Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Prostitution, gambling or drugs on the other hand are seen as not filling any kind of need, which is something I disagree with.

They are not. The desire for sex/physical intimacy is one thing. Paying for it is not a need. Gambling may be something you enjoy. So break out the chips and have a no-cash fun game, but the children who become homeless because daddy got in over his head are more than enough justification to regulate it heavily. The abuses and tragedies that come along with drugs need not be pointed out.
 
Last edited:
What the hell are you talking about? The individuals register themselves, like with a photo ID that is the most commonplace thing in the world, from grade school IDs to drivers licenses and beyond.
How does that protect the workers from the likes of criminal pimps?
I'm modelling this after the very requirements I go through to be a construction contractor in NJ USA. The requirements were specifically set up to stop illegal contracting. The contractor cannot disappear with the same ease he could previously, as he is documented up one side and down the other, with notarized ID verification. Not perfect (and nothing is), but makes it basically impossible for an illegal contractor to do anything.

I'm sure there are benefits for the customers, but how is it good for the prostitutes, how does it provide or increase safety for them? How does it stop them being exploited?

Back to all or nothing, I see? Yes, your criminal masterminds in the Triads or whatever you are theorizing might always hold families hostage or whatever.

Families? :confused:
The average age of a prostitute entering the work in the States is 15 years old. A simple registration would stop them from working legally. Johns, I believe, would be skittish enough about a felony for statutory rape and worse to run the risk if a legal option were available.

Have you looked to see if in countries that have much more severe penalties for customers of prostitution see a reduction compared to countries without such penalties?

...what? It's not a legal out. It's a felony if caught, as "she looked 18" would no longer be an excuse, or even relevant. Recall the up thread story of the child trafficked for a year. If she had to register herself with the State, it effectively couldn't have happened.
Oh, and if you forgot, her "clients" over that year we're not charged. The "manager" who "verified" her age got a slap on the wrist, and the brothel continued operating with a new "manager", with the registered owner unscathed.

Have you considered people may lie and make false declarations on their registrations as well as to other people?

The only people I see benefiting from your idea is the customers.
 
How does that protect the workers from the likes of criminal pimps?

I'm sure there are benefits for the customers, but how is it good for the prostitutes, how does it provide or increase safety for them? How does it stop them being exploited?

As I said, I'm talking about a simple measure to keep underage workers out of the market. Running around saying "but it doesn't solve any conceivable problem" is yet again, the "all or nothing" approach you have tried to blast me for.

Families? :confused:

Or whatever leverage you think is being used to coerce them.

Have you looked to see if in countries that have much more severe penalties for customers of prostitution see a reduction compared to countries without such penalties?

I am thinking about what might be practical.in the States. What a theocracy or whatever might do is not interesting to me rn.

Have you considered people may lie and make false declarations on their registrations as well as to other people?

Lie all you want. No docs, no dice. The average person doesn't lie their way into valid ID in the States. Certainly a broke runaway girl isn't procuring Ethan Hunt level fake passports.

The only people I see benefiting from your idea is the customers.

You seriously can't see how a runaway 13 year old might hit a bit of a roadblock?
 
The average bartender entering the trade, for instance, is not a ******* 15 year old runaway or addict with literally no other options, for a start.
:rolleyes:
I assume you'll be providing evidence that this is a common problem in the legal brothels of AUS/NZ.

ie, protection, with a resectable haircut.
:rolleyes:
Most managed workspaces have equivalent charges.
 
How does that protect the workers from the likes of criminal pimps?


I'm sure there are benefits for the customers, but how is it good for the prostitutes, how does it provide or increase safety for them? How does it stop them being exploited?



Families? :confused:


Have you looked to see if in countries that have much more severe penalties for customers of prostitution see a reduction compared to countries without such penalties?



Have you considered people may lie and make false declarations on their registrations as well as to other people?

The only people I see benefiting from your idea is the customers.

On registration....

It doesn't add additional protection to legal prostitutes, but it would, if managed correctly, make trafficking and pimping more difficult.

How?

Suppose a prostitute is required to display a visible registration ID (with photo, but no name, just an ID number). A client could not claim that he didn't know that the prostitute was not legal. Combined with stiffer fines/penalties, it would discourage clients from going to the black market.

Now, the IDs would have to be difficult to fake in such a way that detecting one would not require super close inspection. I think they would have to be displayed, not just provided on request as well. Also, the application process would need to be designed to prevent third party or coerced applications. Which may involve an in-person component that might deter some people from pursuing the career. But if someone is not up for that, it might not be the right job for them anyway.

In theory, could make things more difficult for a black market.

Perfect? No. But what crime has been eliminated by prohibition? What legally regulated industry has not had someone find a way to bypass regulation?
 
Already done, you're just way behind. NZ has about 3500 sex workers. The States have about 2 ******* million. NZ is still reporting frequent problems with underage and trafficked workers, even with such a tiny work force. One was posted earlier, about a child working in a legal brothel for a year with full legal protection to her clients. Extrapolate that to the States.

Now, you can keep arguing "**** those kids" (literally), but I'm in favor of a different model to drop those odds significantly lower.
Let's see some numbers.
 
Is it puritanical to view something like a film director asking an actress for sex in exchange of roles as a worse thing than for example a film director asking an actress for a car wash for roles? Do you view them as the same thing? I think society usually regards the first as a worse offence. Do you think the reason for that is puritanism?

Yes, this is giving sex some special religious value over other actions and its silly. Also it removes agency and autonomy from the parties involved

Is it puritanical to be disgusted by rape? Should an atheist be unconcerned about non-violent rape? After all, it´s just sex, a "normal" thing...

If yes, why?

Rape is an imposition of will against someone else. Do you think mugging is ok or something? What about theft?
 
:rolleyes:
I assume you'll be providing evidence that this is a common problem in the legal brothels of AUS/NZ.

Please try to maintain the attention span of the average poodle before rolling your eyes. I was referring to the American market. Clearly. Repeatedly.

:rolleyes:
Most managed workspaces have equivalent charges.

The managed workspaces I am.most familiar with charge flat monthly rates, whether you use the space or not. The brothels are charging per client, and as has been cited upthread, are telling the workers who will be serviced whether the contractor likes it or not. In the States, this would be a statutory employee arrangement, although the "per dude serviced" rate would be unusual at best.

Either way, I look forward to your evidence that managed spaces most often charge their renters based on volume, rather than flat rate.

Or silence from you. Who can tell? :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 
My suggestion isn't all that hard to figure out. I have presented it again and again:
Your idea that prostitution is ******* great and improves the lives of those working in prostitution if only it's properly regulated, i.e. your own bordello Utopia, is wrong.
It's as simple as that.
Your interest in saving and cleaning up the image of prostitution by means of regulation just doesn't appeal to me at all, sorry!
That's my suggestion.

So apart from totally misrepresenting my standpoint, you have no actual contribution other than "it should not happen!"

Sticking your head in the sand does not make things go away, actual solutions do.
Legalization does not totally prevent abuse, but it does make it easier to help those in an abusive situation and a allows them to seek help.
Not to mention that there are many women who are prostitutes who do not fit your 'broken bird that needs rescuing' idea.
They are not 'happy hookers' either, but just doing a job they consider to be less strenuous then other alternatives.
 
Please try to maintain the attention span of the average poodle before rolling your eyes. I was referring to the American market. Clearly. Repeatedly.
:rolleyes:
Right..... Of course the rest of us were looking at the more successful NZ/AUS model

The managed workspaces I am.most familiar with charge flat monthly rates, whether you use the space or not. The brothels are charging per client, and as has been cited upthread, are telling the workers who will be serviced whether the contractor likes it or not. In the States, this would be a statutory employee arrangement, although the "per dude serviced" rate would be unusual at best.

Either way, I look forward to your evidence that managed spaces most often charge their renters based on volume, rather than flat rate.

Or silence from you. Who can tell? :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:
Then you're obviously not that familiar with managed workspaces. Most charge a per-use fee for facilities above the basics.
Of course this entire "comparison" of yours is another attempt to paper over the gaps in your argument. Regardless of the details of the arrangement, payment for facilities used is quite normal, not done form of extortion as you suggested.
 
Last edited:
Color me on Team "Rape Should Not Be an Acceptable Job Annoyance".

Just to clarify that that situation does not apply in countries where prostitution is legal - police not only will prosecute rape that occurs, I gave the example of a bloke who took his condom off and was jailed for three years for rape.

Legalisation is safer for the girls, and prostitution isn't going to disappear. Even Jeebus' best pal was a hooker.

The average bartender entering the trade, for instance, is not a ******* 15 year old runaway or addict with literally no other options, for a start.

Nor are any legal prostitutes.

Legalisation reduces the likelihood of both clients and prostitutes getting involved in underage sex.

A client has the choice of having sex with a 15-year-old and potentially being convicted of underage sex offences, or pretending the 18-year-old legal prostitute wearing a school uniform is 15.

Pretty simple.
 
Yes, this is giving sex some special religious value over other actions and its silly.

You really don't need to appeal to religion to recognize that sex really does have special status. Even from a purely psychological perspective, sex is different than most activities, and for very good evolutionary reasons, especially for women. Pretending that sex is not special isn't enlightened, it's delusional.

Also it removes agency and autonomy from the parties involved

Uh, no. It's a recognition of the abuse of power. That scenario isn't an exchange between equals. Even if you're OK with legalized prostitution, the scenario of a director demanding sex in order to cast an actress isn't the same as ordinary prostitution.
 
Last edited:
Please try to maintain the attention span of the average poodle before rolling your eyes. I was referring to the American market. Clearly. Repeatedly.



The managed workspaces I am.most familiar with charge flat monthly rates, whether you use the space or not. The brothels are charging per client, and as has been cited upthread, are telling the workers who will be serviced whether the contractor likes it or not. In the States, this would be a statutory employee arrangement, although the "per dude serviced" rate would be unusual at best.

Either way, I look forward to your evidence that managed spaces most often charge their renters based on volume, rather than flat rate.

Or silence from you. Who can tell? :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
The model this most resembles in the US, I think is strip clubs.

My understanding is that some clubs charge the dancer a fee to dance and then get a (large) cut of the "private dance" fees. They then consider the dancers to be "independent contractors" and screw them over as far as any kind of benefits. thinking about it, I think some hair salons and barber shops may do the same thing.

It's a crappy business model. the house getting a per client cut would, I think, serve to undermine the ability of the prostitute to reject a client at will. Even if subtle, there is likely to be pressure not to let dollars walk out the door. "You aren't doing enough volume, so we are giving your space to someone else. Sorry."

A better model would be each prostitute to pay a flat room fee per shift and have the house's income be independent of volume of clients.
 
The perfect is the enemy of the good.
Legalizing exploitation is the enemy of reducing exploitation.

If you're complaining about the complete elimination of criminal activity not having been achieved, well, good luck because nobody will ever be able to do that. Trafficking is heavily penalised in New Zealand Aotearoa, and Australia, as it should be. Is it gone? Would that we could.

It's heavily penalized in most places. And I fail to see how making it legal for a buyer to make use of a trafficked individual is a good move at all.
 
It didn't. They just rebranded into darker territory, and continued to flourish. With the amount of decadent tastes available, I don't like the odds of where they might see a new market.

Btw, brothel operators seem to still be pimps. They pull half the cut of the workers, in exchange for "protection". And reporting up thread is that some still coerce workers into taking on men that the workers don't want to.

Again, I'm in favor of decriminalization and some kind of legalization for those willing and ok with it all. I'm trying to work out what happens to the more vulnerable end, which this model seems inadequate for.

Bollocks. That never happened here, or in Australia, and still does not. You talk as if legalizing sex-work hasn't changed anything as regards prostitution. If you actually lived here, you would absolutely know just how much has changed in that regard.

I really don't know where you get your whacko ideas from about the way things work in this country, but its clearly not from the real world, that's for sure. Prostitution in this country was at one time a racket, being run mostly by pimps who were part of the criminal gangs, mostly foot-sloggers, but some motorcycle gangs too, such as Lost Breed and Highway 61
. The 2003 PRA blew the criminal element out of the game in short order.

The vast majority of sex-workers in this country do what they do because they choose to do so, not because they are forced or coerced into it. This is an irrefutable fact. Sure, there is an underground, illegal element, just as there is in any trade, but its minuscule compared with what it was in the 1990's. Its it perfect? No, of course not. There is no such thing as perfect, and there never will be - but what we have in New Zealand and Australia is a colossal improvement over the situation that existed before the PRA was enacted. It is also and vastly superior to what happens in other countries, including the unworkable Nordic Model, a system that does absolutely nothing to protect sex-workers from the criminal element.
 
Would I generally be happier if workers had more direct control over their workplace? Sure. I don't see why a brothel couldn't be run as a worker owned cooperative instead of enriching some owner, for example. But that's not specific to sex work, I'd say the same about most industries and especially small businesses.

In this country many, if not most of them choose to operate that way.
 
Already done, you're just way behind. NZ has about 3500 sex workers. The States have about 2 ******* million. NZ is still reporting frequent problems with underage and trafficked workers, even with such a tiny work force.

Newsflash for Thermal. This was much more rife before the PRA. Less so now.

One was posted earlier, about a child working in a legal brothel for a year with full legal protection to her clients. Extrapolate that to the States.

Now, you can keep arguing "**** those kids" (literally), but I'm in favor of a different model to drop those odds significantly lower.

You understand that the case you appear to be talking about was from almost 20 years ago in 2004 - only 8 months after the PRA was enacted, right? This was also a case of a family prostituting their daughter - her father had coached her to have sex for money from a very early age.

There is also another case where a girl of 16 was found working in a brothel. She had provided the owner with fake documentation, including a fake birth certificate and driver's license. Do you expect brothels to have a forensic forgery detection unit at hand?

Legalizing sex-work was never intended to deal with this sort of reprehensible behaviour. The purpose was to decriminalize prostitution - while not endorsing or morally sanctioning prostitution or its use, to create a framework that safeguarded the human rights of sex workers and helped to protect them from exploitation, as well as promoting the welfare and occupational health and safety of sex workers. In the 20 years since the PRA it was enacted, it has largely succeeded in what it set out to do - largely but not entirely. Given the nature of humans, it was never going to eliminate all illegal prostitution - there is simply no way to do that. If you're going to try to adapt the US gun nut model of "don't do anything to fix a problem if it won't fix it 100% of the time" then you are going to be disappointed - we don't do things that way in Australia and New Zealand - never have, and never will!
 
The model I proposed up thread (you were on hiatus) is individual registering with the state as a sex worker, like I register as a contractor. Commercial sex with an unregistered worker becomes a serious felony. I think some variation of this would tamp out the demand for the illegal market.

FFS chum - you have been told previously this would never work in the way you suggest, in a post, by me, replying to a post, by you, about the exact same suggestion you are making here.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13927413&postcount=1254

It would mean a sex-worker would have to give over their personal data to the government to go on a database. Such databases have been compromised on numerous occasions over the years, and personal, private sensitive information has ended up in public.

You have also been told that there is already a form of registration in place with the ACC (Accident Compensation)

"the government already has you registered as to what you do for a living by virtue of the fact that you have an ACC account number, that you have been assigned a BIC number and both you and your employer pay ACC levies (if you are self employed you pay both)".​
‎
‎
 
Last edited:
It can't be said often enough.

But it's not going to stop people demanding it be implemented.

Some people have an idea of a perfect society that only they can organise. I think it's naive nonsense, myself, but here we are.



You missed out:

10 days of paid sick leave each year.
20 days of paid annual leave each year.

"You know, we've got a problem with child labor in this country. There are quite a few kids who are coerced into having to work, either by abusive adults or by financial circumstances. Many of them are homeless and have histories of abuse. And they end up being placed into a position where they illegally take jobs under the table just so they can get by. It's really a sad state, a lot of these kids are physically and emotionally abused too, and a lot of them turn to drugs to ease the mental trauma of their situation. We really need to do something about it."

"Oh, I know, I know! We should remove the age limit on work. Then those unfortunate kids in dire situations can work legally, and they can even get some paid time off! It's brilliant, it will be a vast improvement in the lives of kids who have to work when they ought to be in school so they can get by and make ends meet and not starve to death."

That's how I end up seeing the NZ Model. It's a solution to a side effect of the problem, but it doesn't actually address the problem. It makes it legal to exploit people in poverty and in dire situations, in a way that would be unacceptable in any other line of work, period. It doesn't address the underlying reason that people end up being prostituted in the first place, and it doesn't prevent them continuing to be exploited. It just makes the exploitation legal to do in the first place, and it gives a veneer of empowerment to those who are exploited - now they're allowed to talk about their exploitation!

But it doesn't reduce the exploitation.

It's not a question of "perfect being the enemy of good". It's a matter of snake oil glossing over the illness, and everyone just smiles about how great the snake oil is.
 
Has it ever occurred to you that the simple act of legalising prostitution will drive out much of the criminal element and the power of pimps and traffickers?
Nah, it just renames them as "managers" and nothing else changes really. I mean, sure there will be a few brothels that become up-and-up establishments... but there's no real change to most of them. It legitimizes the same behaviors that happened pre-legalization.

It's been 20 years, and the rate of murders and abuses of prostituted individuals in NZ doesn't seem to have evaporated, or even reduced to on-par with "any other job".

You know, just what happened with the end of Prohibition in the US?

Will it eliminate all illegal sex work? No, just as moonshine merchants continued after Prohibition. Will it make sex work safer? Yes it will.

Your (and Dann’s ) other objections to sex work are moralistic and can be instantly dismissed.
The parallel to prohibition is flawed. The criminal element involved in prohibition was on the supply side - they had to actually have the facilities to make the supply of alcohol, and then distribute it. When prohibition ended, the ability to create alcohol was no longer illegal, and anyone who could get a license could make alcohol.

On the other hand, removing prohibition did not reduce demand. It did not reduce alcohol consumption, nor did it reduce alcoholism, nor any of the social harms that arise from the demand side.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom