Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

Fantastic. Here I had my doubts.


Until you can show me that you know each and every one of these "non extreme" pacifists, this is merely a form of Argument from Ignorance; "I haven't seen any of them myself, ergo, they must not exist". It's like the whole "There are No Atheists in Foxholes" defense. "I've never seen an Atheist in a Foxhole, so they must not exist". Yet the group "Atheists in Foxholes" disproves that by their very existence.

Well I must say, I have known hundreds of soldiers in the military. From my personal experience, I have yet to meet a single pacifist in the military. Perhaps there is a pacifist unit somewhere that I am unaware of?
Furthermore, and this may surprise you, but there are many people that don't pick up guns within any country, that still further causes of peace and diplomacy. You don't need to shoot someone to do good. Most of the founding fathers were lawyers and politicians that never shot anyone, including my favorite, Thomas Payne. Are you going to claim that they're worth less because they never picked up a gun and shot someone?

I never said you need to shoot someone to do good. I just have something against those that refuse to pick up a rifle because they are "against violence". This may be referring more to the extreme portion of people.

I'd like to see that. "Thomas Payne less of a human being because he used the pen, not a gun".



I don't believe that efforts in Iraq will be successful. Forcing a democracy on a people that don't want it is useless, and the situation in Iraq seems to be exactly that. Even the people that support a democracy tend to vote towards leaders that will take it away from them. The culture is just too different, there isn't enough of a backdrop to continue.

While efforts have somewhat worked in Asian countries, there have been more failures than successes (Japan being the biggest exception). Germany is also somewhat of an exception, although they did have a democracy before Hitler took power, so it's probably a bad example.

But yes, is violence necessary for that end at times? I think so. I certainly would have supported the American Revolution, although I would not have supported unnecessary bloodshed at any point of time, nor do I ever.

You seem to know when violence is necessary so I don't really see what you are mad about.
 
Well I must say, I have known hundreds of soldiers in the military. From my personal experience, I have yet to meet a single pacifist in the military. Perhaps there is a pacifist unit somewhere that I am unaware of?
So the United States military is made up of hundreds of people.

Fantastic. :rolleyes:

So the United States has entire units made up of one philosophical belief? They have the Realists over here, and the Constructivists over there, and the Post Modernists unit?

:rolleyes:

I never said you need to shoot someone to do good. I just have something against those that refuse to pick up a rifle because they are "against violence". This may be referring more to the extreme portion of people.
Yes, it is. You are talking about total nonviolence, which is not what pacifism necessarily means. It is, however, the definition which many people associate it with, such as "atheism" meaning "total and abject rejection of a God", even though atheists themselves often have problems with that definition.

You seem to know when violence is necessary so I don't really see what you are mad about.
Because, you keep ranting about "those pacifists" even after it was made clear that "those pacifists" are more complicated than you give them credit for, and don't follow within the narrow definition you apply.
 
But do you see very many of these "non extreme' pacifists picking up rifles and defending anything?
I just have something against those that refuse to pick up a rifle because they are "against violence".
Uh... do these statements sound absurd to anyone else?

I am a pacifist, so I don't pick up a rifle. I am against violence, so I don't pick up a rifle. I've never picked up and fired a rifle in my life because I'm a pacifist, and I'm against violence.

I thought that would have been completely freaking obvious.
 
Notice my argument, arthwollipot. There's different shades of pacifism, and some pacifists do, indeed, at times, find violence, as a last resort, necessary. Thus, a pacifist could easily join a war, in order to fight for peace, in their country or in another area.

The problem is, I would not want to be engaged in the Vietnam War, nor the War in Iraq. I don't see either measure as all that useful, and it just gets people killed unnecessarily.
 
I am still under the belief that pacifism is quite the selfish ideology.

That's okay, though. I'm sure many pacifists believe that the opposite philosophy is quite selfish, or primitive.

Oh and if our own country ever came under attack (such as on 9/11) would you be willing to pick up a rifle and defend it? Probably not. Because you don't believe in violence. You would leave it up to others to do what is necessary to ensure you sleep safe in your bed every night.

You guys leave it up to me to program new software. I leave it up to you to defend our freedoms. Deal ?
 
Well I must say, I have known hundreds of soldiers in the military. From my personal experience, I have yet to meet a single pacifist in the military. Perhaps there is a pacifist unit somewhere that I am unaware of?

Well, obviously if they're getting trained for war, then they might not be pacifists.
 
Who's seen Full Metal Jacket?

A soldier goes into war wearing a peace sign. When asked about this "stupidity", he says something about the duality of man.

What if he was fighting for, as he believed in, peace? What if he believed in no other possible alternative? What makes him not actually a pacifist?
 
If pacifism is about lessening the amount of violence present in the world, what are pacifists doing about it? If they want to lessen the violence in their community, what are they doing about it? I am pretty sure every decent human being wants less violence in the world. That's nothing special. But what people are doing about it is.

Careful where you head with this argument. What you don't want to do is create a higher bar for the ideology you feel you disagree with than you would have for your own or for others you have less of a problem with. But what have people who are different degrees of pacifist been doing about it? Well, you could start with the demonstrations both before the Iraq War and since the war has been going-- not all of them are likely to be pacifist of some sort, but many are. You can look at victim advocacy groups-- not all pacifist in nature, but their purpose in general fits in with the pacifist ideal. It was notable pacifists (Ghandi, MLK) who brought passive resistance into play as one of the main forms of protest in the 20th century. Granted, the government agency (AmeriCorps) meant to be a pacifist branch for public service (instead of the military) has seen progressively dwindling numbers, but this also can't be dismissed as insignificant.

There's probably more, but off the top of my head that's some of the stuff "they" have been doing.

Yes methods used by MLK, Gandhi, and Otpor work great against governments that are not willing to commit genocide. Now what about the ones who don't give a damn? Do you think Gandhi would fare well in a place like Somalia or Rwanda?

I understand what you're saying here, but the mistake you're making is that you're arguing from the exception rather than the rule. Governments in general are usually averse to destroying huge chunks of their population-- it tends to cause income and cash flow issues for the governments. Yes, there are several exceptions to the rule out there, but in general governments of the world are becoming less likely to willfully engage in genocide than used to be, not more. After all, do you treat every new individual you meet as a potential mugger or pickpocket or scam artist? There are certainly plenty of muggers and pickpockets and scam artists out there to use as your basis for doing so. By the logic you propose above it even makes sense to treat everyone that way. It probably won't make you very many friends, but if we're talking logical approaches here it would be consistent with what you're suggesting.
 
Notice my argument, arthwollipot. There's different shades of pacifism, and some pacifists do, indeed, at times, find violence, as a last resort, necessary. Thus, a pacifist could easily join a war, in order to fight for peace, in their country or in another area.

The problem is, I would not want to be engaged in the Vietnam War, nor the War in Iraq. I don't see either measure as all that useful, and it just gets people killed unnecessarily.
I agree.

But the fact remains that I have never been in any way even remotely inclined to learn how to fire a gun, and I attribute that to the fact that I am a a pacifist. Should I need to learn, then I would have no problem with doing so, as long as I was convinced that it was absolutely necessary.

Think "zombie apocalypse".
 
Meanwhile, I shoot guns, learn archery, and beat people up with sticks as a hobby. ;)
 
Yeah - my hobby (as was pointed out earlier) is learning to fight with swords, axes and spears.

No, I don't see any contradiction. Why do you ask?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom