How impressive, that you could be this consistently amusing.
And I apologize to everyone else on this thread for the length. I tried to eliminate this style of back and forth, but it seems to be the prefered method of Piscivore.
Who do you hold responsible someone not doing so if they don't try? Their coaches? The people in the stands? The world class athlete that didn’t carry them? The guy who told them they couldn’t do it?
Unsurprisingly, you've missed the point. Characteristics, abilities, and actions of others cannot necessarily be translated to others.
It isn't an issue of who bears the responsibility, we can imagine a million circumstances both in the control of and beyond the means of any given individual that would conspire to deny them the ability to run 100m in under 10sec.
But why should I care who is to blame? This is the massive leap of logic you continually assert, but never substantiate.
If a woman goes stumbling into a dark alley late at night completely drunk and is raped, we can surely say some of the responsibility for the crime rests with her irresponsible behavior. Yet that contribution in no way lessens the punishment of the assailant. Nor should we abandon that woman to her fate dismissing it as "she was asking for it."
Certainly she could have behaved otherwise, but that in no way exonerates or even mitigates the punishment for the rapist.
Now if you want to argue that not revolting creates a system of contributory negligence, then you have to make that argument. You have done nothing of the sort, nor can you, judging by your previous work.
Your assertion that those people who chose not to revolt did so because of the negative consequences of resistance. So with your statement here in mind, what is their excuse now?
Different situation. The police officer and the citizen already have an agreement that outlines that is what the officer is meant to do. In this case, the help was requested beforehand.
What is the basis of that agreement? I never signed any paper that said I abdicate my responsibility for self-reliance and pass it to law enforcement agencies. Why are the police required to help me if I do not help myself?
The agreement is purely voluntary on the part of the police, so to is the agreement we make on humanitarian missions. Neither have a meta-physical obligation that predates conscious assent.
On the one hand we recognize the importance of laws to the health of a society. As the world becomes more and more intertwined, we are beginning to recognize the benifits of a world that obeys laws. The only difference is one of custom and history, but that is changing.
Where is the agreement that made us the world police, Trane?
We volunteered when we signed documents like:
http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geneva_Conventions
http://www.un.org/aboutun/charter/
We voluntarily bound ourselves to international obligations just as we voluntarily bound ourselves to the Constitution.
What part of "modern psychology"? Under what model? Don't just throw out vague assertions.
Only the issue I've linked and brought up three times now:
http://www.heart-2-heart.ca/women/page4.html
We understand that psychological issues limit people's ability to act. We are now smart enough to intervene in cases of domestic violence whether or not the woman tries to leave. Modern science informs our judgments.
But please, continue to pretend like we're living in the 1920's, "I done hit 'er cause she got sassmouth. If she dinnit like it, she could leave..."
What fallacy? Specifically what statements are fallacious?
Seriously? I can't put it any simpler: it is fallacious to assert that because an event happened once, it can, should, and will happen in all circumstances. The conclusion simply does not follow from the premises, and there is ample evidence to support the contrary:
"Home prices have gone up in the past, therefore we should build our economy around the assumption that they will continue to go up forever."
"Benedict Arnold has been on our side in the past, therefore we can conclude he will be on our side in the future."
"Japan was our enemy in the past, therefore we can conclude that they will be our enemy in the future."
Historical events and the actions of humans are not uniform, and it is fallacious to think otherwise.
"something by which a person is bound or obliged to do certain things, and which arises out of a sense of duty or results from custom, law, etc."
As I have shown via our international agreements, we are bound and obligated to act in these situations.
I even left one out that has specific relevance to the Kosovo issue:
http://www.nato.int/docu/basictxt/treaty.htm
Speaking of terms "so vague as to be meaningless", here you go invoking "modern psychology" again. Are you asserting that every single person that has ever been oppressed has this specific psychological condition? How did you diagnose those you haven't met, doctor? How do you explain the ones that do not act as your “syndrome” dictates?
No, I don't need to hold that
all people have a psychological condition, though a great deal of research is being done to understand oppressed people, it is sufficient to not that there are some.
It thus invalidates your self-serving claim that
all people have the ability to revolt. This is expressly denied by Battered Wives' Syndrom, Stockholm Syndrome, and a host of other related issues.
I don’t see anywhere in there the requirement that someone who considers themselves a “humanist” must provide assistance to any and every human being that suffers, as your statement suggested
Nice bit of straw man building. Once again, here is the definition of humanitarian:
"Humanitarianism is an active belief in the value of human life (humanism), whereby humans practice benevolent treatment and provide assistance to other humans, in order to better humanity for both moral and logical reasons."
No where does that say you have to help
all people. It is the claim that you are obliged to assist when and where you can.
Let me offer you the only definition of “humanitarianism” that matters, when applied to states, organizations, or groups- the one that is actually
practiced, by all of them:
“Do what you can afford to do for other people, when it is expedient to do so, unless compelled.”
No matter what pretty words the UN puts on paper, what counts is what they actually do. If you think I’m wrong, if you think whatever fancy ideals they pay lip service to has any meaning, you need to explain why they intervened in Kosovo (which you seem to delight in mentioning) but have and are letting Africa destroy itself- Rwanda, Somalia, Sudan. Because I can think of
60 kilos of reason they intervened in Kosovo that have gorram all to do with Albanians dying.
First of all, your quote contradicts nothing I've said, second, where's your source for that quote? Support the claim that this is the opperational definition. That's certainly not the opperational definition used in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
This is more pathetic misdirection on your part. My argument has never included a claim about the historical purity of the UN. Incidentally, I don't even have to say that they intervened in Kosovo for humanitarian reasons.
Clearly there was a humanitarian disaster in the Balkans that was halted by bombing. Whether or not that was the first priority, the question is how pacifists would have stopped that humanitarian disaster.
You can't follow the simple structure of the argument, so I shouldn't be surprised that you're responses are so childishly random.
God, it's like you're going out of your way to help me make you look bad.
See above, lot's of irrelevant nonsense about UN motives.
What would you like to see? I mean, I’ve already had to give you dictionary definitions of a common English word, I don’t want to make any assumptions on how basic you need it.
Oh ****, I forgot you used the dictionary. I guess I'm wrong, all arguments can be supported by using an out of context, misapplied, inappropriately asserted definition. What was that word, by the way, it wasn't "humanitarian:"
http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_1861619155/humanitarianism.html
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...f9jIGRBw&sa=X&oi=glossary_definition&ct=title
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rlz=1T4WZPA_enUS311US311&q=define:humanitarian
What I'm asking for is some type of argumentation to, for example, support the currently fallacious assertion that the occurence of an incident in the past allows us to conclude that it can and should happen in all situation.
Because if the moral standard you allege I have “perverted” does not apply to everybody, than “perversion” peans nothing more than “I don’t agree with you and I don’t want anyone else to either, so I’ll use a term with negative emotive connotations to prejudice them against it.” It’s called “appeal to emotion”, and it is a fallacy.
No, your standard disagrees with every international charter that nations have voluntarily signed on to. Whether or not those rules extend beyond human kind, to all potential iterations of society and life is irrelevant. We have empiraclly observed the world and drawn conclusions about the inherent rights of
homo sapiens sapiens, whether or not they're universal, they've been adopted just like the laws of an individual country are developed and enforced.
Trying to bring in some meta-physical nonsense about universalism is just more distraction. It's a weak attempt to add something with the faint scent of intellect to your astonishingly banal arguments. And it fails.
“So it's ok to let groups slaughter their own people? That may technically be pacifism, but it's a version of the ethos that completely ignores it's historical humanitarian roots.”
Quote me where I said that.
It's the obvious implication of your view. I ask how a pacifist would have saved the kosovars and Muslims in the Balkans and you say they should have tried to save themselves, we have no obligation to help them.
Your only answer is to allow them to be slaughtered. Please, by all means, if you have an actual practical answer, share it, but that's all you've offered so far.
Unfounded assumption. Where is the evidence for that assumption? Does not the unrest and insurgency in Iraq contradict that statement?
How does that contradict the statement at all? You don't think there are millions of people in Iraq who desperately want the violence to end and would happily support anyone who could actually make that happen?
The problem in Iraq is that no side shows a real commitment to ending violence. The US made a half-hearted attempt 5 years after demolishing the nation's infrastructure, but it's descending back into chaos as we speak.
If you're argument is that we weren't greeted as liberators, I would say that just shows that Iraq's humanitarian issues were impossible to solve by military intervention.
My argument is not that
all situations of repression and subjugation are best solved with force, it is simply that
some present no alternative. I chose to focus on those because the pacifist does make the strong claim that violence is wrong in
every situation. When you make a universal claim, a single contradictory example suffices.
But this is more nonsesne and aimless rambling from you. You don't understand the basic course of this argument.
On paper, maybe. Not in practice. Show me otherwise..
I linked you to the wiki article on the history of humanitarianism. It is, quite simply, the belief that we're obligated to our fellow man.
Of course you help where you have the power to help, but I defy you to find a humanitarian organization that works for any reason other than a sense of responsibility for their fellow man.
Here's a list of a few:
http://www.exploringabroad.com/humanitarian-org.htm
Find me the organizations that do not believe in an obligation or duty to care for others.
I’m telling you that the word “bestowes” no responsibility or obligation whatsoever. For anyone.
Yes it does. If you voluntarily desire to be called a humanitarian, you have voluntarily assented to the notion that you have a responsibility to care for others. There is no humanitarian organization you can join that would say otherwise.
You may not have an obligation to become a humanitarian, but once you say you are one, you have to behave in a certain way.
"Yeah, I'm a fire fighter, but I don't think I have a duty to fight
all fires in my area. I just sort of squirt water at the ones I feel like."
My “bizarre brand of pacifism”? Who said I was a pacifist?
Fair enough, then it shall be modified to you bizzare brand of neo-humanitarianism that isn't humanitarianism.
Then that does not speak well for either your reading comprehension or your political understanding.
That makes no sense.
There is no obligation. That’s my whole point. That you assume there is one is your naïve error that I was endeavoring to correct.
If you don't believe there's an obligation, then you're not a humanitarian.
This is the point, you want to claim the word, for some reason, yet deny what it entails. Find me a single humanitarian organization or foundational document that denies an obligation to help others.
You can't volunteer for Peace Corps and then not do anything. Once you sign on to be a humanitarian, you have to go help others.
I suppose you could sit idly by as others do work and merely keep your name on the list, but once anyone was given all the facts concerning your behavior, they would deny your claim to be a humanitarian.
In my misreading, apparently you were sincere, more’s the pity.
Haha, ok. You want to be a humanitarian but not do any humanitarian work. Yes, I will really take a weak insult from such a person seriously.