Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Try adressing what I said then. All you did was Textbook Special Pleading

More copouts. Sex for women carries the possibility of pregnancy. That has consequences that no other activity carries. It IS special, and obviously so. And there is nothing religious about recognizing that BIOLOGICAL reality.
 
The problem is that 1) nobody is collecting the kind of data needed and 2) most people involved in prostitution - even where completely legal - are probably not going to be willing to provide the data.

Some of the data could be collected, but yes, there's a lot more that's hard to get.

Yes, legalizing it reduces some harms. The biggest of those reduced harms being that the victim is no longer prosecuted as a criminal.

There are other harm reductions. In Nevada, where prostitution is legal, it's also regulated. One of the regulations is that customers must have their genitals inspected before they can have sex with a prostitute, in order to reduce the spread of certain STDs like herpes. This is a harm reduction. Legalization also allows prostitutes to work out of established facilities which have security. Physical abuse is still possible but less likely under such conditions.

But it does nothing to address the physical and emotional damage.

It can do a lot to address physical damage, I think you're wrong on that count. But yes, the emotional toll of prostitution is no small thing, and legalization doesn't eliminate that. I'm in agreement with you there. And this is a particularly hard to quantify aspect. So even though I think you're unfairly discounting a number of harm reductions that legalization offers, there's still a case to be made against it.

It doesn't result in a reduction of violence against females

This is in principle something that we could quantify fairly directly. I'm not sure that you're correct. I'd like to see actual numbers.

it doesn't even seem to have materially reduced the violence against prostitutes, which seems to still be common, at least according to those who have shared their stories.

Stories aren't good metrics for that, though. There's no way to tell how representative they are, how much selection bias may be tilting it.

What bothers me most about this discussion is that a move of desperation is being rebranded and valorized as "sexual liberation".

I agree about that. There's a huge Chesterton's fence aspect to this, a seeming belief that because someone doesn't understand why sexual taboos exist, it means that they shouldn't.

And as the only female in this thread, I've been told that I'm toxic, that I'm anti-woman, that I'm a prude, and several other insinuated insults. Simply because I don't fall in line and vapidly endorse the use of human bodies as objects to be used and discarded when done.

Yeah, I can see why that would get your hackles up. I'm not in agreement with you about some factual questions I think are still open, but the harms of prostitution are being undersold by a lot of posters here. Even when no physical abuse is happening, even when clients behave themselves, I think prostitution is an inherently degrading profession that harms those who engage in it. That alone isn't proof it should be outlawed, but that harm does need due consideration, and it's not really being given that by most posters here. And it's completely reasonable to be upset by that.
 
What prompts such confidence in your view?

I know what happens in my own bloody country!!!

Your characterization of how the New Zealand model works is complete bull-****. You are totally ignorant of how the 2003 PRA has dramatically improved the lives of sex-workers in this country! Your last dozen or so posts in this thread just confirm for me, that like dann, and Thermal and Abooga, you have utterly no ******* idea what happens in this country.

I know what happens here because I ******* well live here and I know you are completely and utterly wrong!
 
Because atheists are totally on board with exploiting the desperation of those in dire circumstances and feel perfectly fine treating other people's bodies as objects to be used and discarded when they've got their rocks off?

Who in the world said anything like this?
 
More copouts. Sex for women carries the possibility of pregnancy. That has consequences that no other activity carries. It IS special, and obviously so. And there is nothing religious about recognizing that BIOLOGICAL reality.

And baseball for men carries the possibility of getting beaned in the nuts, so what?
 
I know what happens here because I ******* well live here and I know you are completely and utterly wrong!

Living in the country alone doesn't really mean much of anything. Are you involved with the profession somehow? Have you been reading up on the effects of the law? Watching news coverage? You may well know more than EC, but a bit more detail on how you have come to know more besides "I live here" would be useful.
 
Last edited:
And baseball for men carries the possibility of getting beaned in the nuts,

Baseball is not unique or even peculiar in that regards.

And if you don't understand why sex has deep psychological mechanisms at play because of the possibility of pregnancy, you really don't understand humans. Or evolution.
 
More copouts. Sex for women carries the possibility of pregnancy.

I'm pretty sure there are methods of preventing pregnancy, and that professional prostitutes would be the most likely to employ them.

Baseball was also mentioned: there are also protective measures that can be taken to prevent injuries of that sort. I'm pretty sure professionals employ them.
 
More copouts. Sex for women carries the possibility of pregnancy. That has consequences that no other activity carries. It IS special, and obviously so. And there is nothing religious about recognizing that BIOLOGICAL reality.
The possibility of pregnancy is virtually eliminated by modern reproductive science. Which is why it is mandatory at all times under any reasonably regulated sex industry. Most sex workers will use multiple layers of protection, reducing the chances of unwanted pregnancy (and incidentally STIs) to virtually zero.
 
Just to clarify that that situation does not apply in countries where prostitution is legal - police not only will prosecute rape that occurs, I gave the example of a bloke who took his condom off and was jailed for three years for rape.

Right, but the point is that we are talking out being raped on the job like that's any kind of normal discussion and not sociopathic. Remember the stats about three quarters of NZ prostitutes report being raped/assaulted on the job? I'm having trouble cheering for a legal stamp of approval on a line of work that almost guarantees being literally raped.

Legalisation is safer for the girls, and prostitution isn't going to disappear. Even Jeebus' best pal was a hooker.

False. The disciple whom
Jesus loved was literally a John. Mebbe JC was turning more tricks than just turning water into wine? I hope the bar is well stocked in Hell.

Nor are any legal prostitutes.

Legalisation reduces the likelihood of both clients and prostitutes getting involved in underage sex.

A client has the choice of having sex with a 15-year-old and potentially being convicted of underage sex offences, or pretending the 18-year-old legal prostitute wearing a school uniform is 15.

Pretty simple.

And how do they know the worker is legal? The difference between a mature looking 15yo and a youngish looking 18 or even 20yo is not always that simple. And don't forget, it's not theory. It actually happened in your hood. And the men were not charged with ******* a child, which they demonstrably did, receipts and everything.
 
Bollocks. That never happened here, or in Australia, and still does not. You talk as if legalizing sex-work hasn't changed anything as regards prostitution. If you actually lived here, you would absolutely know just how much has changed in that regard.

I really don't know where you get your whacko ideas from about the way things work in this country, but its clearly not from the real world, that's for sure....

Yet again...the post you have your knickers in a twist about is answering what happened to American rum runners after the repeal of prohibition. Do you get that? We weren't taking about NZ in that particular posting, so please shove the snark. Yet again.
 
FFS chum - you have been told previously this would never work in the way you suggest, in a post, by me, replying to a post, by you, about the exact same suggestion you are making here.

Yes. I know. It was a piss poor argument when you first made it and it is not improving with age.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13927413&postcount=1254

It would mean a sex-worker would have to give over their personal data to the government to go on a database. Such databases have been compromised on numerous occasions over the years, and personal, private sensitive information has ended up in public.

"Prostitutes are a-scared of a data breach" is a comically bad argument. Like, literally a joke. I'm not sure if you even mean this seriously.

You have also been told that there is already a form of registration in place with the ACC (Accident Compensation)

An even worse argument. The registration I am proposing would be for on the spot public verification with clients. Your ACC policy is no on the spot verification of anything.

These are truly awful arguments, yet you keep reposting them.
 
Last edited:
Living in the country alone doesn't really mean much of anything. Are you involved with the profession somehow? Have you been reading up on the effects of the law? Watching news coverage? You may well know more than EC, but a bit more detail on how you have come to know more besides "I live here" would be useful.

It has the advantage of being able to ask people directly, things that you will never find in a Google search. As Jay Utah has said, "You can Google for information, but you can't Google for understanding". Both TheAtheist and I personally know some of these women - in my case, two customers of my former retail business (I have posted about them previously). I have spoken to both of them about some of the opinions that people like EC, Abooga, dann expressed. I think "totally clueless" was the kindest response. Some of the other things they said would probably get me yellow carded were I to repeat them here.

The sex-workers of Nelson all know each other - they keep in touch and compare notes about the difficult clients they have dealt with. There is an unofficial ban list in Nelson.
 
You don't think a sex worker has good reason to be concerned about a breach of their privacy?

Not if the work is "no big deal" and "work like any other" and "no different than hauling concrete".

I mean, you don't suppose the posters making those arguments are utterly full of **** or anything, do ya?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom