Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

What I always say is that I am a peaceable man, but I am not a pacifist. If you cause me no harm, then we'll have no problems. I've never had any cause to become violent, and I hope things stay that way. However, I do not subscribe to the philosophy of peace at any price.
 
There's a difference between solving a problem and solving all problems.

[snip brief history recap]

I'm not arguing that the Balkans are a utopia now, but that intervention quite clearly ended the Serbian aggression and brought the region back from the brink of total chaos and genocide. It is all but certain that Serbia would have continued with similar refuge massacres. So despite the current tensions, I would assert that they're better off than they could have been if no one had intervened.

Yeah, but that gets into "what if" alt-history possibilities that can likely go in a myriad of directions.

The question at issue is if there was any way other than the administration of NATO force to halt the Serbian advance and end the ethnic cleansing?

I didn't realize you weren't arguing the pacifist stance, so that question isn't necessarily aimed at you, but I am interested in hearing solutions from people claiming to be pacifists.

My guess is that the answer would revolve around making diplomatic responses. Being pacifist doesn't preclude taking the carrot-stick approach, it's just that the sticks are different in nature. I couldn't give you too many details because I don't hang around with political pacifists much, but I imagine that it would revolve around the methodology I mention here, not just doing nothing or ignoring it.

-----

I am still waiting for a coherent pacifist argument in this thread. As of right now, it seems that pacifists would sit back and do nothing if harm were being done to others. Or they would just run away. Am I incorrect with that statement?

Yes, you're incorrect in that statement.

The problem I see with your apparent incomprehension of the concept can be summed up with the following saying: when the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem begins to look a lot like a nail.
 
Yes, you're incorrect in that statement.

The problem I see with your apparent incomprehension of the concept can be summed up with the following saying: when the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem begins to look a lot like a nail.

Gonna have to do better than that. I said a coherent argument, you gave me a sentence. It has already been presented why violence is sometimes unavoidable. I have yet to see someone explain why pacifism would be a better idea in an unavoidable violence situation, such as Nazi Germany.
 
Arth, you are aware of a little thing called "for the sake of argument" ?
Yes, which is why I went on to say:

But granted that, if I choose to accept your hypothetical, then I would say that I would probably try to be violent. I just don't know that I'd be very effective at it. I'd probably compromise my own safety and that of my hypothetical daughter by doing so.
A paragraph that you appear to have chosen to ignore. :confused:
 
Yeah, but that gets into "what if" alt-history possibilities that can likely go in a myriad of directions.

My guess is that the answer would revolve around making diplomatic responses. Being pacifist doesn't preclude taking the carrot-stick approach, it's just that the sticks are different in nature. I couldn't give you too many details because I don't hang around with political pacifists much, but I imagine that it would revolve around the methodology I mention here, not just doing nothing or ignoring it.

-----

Yes, you're incorrect in that statement.

The problem I see with your apparent incomprehension of the concept can be summed up with the following saying: when the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem begins to look a lot like a nail.

With all due respect, you haven't presented any sort of argument that makes me think pacifistic solutions are viable when faced with extremely brutal enemies.

I think groups like the mid-90's Serbs, Nazis, and, say, the Khmer Rouge are minority instances. That being said, they have to be dealt with. They may not be common, but there's been at least one such regime for every generation in the past two centuries.

If you can't come up with a viable explanation of how you would deal with historical examples, why should I take you seriously? All you've said is that you think diplomacy might possibly have worked and offer no evidence to support that claim. Remember, the area where the most horrific massacre in the Balkans took place was a diplomatically negotiated "safe zone."

I'll give an example of the sort of argument I think a pacifist needs to make: take Bush's Excellent Iraqi Adventure. I would argue that military intervention was a poor choice. Given that Saddam was completely disarmed and thoroughly isolated, there was no reason to further destabilize that nation. The consequences speak for themselves.

That is hardly a detailed account, but it's a basic schematic of the sort of claims that are necessary to support the position. Remember, pacifism, at least as we have been discussing it, holds that violence isn't appropriate in any situation. If you hold a view that strong, you have to be prepared to defend it.
 
Gonna have to do better than that. I said a coherent argument, you gave me a sentence. It has already been presented why violence is sometimes unavoidable. I have yet to see someone explain why pacifism would be a better idea in an unavoidable violence situation, such as Nazi Germany.

The problem is that you keep coming back to situations where violence is already in play, or with situations from history where the discussion can easily turn into an alt-history argument about what would-have-happened. How about you ask a more pertinent question of pacifists, like what they suggest be done in Pakistan now that the Taliban are moving in on Islamibad? Or what a pacifist would do to address Iran or North Korea?
 
Are you saying the real world doesn't have violent people, who will only stop being violent upon being confronted with greater violence, or at least the threat thereof?
No, I'm saying that hypothetical situations rarely find parallels in the real world, and are therefore rarely helpful when dealing with real world situations.

For example - I have always had a scenario in my head about what I'd do if someone throws a punch at my face. I would grab his wrist from underneath with my right hand while dodging with my upper body, then twist his arm clockwise and apply pressure with my left hand on his locked elbow while stepping back with my right foot to pull him off balance.

This is a very nice hypothetical scenario which ends with me holding my assailant face down in a joint lock. Does it have any applicability to a real situation? No, it really doesn't. A real situation would not go according the way I would expect it to go. That's what I mean when I say that hypothetical situations are not usually helpful when dealing with real world situations.
 
With all due respect, you haven't presented any sort of argument that makes me think pacifistic solutions are viable when faced with extremely brutal enemies.

I think groups like the mid-90's Serbs, Nazis, and, say, the Khmer Rouge are minority instances. That being said, they have to be dealt with. They may not be common, but there's been at least one such regime for every generation in the past two centuries.

If you can't come up with a viable explanation of how you would deal with historical examples, why should I take you seriously? All you've said is that you think diplomacy might possibly have worked and offer no evidence to support that claim. Remember, the area where the most horrific massacre in the Balkans took place was a diplomatically negotiated "safe zone."

I'll give an example of the sort of argument I think a pacifist needs to make: take Bush's Excellent Iraqi Adventure. I would argue that military intervention was a poor choice. Given that Saddam was completely disarmed and thoroughly isolated, there was no reason to further destabilize that nation. The consequences speak for themselves.

That is hardly a detailed account, but it's a basic schematic of the sort of claims that are necessary to support the position. Remember, pacifism, at least as we have been discussing it, holds that violence isn't appropriate in any situation. If you hold a view that strong, you have to be prepared to defend it.

Actually, I do believe that those Iraq arguments were made by pacifist crowds back in 2003. Hindsight is always 20/20, huh?
 
The problem is that you keep coming back to situations where violence is already in play, or with situations from history where the discussion can easily turn into an alt-history argument about what would-have-happened. How about you ask a more pertinent question of pacifists, like what they suggest be done in Pakistan now that the Taliban are moving in on Islamibad? Or what a pacifist would do to address Iran or North Korea?

My whole argument here is that Pacifism is ridiculous because there are situations when there is no other choice but to use violence. I want to know what they would do in those situations.
 
If your martial arts training is geared to competition and if you come up against a seasoned street fighter intent on doing you harm you will likely find yourself with your guts stomped out.
No, my martial arts training has not been geared to competition. A majority of my training has been in western martial arts, which consist of extremely brutal techniques of killing an opponent with a sword (or other weapon). However, I have also studied both western and eastern unarmed techniques as well, both from what I call "practical" martial arts and "impractical" martial arts. I know the difference between the dojo and the street.

But please let's not turn this thread into another martial arts thread.
 
Actually, I do believe that those Iraq arguments were made by pacifist crowds back in 2003. Hindsight is always 20/20, huh?

Yes, I was making those arguments in 2003. I was protesting on street corners in Kansas as hillbillies drove by and threw beer bottles at me.

But the pacifist stance is stronger, they say that all violence should be avoided. If you can't answer the tough situations you can't make universal statements.
 
Yes, I was making those arguments in 2003. I was protesting on street corners in Kansas as hillbillies drove by and threw beer bottles at me.

But the pacifist stance is stronger, they say that all violence should be avoided. If you can't answer the tough situations you can't make universal statements.

I can understand that (and mostly agree). The pacifist stance usually revolves around those tough situations usually having preceding incidents with underlying factors that could be handled differently. Most of the military situations the US has been in for the last 50 years could qualify for that. Of course, then the conversation normally shifts to the personal situations.
 
Arth---generally I agree with you, but I feel I have to point out that "what ifs" are highly valuable.

I trained in CPR and 1st aid. I've had to perform the Heimleich once, but other than that I haven't used any of the information from the course, and hope I never have to. However, that whole course was one series of "what ifs", and if I hadn't considered them at the time and learned how to deal with them, right now there'd be one more dead kid with a piece of hot dog lodged in his throat.
And that's a completely valid statement. However, the "what ifs" you're referring to here are completely different from the ones that I was addressing. You're referring to training.

In martial arts, one is taught to perform a strike, or a throw, or a lock, and then one practices it, so that if it is required in a fight, you do it right first time. This is how you learn CPR as well. In either case, an incorrect technique may cause more harm than it mitigates.

Quad4_72's scenario wasn't that. It was a hyothetical situation, where a choice is forced. It's unrealistic because of the very real possiblity that I may make a certain choice when answering the hypothetical, but react in an entirely different way if the actual situation - with all the information available to me and not just that provided by the hypothetical - occurs in real life.

I wouldn't claim that all hypotheticals are by definition useless in all situations. That would be absurd. But I don't see much point in using a hypothetical to "test" how I would react in certain idealised situations. The real world is much messier than that, and I'll only know for sure if and when the situation actually occurs.
 
Quad4_72's scenario wasn't that. It was a hyothetical situation, where a choice is forced. It's unrealistic because of the very real possiblity that I may make a certain choice when answering the hypothetical, but react in an entirely different way if the actual situation - with all the information available to me and not just that provided by the hypothetical - occurs in real life.

I wouldn't claim that all hypotheticals are by definition useless in all situations. That would be absurd. But I don't see much point in using a hypothetical to "test" how I would react in certain idealised situations. The real world is much messier than that, and I'll only know for sure if and when the situation actually occurs.

This sounds like a cop out. There are situations where you are FORCED to make a choice. I am really curious if you would use force to defend your family or other people if put in that situation. I realize that you have never been in that situation, but use your brain and think about it.
 
Unfortunately, ultimately yes. However, had the decision been mine, I would not have used violence as a first resort. As far as I know, neither did Chamberlain.

So when Japan bombed us, you would not have seen that as a reason to go to war?
 
I can understand that (and mostly agree). The pacifist stance usually revolves around those tough situations usually having preceding incidents with underlying factors that could be handled differently. Most of the military situations the US has been in for the last 50 years could qualify for that. Of course, then the conversation normally shifts to the personal situations.

I have a great deal of sympathy with that view. Choosing to engage and support Middle Eastern wars in the 80's directly led to many of the issues we face today. If we hadn't used violence to instal the Shaw of Iran in the 50's, the threat of religious extremists getting a hold of a nuke would be significantly less.

The problem is that we cannot at any time control all variables. The Civil War was a violent action taken to end slavery. Given that the South was willing to secede, there was no other way to force them to abandon slavery. Many people died. Many slaves would have continued to live in inhuman oppression if the war hadn't been fought.

The argument is that action should have been taken long before the Civil War in order to avoid the uncomfortable choice.

But when do you start? Presumably we have to act now to avoid situations like the Civil War and Kosovo in the future. But the present pressures us with decisions that are similarly compelled: How do you stop Al Qaeda, an organizition with no real desires save bringing about the end times, peaceably? Certainly a number of the specific actions we've taken have been suspect, but whether through military intervention or international policing, some violence will be necessary to stop that organization from murdering innocent people.

There's no moment of purity where we can start the chain of non-violent acts that end violence forever. It's a fantasy.
 
Last edited:
I understand where you are coming from, but I think you are missing what I am trying to get out of it. I am trying to understand a pacifists mind. In other words, what WOULD get someone who is so against violence to use violence. Is there a point when an extreme pacifist would use violence in the defense of themselves or another person? That is where the what if scenario comes into play. If you came into your home and saw a man attempting to rape your daughter, would you use violence to stop this? I honestly don't think this scenario is TOO far out there either. I realize the unlikeliness of the situation, but it serves a purpose. The purpose is to see if there is a point where an extreme pacifist would resort to violence.
I understand what you're asking for here, and I'm afraid that the only answer I have is "I don't know". I have not encountered a situation since growing out of short pants where I thought violence was justified.

That's right - I have never used violence for any purpose, offense or defense. I just don't know what would push me that far. I imagine that there may be a point beyond which I would be motivated to violence, but I can't imagine what that point may be, and I don't think that engaging in hypotheticals is a very good way of exploring the question, for reasons that I have already outlined.
 
What you're describing here isn't trying to understand the mind of a pacifist. What you're attempting to do is catch the pacifist mindset in a "gotcha!" moment. It more resembles the evangelical Christian constantly trying to ask pointed questions of an atheist to finally say, "Ha! See? You don't know that there isn't a God, do you? You just believe you do! You rely on faith!"

Try to examine it without looking for a "gotcha!" moment for a bit. You might be able to approach the concept with a little less trouble for doing so.
Very good point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom