Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

If you're depending for your livelihood on the willingness of others to do something you won't, then yes, you are. If they won't work the shift, will you protest? Will you quit? Or will you just buckle down and do what needs to be done.
No, of course I'll do it. What do you take me for? It hasn't been necessary, but if ever we ran out of volunteers, then it's part of my employment contract. Of course the analogy is not perfect. I never said that it was. But I don't believe that we'll ever run out of volunteers for the military.

If I were conscripted (which I'm too old for now) then I would register as a conscientious objector and do my time. I decided that a long time ago.

If you deny the value of their job, and the necessity of it., and deride them for doing it like so many pure pacifists do; then yes, it is parasitic.
Excuse me? Did you perhaps miss the part where I said

I commend and admire Quad4_72 and anyone else who has chosen to serve in uniform for doing a nasty, nasty job that I would never, ever do myself.
?

That's nice. How is that relevant?
I don't know. You brought him up, not me.
 
*crickets*

This conversation is already going as I expected it would.
 
Actually, I'm hoping that I've been able to present my point of view clearly enough that Quad4_72 and Tranewreck are able to understand where I'm coming from. Quad4_72 in particular I've come to somewhat respect, since he's politely asking questions, not resorting to attcks, and pressing me on matters that I actually asked him to press me on.

Like I said, I'm taking this thread very seriously, and I'm actually rather enjoying it. My day's quota of other threads has suffered from my attention to this one. :p
 
Yeah, unfortunately I frequently underestimate Quad, and I do respect Tranewreck.

I keep expecting Quad to be another Texas, but he keeps turning out different in key aspects. Luchog pretty much lost my respect after essentially comparing the mentally ill to rabid dogs, and never even bothering to defend his comparison.

Personally, I view pacifism as more complicated than most make it out to be. I don't see why it must necessarily mean "total nonviolence". But I think that almost every culture throughout history with a strong military has been all too quick on the trigger, and in their quest to stave off further conflict, have only escalated the situation further. It doesn't help that all cultures tend to view themselves as superior to others in some way, and further tend to view acts against them as worse than any acts they commit against others... which leads, in situations dependent on Reciprocity (which is most international relations), to a downward spiral.

The First World War is pretty much the greatest example of a bunch of nations assuming that radical, sudden violence can prevent future violence. That didn't turn out well.

Essentially, it comes down the Prisoner's Dilemma, but with bigger stakes (and a much harsher penalty if we all plead "guilty"). If we all go violent to prevent violence, we get World War I. I don't like that method. If we all go pacifist, there is no war. But none of us can count on the other person to choose to become a pacifist -- but if we choose to become violent, we have to count on everyone else also not going violent.

It only makes logical sense to prefer a pacifist approach above and beyond a violent approach.
 
Last edited:
I see your Heinlein and raise you an Asimov :D :

"Violence is the last resort of the incompetent" - Isaac Asimov (possibly paraphrased)

Seriously though I've generally considered my self a pretty extreme pacifist, but this conversation (and others) have me questioning my position. I'm not too sure anymore where I stand.

Perhaps an interesting viewpoint I just thought of is the difference between violence and aggression and as a pacifist I can condone aggression but not violence. To explain what I mean I offer the following example:

A week ago I went out with my girlfriend to a club/bar in a student town. I was on holiday in the student town so I hadn't been to the club before. My girlfriend was feeling somewhat depressed that night and didn't really want to take part in all the dancing and whatnot so we spent most of the night outside. At one point though she need to go to the bathroom but to do that she would have had to worm her way through the crowded dance floor.

So I decided to shove my way through and help her along behind me. Now generally I would have just tried to worm my way semi-politely through, but becuase she was feeling ill and down I acted quite aggressively, literally pushing people out of the way. (Luckily it was crowded and they were drunk and there were no unwanted incidents.)

In this case I feel I was aggressive (as one possible solution to a problem) without being necessarily violent. Could this kind of approach not also be a better way of seeing things like the Kosovo situation. One where aggression by NATO was necessary to prevent further violence?

(I know I'm not using the standard definition of aggression but it was the word that fit closest to what I wanted to express)
 
Seriously though I've generally considered my self a pretty extreme pacifist, but this conversation (and others) have me questioning my position. I'm not too sure anymore where I stand.
Then my work here is done! :D

(I know I'm not using the standard definition of aggression but it was the word that fit closest to what I wanted to express)
I think what you're trying to describe is the difference between agressive and assertive. One can be assertive without being agressive.
 
Essentially, it comes down the Prisoner's Dilemma, but with bigger stakes (and a much harsher penalty if we all plead "guilty"). If we all go violent to prevent violence, we get World War I. I don't like that method. If we all go pacifist, there is no war. But none of us can count on the other person to choose to become a pacifist -- but if we choose to become violent, we have to count on everyone else also not going violent.

It only makes logical sense to prefer a pacifist approach above and beyond a violent approach.
That's exactly how I feel - and I'm an avid fan of the Prisoner's Dilemma. But I hadn't thought to apply it to this situation. What a brainwave!
 
It's actually nothing new. Political Science courses do it all the time. ;)
 
I'm sure they do. But it's an approach that hadn't occurred to me before.

Probably because I've never done a Political Science course. :rolleyes:
 
What do you call fleeing from the merest chance of violence to abandon people to their fate if not cowardice?

Well, your definition here ensures that it will be called cowardice... But it really depends on the specific scenario.

And as I said, not everybody has the same reaction to violent situations. Personally I tend to flee from violent situations. Is that so bad ?
 
Most pacifists, faced with the ultimate test of their ideology, will do what 99% of ideologists have done throughout human history. They will abandon their ideology in favour of survival.

Sorry, Gum, but that sounds like a "no atheists in foxholes" kinda comment. I don't doubt that people act differently under duress, but many people shun violence even when its justifiable.

Of course it depends what you mean by "ultimate test". If it means "a situation where violence is the ONLY option", then you can go for 100%, by definition.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, Gum, but that sounds like a "no atheists in foxholes" kinda comment. I don't doubt that people act differently under duress, but many people shun violence even when its justifiable.


I'm more referencing the fact that very few people genuinely adhere to any ideology the way they claim to. For the overwhelming majority of people survival takes precedent, and their ideologies exist only when its convenient. There's precious few people who have the conviction to adhere to their ideals to the bitter end, no matter the cost.

Pacifism is just another ideology.
 
The First World War is pretty much the greatest example of a bunch of nations assuming that radical, sudden violence can prevent future violence. That didn't turn out well.


I think the two World Wars, collectively, provide the perfect example of why putting all your eggs in one basket is disastrous. The aggressive and preemptive stance of Europe led to the horrific bloodshed of WWI, but their blind "no violence, no matter what" stance in response to WWI led to the even greater bloodshed of WWII.

Diplomacy, reconciliation, compromise, these all have their place. And so does violent action. The trick is to know when to use each of them. Work that one out and history will make you immortal.
 
What do you call fleeing from the merest chance of violence to abandon people to their fate if not cowardice?

What do you call someone who takes a bullet for another person? Who intervenes, facing death, but doesn't raise a fist or a gun while doing so?

You can't insult these people without also insulting MLK or Gandhi.
 
Last edited:
I'm more referencing the fact that very few people genuinely adhere to any ideology the way they claim to.

I can agree to that! Human behaviour follows two tendencies:

1) Doing whatever the hell they feel like doing at the time
2) Justifying those actions so as to keep the moral high ground

Which of course means that their moral values are often very... flexible.
 
Lots of issues being tossed around here since my initial post...

One thing I've noticed over the years is that some folks have the mindset for violence and some do not. I don't think it's productive to refer to those who do not as "cowards". In war, as has been observed many times, there are individuals who simply go through the motions. They will be in the trenches, and they may fire their weapons in the general vicinity of the enemy. They are not actively engaging the enemy.

I think this is a fairly common situation with modern military structures and conscript armies. In previous history, "warriors" constituted a caste or social strata. People were indoctrinated into these groups at a very young age, and trained from childhood. Those who could not cope were weeded out and became otherwise involved in society.

It's been noted by more than a few that the mindset of the criminal and the mindset of the police who oppose them is somewhat similar....At least in regards to the willingness to use violence when necessary.
As far as resistance to violent crime by citizens...Rather depends what you're talking about. If it's a "stand and deliver" street robbery, where the bad guy displays a weapon and demands your wallet; by all means the best course of action is to hand over the wallet. There is always a slight chance you'll be shot anyway, but statistically it's pretty safe.
However, if you are sitting in your place of business and a "rage shooter" bursts in with guns in hand....It's pretty obvious that cowering in the corner is simply going to result in your being shot.
A rapist, breaking into a woman's home will not be deterred by non-violence. If he is a particular type of rapist, he may well culminate his activity with homicide.

There were comments about the Somali people and their subjugation by the warlords and pirates. I have heard the notion..."people get the government they deserve."

This seems rather repugnant to me. A blame-the-victim philosophy if you will. The warlords have power. They have the guns, whatever money that's available, and followers who know where their bread is buttered, if nothing else.
What on earth would impoverished, weaponless villagers be able to do to depose such people? Hold a rally?
 
I have a great deal of sympathy with that view. Choosing to engage and support Middle Eastern wars in the 80's directly led to many of the issues we face today. If we hadn't used violence to instal the Shaw of Iran in the 50's, the threat of religious extremists getting a hold of a nuke would be significantly less.

Yeah, that's part of the particular iceberg that is the Mid-East. There's a lot of stuff we did using Cold War justifications that, in hindsight, seem a bit like madness.

The problem is that we cannot at any time control all variables. The Civil War was a violent action taken to end slavery. Given that the South was willing to secede, there was no other way to force them to abandon slavery. Many people died. Many slaves would have continued to live in inhuman oppression if the war hadn't been fought.

The argument is that action should have been taken long before the Civil War in order to avoid the uncomfortable choice.

Well, the American Civil War didn't work exactly like that. However, the point you state that not all variables can be controlled for is one I agree with, and it neither supports nor refutes the pacifist ideal. The difference is in the methods for approaching the problem, not controlling the variables creating the problem. If it helps, consider it a little like a hostage negotiator who is attempting to talk the hostage-takers into releasing the prisoners and preventing as many deaths as possible, in order to avoid a messier incident where more people will definitely die. The ideal for pacifism isn't to fold or accept any violence directed toward them, it's to minimize damage and attempt to eliminate the need for violence-- much like many other ideals, just with a different approach.

But when do you start? Presumably we have to act now to avoid situations like the Civil War and Kosovo in the future. But the present pressures us with decisions that are similarly compelled: How do you stop Al Qaeda, an organizition with no real desires save bringing about the end times, peaceably? Certainly a number of the specific actions we've taken have been suspect, but whether through military intervention or international policing, some violence will be necessary to stop that organization from murdering innocent people.

There's no moment of purity where we can start the chain of non-violent acts that end violence forever. It's a fantasy.

Well, I don't think any notable pacifists I've read about have looked for a moment of purity, but I'd agree that hoping for one is a fantasy. The goal for most of the more sophisticated pacifist thinkers I've read is to create the chain of non-violent acts and work toward propagating it. This thinking acknowledges that there will be failures and losses along the way-- Martin Luther King, Jr. was one advocate of this thinking-- but the long-term goal is an advancement of the ideal toward either a majority thinking or a workable (and influential) minority of thinking. The methods tend to complicate there, mostly regarding activism and advocacy, and differing depending on which source you're looking into, but that's a good starting point for examining the type of thinking and thought processes involved.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom