Quad4_72
AI-EE-YAH!
- Joined
- Nov 7, 2006
- Messages
- 6,354
Fantastic. Here I had my doubts.
Until you can show me that you know each and every one of these "non extreme" pacifists, this is merely a form of Argument from Ignorance; "I haven't seen any of them myself, ergo, they must not exist". It's like the whole "There are No Atheists in Foxholes" defense. "I've never seen an Atheist in a Foxhole, so they must not exist". Yet the group "Atheists in Foxholes" disproves that by their very existence.
Well I must say, I have known hundreds of soldiers in the military. From my personal experience, I have yet to meet a single pacifist in the military. Perhaps there is a pacifist unit somewhere that I am unaware of?
Furthermore, and this may surprise you, but there are many people that don't pick up guns within any country, that still further causes of peace and diplomacy. You don't need to shoot someone to do good. Most of the founding fathers were lawyers and politicians that never shot anyone, including my favorite, Thomas Payne. Are you going to claim that they're worth less because they never picked up a gun and shot someone?
I never said you need to shoot someone to do good. I just have something against those that refuse to pick up a rifle because they are "against violence". This may be referring more to the extreme portion of people.
I'd like to see that. "Thomas Payne less of a human being because he used the pen, not a gun".
I don't believe that efforts in Iraq will be successful. Forcing a democracy on a people that don't want it is useless, and the situation in Iraq seems to be exactly that. Even the people that support a democracy tend to vote towards leaders that will take it away from them. The culture is just too different, there isn't enough of a backdrop to continue.
While efforts have somewhat worked in Asian countries, there have been more failures than successes (Japan being the biggest exception). Germany is also somewhat of an exception, although they did have a democracy before Hitler took power, so it's probably a bad example.
But yes, is violence necessary for that end at times? I think so. I certainly would have supported the American Revolution, although I would not have supported unnecessary bloodshed at any point of time, nor do I ever.
You seem to know when violence is necessary so I don't really see what you are mad about.