Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

Quad4_72

AI-EE-YAH!
Joined
Nov 7, 2006
Messages
6,354
Some talk of pacifism came up in the pirate thread so I went ahead and made another thread for it, as requested by poster arthwollipot. I think that pacifism definitely needs some clarification, because as of right now there is no rationale for it. First, let's go over what self proclaimed pacifist arthwollipot said.

First he told me that I am evil for using violence and that anyone else who uses violence for defense is evil.

And there'll always be people like you who are perfectly willing to use violence as a solution to that problem. To me, that makes you just as evil as them. Perhaps that's the part you're not understanding.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4682707#post4682707

Then, arthwollipot commends me for doing something that he is unwilling to do, but also commends garbage men for the same reason. This strikes me as strange because the difference between garbage men and the military is glaringly obvious.
I commend and admire Quad4_72 and anyone else who has chosen to serve in uniform for doing a nasty, nasty job that I would never, ever do myself. But then again, I commend and admire garbage collectors for the same reason. That's my last word. If anyone wants to start a pacifism thread, I'll be there.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4682913#post4682913

So basically, someone needs to explain this pacifist thing to me. Here is my take on it. As I stated in the other thread, there will ALWAYS be people in this world willing to commit violence against others for evil purposes. The only way evil can prevail is if good men sit by and do nothing (pacifists). To me, I feel that pacifists are either being cowards or lazy because they are unwilling to defend themselves or others and rely on other people to do it for them. Did I get that right?
 
As I stated in the other thread, there will ALWAYS be people in this world willing to commit violence against others for evil purposes. The only way evil can prevail is if good men sit by and do nothing (pacifists).

Well there is a difference between doing nothing and using violence to do a something. I think it depends on the circumstance. Nothing other than severe violence could have stopped Nazi Germany, yet non-violence was the driving force behind The Civil Rights Movement.
 
Well there is a difference between doing nothing and using violence to do a something. I think it depends on the circumstance. Nothing other than severe violence could have stopped Nazi Germany, yet non-violence was the driving force behind The Civil Rights Movement.

Yes I actually stated this in the other thread when art said that guns never solve anything. He chose to ignore my response though.
 
My mother always told me there was a time for violence and a time for peace. A wise man knows when to do both. I can't imagine that anybody would simply refuse to use violence even when it is necessary to protect himself or his loved ones, for the same reason why I can't imagine anybody who would use violence when it isn't necessary.

I'd like to know what exactly a 'pacifist' is in this context too.
 
I will only discuss the strongest version of pacifism I can think of, what's ridiculous is ridiculous.

The best sort of pasifism comes from a good place, abject hatred of war. My granddad fought in Europe in WWII. He sat out DDay because he had the flu (which he claimed saved his life) and was rewarded with the duty of tagging bodies. He won the Dutch equivalent of the medal of honor and refused to talk about. He was as far right as you could get and intensely argued that no war was worth fighting. There had to be another solution.

I live in a nation of luxury that his bravery created, and I have no desire to go through whatever he did to swear off warfare.

I also think that 90% or more of armed engagements create more problems than they solve, our escapade in Iraq being the most recent example.

But practically, there are times when you have to use force. I remember Howard Zinn came to my University to give a lecture in the late 90's, after our intervention in Kosovo. At the time I was heavily influenced by A People's History of the United States and his seemingly uncompromising pacifism. Nevertheless, I wondered how you could stop the ethnic cleansing in Kosovo without using force.

He was quite clear in the lecture that military options were always a bad choice, so after the lecture I asked him what he would have done with Kosovo. He answered that being a pacifist didn't mean never using force, and that the air raids were probably a good idea.

I was obviously stunned, and I asked him why he never added this modification of his views to his writing, he sort of shrugged off the question and I didn't want to harass the man.

I thought Zinn was an unapologetic pacifist, but even he recognized that a stick was sometimes necessary. I still think that almost all forms of violence are counterproductive, but we had to shoot the damn pirates to save that captain's life. I can't even imagine another solution, save dumping money into their hands which has the long term net effect of promoting piracy and creating more violence. You simply shift the burden of suffering from the criminals to the victims. We can either kill pirates or let them kill innocent people.
 
Last edited:
My mother always told me there was a time for violence and a time for peace. A wise man knows when to do both. I can't imagine that anybody would simply refuse to use violence even when it is necessary to protect himself or his loved ones, for the same reason why I can't imagine anybody who would use violence when it isn't necessary.

I'd like to know what exactly a 'pacifist' is in this context too.

It was discussed in the other thread that he would never use violence for anything. I know this seems extremely strange to me as well. That is why I started this thread.
 
I will only discuss the strongest version of pacifism I can think of, what's ridiculous is ridiculous.

The best sort of pasifism comes from a good place, abject hatred of war. My granddad fought in Europe in WWII. He sat out DDay because he had the flu (which he claimed saved his life) and was rewarded with the duty of tagging bodies. He won the Dutch equivalent of the medal of honor and refused to talk about. He was as far right as you could get and intensely argued that no war was worth fighting. There had to be another solution.

I live in a nation of luxury that his bravery created, and I have no desire to go through whatever he did to swear off warfare.

I also think that 90% or more of armed engagements create more problems than they solve, our escapade in Iraq being the most recent example.

But practically, there are times when you have to use force. I remember Howard Zinn came to my University to give a lecture in the late 90's, after our intervention in Kosovo. At the time I was heavily influenced by A People's History of the United States and his seemingly uncompromising pacifism. Nevertheless, I wondered how you could stop the ethnic cleansing in Kosovo without using force.

He was quite clear in the lecture that military options were always a bad choice, so after the lecture I asked him what he would have done with Kosovo. He answered that being a pacifist didn't mean never using force, and that the air raids were probably a good idea.

I was obviously stunned, and I asked him why he never added this modification of his views to his writing, he sort of shrugged off the question and I didn't want to harass the man.

I thought Zinn was an unapologetic pacifist, but even he recognized that a stick was sometimes necessary. I still think that almost all forms of violence are counterproductive, but we had to shoot the damn pirates to save that captain's life. I can't even imagine another solution, save dumping money into their hands which has the long term net effect of promoting piracy and creating more violence. You simply shift the burden of suffering from the criminals to the victims. We can either kill pirates or let them kill innocent people.

Very good post. I agree. There is a time and a place for violence. Sometimes my strong convictions are taken as war mongering and that I love to kill. This is far from the case. It is a last resort. I just express with strong passion that I am more than willing to kill if it means self defense, the defense of others, or for the defense of my country.
 
My mother always told me there was a time for violence and a time for peace. A wise man knows when to do both. I can't imagine that anybody would simply refuse to use violence even when it is necessary to protect himself or his loved ones, for the same reason why I can't imagine anybody who would use violence when it isn't necessary.

I think there's quite a bit of room for disagreement about when violence is "necessary."

For example, if someone pulls a handgun on you and starts firing, is violence "necessary"? Some would say yes. Others would say no -- what is "necessary" is to get the hell out of there. I must admit that I incline to the latter; police stats suggest that you're more likely to get hurt or killed in this situation if you return fire, and much more likely to get hurt/killed if you try to resist but don't have a firearm yourself. (Part of the reason for that is that most people are just lousy shots and if you can get more than about 20 feet away, their chance of hitting you is almost nil. If you're facing Wyatt Earp, your statistics may vary.)
 
This is rather difficult for me, since I am very well aware that my attitude and philosophy appears more than a little bit contradictory.

Let me say right at the start that the original thread is the first time I actively identified as a pacifist. I never used that word to refer to myself prior to this post. So I haven't spent a great deal of time thinking about myself as pacifist.

I'll start by saying that violence can sometimes be a necessary evil. I commended Quad4_72 for doing a nasty job that I couldn't do, and I stand by that. I could not and would not take up arms and join any kind of military. Part of the reason for that is that I'd make a truly awful soldier. I have very little respect for authority and would most likely disobey orders simply to make a point. That's not what the military needs. It's counterproductive. The military doesn't want me.

Yes, I said that people who assume that guns are a problem solver are evil. Perhaps that particular statement was a little strong, and I will willingly back off from it. As I said, if guns are evil, then they are at least sometimes a necessary evil.

I count myself fortunate to live in a place where violent crime is extremely rare. This situation has significantly contributed to my pacifist nature. I have never had to defend myself in an assault, and I have never had any reason to fear that my life or my person may be in danger from others. I fully recognise that this is not true everywhere, but I make no apologies for my attitude. I still believe that violence merely begets more violence, that violence is a vicious cycle, and that people should be more forgiving of one another and should not try to use guns to solve their problems.

Please challenge any of my statements on this subject. Like I said, the idea of being a pacifist is a new one to me. I'm still not sure whether the label actually fits. It's an area where I need to think about how I think. Other peoples' input - especially that of people who do not agree with me - is valued. I'm pretty thick-skinned, so don't worry too much about offending me.

This is a subject that I need to examine thoroughly. For my own self-image if nothing else. Talk to me. Thanks.
 
I think there's quite a bit of room for disagreement about when violence is "necessary."

For example, if someone pulls a handgun on you and starts firing, is violence "necessary"? Some would say yes. Others would say no -- what is "necessary" is to get the hell out of there. I must admit that I incline to the latter; police stats suggest that you're more likely to get hurt or killed in this situation if you return fire, and much more likely to get hurt/killed if you try to resist but don't have a firearm yourself. (Part of the reason for that is that most people are just lousy shots and if you can get more than about 20 feet away, their chance of hitting you is almost nil. If you're facing Wyatt Earp, your statistics may vary.)

Your scenario is one where violence isn't necessary. If I were alone, getting the hell out of there is job 1. But, what if the person was firing at your family, and they couldn't run?
 
It was discussed in the other thread that he would never use violence for anything. I know this seems extremely strange to me as well. That is why I started this thread.
Yes - I would never consider using violence as a tool for any purpose. I believe that it would be counterproductive in pretty much any circumstance that I can see myself getting into.

Note here - I'm talking about circumstances that I can imagine myself in. This does not include scenarios such as "say you're a police officer" or "what if you're in the military and..." These situations simply do not and will not apply to me and I will not consider them.

There are police officers and uniformed military, and as I said in the other thread I have the utmost respect for them and the job that they do. I will never do that job, so it is pointless speculating about what I might do if I ever did.
 
Your scenario is one where violence isn't necessary. If I were alone, getting the hell out of there is job 1. But, what if the person was firing at your family, and they couldn't run?
I find that subjects like this involve an awful lot of what if... scenarios. I generally don't find considerations of hypotheticals very productive, because they tend to address idealistic, fantasy worlds rather than the real world.
 
Last edited:
As I said, if guns are evil, then they are at least sometimes a necessary evil.

This is indeed a correct statement. I am glad that you clarified that and understand that.

I count myself fortunate to live in a place where violent crime is extremely rare. This situation has significantly contributed to my pacifist nature. I have never had to defend myself in an assault, and I have never had any reason to fear that my life or my person may be in danger from others. I fully recognise that this is not true everywhere, but I make no apologies for my attitude. I still believe that violence merely begets more violence, that violence is a vicious cycle, and that people should be more forgiving of one another and should not try to use guns to solve their problems.

I agree. Violence sucks. It is truly awful some of the things humans do to each other. But, nevertheless, violence is a fact of life and always has been. There will never be a world without violence, as history has shown. It is great that you live in a place where violence is rare. But once again as history has shown, some terrible acts of violence have happened in the nicest and safest of places. Tell me, would you be willing to use violence to defend your family? For example, lets say you come home and your daughter is about to be raped. Would you use violence to stop this man from raping your daughter?
[/quote]
 
Yes - I would never consider using violence as a tool for any purpose. I believe that it would be counterproductive in pretty much any circumstance that I can see myself getting into.

Note here - I'm talking about circumstances that I can imagine myself in. This does not include scenarios such as "say you're a police officer" or "what if you're in the military and..." These situations simply do not and will not apply to me and I will not consider them.

There are police officers and uniformed military, and as I said in the other thread I have the utmost respect for them and the job that they do. I will never do that job, so it is pointless speculating about what I might do if I ever did.

Noted. Please see my scenario in my previous post.
 
Your scenario is one where violence isn't necessary. If I were alone, getting the hell out of there is job 1. But, what if the person was firing at your family, and they couldn't run?

Grab 'em and drag 'em. (Implicit "duh.")

That almost makes my point stronger. If you resist, you get shot, and they still (by assumption) can't run. So now they're still at his mercy and you're now hurt, too?

Resist and you give the perp a great opportunity for a twofer.
 
I find that subjects like this involve an awful lot of what if... scenarios. I generally don't find considerations of hypotheticals very productive, because they tend to address idealistic, fantasy worlds rather than the real world.

I beg to differ. Crime is not a fantasy. Just because you live in a place where crime is rare does not mean it could not happen. You being a pacifist I think it is essential for clarification to know what you would do in certain hypothetical situations where you would be forced to defend your family.
 
Back a while ago, during the civil-rights movement, I recall listening to a number of people (mostly in the entertainment industry) who were fans of what you might call extreme pacifism.
They maintained that they simply would not harm another human being, regardless of the circumstances. Unprovoked attack, rape, whatever. They thought that violence was simply never justified.
You can see religious antecedents; the Jains, for instance. I believe that Ghandi was influenced by the Jains. I've heard the attitude that one who presents no threat whatever would not be likely to be the victim of attack. My experience in police work has shown this demonstrably false.

I suppose that it's possible to look on such a philosophy as admirable...

I certainly don't think so. Perhaps I'm jaded by my profession, but even as a young child I learned that the best way to avoid the typical schoolyard bullying was to fight back.
I have a rather sanguine attitude towards the Sudanese pirates; they are armed robbers and they should be killed. Their "mother ships" should be located and sunk.

I know very well that these people have problems; no government, poverty, exploitation of their resources by foreigners, etc. These things are soluble by means other than piracy. (and piracy isn't doing a damned thing to solve them...)

I have the same attitude towards armed robbers in general. If you walk into a store and threaten violence in order to obtain money, your life should be forfeit. If the store owner shoots you, I will not weep over your body.

Violence is an appropriate response to violent attacks. If the non-violent wish to throw their lives away, that's their decision.
 
Back a while ago, during the civil-rights movement, I recall listening to a number of people (mostly in the entertainment industry) who were fans of what you might call extreme pacifism.
They maintained that they simply would not harm another human being, regardless of the circumstances. Unprovoked attack, rape, whatever. They thought that violence was simply never justified.
You can see religious antecedents; the Jains, for instance. I believe that Ghandi was influenced by the Jains. I've heard the attitude that one who presents no threat whatever would not be likely to be the victim of attack. My experience in police work has shown this demonstrably false.

I suppose that it's possible to look on such a philosophy as admirable...

I certainly don't think so. Perhaps I'm jaded by my profession, but even as a young child I learned that the best way to avoid the typical schoolyard bullying was to fight back.
I have a rather sanguine attitude towards the Sudanese pirates; they are armed robbers and they should be killed. Their "mother ships" should be located and sunk.

I know very well that these people have problems; no government, poverty, exploitation of their resources by foreigners, etc. These things are soluble by means other than piracy. (and piracy isn't doing a damned thing to solve them...)

I have the same attitude towards armed robbers in general. If you walk into a store and threaten violence in order to obtain money, your life should be forfeit. If the store owner shoots you, I will not weep over your body.

Violence is an appropriate response to violent attacks. If the non-violent wish to throw their lives away, that's their decision.

What did you do some kind of mind swap with me? Lol. That is my philosophy exactly and I have actually said some of those sentences before down to the T. I have worked as a bouncer and actually done some law enforcement myself (not to mention I am in the military). Isn't it funny how the people who have actually been out there and experienced the violence realize that being a pacifist will get you killed in certain situations? Then on the flipside, the pacifists who have never been in a fight in their life think that being peaceful will get them out of trouble.
 
I agree. Violence sucks. It is truly awful some of the things humans do to each other. But, nevertheless, violence is a fact of life and always has been. There will never be a world without violence, as history has shown. It is great that you live in a place where violence is rare. But once again as history has shown, some terrible acts of violence have happened in the nicest and safest of places.
Intellectually, I know that. Viscerally, I still don't grok it. I'm talking about subconscious reactions here. I never grew up with violence being a fact of life. Had my circumstances been different, I'm sure that I'd have a different opinion.

Tell me, would you be willing to use violence to defend your family? For example, lets say you come home and your daughter is about to be raped. Would you use violence to stop this man from raping your daughter?
Well, once again this is a totally unrealistic "what if" scenario. For a start, I don't have a daughter. Secondly, a situation like this is statistically very unlikely in my region.

But granted that, if I choose to accept your hypothetical, then I would say that I would probably try to be violent. I just don't know that I'd be very effective at it. I'd probably compromise my own safety and that of my hypothetical daughter by doing so.

Let me say here that I have had some training and practice in various martial arts. I believe that if it came to a one on one violent confrontation I could probably hold my own. But I would be using nonlethal techniques (joint locks and holds), and more importantly I have never tested this belief. I just don't know. I'll probably never know. I would rather not find out.
 
...snip... The only way evil can prevail is if good men sit by and do nothing (pacifists). To me, I feel that pacifists are either being cowards or lazy because they are unwilling to defend themselves or others and rely on other people to do it for them. Did I get that right?

Well there are many variations of what people consider a "pacifist" to be (just like all such idealogical labels).

One form of pacifism is that you cannot be coerced by violence as much as it is about you not using violence yourself. When you run with that definition as a thought experiment it is quite interesting, for example a pacifist nation could never be militarily occupied using traditional methods since such an occupation relies on the threat of violence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom