Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
I....don't think you answered the question. I'm asking it because a sex worker is a public contractor...I mean she's literally offering to **** the general population...and generally, when you are hustling money from the grnetal public, yoi forgo a bit of privacy.

As we discussed last year, a plumber does in fact not hide himself or his identity. Very often,he is legally required to disclose it on demand. It's at least logical to want people to know who you are/what you do, so that they call you when you want that service. But with prostitution, the worker does everything possible to hide, right down to fake names.

It's almost like sex work is a little different than other kinds of work. Nah, that's silly, right?
The circumstances under which a person can be required to disclose private information are clearly outlined in legislation. And those circumstances can be different for different categories of people. Regardless, privacy is protected by law.

And yet again, do you not think a sex worker has good reason to be concerned about a breach of their privacy?

You're arguing against the "all work is identical" argument which I am very explicitly not making. I will answer my own question: sex workers have very good reasons for valuing their privacy, moreso than other professions. For reasons of privacy alone, yes - sex work is a little different from other kinds of work.
 
I....don't think you answered the question. I'm asking it because a sex worker is a public contractor...I mean she's literally offering to **** the general population...and generally, when you are hustling money from the grnetal public, yoi forgo a bit of privacy.

As we discussed last year, a plumber does in fact not hide himself or his identity. Very often,he is legally required to disclose it on demand. It's at least logical to want people to know who you are/what you do, so that they call you when you want that service. But with prostitution, the worker does everything possible to hide, right down to fake names.

It's almost like sex work is a little different than other kinds of work. Nah, that's silly, right?

I see you have yet post those personal details that I asked for.

whats-the-matter-chicken.gif


Privacy is no biggie right, so we are looking forward seeing you putting your claim where your bull-**** is!
 
This is yet another example of how people like Thermal et al simply have no understanding of how things such as laws and regulations work in other countries.

Man, if you are going to be smug and condescending, you can't say things that are stupid. The two don't mix well. We have similar privacy laws here, but they often don't matter, as we see below.

Thermal, if you think privacy is no big deal, then how about you post the following personal details here in the forum...

Real Name
Telephone number (including mobile)
Home Street address
Work Street Address
Social Security Number

Are you comfortable doing that?

As a contractor (like our sex worker) I have to, by law, print that info on every contract, on business cards that I must dispense on demand, and have printed on my ******* truck.

Except for the ss# of course, but that was a stupid thing to bring up anyway, as it is not a privacy issue, but a financial security issue. One's ss# is not a private thing to be shared between intimate companions only. It's a tax and credit reference number. I mean, do you read your posts at all before hitting "submit reply"?

No? If not, then you might begin to understand why a sex-worker would not want to have this sort of information out in the clear, because this is exactly the type of information what would be required for registration of both the owner of a brothel, and a self-employed sex-worker!

Btw, I'm not contracting with you or this forum, so again, your analogy doesn't work. No money changes hands, so parties here have no need to know any of that for any reason (although many do anyway..I could literally dtive to arthwollipots's home and moan his real name outside his window should i feel like it, because he posts his real info all over).

Oh, and sleep well arthwollipot
 
Last edited:
As a contractor (like our sex worker) I have to, by law, print that info on every contract

Well, since you're happy to do that, lets have your details.

on business cards that I must dispense on demand, and have printed on my ******* truck.

You're required by law to have a business card?

You're required by law to put your home address and your SSN on your business card and the side of your truck? Really?
 
Last edited:
Except for the ss# of course, but that was a stupid thing to bring up anyway, as it is not a privacy issue, but a financial security issue. One's ss# is not a private thing to be shared between intimate companions only. It's a tax and credit reference number.

You do understand about identity theft, right? I mean, you do know what it is don't you?
 
The circumstances under which a person can be required to disclose private information are clearly outlined in legislation. And those circumstances can be different for different categories of people. Regardless, privacy is protected by law.

And yet again, do you not think a sex worker has good reason to be concerned about a breach of their privacy?

You're arguing against the "all work is identical" argument which I am very explicitly not making. I will answer my own question: sex workers have very good reasons for valuing their privacy, moreso than other professions. For reasons of privacy alone, yes - sex work is a little different from other kinds of work.

Ok. Why? Why wouldn't she want her profession known?

And don't say "because the stigma, man" unless she desires to perpetuate the stigma. You know how it's considered healthy to "come out of the closet"? Same same. You can't honestly say you want to be treated with respect and dignity while you make great efforts to stay hidden and calling yourself Madame Boopsie.
 
I would like to see that legislation, please.

Knock yourself out at NJ DCA (New Jersey Division of Community Affairs) Home Improvement Contractors requirements. Vehicle requirements additionally fall under title 19 of NJ motor vehicle laws, commercial vehicle lettering.
 
Ok. Why? Why wouldn't she want her profession known?

And don't say "because the stigma, man" unless she desires to perpetuate the stigma. You know how it's considered healthy to "come out of the closet"? Same same. You can't honestly say you want to be treated with respect and dignity while you make great efforts to stay hidden and calling yourself Madame Boopsie.
Yeah. Okay. "Same same". Right.

Sorry, but I just have to take a moment to reflect on that, and on what might cause someone to come to such a bizarre conclusion. While I think about that, how about that legislation that requires you to disclose personal information?
 
Well, since you're happy to do that, lets have your details.



You're required by law to have a business card?

You're required by law to put your home address and your SSN on your business card and the side of your truck? Really?

Squirrelly and contradictory laws, but yes, a contractor interacting with the public is technically required to have a business card. There are a list of circumstances that you are required to present one on reqúest, and mandated information on them, including my HIC registration number.

For the truck lettering, it's my name and town/state and again HIC registration, but anyone with a smart phone can get the rest of my salient data from there, whether I like it or not. .
 
Knock yourself out at NJ DCA (New Jersey Division of Community Affairs) Home Improvement Contractors requirements. Vehicle requirements additionally fall under title 19 of NJ motor vehicle laws, commercial vehicle lettering.
Cross-post. Thanks. I'm looking through it now - or rather, since you didn't provide a link, I googled it and am looking through what I found.

ETA: I've found that the legal name and business address of the seller of contracted services must be on the contract. Still looking for the bit that applies to you.
 
Last edited:
I've found section 13:45A-17.5 - Initial and Renewal Applications, which sets out the requirement for certain information relating to "each officer, director, principal and person with an ownership interest of 10 percent or more in the home improvement contractor business" to be recorded in the business registration, but it doesn't say that this must be disclosed to the public.

Still looking for the bit that says you're required to have a business card. Give me time. Legislation tends to be a little hard to read. :p
 
And if you don't understand why sex has deep psychological mechanisms at play because of the possibility of pregnancy, you really don't understand humans. Or evolution.

If you don't understand why music has deep psychological mechanisms at play because of the possibility of hearing loss, you really don't understand humans. Or evolution.
 
13:45A-17.5A - Identification Badges.

Apparently you do need steenking badges, but there's nothing here that says you have to have your address and phone number on them, only your "name, color, photograph, and signature". I'm not sure whether that means "color photograph" or whether you literally have to say on the badge what color you are. Which strikes me as potentially problematic, actually.

And no, my spellchecker does not like that word, but it's an American document so it naturally uses the American spelling.
 
Cross-post. Thanks. I'm looking through it now - or rather, since you didn't provide a link, I googled it and am looking through what I found.

I didn't provide a link because it's ******* 2 AM here and I don't feel like being handed gratuitous busy work.

ETA: I've found that the legal name and business address of the seller of contracted services must be on the contract. Still looking for the bit that applies to you.

Enjoy. It took me about two years to round up the different requirements from different parts of that site and other relevant ones. Good times.
 
I've found section 13:45A-17.5 - Initial and Renewal Applications, which sets out the requirement for certain information relating to "each officer, director, principal and person with an ownership interest of 10 percent or more in the home improvement contractor business" to be recorded in the business registration, but it doesn't say that this must be disclosed to the public.

Still looking for the bit that says you're required to have a business card. Give me time. Legislation tends to be a little hard to read. :p

Not that you have to have a business card. What information is contained on a business card has requirements, not all by NJDCA. General Contract Law (outside DCA) covers registration number being on all stationary, contracts etc.
 
13:45a-17.11 Ownership And Use Of Registration Number; Replacement And Duplicate Certificates

Here's the bit that says you have to display the registered contractor's name and HIC number on vehicles, so that checks out.

Aaand I've made it to the end. Nothing about business cards. I did a Ctrl-F and the only mention of business cards is in the definition of "advertising" so I can't see anything in this document which mandates what information you need to disclose.

I can see that certain information needs to be recorded on the registration form, but there is no indication that this information needs to be disclosed to the public. I presume, however, that given a compelling reason this information can be disclosed under Freedom of Information, about which I have also recently completed a refresher, and which outlines exactly under what circumstances FOI applies.

This is the document I've been perusing, by the way. I hope it is the same as the one you are familiar with:

https://www.njconsumeraffairs.gov/r...nt-Contractors-Home-Elevation-Contractors.pdf

It seems to be more about how a home improvement business is to be registered and the requirements thereof rather than about the conduct of the contractors, but it was interesting. Thank you for this diversion to what has otherwise been quite a dull Tuesday afternoon.
 
I didn't provide a link because it's ******* 2 AM here and I don't feel like being handed gratuitous busy work.
Totally fair. Get some sleep!

Not that you have to have a business card. What information is contained on a business card has requirements, not all by NJDCA. General Contract Law (outside DCA) covers registration number being on all stationary, contracts etc.
The ways in which different pieces of legislation interact can be dizzying, and why the lawyers get the big bucks.

How this relates to legal prostitution (to bring it back to the subject) is in the way businesses are required to be registered. There is an equivalent piece of legislation covering the operation of brothels, with similar requirements for the public disclosure of business name, operating addresses and registration number. What is not required - in either case - is disclosure of the personal details of employees and contractors.

In the case of a sole business owner and operator, the disclosed business address might also be their home address, and this is true in both cases. But otherwise a contractor's or employee's home address and phone number is not required to be disclosed.

Anyway, this digression has gone on long enough. I will conclude by saying that it should be fairly obvious to anybody why a sex worker has a reasonable expectation of a higher level of privacy than a home improvement contractor.
 
13:45a-17.11 Ownership And Use Of Registration Number; Replacement And Duplicate Certificates

Here's the bit that says you have to display the registered contractor's name and HIC number on vehicles, so that checks out.

Aaand I've made it to the end. Nothing about business cards. I did a Ctrl-F and the only mention of business cards is in the definition of "advertising" so I can't see anything in this document which mandates what information you need to disclose.

I can see that certain information needs to be recorded on the registration form, but there is no indication that this information needs to be disclosed to the public. I presume, however, that given a compelling reason this information can be disclosed under Freedom of Information, about which I have also recently completed a refresher, and which outlines exactly under what circumstances FOI applies.

This is the document I've been perusing, by the way. I hope it is the same as the one you are familiar with:

https://www.njconsumeraffairs.gov/r...nt-Contractors-Home-Elevation-Contractors.pdf

It seems to be more about how a home improvement business is to be registered and the requirements thereof rather than about the conduct of the contractors, but it was interesting. Thank you for this diversion to what has otherwise been quite a dull Tuesday afternoon.

NJ, of all states, does not exactly have one stop shopping or one click websites for all the information you are looking for. Some, as I said is contract law, some is in motor vehicle law, some on DCAs site, which to be honest, I visit once a year at renewal time but haven't had to do anything new there in a decade and a half. Not sure if they've fixed that train wreck yet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom