decriminalization has improved the industry in regards to the safety of the extremely high end escort workers", then perhaps we would have a point of agreement.
 
You really don't need to appeal to religion to recognize that sex really does have special status. Even from a purely psychological perspective, sex is different than most activities, and for very good evolutionary reasons, especially for women. Pretending that sex is not special isn't enlightened, it's delusional.
It may not be delusional. It very well may be nothing more than special pleading for the right of males to have access to sex as a service or a right.
 
The model this most resembles in the US, I think is strip clubs.

My understanding is that some clubs charge the dancer a fee to dance and then get a (large) cut of the "private dance" fees. They then consider the dancers to be "independent contractors" and screw them over as far as any kind of benefits. thinking about it, I think some hair salons and barber shops may do the same thing.
It's a crappy business model. the house getting a per client cut would, I think, serve to undermine the ability of the prostitute to reject a client at will. Even if subtle, there is likely to be pressure not to let dollars walk out the door. "You aren't doing enough volume, so we are giving your space to someone else. Sorry."

A better model would be each prostitute to pay a flat room fee per shift and have the house's income be independent of volume of clients.

I think this is uncommon nowadays, although I can't say for certain. I have a few friends who worked in salons, and they were charged a "chair fee" per shift. That was still a challenge in many cases though, a lot of times the chair fee was high enough to make it really difficult to cover it in a regular shift, and still leave time for the necessary cleaning between clients. If they had a slow day, it would cost them to go to work.
 
You really don't need to appeal to religion to recognize that sex really does have special status. Even from a purely psychological perspective, sex is different than most activities, and for very good evolutionary reasons, especially for women. Pretending that sex is not special isn't enlightened, it's delusional.



Uh, no. It's a recognition of the abuse of power. That scenario isn't an exchange between equals. Even if you're OK with legalized prostitution, the scenario of a director demanding sex in order to cast an actress isn't the same as ordinary prostitution.

This is what religious people would say
 
The vast majority of sex-workers in this country do what they do because they choose to do so, not because they are forced or coerced into it.
According to whom? According to the $2K a night high-end escort who was a well-paid accountant prior to changing fields? Or according to the destitute and homeless minor who ended up in a brothel still unable to make ends meet or get ahead?

This is an irrefutable fact. Sure, there is an underground, illegal element, just as there is in any trade, but its minuscule compared with what it was in the 1990's. Its it perfect? No, of course not. There is no such thing as perfect, and there never will be - but what we have in New Zealand and Australia is a colossal improvement over the situation that existed before the PRA was enacted. It is also and vastly superior to what happens in other countries, including the unworkable Nordic Model, a system that does absolutely nothing to protect sex-workers from the criminal element.

What prompts such confidence in your view? I mean, yes, not arresting the prostitute when they've been beaten up is a definite improvement, sure. But looking at the experiences of people prostituted in brothels or street walking, it really doesn't sound like it's produced a "colossal improvement" for them.

Was the situation in NZ so incredibly bad in the late 90s, that the current situation is that much of an improvement? If so, good job for addressing an abysmal situation... but I don't see that as something to crow about.
 
How do you know? What's the metric for that?

I don't mean that flippantly. Unlike some here, I think people do get exploited even when they willingly agree to things, and sex work is exploitative. But that's not the end of the story. The whole thing is more complicated than just that. There are harms associated with prostitution which largely come from it being illegal. But there are also harms intrinsic to it, regardless of legality. Legalization reduces some harms and exacerbates others. If you want to find out whether that's a net good or bad on balance, you need to actually be able to define and measure the harm. Neither side seems to really be doing that. It's all abstract claims or unsupported assertions.

I would like to see hard data. I haven't seen any yet.

The problem is that 1) nobody is collecting the kind of data needed and 2) most people involved in prostitution - even where completely legal - are probably not going to be willing to provide the data.

Yes, legalizing it reduces some harms. The biggest of those reduced harms being that the victim is no longer prosecuted as a criminal. And yes, hypothetically if a brothel employs the prostitutes as actual employees, they would get sick and vacation time. But so far as I can tell, the vast majority are being treated as independent contractors - but only in the ways that benefit the owner of the establishment, not in the ways that benefit the prostitute.

But it does nothing to address the physical and emotional damage. It does nothing to address the circumstances that lead most people to enter prostitution. And it doesn't in any way address society's widespread view of females as being objects to be used, the view of females having value defined largely by whether or not males want to **** them. It doesn't result in a reduction of violence against females, it doesn't even seem to have materially reduced the violence against prostitutes, which seems to still be common, at least according to those who have shared their stories.

What bothers me most about this discussion is that a move of desperation is being rebranded and valorized as "sexual liberation". And I really cringe that almost this entire discussion about "what females (and some few males) should be legally allowed to do for the gratification of males" is happening among males. I seem to be the only female to have taken part and spoken up.

And as the only female in this thread, I've been told that I'm toxic, that I'm anti-woman, that I'm a prude, and several other insinuated insults. Simply because I don't fall in line and vapidly endorse the use of human bodies as objects to be used and discarded when done.
 
This is what religious people would say

Because atheists are totally on board with exploiting the desperation of those in dire circumstances and feel perfectly fine treating other people's bodies as objects to be used and discarded when they've got their rocks off?

I think your appeal to religiosity is a transparent attempt to poison the well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom