Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

Most pacifists, faced with the ultimate test of their ideology, will do what 99% of ideologists have done throughout human history. They will abandon their ideology in favour of survival.
 
Wait, a guy who re-enacts medieval battles with rather large swords and axes is actually a pacifist?

Now I have seen everything.
 
I can't speak for everyone, so I will just say that I am legitimately curious how pacifism is instantiated in the real world.

This isn't a hypothetical, it was a real world event:

As a pacifist, how would you have handled the ethnic cleansing in Kosovo.

The only pacifists that have tried to answer so far have essentially said that they would ignore the situation or run from it.

I criticized them personally for what I find to be a horrific sense of shared humanity, but for the other pacifists out there, I would love to hear your opinions.

I'm not even asserting that there was no possible way to handle Kosovo without force, I just can't imagine it and neither could Howard Zinn when I asked him.

You can't dismiss the scrutiny of an ideology in real events as "gotcha" questions.
Well, the situation itself was indeed a real world event. However, putting myself in a hypothetical situation where I was solely responsible for the response to the situation is highly unrealistic.

That said, if, as posited by the scenario, I were solely responsible for the international response to the situation - assuming that I had as much in the way of diplomatic skills and foreign relations experience, which I don't - then I doubt that my response would be very different from what the response of the international community actually was.

Again, it is extremely unrealistic to put me in that position. I have neither the skills nor the understanding to be able to handle a situation like that. I would be a foreign relations disaster. You'd be a lot better off with Zinn, quite frankly. However, I would neither ignore the situation nor run from it. I would insist that you not place me in the position in the first place, since I am horribly underqualified.
 
I am still waiting for a coherent pacifist argument in this thread. As of right now, it seems that pacifists would sit back and do nothing if harm were being done to others. Or they would just run away. Am I incorrect with that statement?
It would depend on the actual circumstances. If you're going to go with a hypothetical, then you'll have to give me a LOT more information.

For example - in the daughter rape scenario - does the assailant have any accomplices? How many? Are they armed? Am I armed? Do I have any friends? What self-defence training does my daughter have? If she has training, what method did the assailant use to overpower her?

See, all of these factors will affect my decision whether to intervene with violence or not. If the assailant has three buddies, all armed with guns, then I'm not likely to try violence. If he's on his own and my daughter is already fighting back, then I'm more likely to try violence.

Your situations don't have enough detail for me to make a firm statement. And they probably never will, since any hypothetical situation will always leave out some details.
 
Unfortunately, this doesn't stop the determined jerks. I was a big kid (and nerd), but would never fight back, until one day I finally had enough (this is at maybe age 10), and when a bully grabbed me, I stood tall and shoved him to the ground. The bullying *stopped* that day.

Is violence a good first option? Probably not, but sometimes it is all that will work.
In your case, violence was not your first option. But you were pushed just over Quad4_72's line. My line is clearly in a different place, since I never did that. For me, the bullying (which was rarely actually physical, but a LOT of verbal) stopped when I left school.
 
This sounds like a cop out. There are situations where you are FORCED to make a choice. I am really curious if you would use force to defend your family or other people if put in that situation. I realize that you have never been in that situation, but use your brain and think about it.
I have thought about it. I would avoid using violence until such point as I believed I had no choice. What point is that? I don't know - it would depend on the circumstances. And that's kinda been my point all along.
 
Most pacifists, faced with the ultimate test of their ideology, will do what 99% of ideologists have done throughout human history. They will abandon their ideology in favour of survival.
This is very true. If push came to shove, and I genuinely believed that I had absolutely no other option, then and only then I would indeed resort to violence. But I think it'd have to be a pretty extreme circumstance.
 
Wait, a guy who re-enacts medieval battles with rather large swords and axes is actually a pacifist?

Now I have seen everything.
Well, in reenactment we're not seeking to actually cause harm to one another. I can find mock-fighting fun and still be against causing harm. :D
 
Yes - I would never consider using violence as a tool for any purpose. I believe that it would be counterproductive in pretty much any circumstance that I can see myself getting into.
So you agree with Ghandi that the Jews in Nazi Germany should have committed mass suicide by allowing themselves to be massacred rather than defend themselves violently?

"Pacifism is a shifty doctrine under which a man accepts the benefits of the social group without being willing to pay -- and claims a halo for his dishonesty." -- Robert A. Heinlein

The problem with pure pacifism is that it is inherently parasitic. The pacifist depends for his wellbeing on the good will of those in power, or the willingness of others to use violence to protect him. For example, Ghandi's non-violence worked because the British were, as a whole, a moral people unwilling to commit large-scale genocide simply to maintain their empire. He depended entirely on the British sense of justice for his non-violent protest to work. His comments regarding the Jews in Nazi Germany show just how out of touch he was with the reality of the Final Solution.

The world is full of individuals, groups, and governments that would happily exterminate anyone they felt was less than human; a definition which typically includes anyone outside their group. Many have no problem eliminating anyone they find simply inconvenient. The Myanmar government is currently engaged in a slow genocide of the Chittagong Hill Tract peoples, practically unopposed. Pot Pot's Khmer Rouge engaged in wholesale massacres of all "undesirable" enthic minorities. Stalin and Mao murdered millions. First president of Equatorial Guinea, Francisco Macias Nguema, killed close to a third of the population of his own country. The Ottoman Turks killed 1.5 million Armenians.

Non-violent resistance and "international outrage" did nothing to stop any of these. The only action which was ever effective was forceful resistance. Violence in defense of the victims.

In the land of pacifists, the man with a gun is a god.

"Those who cling to the untrue doctrine that violence never settles anything would be advised to conjure up the ghosts of Napoleon Bonaparte and of the Duke of Wellington and let them debate it. The ghost of Hitler could referee, and the jury might well be the Dodo, the Great Auk, and the Passenger Pigeon. Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor, and the contrary opinion is wishful thinking at its worst. Nations and peoples who forget this basic truth have always paid for it with their lives and freedoms." -- Robert A. Heinlein
 
Luchog said:
"Pacifism is a shifty doctrine under which a man accepts the benefits of the social group without being willing to pay -- and claims a halo for his dishonesty." -- Robert A. Heinlein
Hey, a quote from a guy who basically stated that someone expecting to breathe even if he's poor was "insane" (read The Cat that Walks Through Walls). I'm impressed!
 
So you agree with Ghandi that the Jews in Nazi Germany should have committed mass suicide by allowing themselves to be massacred rather than defend themselves violently?
No. Again, you're taking statements I make about myself and assuming that I believe that other people are like that also! I said that I would not consider using violence as a tool. And anyway, my later posts should have indicated that I have backed off from the absolutist claim of pacifism anyway.

The problem with pure pacifism is that it is inherently parasitic. The pacifist depends for his wellbeing on the good will of those in power, or the willingness of others to use violence to protect him.
Let me answer this with an analogy.

I work on a roster. The phones have to be staffed 24/7, including night shifts and weekends. My employment contract includes this. However, in two and a half years I have never had to work a night shift or a weekend. Why? Because there are always plenty of volunteers.

Is it parasitic to allow the work to be done by those who want to do it? Neither Australia nor the USA practices conscription any more. Anyone who is in the military is there because they chose to be there. Is it parasitic to allow them to do their job?

In the land of pacifists, the man with a gun is a god.
No, in the land of pacifists, the man with a gun is a tyrant.

Hey, a quote from a guy who basically stated that someone expecting to breathe even if he's poor was "insane" (read The Cat that Walks Through Walls). I'm impressed!
My personal opinion is that Heinlein was a dick.
 
This is a ludicirous analogy, but I'll address it.
I work on a roster. The phones have to be staffed 24/7, including night shifts and weekends. My employment contract includes this. However, in two and a half years I have never had to work a night shift or a weekend. Why? Because there are always plenty of volunteers.
So you depend for your shift on the willingness of others.
Is it parasitic to allow the work to be done by those who want to do it?
If you're depending for your livelihood on the willingness of others to do something you won't, then yes, you are. If they won't work the shift, will you protest? Will you quit? Or will you just buckle down and do what needs to be done.
Neither Australia nor the USA practices conscription any more. Anyone who is in the military is there because they chose to be there. Is it parasitic to allow them to do their job?
If you deny the value of their job, and the necessity of it., and deride them for doing it like so many pure pacifists do; then yes, it is parasitic.
No, in the land of pacifists, the man with a gun is a tyrant.
So you agree with me, then? Since you're saying exactly the same thing I am; you're just using a more emotionally loaded one. Do you deny that I'm right, and if so, why?
My personal opinion is that Heinlein was a dick.
That's nice. How is that relevant?
 
Last edited:
That's nice. How is that relevant?

Because, unlike what some narcissists like to believe, he's actually capable of communicating with other people besides them, and he was obviously sharing an opinion with me.

If you don't like it, you don't have to respond to it.

What I find funny is that you did deliberately ignore something that actually is very relevant:

Arthwollipot said:
And anyway, my later posts should have indicated that I have backed off from the absolutist claim of pacifism anyway.

But it would just take too much effort to actually notice that, wouldn't it?
 
Last edited:
Because, unlike what some narcissists like to believe, he's actually capable of communicating with other people besides them, and he was obviously sharing an opinion with me.

If you don't like it, you don't have to respond to it.
Because personal insults are a much more useful and worthwhile response than addressing the actual issue.
 
Because personal insults are a much more useful and worthwhile response than addressing the actual issue.

Well, given my experience with how you "address" issues, I'm not sure it's worth the time one way or the other.

And I was just educating you on a simple fact. You're welcome to accept it or not, doesn't change anything.

Also, see my edited post for a relevant bit of the topic that you also haven't addressed.

And personally, when I quote someone, I prefer to quote people that actually deserve my respect, but that's just me.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom