Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

I think the two World Wars, collectively, provide the perfect example of why putting all your eggs in one basket is disastrous. The aggressive and preemptive stance of Europe led to the horrific bloodshed of WWI, but their blind "no violence, no matter what" stance in response to WWI led to the even greater bloodshed of WWII.

Diplomacy, reconciliation, compromise, these all have their place. And so does violent action. The trick is to know when to use each of them. Work that one out and history will make you immortal.

To be fair, the stance in Europe following WWI was that they didn't want another huge war that took such a massive toll on their respective populations. It affected practically everyone in Europe (and much of the world) to their core, and there were only few families who didn't suffer some kind of loss. I agree that the resistance to fighting the growing Nazi menace made the fight more difficult when it began full bore, but most of the Western world had grown punch-shy from the Great War.
 
Well I am not a pacifist, and I doubt many people are. I think the thing that gets confused is the difference between conscientious objection and pacifism.

The c.c. position is that I would avoid premeditated violence in the interest of not hurting people, because I personally abhor killing in most forms. Still the c.c. position is that I would defend myself if someone was threatening my life or the lives of someone else.

Pacifism is something else. It would require me to always avoid violence, and I couldn't do that. If someone is trying to kill me or my loved ones I would be compelled to fight; thus is human nature. Hell, if someone was trying to kill my cat or another animal (for no legitimate purpose {defense, food or mercy}) I would be compelled to fight.

Conscientious Objection is realistic in that you are avoiding foreseeable violence still allowing for defense, whereas pacifism is unrealistic in my opinion given that you are saying that all violence is wrong regardless of context.
 
What do you call someone who takes a bullet for another person? Who intervenes, facing death, but doesn't raise a fist or a gun while doing so?

Ineffective. Because unless that was the last bullet in the gun, or unless someone else stops said person from shooting the person this hypothetical someone took the bullet for, then all this someone has done is add to the death toll.

You can't insult these people without also insulting MLK or Gandhi.

I wouldn't dream of insulting MLK or Ghandi. The problem is, identifying the flaws in the concept of nonviolence is not insulting either of them. The fact that they've done much good does not negate the fact that there are situations where nonviolence is inapplicable, or even counterproductive.

The whole problem with pacifism is the proactive rejection of violence. Simply put, the idea that up-front rejection of violence leads to the avoidance of violence is unfortunately naive. I fully admit there are situations where violence begat violence - hell, the history of wars in Africa and the Middle East is replete with that - but the idea that pacifism works to reduce that violence is unfortunately not proven to work consistently. For instances where it works - the afore mentioned Dr. King's movement, as well as Ghandi's - you have clear situations where it only results in the deaths of the nonviolent; at risk of Goodwining the thread, I would point towards the German Jews, gypsies and other victims of the Holocaust as one such example. If you want another situation, I would point to the Cambodians submitting to the Khmer Rouge. If you want one that doesn't involve war or nations, the Columbine event, or the 2006 Amish school shooting. The point is that up-front rejection of violence is a severely limiting philosophy. Choosing not to default to it is one thing, and that's entirely reasonable, but saying that all violence is counterproductive is going too far.
 
Well I am not a pacifist, and I doubt many people are. I think the thing that gets confused is the difference between conscientious objection and pacifism.

The c.c. position is that I would avoid premeditated violence in the interest of not hurting people, because I personally abhor killing in most forms. Still the c.c. position is that I would defend myself if someone was threatening my life or the lives of someone else.

Pacifism is something else. It would require me to always avoid violence, and I couldn't do that. If someone is trying to kill me or my loved ones I would be compelled to fight; thus is human nature. Hell, if someone was trying to kill my cat or another animal (for no legitimate purpose {defense, food or mercy}) I would be compelled to fight.

Conscientious Objection is realistic in that you are avoiding foreseeable violence still allowing for defense, whereas pacifism is unrealistic in my opinion given that you are saying that all violence is wrong regardless of context.

I'd simply have said that there are several shades of pacifism.
 
So you agree with Ghandi that the Jews in Nazi Germany should have committed mass suicide by allowing themselves to be massacred rather than defend themselves violently?

"Pacifism is a shifty doctrine under which a man accepts the benefits of the social group without being willing to pay -- and claims a halo for his dishonesty." -- Robert A. Heinlein

The problem with pure pacifism is that it is inherently parasitic. The pacifist depends for his wellbeing on the good will of those in power, or the willingness of others to use violence to protect him. For example, Ghandi's non-violence worked because the British were, as a whole, a moral people unwilling to commit large-scale genocide simply to maintain their empire. He depended entirely on the British sense of justice for his non-violent protest to work. His comments regarding the Jews in Nazi Germany show just how out of touch he was with the reality of the Final Solution.

The world is full of individuals, groups, and governments that would happily exterminate anyone they felt was less than human; a definition which typically includes anyone outside their group. Many have no problem eliminating anyone they find simply inconvenient. The Myanmar government is currently engaged in a slow genocide of the Chittagong Hill Tract peoples, practically unopposed. Pot Pot's Khmer Rouge engaged in wholesale massacres of all "undesirable" enthic minorities. Stalin and Mao murdered millions. First president of Equatorial Guinea, Francisco Macias Nguema, killed close to a third of the population of his own country. The Ottoman Turks killed 1.5 million Armenians.

Non-violent resistance and "international outrage" did nothing to stop any of these. The only action which was ever effective was forceful resistance. Violence in defense of the victims.

In the land of pacifists, the man with a gun is a god.

"Those who cling to the untrue doctrine that violence never settles anything would be advised to conjure up the ghosts of Napoleon Bonaparte and of the Duke of Wellington and let them debate it. The ghost of Hitler could referee, and the jury might well be the Dodo, the Great Auk, and the Passenger Pigeon. Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor, and the contrary opinion is wishful thinking at its worst. Nations and peoples who forget this basic truth have always paid for it with their lives and freedoms." -- Robert A. Heinlein

I find this to be a great post, whether people like Heinlen or not. His words are still true. It is especially easy to be a pacifist in America. There are many volunteers willing to pick up arms and defend their freedoms. Now, what I would like to see is someone attempt to be a pacifist under a different oppressive government. Its a good way to lose your life and not have any freedoms either.
 
I'm more referencing the fact that very few people genuinely adhere to any ideology the way they claim to. For the overwhelming majority of people survival takes precedent, and their ideologies exist only when its convenient. There's precious few people who have the conviction to adhere to their ideals to the bitter end, no matter the cost.

Pacifism is just another ideology.

This may be one of the most relevant posts in this entire thread. Like I was saying, its quite simple to be a pacifist in a quiet safe neighborhood with no crime in America. But if it ever came to life or death, that ideology would go right out the window as we have seen in this thread.
 
There have been a lot of posts in this thread, but I think my ultimate goal has been accomplished. Arth has realized that there are times when pacifism would simply not be rational. He has also realized that extreme pacifism does not work either.

Now it is still my opinion that pacifism is a very silly ideology. It is selfish and will get you killed and others killed as well.
 
Well, the American Civil War didn't work exactly like that. However, the point you state that not all variables can be controlled for is one I agree with, and it neither supports nor refutes the pacifist ideal. The difference is in the methods for approaching the problem, not controlling the variables creating the problem. If it helps, consider it a little like a hostage negotiator who is attempting to talk the hostage-takers into releasing the prisoners and preventing as many deaths as possible, in order to avoid a messier incident where more people will definitely die. The ideal for pacifism isn't to fold or accept any violence directed toward them, it's to minimize damage and attempt to eliminate the need for violence-- much like many other ideals, just with a different approach.

The idea that peace will necessarily beget peace is a massive assumption that has no empirical evidence.

Is India a nation without violence because it emerged from a pacifist resistence? Did MLK halt violence against and among the black community?

I'm interested in seeing one real world iteration of this ideology in practice.

Hostage negotiation works wonderfully when you have criminals with tangible wants and desires. How would you have negotiated with the 9-11 hijackers?

I suppose the pacifist would argue that the religious extremism of Al Qaeda was a reaction to previous regional violence, but then what do you make of Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols? The only "violence" they suffered was being racist in a nation that supports equality. Their brand of extremism had no such source. You can be as peaceful as you want, but sometimes there are just poisoned people.

These chains of peace have no inertia, they are clubbed into nothingness by the first psychopath that you run into. Again, such people might be minority examples, but they certainly aren't rare.

Well, I don't think any notable pacifists I've read about have looked for a moment of purity, but I'd agree that hoping for one is a fantasy. The goal for most of the more sophisticated pacifist thinkers I've read is to create the chain of non-violent acts and work toward propagating it. This thinking acknowledges that there will be failures and losses along the way-- Martin Luther King, Jr. was one advocate of this thinking-- but the long-term goal is an advancement of the ideal toward either a majority thinking or a workable (and influential) minority of thinking. The methods tend to complicate there, mostly regarding activism and advocacy, and differing depending on which source you're looking into, but that's a good starting point for examining the type of thinking and thought processes involved.

The point I was trying to make is that pacifists constantly say that it's unfair to force them to decide a dilemma like Kosovo in the mid-90's. By the time the slaughter was happening, it was too late, pacifism would have intervened prior to all of that in order to avoid the violence.

I'm saying that you can never start a wholly pacifistic chain of events because the modern world constantly presents dilemmas where violence is the only solution. Every day crimes are commited and police officers have to chose the amount of force to use. They face this dilemma on a daily basis, and their decisions provide the sanctuary for pacifists to criticize their actions.

There are troops in Afghanistan and Iraq who have to decide whether to shoot or be shot, and a great many of their opponents are people willing to commit suicide to see them dead.
 
Last edited:
People can and have run 100m in less than 10seconds, does that mean I should expect everyone to?
Who do you hold responsible someone not doing so if they don't try? Their coaches? The people in the stands? The world class athlete that didn’t carry them? The guy who told them they couldn’t do it?

The situation they're in includes "suffering, hardship, want, and fear." The revolt is meant to escape it.
Your assertion that those people who chose not to revolt did so because of the negative consequences of resistance. So with your statement here in mind, what is their excuse now?

So if someone runs up and robs you, takes your wallet and runs off, a police officer shouldn't chase the suspect unless you start running first?
Different situation. The police officer and the citizen already have an agreement that outlines that is what the officer is meant to do. In this case, the help was requested beforehand.

Where is the agreement that made us the world police, Trane?

Again, this ignores modern psychology, but whatever, it's the least dumb of your points.
What part of "modern psychology"? Under what model? Don't just throw out vague assertions.

1 is logically fallacious. Simply because there are past instances of something occurring, that doesn't mean we should expect or demand it to always occur.
What fallacy? Specifically what statements are fallacious?

3 is an unargued for assertion, what do you mean by "obligation?" It's so vague as to be meaningless.
"something by which a person is bound or obliged to do certain things, and which arises out of a sense of duty or results from custom, law, etc."

4 is contradicted by modern psychology, most notably phemonena like battered wives' syndrome. So it isn't logically fallacious, just empirically false.
Speaking of terms "so vague as to be meaningless", here you go invoking "modern psychology" again. Are you asserting that every single person that has ever been oppressed has this specific psychological condition? How did you diagnose those you haven't met, doctor? How do you explain the ones that do not act as your “syndrome” dictates?

5 is another unargued for assertion, you don't bother to explain what humanitarian means while simultaneously applying it to a concept that baldly contradicts most historical uses of the term.

"Humanitarianism is an active belief in the value of human life (humanism), whereby humans practice benevolent treatment and provide assistance to other humans, in order to better humanity for both moral and logical reasons."
I don’t see anywhere in there the requirement that someone who considers themselves a “humanist” must provide assistance to any and every human being that suffers, as your statement suggested

Let me offer you the only definition of “humanitarianism” that matters, when applied to states, organizations, or groups- the one that is actually practiced, by all of them:

“Do what you can afford to do for other people, when it is expedient to do so, unless compelled.”

No matter what pretty words the UN puts on paper, what counts is what they actually do. If you think I’m wrong, if you think whatever fancy ideals they pay lip service to has any meaning, you need to explain why they intervened in Kosovo (which you seem to delight in mentioning) but have and are letting Africa destroy itself- Rwanda, Somalia, Sudan. Because I can think of 60 kilos of reason they intervened in Kosovo that have gorram all to do with Albanians dying.

The only facts you've offered have been grossly misapplied to the discussion.
Which ones?

You haven't offerend any facts that adequately support the assertions you made above.
What would you like to see? I mean, I’ve already had to give you dictionary definitions of a common English word, I don’t want to make any assumptions on how basic you need it.

Why does it have to be universal?
Because if the moral standard you allege I have “perverted” does not apply to everybody, than “perversion” peans nothing more than “I don’t agree with you and I don’t want anyone else to either, so I’ll use a term with negative emotive connotations to prejudice them against it.” It’s called “appeal to emotion”, and it is a fallacy.

No, you're barely moving at all.

Where did I assume that to be a pacifist meant you were obligated to intervene?
“So it's ok to let groups slaughter their own people? That may technically be pacifism, but it's a version of the ethos that completely ignores it's historical humanitarian roots.”

I offerend historical examples and asked how pacifists would solve the dilemma.

Your answer seems to be that you would just let people die.
Quote me where I said that.

I find this perverse and comical because were you or your loved ones in peril you would most certainly be overjoyed to have someone step in on their behalf, as would we all.
Unfounded assumption. Where is the evidence for that assumption? Does not the unrest and insurgency in Iraq contradict that statement?

And as for "humanitarian," the term most definitely implies an obligation to aid your fellow man.
On paper, maybe. Not in practice. Show me otherwise..

You're trying to claim the word while avoiding the responsibility it bestowes.
I’m telling you that the word “bestowes” no responsibility or obligation whatsoever. For anyone.

I am criticizing you for failing to understand how your bizarre brand of pacifism
My “bizarre brand of pacifism”? Who said I was a pacifist?

And I don't think you understand what the word "sarcasm" means. There was no irony in my statement.
Then that does not speak well for either your reading comprehension or your political understanding.

Whatever you're defining as pacifism abondons the obligation to collective humanity that serves as the basis of humanitarianism. Pacifism is an outgrowth of that historical position.
There is no obligation. That’s my whole point. That you assume there is one is your naïve error that I was endeavoring to correct.

Where was the "smarmy" sarcasm?
In my misreading, apparently you were sincere, more’s the pity.
 
Last edited:
This seems rather repugnant to me.
That doesn't make it less true.

A blame-the-victim philosophy if you will.
As I said, blame can fall in both directions. it is not a black-and-white, either-or situation.

The warlords have power. They have the guns weapons, whatever money that's available, and followers who know where their bread is buttered, if nothing else.
Such has been the case in the majority of insurrections and revolutions throught history.

What on earth would impoverished, weaponless villagers be able to do to depose such people?
What indeed?
 
I find this to be a great post, whether people like Heinlen or not. His words are still true. It is especially easy to be a pacifist in America. There are many volunteers willing to pick up arms and defend their freedoms. Now, what I would like to see is someone attempt to be a pacifist under a different oppressive government. Its a good way to lose your life and not have any freedoms either.

Just like Otpor?

They were under an oppressive government.

Martin Luther King wasn't exactly in a peaceful district during his marches.
 
Just like Otpor?

They were under an oppressive government.

Martin Luther King wasn't exactly in a peaceful district during his marches.

In both of those examples, the government was not willing to kill. Both Martin Luther King and Otpor were well aware of this, and that is why peaceful protest worked. This was already explained in this thread.
 
Just wondering what the pacifist solution to this situation would have been.

Bailey said he thought it was the end of his life and the lives of the 10 people inside his apartment for a birthday party after two masked men with guns burst in through a patio door.

“They just came in and separated the men from the women and said, ‘Give me your wallets and cell phones,’” said George Williams of the College Park Police Department.

Bailey said the gunmen started counting bullets. “The other guy asked how many (bullets) he had. He said he had enough,” said Bailey.

That’s when one student grabbed a gun out of a backpack and shot at the invader who was watching the men. The gunman ran out of the apartment.

The student then ran to the room where the second gunman, identified by police as 23-year-old Calvin Lavant, was holding the women.

“Apparently the guy was getting ready to rape his girlfriend. So he told the girls to get down and he started shooting. The guy jumped out of the window,” said Bailey.

A neighbor heard the shots and heard someone running nearby.

“And I heard someone say, ‘Someone help me. Call the police. Somebody call the police,’” said a neighbor.

The neighbor said she believes it was Lavant, who was found dead near his apartment, only one building away.

Bailey said he is just thankful one student risked his life to keep others alive.
 
Not for nothing, but is this thread trying to understand a differing viewpoint, or simply beating up on a minority viewpoint, calling it names, etc? Seems rather a waste of time.
 
I think that another way to look at it is, my brand of pacifism isn't an ideology as much as it is a journey -- or, more aptly perhaps, a goal.

Should we go back to the time periods of the Crusades, have war for war's sake, or because we think God told us so? No, that's unjust, we move away from it.

So we move into methods of dealing with problems in less and less violent ways -- but that requires a lot more than "on the spot thinking", it requires a careful and steady framework. One example is the U.S. government. While so many of the founding fathers expounded on the virtues of blood, warfare, and getting rid of tyrants, we haven't had any need for a violent revolution in centuries, because constitutional republics/modern democracies are set up in such a way that the people can influence government without having to make their voices heard through violent actions. It is through this democracy that someone like Martin Luther King can influence the hearts and minds of the average person in the United States, and thereby influence the government by influencing the voter (who have power only through the careful and steady framework that was provided beforehand).


. In many democracies, including the case that Otpor was in, this is also true. Furthermore, as in the case of Otpor, by identifying themselves as pacifists and non-violent from the get-go, police and similar figures were unwilling to attack them, even under direct orders to do so. By setting up a careful framework and being careful, one can lessen the need for violence to achieve an objective.

There are some objectives that require violence, of course, but they are becoming increasingly few compared to past years. You can come up with all sorts of hypotheticals in which one is required to be violent or die, and by that nature show that you must accept violence or die. But that's not necessarily true; it's not one dichotomy (go violent or die!) in most situations, and there are ways to reduce the need for violence by reducing being in those hypothetical situations altogether. For instance, why would one need to kill a mugger alone in a dark alleyway, if one was able to avoid that dark alleyway to begin with? Through this, those hypothetical examples become more and more extreme -- and thereby, more and more rare -- realities.

And in the case of BPSCG's example, I agree that violence was the only conceivable solution at the point they were in, given the limited data that is made available. Perhaps that situation could have been surpassed by more careful thinking before then (better security system, etc.), but either way, in that case violence was the last resort.

But that doesn't suddenly make me "not a pacifist", as I don't think that pacifism must necessarily be the extreme extreme view. However, even if I do accept that some violence must still exist in the world, I can still maintain that we should do whatever we can to curb it -- and if you take that logic to the natural conclusion, I want to shrink violence until it's practically negligible.

(By the way, this doesn't necessarily mean that I think we should disarm and weaken our militaries. Just the existence of an army can stave off conflict, as also seen in the concept of Mutually Assured Destruction during the Cold War).
 
Last edited:
How impressive, that you could be this consistently amusing.

And I apologize to everyone else on this thread for the length. I tried to eliminate this style of back and forth, but it seems to be the prefered method of Piscivore.


Who do you hold responsible someone not doing so if they don't try? Their coaches? The people in the stands? The world class athlete that didn’t carry them? The guy who told them they couldn’t do it?

Unsurprisingly, you've missed the point. Characteristics, abilities, and actions of others cannot necessarily be translated to others.

It isn't an issue of who bears the responsibility, we can imagine a million circumstances both in the control of and beyond the means of any given individual that would conspire to deny them the ability to run 100m in under 10sec.

But why should I care who is to blame? This is the massive leap of logic you continually assert, but never substantiate.

If a woman goes stumbling into a dark alley late at night completely drunk and is raped, we can surely say some of the responsibility for the crime rests with her irresponsible behavior. Yet that contribution in no way lessens the punishment of the assailant. Nor should we abandon that woman to her fate dismissing it as "she was asking for it."

Certainly she could have behaved otherwise, but that in no way exonerates or even mitigates the punishment for the rapist.

Now if you want to argue that not revolting creates a system of contributory negligence, then you have to make that argument. You have done nothing of the sort, nor can you, judging by your previous work.

Your assertion that those people who chose not to revolt did so because of the negative consequences of resistance. So with your statement here in mind, what is their excuse now?

Different situation. The police officer and the citizen already have an agreement that outlines that is what the officer is meant to do. In this case, the help was requested beforehand.

What is the basis of that agreement? I never signed any paper that said I abdicate my responsibility for self-reliance and pass it to law enforcement agencies. Why are the police required to help me if I do not help myself?

The agreement is purely voluntary on the part of the police, so to is the agreement we make on humanitarian missions. Neither have a meta-physical obligation that predates conscious assent.

On the one hand we recognize the importance of laws to the health of a society. As the world becomes more and more intertwined, we are beginning to recognize the benifits of a world that obeys laws. The only difference is one of custom and history, but that is changing.

Where is the agreement that made us the world police, Trane?

We volunteered when we signed documents like:

http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geneva_Conventions
http://www.un.org/aboutun/charter/

We voluntarily bound ourselves to international obligations just as we voluntarily bound ourselves to the Constitution.

What part of "modern psychology"? Under what model? Don't just throw out vague assertions.

Only the issue I've linked and brought up three times now:

http://www.heart-2-heart.ca/women/page4.html

We understand that psychological issues limit people's ability to act. We are now smart enough to intervene in cases of domestic violence whether or not the woman tries to leave. Modern science informs our judgments.

But please, continue to pretend like we're living in the 1920's, "I done hit 'er cause she got sassmouth. If she dinnit like it, she could leave..."

What fallacy? Specifically what statements are fallacious?

Seriously? I can't put it any simpler: it is fallacious to assert that because an event happened once, it can, should, and will happen in all circumstances. The conclusion simply does not follow from the premises, and there is ample evidence to support the contrary:

"Home prices have gone up in the past, therefore we should build our economy around the assumption that they will continue to go up forever."

"Benedict Arnold has been on our side in the past, therefore we can conclude he will be on our side in the future."

"Japan was our enemy in the past, therefore we can conclude that they will be our enemy in the future."

Historical events and the actions of humans are not uniform, and it is fallacious to think otherwise.

"something by which a person is bound or obliged to do certain things, and which arises out of a sense of duty or results from custom, law, etc."

As I have shown via our international agreements, we are bound and obligated to act in these situations.

I even left one out that has specific relevance to the Kosovo issue:
http://www.nato.int/docu/basictxt/treaty.htm

Speaking of terms "so vague as to be meaningless", here you go invoking "modern psychology" again. Are you asserting that every single person that has ever been oppressed has this specific psychological condition? How did you diagnose those you haven't met, doctor? How do you explain the ones that do not act as your “syndrome” dictates?

No, I don't need to hold that all people have a psychological condition, though a great deal of research is being done to understand oppressed people, it is sufficient to not that there are some.

It thus invalidates your self-serving claim that all people have the ability to revolt. This is expressly denied by Battered Wives' Syndrom, Stockholm Syndrome, and a host of other related issues.

I don’t see anywhere in there the requirement that someone who considers themselves a “humanist” must provide assistance to any and every human being that suffers, as your statement suggested

Nice bit of straw man building. Once again, here is the definition of humanitarian:

"Humanitarianism is an active belief in the value of human life (humanism), whereby humans practice benevolent treatment and provide assistance to other humans, in order to better humanity for both moral and logical reasons."

No where does that say you have to help all people. It is the claim that you are obliged to assist when and where you can.

Let me offer you the only definition of “humanitarianism” that matters, when applied to states, organizations, or groups- the one that is actually practiced, by all of them:

“Do what you can afford to do for other people, when it is expedient to do so, unless compelled.”

No matter what pretty words the UN puts on paper, what counts is what they actually do. If you think I’m wrong, if you think whatever fancy ideals they pay lip service to has any meaning, you need to explain why they intervened in Kosovo (which you seem to delight in mentioning) but have and are letting Africa destroy itself- Rwanda, Somalia, Sudan. Because I can think of 60 kilos of reason they intervened in Kosovo that have gorram all to do with Albanians dying.

First of all, your quote contradicts nothing I've said, second, where's your source for that quote? Support the claim that this is the opperational definition. That's certainly not the opperational definition used in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

This is more pathetic misdirection on your part. My argument has never included a claim about the historical purity of the UN. Incidentally, I don't even have to say that they intervened in Kosovo for humanitarian reasons.

Clearly there was a humanitarian disaster in the Balkans that was halted by bombing. Whether or not that was the first priority, the question is how pacifists would have stopped that humanitarian disaster.

You can't follow the simple structure of the argument, so I shouldn't be surprised that you're responses are so childishly random.

Which ones?

God, it's like you're going out of your way to help me make you look bad.

See above, lot's of irrelevant nonsense about UN motives.

What would you like to see? I mean, I’ve already had to give you dictionary definitions of a common English word, I don’t want to make any assumptions on how basic you need it.

Oh ****, I forgot you used the dictionary. I guess I'm wrong, all arguments can be supported by using an out of context, misapplied, inappropriately asserted definition. What was that word, by the way, it wasn't "humanitarian:"
http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_1861619155/humanitarianism.html
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...f9jIGRBw&sa=X&oi=glossary_definition&ct=title
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rlz=1T4WZPA_enUS311US311&q=define:humanitarian

What I'm asking for is some type of argumentation to, for example, support the currently fallacious assertion that the occurence of an incident in the past allows us to conclude that it can and should happen in all situation.

Because if the moral standard you allege I have “perverted” does not apply to everybody, than “perversion” peans nothing more than “I don’t agree with you and I don’t want anyone else to either, so I’ll use a term with negative emotive connotations to prejudice them against it.” It’s called “appeal to emotion”, and it is a fallacy.

No, your standard disagrees with every international charter that nations have voluntarily signed on to. Whether or not those rules extend beyond human kind, to all potential iterations of society and life is irrelevant. We have empiraclly observed the world and drawn conclusions about the inherent rights of homo sapiens sapiens, whether or not they're universal, they've been adopted just like the laws of an individual country are developed and enforced.

Trying to bring in some meta-physical nonsense about universalism is just more distraction. It's a weak attempt to add something with the faint scent of intellect to your astonishingly banal arguments. And it fails.

“So it's ok to let groups slaughter their own people? That may technically be pacifism, but it's a version of the ethos that completely ignores it's historical humanitarian roots.”

Quote me where I said that.

It's the obvious implication of your view. I ask how a pacifist would have saved the kosovars and Muslims in the Balkans and you say they should have tried to save themselves, we have no obligation to help them.

Your only answer is to allow them to be slaughtered. Please, by all means, if you have an actual practical answer, share it, but that's all you've offered so far.


Unfounded assumption. Where is the evidence for that assumption? Does not the unrest and insurgency in Iraq contradict that statement?

How does that contradict the statement at all? You don't think there are millions of people in Iraq who desperately want the violence to end and would happily support anyone who could actually make that happen?

The problem in Iraq is that no side shows a real commitment to ending violence. The US made a half-hearted attempt 5 years after demolishing the nation's infrastructure, but it's descending back into chaos as we speak.

If you're argument is that we weren't greeted as liberators, I would say that just shows that Iraq's humanitarian issues were impossible to solve by military intervention.

My argument is not that all situations of repression and subjugation are best solved with force, it is simply that some present no alternative. I chose to focus on those because the pacifist does make the strong claim that violence is wrong in every situation. When you make a universal claim, a single contradictory example suffices.

But this is more nonsesne and aimless rambling from you. You don't understand the basic course of this argument.

On paper, maybe. Not in practice. Show me otherwise..

I linked you to the wiki article on the history of humanitarianism. It is, quite simply, the belief that we're obligated to our fellow man.

Of course you help where you have the power to help, but I defy you to find a humanitarian organization that works for any reason other than a sense of responsibility for their fellow man.

Here's a list of a few:
http://www.exploringabroad.com/humanitarian-org.htm

Find me the organizations that do not believe in an obligation or duty to care for others.

I’m telling you that the word “bestowes” no responsibility or obligation whatsoever. For anyone.

Yes it does. If you voluntarily desire to be called a humanitarian, you have voluntarily assented to the notion that you have a responsibility to care for others. There is no humanitarian organization you can join that would say otherwise.

You may not have an obligation to become a humanitarian, but once you say you are one, you have to behave in a certain way.

"Yeah, I'm a fire fighter, but I don't think I have a duty to fight all fires in my area. I just sort of squirt water at the ones I feel like."

My “bizarre brand of pacifism”? Who said I was a pacifist?

Fair enough, then it shall be modified to you bizzare brand of neo-humanitarianism that isn't humanitarianism.

Then that does not speak well for either your reading comprehension or your political understanding.

That makes no sense.

There is no obligation. That’s my whole point. That you assume there is one is your naïve error that I was endeavoring to correct.

If you don't believe there's an obligation, then you're not a humanitarian.

This is the point, you want to claim the word, for some reason, yet deny what it entails. Find me a single humanitarian organization or foundational document that denies an obligation to help others.

You can't volunteer for Peace Corps and then not do anything. Once you sign on to be a humanitarian, you have to go help others.

I suppose you could sit idly by as others do work and merely keep your name on the list, but once anyone was given all the facts concerning your behavior, they would deny your claim to be a humanitarian.

In my misreading, apparently you were sincere, more’s the pity.

Haha, ok. You want to be a humanitarian but not do any humanitarian work. Yes, I will really take a weak insult from such a person seriously.
 
On this topic: Blogger NeoNeocon did a post studying the nuances of one well known group of pacifists: The Quakers. That can be found here:
http://neo-neocon.blogspot.com/2005/10/varieties-of-pacifism-part-iia.html

I was especially taken by her quoting of Wolf Mendl, who in my mind produced a compelling analysis of the fundamental issue in balancing pacifism with the reality of "evil and conflict":

Because of their personal experience and convictions, [early] Friends did not deny the reality of evil and of conflict. Nor did they equate conflict with evil. They were well aware of the suffering which a non-violent witness could bring in an imperfect world. This is in contrast to those who identify peace with the absence of conflict and value that above all things. It is the latter who have given modern pacifism its bad name and have led their critics to refer to them contemptuously as 'passivists'. The failure to take evil and conflict into account as elements in our human condition and an obsession with the need for peace and harmony have led pacifists badly astray... Christian pacifists [are] not exempt from the temptation to sacrifice others for the sake of peace.

As NeoNeocon goes on to say:
Mendl is not exactly a hawk, to be sure. But his writing shows a deep awareness on the part of at least some Quakers about what is at stake, and of the damage that can be done by "passivists" in the name of goodness.

Regardless of whether you consider yourself on the right or the left politically, I think this is a well considered essay on the very topic of this thread.
 
The idea that peace will necessarily beget peace is a massive assumption that has no empirical evidence.

That's not the impression I've gotten reading literature on the subject. However, I do think (if I recall properly) that the main examples of it working have been smaller in scale, or more specific than some general form of peace (goal- or objective-oriented), more in the form of activism.

Is India a nation without violence because it emerged from a pacifist resistence? Did MLK halt violence against and among the black community?

I'm interested in seeing one real world iteration of this ideology in practice.

In practice, or in practice successfully? Tibet would be an example of it in practice, but I wouldn't call the Dalai Lama's efforts all that successful.

Hostage negotiation works wonderfully when you have criminals with tangible wants and desires. How would you have negotiated with the 9-11 hijackers?

It works pretty well when you have enemies with wants and desires as well. International diplomacy consists of many similarities to hostage negotiation. Conflict negotiation and mediation are roles becoming more common nowadays as well. As for the hijackers on 9/11-- again, I'm not a pacifist, and without being present in the situation at the time I can't give an accurate representation of what I'd have done. I can give a good approximation of what I'd do if someone decided to get all stabby with me or someone I'm with, but that's because I know what such a situation is like and have a basis from which to draw a description.

I suppose the pacifist would argue that the religious extremism of Al Qaeda was a reaction to previous regional violence, but then what do you make of Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols? The only "violence" they suffered was being racist in a nation that supports equality. Their brand of extremism had no such source. You can be as peaceful as you want, but sometimes there are just poisoned people.

These chains of peace have no inertia, they are clubbed into nothingness by the first psychopath that you run into. Again, such people might be minority examples, but they certainly aren't rare.

Yep, and as I recall MLK wrote about that reality as well. The idea wasn't to assume that there would be no (or even fewer) poisonous people, but that the poisonous mentality could be eventually suppressed without violence. It's tough for me to condense the breadth of pacifist literature out there, especially since I don't agree with many of the conclusions throughout, but that doesn't preclude understanding where they come from and that they aren't all just built around folding in the face of violence or running away. There's an expectation of altruistic action that often involves hoping for the most positive result but expecting the worst, and being prepared to deal with the repercussions as best as one can. This certainly doesn't mean taking a beating because you won't fight back, by the way-- one of the pacifists I met was a martial arts sifu who was quite capable of keeping himself safe from a decent range of attacks without having to resort to violence in return.

The point I was trying to make is that pacifists constantly say that it's unfair to force them to decide a dilemma like Kosovo in the mid-90's. By the time the slaughter was happening, it was too late, pacifism would have intervened prior to all of that in order to avoid the violence.

Most of the ones I've heard faced with questions like that don't say much about fairness, but plenty about logic. I've had a few argue back that why would Kosovo count more than Darfur or Rwanda or even Israel/Palestine? Not to bring up another hotbed topic, but there is plenty of displacement and violence to go around between Israel and Palestine, both using the "they started it" justification for each attack and neither willing to invest enough to bring the violence to a halt aside from occasional lip service. What did we do about the conflict over Kashmir? Chechnya? We pick and choose which fights we're going to join already, and if nothing else at least the pacifist methodology stays fairly consistent throughout, regardless of whether the involved parties are allies or not, giving the impression of intellectual consistency. That's not enough to convince me, and it may not be enough to convince you, but fairness isn't necessarily the first thing I've heard in conversations like this with people who have adopted the pacifist mindset in the political sense.

I'm saying that you can never start a wholly pacifistic chain of events because the modern world constantly presents dilemmas where violence is the only solution. Every day crimes are commited and police officers have to chose the amount of force to use. They face this dilemma on a daily basis, and their decisions provide the sanctuary for pacifists to criticize their actions.

There are troops in Afghanistan and Iraq who have to decide whether to shoot or be shot, and a great many of their opponents are people willing to commit suicide to see them dead.

To the latter, I think it's worth noting that the frame of mind to accept suicide to inflict damage on an enemy is one of desperation in the face of overwhelming force, in and of itself a form of evidence to the propagation of violence leading to more violence. Keeping in mind my caveat that I do not agree with the overall ideology, the pacifist stance would be to try and find ways to undermine the rhetoric leading the people who carry out these attacks to agree to die in order to fight back. In reality, parts of pacifist ideals are practiced even in regular modern strategies to quell local populations from joining insurgencies, to foment insurrection or undermine the authorities in states we would consider dangerous or enemies (we did it in the USSR, and we're currently doing it in Iran), and in many areas where diplomacy is currently effective throughout the world.

To the former, I again point out that being a pacifist doesn't mean being a wuss-- referring again to the sifu I knew, with whom I actually had several conversations on the subject. He's an extreme example, I realize that, but there are plenty of others for whom I wouldn't be too worried about in most conceivable (realistic) situations in their personal lives. The people I've known who were pacifists weren't cowards, wouldn't just back down from someone threatening them, but they also wouldn't threaten back. However, considering they aren't of a mind to accept violence as a possible option for their own actions, they tend to avoid through their normal behavior situations where emotions escalate to a level where violence becomes a higher probability-- there's a sort of feedback loop where their general outlook affects their behavior, which affects how they interact with others, which affects their general exposure to violence, which affects their general outlook, rinse, repeat.

Overall, though, what I'm trying to point out with the arguments I'm making is that the assertions being made in this thread about how untenable pacifism actually is just don't match up with what I've seen as real examinations of pacifist ideals and ideology on the whole. I understand the desire to have a better comprehension of the pacifist mindset, but over and over in this thread I keep seeing these unrepresentative examples of what is assumed to be what pacifists in general think or believe, but just don't square with the experiences I've had knowing pacifists and examining the mindset in-depth myself. I'm sure there are probably plenty of people who might fit the stereotype being presented so far in this thread, but the only ones I've met even close to that were hippie-wannabe stoners in college-- sure, (technically) real people, but just like the many experimenting 'lesbians' in college by graduation their outlook tends to change drastically (sometimes three or four times). Jokes aside, most of the actual people who tend to hold pacifist ideals usually hold them in varying degrees from strictly pacifist to pacifist on personal behavior to pacifist regarding foreign policy, and so on (and so forth).

I'd say that even though I don't agree with pacifism as a general outlook, learning more about its concepts and ideals over the years has given me the opportunity to look at how I react to things personally, re-evaluate my default actions and reactions, and worry less about feeling like I have only one option in situations where tensions are escalating. I could even relate a few anecdotes as examples, giving the response I may have done previously and what I actually did that was different, but I think that would be getting too preachy and unnecessary. I'm not here to sell anyone on pacifism, but I do encourage anyone who is actually interested in what it's all about to find some of the more sophisticated literature out there on the subject and examine it yourself. Even those things didn't sell me on the methods as an ideology, but there were things I found useful that I took with me, which in my opinion is what makes philosophies useful.
 
If a woman goes stumbling into a dark alley late at night completely drunk and is raped, we can surely say some of the responsibility for the crime rests with her irresponsible behavior.
That's all I'm saying.

Yet that contribution in no way lessens the punishment of the assailant.
I didn't say otherwise.

Nor should we abandon that woman to her fate dismissing it as "she was asking for it."
That's a personal decision each person makes. No one is morally or legally obligated to save this person from herself, especially if she repeats this behaviour.

Certainly she could have behaved otherwise, but that in no way exonerates or even mitigates the punishment for the rapist.
I never said otherwise.

Now if you want to argue that not revolting creates a system of contributory negligence, then you have to make that argument. You have done nothing of the sort, nor can you, judging by your previous work.
Yes, I have.

What is the basis of that agreement? I never signed any paper that said I abdicate my responsibility for self-reliance and pass it to law enforcement agencies.
That's not what the agreement is. The agreement is that the police officer is agreeing to respond to criminal activity and we compensate them for this beahvior.

You consented to this agreement by not leaving the jurisdiction of the police officer when you reached the age of personal responsibility.

Why are the police required to help me if I do not help myself?
Because we pay them to.

The agreement is purely voluntary on the part of the police,
Insomuch as no one is conscripted to be an officer, yes. His actions as an officer however are compulsory, restricted, and well defined.

...so to is the agreement we make on humanitarian missions.
Exactly the point, and why the police officer analogy you offered does not apply. There are no humanitarian missions which are compulsory. A police officer that does not perform his duty can be fired or jailed. A humanitarian that does not complete his mission answers to no one but his own conscience.

Neither have a meta-physical obligation that predates conscious assent.
Never said there was. The police office does have a contractual obligation, however, thet the humanitarian does not.

On the one hand we recognize the importance of laws to the health of a society. As the world becomes more and more intertwined, we are beginning to recognize the benifits of a world that obeys laws. The only difference is one of custom and history, but that is changing.
International agreements, UN resolutions, and good intentions are not laws.


If those created actual obligations (as opposed to meaningless paper declarations of good intentions) why are we not interfering in Africa?

We voluntarily bound ourselves to international obligations just as we voluntarily bound ourselves to the Constitution.
Only there is nothing enforcing our "international obligations". If there are, what punishment can we expect for not interfering in Africa?

And by the way, you are now contradicting yourself:
No one said it's our "responsibility," we could happily let them be, like we did with Rwanda.
We did nothing to intervene in Rwanda when a small military force could easily have saved hundreds of thousands of lives.

Only the issue I've linked and brought up three times now:

http://www.heart-2-heart.ca/women/page4.html

We understand that psychological issues limit people's ability to act. We are now smart enough to intervene in cases of domestic violence whether or not the woman tries to leave.
And what happens when the abused spouse doesn't want "intervention"?

Seriously? I can't put it any simpler: it is fallacious to assert that because an event happened once, it can, should, and will happen in all circumstances.
Good thing I did not assert that. I said (and showed) it can happen, as counter to your fallacious assertion that abused or oppressed people are "helpless".

Historical events and the actions of humans are not uniform, and it is fallacious to think otherwise.
Indeed so. I did not make that claim.

As I have shown via our international agreements, we are bound and obligated to act in these situations.
No one said it's our "responsibility," we could happily let them be, like we did with Rwanda.
Which is it? If we are "bound to act" why are we not doing so in Africa?

No, I don't need to hold that all people have a psychological condition, though a great deal of research is being done to understand oppressed people, it is sufficient to not that there are some.
So some people cannot rebel, and some can? Is that what you are saying now?

It thus invalidates your self-serving claim that all people have the ability to revolt.
Show me where I said that. Or how on earth it is "self-serving".

This is expressly denied by Battered Wives' Syndrom, Stockholm Syndrome, and a host of other related issues.
But you just said that these psychological conditions do not necessarily apply to all people. Which is it?

In any case, unless these syndroms apply to everyone in a subjucated population, they are irrelevant. They may explain why a particular individual chooses not to revolt, but not why everyone in the population doesn't- as you try to claim.

Nice bit of straw man building. Once again, here is the definition of humanitarian:

"Humanitarianism is an active belief in the value of human life (humanism), whereby humans practice benevolent treatment and provide assistance to other humans, in order to better humanity for both moral and logical reasons."

No where does that say you have to help all people. It is the claim that you are obliged to assist when and where you can.
So then a "pacifist" may be a humanitarian and yet NOT intervene when people are being slaughtered, yes?

First of all, your quote contradicts nothing I've said, second, where's your source for that quote?
Me.

Support the claim that this is the opperational definition.
No organisation has ever acted, to my knowledge, contrary to that definition.

Show me I'm wrong.

That's certainly not the opperational definition used in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Indeed not. However, their failure to act in Africa shows that definition to be at best merely a statement of hollow ideology and useless good intentions.

Oh ****, I forgot you used the dictionary. I guess I'm wrong, all arguments can be supported by using an out of context, misapplied, inappropriately asserted definition. What was that word, by the way, it wasn't "humanitarian:"
http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_1861619155/humanitarianism.html
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...f9jIGRBw&sa=X&oi=glossary_definition&ct=title
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rlz=1T4WZPA_enUS311US311&q=define:humanitarian
I don't see anything in any of those links that contradicts anything I've said, including letting a people suffer the consequences of their own actions (or inaction). Humanitarians are not superheroes.

What I'm asking for is some type of argumentation to, for example, support the currently fallacious assertion that the occurence of an incident in the past allows us to conclude that it can and should happen in all situation.
Keep looking, I can't help you. I haven't made that assertion. I just disputed your assertion that because they are oppressed "modern psychology" says they can't.

No, your standard disagrees with every international charter that nations have voluntarily signed on to.
But NOT with their actual actions. "Charters" and "voluntary agreements" aren't worth steaming gos se.

We have empiraclly observed the world and drawn conclusions about the inherent rights of homo sapiens sapiens, whether or not they're universal, they've been adopted just like the laws of an individual country are developed and enforced.
Enforced by whom?

It's the obvious implication of your view. I ask how a pacifist would have saved the kosovars and Muslims in the Balkans and you say they should have tried to save themselves, we have no obligation to help them.
Quote me where I said this.

I didn't answer the general question, as I am not a pacifist. And when you asked me I asked a clarifying question you declined to answer. As I have given no answer to the question "how a pacifist would have saved the kosovars and Muslims in the Balkans" claiming "you say they should have tried to save themselves" is an outright fabrication.

Your only answer is to allow them to be slaughtered.
Quote me where I said this. Your lack of intellectual integrity is not becoming.

Please, by all means, if you have an actual practical answer, share it, but that's all you've offered so far.
This is why I suggest your reading comprehension leaves a lot to be desired. You apparently cannot comprehend ideas that do not conform to your precancieved notions. I'm not the only one in this thread to notice this.

How does that contradict the statement at all? You don't think there are millions of people in Iraq who desperately want the violence to end and would happily support anyone who could actually make that happen?
I'm not aware there was any ongoing violence when we "intervened". The gassing of the Kurds to which you previously referred occured two decades prior to our "intervention".

The problem in Iraq is that no side shows a real commitment to ending violence.
Right. And neither does Somalia. That's the point.

The US made a half-hearted attempt 5 years after demolishing the nation's infrastructure, but it's descending back into chaos as we speak.
Sound like a pretty toothless "obligation", don't it?

If you're argument is that we weren't greeted as liberators, I would say that just shows that Iraq's humanitarian issues were impossible to solve by military intervention.
And that often times, "intervention" is not wanted, no matter what one's good intentions might be.

My argument is not that all situations of repression and subjugation are best solved with force, it is simply that some present no alternative.
I don't disagree with that. I just disagree with your apparent insistance that that force must come from an external source.

But this is more nonsesne and aimless rambling from you. You don't understand the basic course of this argument.
I don't think so. I'm not the one contradicting myself and making demonstrably false statments.

I linked you to the wiki article on the history of humanitarianism. It is, quite simply, the belief that we're obligated to our fellow man.
beliefs and intentions are irrelevant. No organisation consistently acts on this alleged "obligation", and precious few individuals.

If that's what "humanitarianism" is to you, it is meaningless, useless idealism.

Of course you help where you have the power to help, but I defy you to find a humanitarian organization that works for any reason other than a sense of responsibility for their fellow man.
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=humanitarian+profit+-non+-not&aq=f&oq=

Find me the organizations that do not believe in an obligation or duty to care for others.
Belief is irrelevant. Mission statements are irrelevant. What they do is relevant, and what humanitarian organisations do is sometimes they let people suffer and die that they could help, despite their "obligations".

Yes it does. If you voluntarily desire to be called a humanitarian, you have voluntarily assented to the notion that you have a responsibility to care for others. There is no humanitarian organization you can join that would say otherwise.
What they say is irrelevant.

You may not have an obligation to become a humanitarian, but once you say you are one, you have to behave in a certain way.
Under what entity's enforcement?

"Yeah, I'm a fire fighter, but I don't think I have a duty to fight all fires in my area. I just sort of squirt water at the ones I feel like."
That's actually true. Buildings have burned while different departments argued over in whose jusrisdiction it was. It was common in the Nineteeth century, but happens even today, especialy between city FDs, Volunteer FDs and Rural Metro FDs. And if your house is not in an area with a tax subsidized FD and you don't pay your subscription fees, they may not put it out if it burns.

That makes no sense.
Q.E.D.

This is the point, you want to claim the word, for some reason, yet deny what it entails.
Actually, I never claimed to be a humanitarian either. What I said was that being a humanitarian created no obligation. The way humanitarian organisations do things, this is evident, despite what they may claim.

It is just like psychic powers. I can claim all day long I can read minds or talk to the dead, but unless I do it, I'm not a psychic.

Find me a single humanitarian organization or foundational document that denies an obligation to help others.
Find me one that acts like they have an obligation to help others.

You can't volunteer for Peace Corps and then not do anything. Once you sign on to be a humanitarian, you have to go help others.

I suppose you could sit idly by as others do work and merely keep your name on the list, but once anyone was given all the facts concerning your behavior, they would deny your claim to be a humanitarian.
Such as watching Africa destroy itself while drafting resolutions declaring good intentions, perhaps?

Haha, ok. You want to be a humanitarian but not do any humanitarian work. Yes, I will really take a weak insult from such a person seriously.
You're confusing me with the UN. And I have not insulted you.
 
Is there any way we could trim down those novel style posts to like a point at a time and just argue that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom