Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I said, upping the penalty (which the post you are citing was not referring to) is a deterrent with teeth. As is, a John can bend over virtually any worker with some level of reassurance that it is legal (yes, what he "should have known" may come into play).

If he bends over an unregistered worker, and this has become a crime equivalent to rape, methinks that's a strong deterrent to pay the extra money to not be a felon rather than a misdemeanor.

Again, severity of punishment has little to no deterrent value compared to likelihood of being caught.
 
Last edited:
It's not up to me to prove your case. I'm not going to sift through this entire thread for numbers you claim are there.

Nor am I spending a single second over your laziness. Keep up or shut up, but don't sit on your thumbs expecting me to do your busy work.
 
As I said, upping the penalty (which the post you are citing was not referring to) is a deterrent with teeth. As is, a John can bend over virtually any worker with some level of reassurance that it is legal (yes, what he "should have known" may come into play).

If he bends over an unregistered worker, and this has become a crime equivalent to rape, methinks that's a strong deterrent to pay the extra money to not be a felon rather than a misdemeanor....snip...

What stops the bad players simply registering the sex workers without their consent or even knowledge? Or forcing them to do it?

Your idea doesn't seem to address any of the issues with decriminalising sex-work, all it does is provide a legal out for the clients.
 
It's page 51 my man, vague references to a citation you seem certain proves your point seems... dubious.

Exactly. You and him diddy-bopping in late and expecting me to trawl through pages from a year ago is not happening. I did that with another poster on this very thread, and he was satisfied with my citations when I reposted them, and the son of a bitch continued to demand I spend my time reading the thread back to him.

No. Keep up or shut up.
 
Exactly. You and him diddy-bopping in late and expecting me to trawl through pages from a year ago is not happening. I did that with another poster on this very thread, and he was satisfied with my citations when I reposted them, and the son of a bitch continued to demand I spend my time reading the thread back to him.

No. Keep up or shut up.

Even if I were "keeping up", I doubt I would recall exactly where these figures were and would want to see them again to check whether your broad statements are supported (which I suspect are not).

Taking the effort to repeatedly whine about reposting these figures seems like more effort than just doing it. Smacks of lack of confidence that these figures will actually demonstrate what you claim they will
 
Last edited:
I suspect you might run into a lot of noncompliance with your "register as a sex worker" plan, especially for the least sophisticated street workers, but that's entirely speculative on my end.

Well one can assume that there will be those who don't want to pay taxes on their work.

For example, with regards to the "Nordic model" as implemented in Sweden, prostituting oneself is perfectly legal. Selling sex is completely legal. And like most forms of income above a certain amount, one is legally obligated to report the income from prostitution in ones tax filings so that one can be taxed.

I don't know if there are any kind of statistics on it but I suspect many prostitutes are not paying their taxes.
 
Last edited:
What stops the bad players simply registering the sex workers without their consent or even knowledge?

What the hell are you talking about? The individuals register themselves, like with a photo ID that is the most commonplace thing in the world, from grade school IDs to drivers licenses and beyond.

I'm modeling this after the very requirements I go through to be a construction contractor in NJ USA. The requirements were specifically set up to stop illegal contracting. The contractor cannot disappear with the same ease he could previously, as he is documented up one side and down the other, with notarized ID verification. Not perfect (and nothing is), but makes it basically impossible for an illegal contractor to do anything.

Or forcing them to do it?

Back to all or nothing, I see? Yes, your criminal masterminds in the Triads or whatever you are theorizing might always hold families hostage or whatever.

The average age of a prostitute entering the work in the States is 15 years old. A simple registration would stop them from working legally. Johns, I believe, would be skittish enough about a felony for statutory rape and worse to run the risk if a legal option were available.

Your idea doesn't seem to address any of the issues with decriminalising sex-work, all it does is provide a legal out for the clients.

...what? It's not a legal out. It's a felony if caught, as "she looked 18" would no longer be an excuse, or even relevant. Recall the up thread story of the child trafficked for a year. If she had to register herself with the State, it effectively couldn't have happened.

Oh, and if you forgot, her "clients" over that year we're not charged. The "manager" who "verified" her age got a slap on the wrist, and the brothel continued operating with a new "manager", with the registered owner unscathed.
 
Last edited:
Even if I were "keeping up", I doubt I would recall exactly where these figures were...

Nor would I. It's been a long thread spanning like a year, not a week old three pager.

...and would want to see them again to check whether your broad statements are supported (which I suspect are not).

Taking the effort to repeatedly whine about reposting these figures seems like more effort than just doing it. Smacks of lack of confidence that these figures will actually demonstrate what you claim they will

You up for an avatar bet, then?

First, specify what "numbers" you are referring to. If you mean number of prostitutes etc, that was probably all Wiki and you could have checked them yourself, in, as you say, less time than you have taken to whine about it.

If the "numbers" you demand are something I never even claimed, you lose (it's a common weasel to say "oh man big misunderstanding").

You in? Hey Arcade22, you in?

ETA: every poster should always challenge your reversed burden of proof, btw. It's not my onus to do busy work for you.
 
Last edited:
Nor would I. It's been a long thread spanning like a year, not a week old three pager.



You up for an avatar bet, then?

First, specify what "numbers" you are referring to. If you mean number of prostitutes etc, that was probably all Wiki and you could have checked them yourself, in, as you say, less time than you have taken to whine about it.

If the "numbers" you demand are something I never even claimed, you lose (it's a common weasel to say "oh man big misunderstanding").

You in? Hey Arcade22, you in?

ETA: every poster should always challenge your reversed burden of proof, btw. It's not my onus to do busy work for you.

It's still not exactly clear to me what claim you're making and what data you think exists to prove it. Would be nice if you posted both of those elements together in one concise post rather than dancing all over the place.
 
It's still not exactly clear to me what claim you're making and what data you think exists to prove it. Would be nice if you posted both of those elements together in one concise post rather than dancing all over the place.

That's not an answer to anything being discussed.

You're now saying you have no idea what I'm talking about so you expect me to repost some unspecified citations?

That's stupid. Shut up.
 
How would that stop "...snip... means literally nothing in the face of a sleazy pimp or trafficker. They tend not to be concerned with the rights of their victims. And an addict or other young woman financially coerced out of desperation is not going to be picky. They don't have that luxury. "


Neither do prostitutes in a New Zealand brothel, apparently. If they try to be picky, the pimps and their assistants make sure that they can't be:
Legally, no one can require sex workers to provide any commercial sexual service – sex workers can refuse or end bookings for any reason.
Coercion, exploitation: The problems of running brothels as businesses (Stuff.co.nz, Sep 11, 2022)


But that's legally. You know, their "ABSOLUTE right." It looks different in the real world, and what's a poor pimp to do, right?! Ya gotta look out for the bottom line, don't cha? Ya can't let Big Daddy down this way, Sweetie. Come on, give'em some sugar. You know that's what they're here for, ain't it, so get out there and work that booty:
“Like, I know I’m not able to say they have to do anything. But then on the other hand what am I meant to do, just open up the doors for them to sit around and not see any punters? That would just be crazy, I’d have a riot on my hands. I’m not running a drop in centre."
Dozens of interviews with sex workers, brothel operators and managers showed similar views were held by operators around the country, Weinhold said.


After all, they're running a business not a shelter, aren't they?
Sex workers commonly reported being coaxed into accepting bookings, often justified by operators on the grounds of professionalism and profit.
One such worker, Ciara​, recalled a situation where the operator’s [hilte]coercive[/hilite] behaviour played out in front of potential clients.
“She has made a booking for you, which you may or may not want, and then it’s very difficult to get out of. Because she’s like, ‘He’s paid. He’s already waiting for you,’” she said.
“And she will be right there in front of the customer saying all this, so it starts you off on the wrong foot … . She’s like, ‘What? Why have you got a problem seeing this client?’”


That's what professionalism and profit means. After all, turning down a john “just loses everyone money.”
And even cameras aren't there to protect the prostitutes against the johns, but to make sure that the johns get what they pay for. One prostitute mentions how cameras can be "coercive, recalling a brothel owner who would watch the camera and complain if he saw workers turning potential customers away."

I see no indication that the prostitutes in the mentioned cases were "an addict or other young woman financially coerced out of desperation is not going to be picky." At least not coerced so much out of desperation that they didn't try to be picky. It wasn't addiction or desperation that prevented them from being picky. It was the surveillance of zealous pimps who saw to it that "They don't have that luxury."

How did the saying go again? You know, the one about something like this being good but not perfect, not 100 percent?
 
So, what is YOUR suggestion?

Given that we do not live in a post scarcity utopia, how would you see things regulated?
And how would that improve the lives of those working in prostitution compared to full legalization?
 
It always cracks me up, that no matter how allegedly secular or atheist, people still view sex in almost Puritanical religious terms.


It always cracks me up, that no matter how allegedly secular or atheist, people still pretend that objections to people being coerced to have sex with people they find disgusting or scary is an objection to sex and not a praise of sex for pleasure's and love's sake.
It is almost as if pretending that the objection is puritanical and religious makes them feel better about sexual coercion.
They object to people having sex!!! How old-fashioned can you get?
 
So, what is YOUR suggestion?

Given that we do not live in a post scarcity utopia, how would you see things regulated?
And how would that improve the lives of those working in prostitution compared to full legalization?


My suggestion isn't all that hard to figure out. I have presented it again and again:
Your idea that prostitution is ******* great and improves the lives of those working in prostitution if only it's properly regulated, i.e. your own bordello Utopia, is wrong.
It's as simple as that.
Your interest in saving and cleaning up the image of prostitution by means of regulation just doesn't appeal to me at all, sorry!
That's my suggestion.
 
My suggestion isn't all that hard to figure out. I have presented it again and again:
Your idea that prostitution is ******* great and improves the lives of those working in prostitution if only it's properly regulated, i.e. your own bordello Utopia, is wrong.
It's as simple as that.
Your interest in saving and cleaning up the image of prostitution by means of regulation just doesn't appeal to me at all, sorry!
That's my suggestion.

You wouldn't think that there are some women who would get into this work eyes open and actually OK with it? I can totally see that, although I wouldn't think it applied to the majority.

I mean, not for me and all, and I want very desperately to protect those who would rather do anything else but rent out their asses, but surely some women (and men) are fine with all this and if it hurts no one, live and let live and all that?
 
It hurts no one? Do you believe that?
Did you read the article?
 
Last edited:
It hurts no one? Do you believe that?

If you're asking me (I'm getting out of the habit of assuming who a dead air post is addressing), then no, I don't think it has to. I think some women are dtf with strangers, and get into it as a profession. I recall reading about a teacher who worked summers in a Nevada brothel, who actually got a thrill out of it. Again, not for me, but I respect that truly consenting adults can fly their freak flags however it turns them on.

The generally seedy side of prostitution I am pretty heartily against, as it has no upside, especially from posters who want to cheer for that Grade A tail they think they can score, guilt free. But if the system allows itself to abuses, I'm focusing on the abused, not trying to look the other way.

Eta: your edit: which article? There've been several.
 
Last edited:
I can't really think of many professions or jobs that have been criminalized or "abolished" because they entail too serious risks as opposed to having become redundant or uneconomic because of technological advances or societal change.

Comparing prostitution with child labour doesn't make sense because we're talking about adult men and women so the arguments used to prohibit or heavily restrict child labour do not apply.

Other professions and jobs that entail real risks of serious physical and/or mental damage are otherwise perfectly legal. Various occupations in heavy industries, construction, security, farming and etc. Massage parlors are a good example of a kind of job that entail many of the direct risks that prostitution does, in terms of being vulnerable to attacks from customers often in a private and discreet location. A security guard at a bank (a real one that stores money, not a just a office) is also a good example of someone who faces a direct and credible risk of being attacked.

Ignoring those who are clearly motivated by religion or ideological convictions, I think a lot of times the reason for why people feel like prostitution could and should be "abolished" is because, similar to the use of drugs and gambling, its considered to involve something of a frivolous and "pointless" activity. People can just "choose" to not have sex with a prostitute, in the same way that they can "choose" to not use drugs, drink alcohol or gamble. So the problems involved with these types of activities and substances are the users fault for funding them. The fact that prohibiting them legally rarely "abolishes" the problematic activity is also held to be the fault of law breaker, and not the laws themselves.

Growing food is necessary because otherwise we would starve. Miners bring us ores and stone that we can build things out of. These kind of professions are held to be "necessary", even-though humanity and our predecessors have lived without them for hundreds of thousands of years. Prostitution, gambling or drugs on the other hand are seen as not filling any kind of need, which is something I disagree with.
 
Last edited:
...snipped the repeated "arguments"...snip

As your quotes keep showing the NZ model of decriminalisation has improved the industry in regards to the safety of the sex workers. Is it perfect? Obviously not. But is it much better than in my country? What's the word - that's it absolutely.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom