Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not if the work is "no big deal" and "work like any other" and "no different than hauling concrete".

I mean, you don't suppose the posters making those arguments are utterly full of **** or anything, do ya?
Hmm, I seem to remember putting a link in my post. I wonder what happened to it when you quoted it?
 
Hmm, I seem to remember putting a link in my post. I wonder what happened to it when you quoted it?

Yes,and of course I knew what you were linking to before I clicked on it.

Did you notice anything about the quote you rely on reposting? Our discussion didn't go anywhere back then, either. You repeatedly asserted that prostitution needed some kind of special treatment, involving special privacies in order to stay clandestine as a special kind of anonymous contractor.

Say, it's that "special" thing again. Just keeps coming up.
 
Last edited:
Yes,and of course I knew what you were linking to before I clicked on it.

Did you notice anything about the quote you rely on reposting? Our discussion didn't go anywhere back then, either. You repeatedly asserted that prostitution needed some kind of special treatment, involving special privacies in order to stay anonymous.. as a contractor.

Say, it's that "special" thing again. Just keeps coming up.
And?

I ask again: don't you think a sex worker has good reason to be concerned about a breach of their privacy?
 

Oh come on. I'm not even going to pretend.

I ask again: don't you think a sex worker has good reason to be concerned about a breach of their privacy?

What's a breach of their privacy? You mean a data breach that makes them rail against any form of registration (the same as every person living in the first world is concerned about and consequently means nothing), or that someone might find out what she did for a living?
 
Oh come on. I'm not even going to pretend.
We're making progress then. Good.

What's a breach of their privacy? You mean a data breach that makes them rail against any form of registration (the same as every person living in the first world is concerned about and consequently means nothing), or that someone might find out what she did for a living?
Okay, it might just be because I'm in a government job and I just completed my mandatory privacy training refresher, but this question took me a little by surprise.

Privacy is defined, and protected, by legislation. In Australia it's the Privacy Act 1988 (Part III-Information Privacy Division 2). It defines Personal Information and provides a legal framework for the protection thereof and requirements in the case of an eligible data breach.

The fact is, even my employment status and history is protected by the Privacy Act, if I do not choose to disclose it. We should expect no less for a sex worker.
 
We're making progress then. Good.

Okay, it might just be because I'm in a government job and I just completed my mandatory privacy training refresher, but this question took me a little by surprise.

Privacy is defined, and protected, by legislation. In Australia it's the Privacy Act 1988 (Part III-Information Privacy Division 2). It defines Personal Information and provides a legal framework for the protection thereof and requirements in the case of an eligible data breach.

The fact is, even my employment status and history is protected by the Privacy Act, if I do not choose to disclose it. We should expect no less for a sex worker.


This is yet another example of how people like Thermal et al simply have no understanding of how things such as laws and regulations work in other countries.

Thermal, if you think privacy is no big deal, then how about you post the following personal details here in the forum...

Real Name
Telephone number (including mobile)
Home Street address
Work Street Address
Social Security Number

Are you comfortable doing that? No? If not, then you might begin to understand why a sex-worker would not want to have this sort of information out in the clear, because this is exactly the type of information what would be required for registration of both the owner of a brothel, and a self-employed sex-worker!
 
Last edited:
Legalization does not totally prevent abuse, but it does make it easier to help those in an abusive situation and a allows them to seek help.
Not to mention that there are many women who are prostitutes who do not fit your 'broken bird that needs rescuing' idea.


What "'broken bird that needs rescuing' idea"? Let's see a link or an actual quotation instead of your strawman.
As for 'helping those in an abusive situation and allowing them to seek help', more after this:
Color me on Team "Rape Should Not Be an Acceptable Job Annoyance".
Just to clarify that that situation does not apply in countries where prostitution is legal - police not only will prosecute rape that occurs, I gave the example of a bloke who took his condom off and was jailed for three years for rape.


Oh, so there was an actual example of one case?! How extraordinary! It must be another example of an "ABSOLUTE right" (smartcooky) in those "countries where prostitution is legal" (The Atheist):
Many workers also observed that security cameras were most frequently used to monitor and discipline sex workers, rather than ensure their safety.
Even where cameras had captured images that could help with pursuing charges against a client, some operators did not seem particularly interested.
Susie​, for example, said that she “waited weeks” to get a copy of a screenshot of a client who had assaulted her from an operator and then “basically gave up.”Sex worker Mimi​ said cameras could be protective and coercive, recalling a brothel owner who would watch the camera and complain if he saw workers turning potential customers away.
“If you know they’ve got eyes on the camera, then it’s like, OK, I can say to him [the client], there’s cameras here, they are people who can see you now. Behave nicely, and we can see you [for a booking].
“If it’s quiet, or I know [the owner] isn’t at the office [to see the camera] I’m more likely to turn them away if they look a bit funny.”
Weinhold said Mimi’s comments implied she would be less likely to turn a potential client away if the owner might be watching, and was less able to exercise agency.
Coercion, exploitation: The problems of running brothels as businesses (Stuff.co.nz, Sep 11, 2022)


It seems like it actually is "an Acceptable Job Annoyance" to be coerced into having sex with johns you don't want to have sex with, and it doesn't seem to do much to "make it easier to help those in an abusive situation and a allows them to seek help."
The john is always right seems to be the slogan in the brothel business, too, and why ruin a good (but not perfect, as many of you like to say) business by handing out footage of assaults to the victims, right?!
 
The possibility of pregnancy is virtually eliminated by modern reproductive science.

Obviously not, or abortion wouldn't be a thing. But it also doesn't matter. Our brains didn't evolve to respond to sex with birth control in mind.
 
The vast majority of sex-workers in this country do what they do because they choose to do so, not because they are forced or coerced into it. This is an irrefutable fact.


Oh, man! I just love smartcooky's irrefutable facts! It's up there with his ABSOLUTE rights! :sdl:
Because I say so, and I know what happens in my own bloody country!!! And both TheAtheist and I personally know some of these women.
I guess The Atheist and smartcooky got together, counted these women they know, and decided that they make up the vast majority of NZ prostitutes.
 
Last edited:
How about we change the entire narrative and instead focus on teaching males that they do not have a right to sexual intercourse, and that trying to purchase the use of another person's body for sexual gratification is a gross abuse of human rights?

I say males here, because the overwhelming majority of punters are male. There may be a scant few females in there, but this behavior - this expectation of sexual satisfaction - is an almost exclusively male trait. And it's one that has been around, and has been coddled by society, for eons.

I partially disagree with you there.
I agree that no one has the *right* to sexual intercourse and this is indeed a vital thing that should and at least in the Netherlands is taught to everyone in schools.

However, if two consenting adults decide that the exchange of money is enough to have sex that should be allowed.
You keep insisting that ALL prostitutes are forced and unwilling even when shown that this is not the case.
Legalization of prostitution IMO gives a better way to prevent forced prostitution than keeping it fully illegal.

In your version going out on a date and then having sex would be criminal if the male pays for everything, even if that is not pre-agreed.
 
Obviously not, or abortion wouldn't be a thing.
Abortion is a separate issue, and for the most part occurs when modern reproductive technology is not used or those rare instances where it fails.

But it also doesn't matter. Our brains didn't evolve to respond to sex with birth control in mind.
Which is exactly why birth control is mandated for all sex work. Don't like it? Tough. If you don't sock, you don't fock.
 
Australia is down under, New Zealand is the land of the long white cloud.

But carry on. Accuracy has never been your forte in this thread.
It's priceless that someone who lives literally on the other side of the planet feels like they have the authority to tell us what it's like where we live.
 
We're making progress then. Good.

Okay, it might just be because I'm in a government job and I just completed my mandatory privacy training refresher, but this question took me a little by surprise.

Privacy is defined, and protected, by legislation. In Australia it's the Privacy Act 1988 (Part III-Information Privacy Division 2). It defines Personal Information and provides a legal framework for the protection thereof and requirements in the case of an eligible data breach.

The fact is, even my employment status and history is protected by the Privacy Act, if I do not choose to disclose it. We should expect no less for a sex worker.

I....don't think you answered the question. I'm asking it because a sex worker is a public contractor...I mean she's literally offering to **** the general population...and generally, when you are hustling money from the grnetal public, yoi forgo a bit of privacy.

As we discussed last year, a plumber does in fact not hide himself or his identity. Very often,he is legally required to disclose it on demand. It's at least logical to want people to know who you are/what you do, so that they call you when you want that service. But with prostitution, the worker does everything possible to hide, right down to fake names.

It's almost like sex work is a little different than other kinds of work. Nah, that's silly, right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom