Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

Oh, but he did! ;)
In the end, yes he did. And he showed the greatest possible moral fiber in doing so. I can only hope that I would have as much integrity in that situation that he did.

Wait, hang on... They're telling me that Spock is... actually a fictional character. Are you... okay, you're sure of that. Okay.
 
Oh snap! You totally got me on that one!


Yes!
As an excuse for you, one might assume that an overflow of male hormones was involved when you made that post. As someone with testicles, I know that this can easily overtrump the usually existent thinking skills. :D
 
Yes!
As an excuse for you, one might assume that an overflow of male hormones was involved when you made that post. As someone with testicles, I know that this can easily overtrump the usually existent thinking skills. :D
Yes! I blame my clear and obvious overabunance of testosterone.
 
Gumboot said:
Pacifism, ideologically speaking rejects violence in any form, at all costs. That's what I mean when I said that like any ideology, it's a matter of convenience.
That's the modernized definition, far as I know, much like people who push that atheist means "hates God" or "says that the supernatural is 100% impossible to ever exist".

This is what wikipedia has to say.

Pacifism is the opposition to war or violence as a means of settling disputes or gaining advantage. Pacifism covers a spectrum of views ranging from the belief that international disputes can and should be peacefully resolved; to calls for the abolition of the institutions of the military and war; to opposition to any organization of society through governmental force (anarchist or libertarian pacifism); to rejection of the use of physical violence to obtain political, economic or social goals; to the condemnation of force except in cases where it is absolutely necessary to advance the cause of peace; to opposition to violence under any circumstance, including defense of self and others.

EDIT: I think I jumped the gun here. You did say "ideologically speaking". Is there a difference between "ideologically speaking" and the terms I bolded above?
 
Last edited:
This is a thread about pacifists, fool. You should be comparing them to "yellow".

:D
 
I don't think this is what I was referring to though. Pacifism as an ideology isn't as simple as "violence is a last resort". By that definition any decent normal human being would be a pacifist.

Pacifism, ideologically speaking rejects violence in any form, at all costs. That's what I mean when I said that like any ideology, it's a matter of convenience.

For someone like you or me, privileged enough to grow up in a safe, protected, stable society, we can afford to grandstand an ideology of rejecting violence at all costs. Likewise we can grandstand an ideology of "the rule of law" and "justice" and "equality". Someone born into a dangerous, violent, and unsafe world doesn't have that luxury. Adhering to those ideologies costs us nothing. Adhering to those ideologies is liable to cost a less fortunate person their life.

Western society is bulging at the seams with an endless parade of ideals, and we like to pontificate on how superior we are to any other civilisation because we adhere to such lofty principles. Fact is, come a crisis, those ideals vanish like mist.

It's the people that first created those ideals, the ones who stood up for them when no one else did, that are the true ideologues. Not us. That's why I laugh when I come across a westerner who claims to be a pacifist. I can guarantee 99 times out of 100 they've never had to actually stand up for pacificism, and if they ever had to, 99 out of 100 would fail the test.

Now an Iraqi pacifist. A Somali pacifist. A Rwandan pacifist. That's something I can admire, even if I don't agree with them.

Me, I'm not a pacifist. Oh no. Not at all. I would fight with every fiber of my being to preserve what I value. I recognise my hypocrisy, and I don't apologise for it. I have ideals. And I would abandon them in a heartbeat if I had to, to preserve what mattered to me. Because the dead don't have the luxury of having ideals.

I think this post sums everything up pretty well. To be honest, most of gumboots post are right on par with what I am thinking. I am willing to say that he conveys it into words much better than I though.

I am still under the belief that pacifism is quite the selfish ideology. Many terrible acts of violence happen all over the world everyday. In many impoverished nations, those that cannot defend themselves become slaves or are murdered by the hundreds. The reasons may range from having conflicting religious beliefs, to simply looking different. When a pacifist sees this kind of injustice on CNN, they simple say "Oh that's so terrible. Someone should do something. I won't though because I don't believe in violence." Then they flip the channel to something more interesting.

Well I got news for you pacifists, not believing in violence doesn't do a damned thing to help those who are being killed. If you are thinking political pressure is the way to go, most tribal leaders in Africa don't give a damn about political pressure. Not to mention by the time the politics finally work out, thousands of people are already dead. Oh and if our own country ever came under attack (such as on 9/11) would you be willing to pick up a rifle and defend it? Probably not. Because you don't believe in violence. You would leave it up to others to do what is necessary to ensure you sleep safe in your bed every night.

Now I don't want people to think that everyone should go join the military or go out and try and save the world. But just realize that being a pacifist really doesn't do much to help anyone.
 
Yeap, this is a thread just for bashing it seems like, not for discussion.

Sorry, but if I want to be insulted all day long... well, I certainly wouldn't stick around here.

By the way, next time someone says "This is what I believe, and why...", maybe you should do more than just sit and ignore them all day long. Might actually lead somewhere. Try it someday.
 
Last edited:
Yeap, this is a thread just for bashing it seems like, not for discussion.

Sorry, but if I want to be insulted all day long... well, I certainly wouldn't stick around here.

By the way, next time someone says "This is what I believe, and why...", maybe you should do more than just sit and ignore them all day long. Might actually lead somewhere. Try it someday.

I read your responses. You said it was more of a journey and about reaching a goal. You never defined what your end goal is why it is a "journey". Do you go on some quest around the world or something and at the end you realize that violence is bad? Please do elaborate.
 
I read your responses. You said it was more of a journey and about reaching a goal. You never defined what your end goal is why it is a "journey". Do you go on some quest around the world or something and at the end you realize that violence is bad? Please do elaborate.

You're the one accusing pacifism of being selfish, so why are you also demanding it have a goal beyond a lessening of the amount of violence present in the world? The only goal in the pacifists I've known, considering these are individuals who have differences in most other aspects of their lives, has been a reduction of violence. There is no single model of overall behavior, no Ten Commandments or some-such that must be followed, for holding a pacifist ideology.

I can understand accusing some forms of extreme pacifism as being altruistic to a fault, but to blanketly condemn all types of pacifism seems a bit on the hyperbolic side.
 
You're the one accusing pacifism of being selfish, so why are you also demanding it have a goal beyond a lessening of the amount of violence present in the world? The only goal in the pacifists I've known, considering these are individuals who have differences in most other aspects of their lives, has been a reduction of violence. There is no single model of overall behavior, no Ten Commandments or some-such that must be followed, for holding a pacifist ideology.

I can understand accusing some forms of extreme pacifism as being altruistic to a fault, but to blanketly condemn all types of pacifism seems a bit on the hyperbolic side.

If pacifism is about lessening the amount of violence present in the world, what are pacifists doing about it? If they want to lessen the violence in their community, what are they doing about it? I am pretty sure every decent human being wants less violence in the world. That's nothing special. But what people are doing about it is.
 
That's the modernized definition, far as I know, much like people who push that atheist means "hates God" or "says that the supernatural is 100% impossible to ever exist".

This is what wikipedia has to say.

EDIT: I think I jumped the gun here. You did say "ideologically speaking". Is there a difference between "ideologically speaking" and the terms I bolded above?


Perhaps I'm misusing the term, but I tend to think of an ideological position as being at the extreme end, so that pacifism as a principle or a value might be "I'd rather not use violence if I can help it" where as, as an ideology it's more "I absolutely will not use violence no matter what".

Hence why I consider most people who claim to adhere to an ideology to be liars or simply adherents of convenience - very few people have the strength of conviction to adhere that strongly to something. I think most people value certain principles, but are smart enough to realise sometimes those principles have to be put aside.

I hope that makes sense. Perhaps I'm reinventing the meaning of words to suit my own interpretation. :boxedin:
 
I read your responses. You said it was more of a journey and about reaching a goal. You never defined what your end goal is why it is a "journey".
Actually, yes, I did. I went at some length of time on it. Read again.

Do you go on some quest around the world or something and at the end you realize that violence is bad? Please do elaborate.
What?

It's about doing what it takes to lessen future violence. Such as, for instance, spreading democracies, as democracies rarely fight each other, or implementing a system of non-violence that actually works (such as the way Otpor came out saying "We won't be violent", found a way to reach the hearts of soldiers, and weren't attacked even though soldiers and police were ordered to attack them, because of their careful planning and implementation).

If you're not even bothering to listen to people, as it's quite clear you haven't even bothered to read any of my posts beyond that snippet, how do you expect this conversation to continue?

Did you even read the wikipedia article I cited, which makes it quite clear that pacifism is not the ultra-simple definition you've ascribed to it? You take the extreme form of it, assume that all pacifists are it, then use that as a platform to bash them.

It's moronic, stupid, and willfully ignorant, making you barely better than most creationists and IDers.
 
If pacifism is about lessening the amount of violence present in the world, what are pacifists doing about it? If they want to lessen the violence in their community, what are they doing about it? I am pretty sure every decent human being wants less violence in the world. That's nothing special. But what people are doing about it is.

You seriously don't know that MLK, Gandhi, and Otpor have all reached their philosophy and laid down guidelines?

People don't just do that because "they felt like it". That's how they're doing it.

Spreading democracy or humanitarian aid is another method.

There are many methods to get to the end goal. That you seem to be willfully ignorant on the matter doesn't mean that no one's doing anything.
 
Actually, yes, I did. I went at some length of time on it. Read again.


What?

It's about doing what it takes to lessen future violence. Such as, for instance, spreading democracies, as democracies rarely fight each other, or implementing a system of non-violence that actually works (such as the way Otpor came out saying "We won't be violent", found a way to reach the hearts of soldiers, and weren't attacked even though soldiers and police were ordered to attack them, because of their careful planning and implementation).

If you're not even bothering to listen to people, as it's quite clear you haven't even bothered to read any of my posts beyond that snippet, how do you expect this conversation to continue?

Did you even read the wikipedia article I cited, which makes it quite clear that pacifism is not the ultra-simple definition you've ascribed to it? You take the extreme form of it, assume that all pacifists are it, then use that as a platform to bash them.

It's moronic, stupid, and willfully ignorant, making you barely better than most creationists and IDers.

Easy. No need to get upset. It's just the internet. I see what you are saying about the differences between pacifists. Not all of them are extreme. Got it. But do you see very many of these "non extreme' pacifists picking up rifles and defending anything? And I see that you talk of spreading democracy. Do you think that violence may be involved in this (For reference, see Iraq).
 
You seriously don't know that MLK, Gandhi, and Otpor have all reached their philosophy and laid down guidelines?

People don't just do that because "they felt like it". That's how they're doing it.

Spreading democracy or humanitarian aid is another method.

There are many methods to get to the end goal. That you seem to be willfully ignorant on the matter doesn't mean that no one's doing anything.

Yes methods used by MLK, Gandhi, and Otpor work great against governments that are not willing to commit genocide. Now what about the ones who don't give a damn? Do you think Gandhi would fare well in a place like Somalia or Rwanda?
 
Easy. No need to get upset. It's just the internet. I see what you are saying about the differences between pacifists. Not all of them are extreme. Got it.
Fantastic. Here I had my doubts.

But do you see very many of these "non extreme' pacifists picking up rifles and defending anything?
Until you can show me that you know each and every one of these "non extreme" pacifists, this is merely a form of Argument from Ignorance; "I haven't seen any of them myself, ergo, they must not exist". It's like the whole "There are No Atheists in Foxholes" defense. "I've never seen an Atheist in a Foxhole, so they must not exist". Yet the group "Atheists in Foxholes" disproves that by their very existence.

Furthermore, and this may surprise you, but there are many people that don't pick up guns within any country, that still further causes of peace and diplomacy. You don't need to shoot someone to do good. Most of the founding fathers were lawyers and politicians that never shot anyone, including my favorite, Thomas Payne. Are you going to claim that they're worth less because they never picked up a gun and shot someone?

I'd like to see that. "Thomas Payne less of a human being because he used the pen, not a gun".

Then there's charitable organizations that are not about warfare, the Red Cross, etc. They aren't worth less because they're not going around with guns.

And I see that you talk of spreading democracy. Do you think that violence may be involved in this (For reference, see Iraq).

I don't believe that efforts in Iraq will be successful. Forcing a democracy on a people that don't want it is useless, and the situation in Iraq seems to be exactly that. Even the people that support a democracy tend to vote towards leaders that will take it away from them. The culture is just too different, there isn't enough of a backdrop to continue.

While efforts have somewhat worked in Asian countries, there have been more failures than successes (Japan being the biggest exception). Germany is also somewhat of an exception, although they did have a democracy before Hitler took power, so it's probably a bad example.

But yes, is violence necessary for that end at times? I think so. I certainly would have supported the American Revolution, although I would not have supported unnecessary bloodshed at any point of time, nor do I ever.

Violence is, and always should be, the last resort. And there are methods -- methodical, long, planned methods -- to avoid requiring that violence. That is what we should aim for, as a people.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom